I wasn't having fun.Golden wrote:Roxy. I may have been bad, but I did keep you alive for a few nights.Roxy wrote:great fun little game even though I was killed off quickly I always enjoy games by Elo <3
(Primarily because it looked like you were really enjoying the game, and I was happy about that).
Search found 98 matches
- Sun Jul 26, 2015 12:33 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 9:54 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
As mafia, were you informed if you got the most votes to ask a question? Did that have anything to do with your case on Hedgeowl?
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 9:53 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Well in that case, I was as surprised as you were that I got a question on Night 3.
In other exciting news, Cincinnati's Todd Frazier won the Home Run Derby last night. A small consolation for what some would call a dissappointing Reds' season.
In other exciting news, Cincinnati's Todd Frazier won the Home Run Derby last night. A small consolation for what some would call a dissappointing Reds' season.
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 9:44 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
If you had killed timmer, Golden would have been the only one left alive with sunglasses.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:We thought he wasn't gonna be active again so early.Black Rock wrote:You should have killed him.Golden wrote:I was always very wary of you. But on that last night epi asked me who I was most worried about and I was very clear - timmer. So you did a good job with that one.Black Rock wrote:Congratulations. I was going to go after Golden but I was killed a night early. I even tried to leave like I somewhat believed him so maybe he wouldn't kill me. I knew he must be Mafia when Llama turned civ.
Did you guys factor player avatars into your nightkills, or did you just kill people as you seemed fit?
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 9:42 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I'm sure with timmer following your vote, you felt rather relieved at that point. You also grew rather quiet after your case, but I know you like to discourage others from posting too much after voting, so I didn't think much of it. And I happened to be chatting with Elohcin, and she said you were at the store. :PEpignosis wrote:I was apprehensive all morning yesterday that you weren't buying what I was selling, MM, and that you would persuade others to vote Golden.
Elohcin and I were also talking about the logistics of dropping info into the thread, and how far I could take it. As it ends up, I said too much, so she deleted a post of mine. I was kinda glad she did though. I was treading lightly with my posts because I didn't want to break any rules or take it too far (which I did anyway). Not having to worry about that, I was able to be more assertive.
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 9:31 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Yes, but I went after llama on Day 4 instead, certainly helped along by others. That was obviously a mistake. Apparently I was the only player with information after your lynch though. :P I can take some comfort in that.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:I'm not making fun of you about the shades thing though, you really had no option. You have 2 people with shades and didn't know who to pick. :PMetalmarsh89 wrote:I've felt the fool quite a bit recently in endgames. Flash, RYM 86, this game... I don't know why you all keep my around so long. I've yet to win a game when making it to lylo as a civilian.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:Also lol at MM having the info to take down Golden but never doing it because timmer was alive.
But yeah, sometimes we have a rough streak in this game. It's okay though, I think you are pretty good at this game.
And it appears I was right this last day phase about the voting. It was as I feared, in that one mafia had already voted Hedgeowl while one had not, putting the game out of reach with nothing I could do. I didn't feel great about Epignosis's case on Hedgeowl, but felt even worse about timmer following his vote. I was almost certain at that point that timmer was on a team with nijuu or Golden, but unfortunately, due to them not voting yet, there was no chance of lynching either of them.
So it was either follow the Hedge vote, or try to lynch timmer.
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 2:43 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I've felt the fool quite a bit recently in endgames. Flash, RYM 86, this game... I don't know why you all keep my around so long. I've yet to win a game when making it to lylo as a civilian.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:Also lol at MM having the info to take down Golden but never doing it because timmer was alive.
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 2:37 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I voted him Day 1 and forgot to do it again.G-Man wrote:That was painful to watch play out. Golden, I will now vote for you automatically on Day 1 if there is no obvious baddie slip-up. As with Economics, you being bad only started to make sense to me near the very end. I never pegged Epi as a baddie. Did you guys plan to set up DDL to be steamrolled or did he come by that on his own? Either way, it was the perfect way for Epi and Golden to sink to the bottom of everyone's suspect lists.
I'm glad I was right about DDL and SD but that only helps confirm that I still totally suck as a civvie.
Well done, you two. I am about to pay you the highest compliment I can give in this game: I hate you both.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 6:57 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Voting for timmer. Sorry I couldn't be around to chat.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 4:16 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I'm going to have to decide on my vote in the next hour or so.
Right now, I think any pairing of Epignosis or timmer with nijuu, Golden, or myself is off the table, because any such pairing that doesn't include Hedgeowl would be an automatic win (on the relatively safe assumption that Hedgeowl will miss the vote).
So the baddie team could be Epignosis and timmer
OR
Any combination of Golden, myself, and nijuu
OR
Hedgeowl with anybody else.
Thoughts?
Right now, I think any pairing of Epignosis or timmer with nijuu, Golden, or myself is off the table, because any such pairing that doesn't include Hedgeowl would be an automatic win (on the relatively safe assumption that Hedgeowl will miss the vote).
So the baddie team could be Epignosis and timmer
OR
Any combination of Golden, myself, and nijuu
OR
Hedgeowl with anybody else.
Thoughts?
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 4:09 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
To expound, I have tried to think of a reason that Epignosis would have come in with this wild case on Hedgeowl while also being a baddie, and I can't think of a logical one.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 4:05 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I was given the oppurtunity to ask a question after Night 3.
I have trouble believing that Epignosis faked doing so for Night 4.
I have trouble believing that Epignosis faked doing so for Night 4.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 11:21 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
My gut reaction was civilian, but I also thought llama was mafia.
Currently, I think she could be bad for reasons I've already stated about Epignosis. But this is based on an assumption about Epignosis. As bizarre as this sounds, I believe that there is a good chance that she is bad, but I don't feel comfortable lynching her today.
Currently, I think she could be bad for reasons I've already stated about Epignosis. But this is based on an assumption about Epignosis. As bizarre as this sounds, I believe that there is a good chance that she is bad, but I don't feel comfortable lynching her today.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 10:53 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Each instance DDL interacted with or talked about timmer.
Each instance DDL interacted with or talked about Golden.
Based on just these interactions alone, timmer looks far worse than Golden. DDL's and timmer's only direct interaction came on a post that was apparently misunderstood.
The interactions between Golden and DDL look sincere to me, and that is just from reading DDL's side of the interactions.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Based on just these interactions alone, timmer looks far worse than Golden. DDL's and timmer's only direct interaction came on a post that was apparently misunderstood.
The interactions between Golden and DDL look sincere to me, and that is just from reading DDL's side of the interactions.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 10:08 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
If you weren't dead I'd go Master Detective all over you right now.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 9:35 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I have come to the conclusion that at least two of these players are mafia.
I considered nijuukyugou as a baddie, but I don't feel strongly about it.
So right now, I have it narrowed down to Golden, timmer, and Hedgeowl.
- Epignosis
Golden
Hedgeowl
nijuukyugou
timmer
I considered nijuukyugou as a baddie, but I don't feel strongly about it.
So right now, I have it narrowed down to Golden, timmer, and Hedgeowl.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:57 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I think I know what I see here.Golden wrote:Seems I have a little more time than I thought, so I'm going to start looking back at people now.
First things first - I don't feel the need to read back hedgeowl. I think epi may have quoted every single post. I don't see anything there. Right now the only thing I have is 'am I to believe epi has info on hedgeowl'. He can only have info on one out of ninja and hedge, not both, so I really don't know if he is trying to get at one of those things, or if he is just being epi.
Which is really more of a read on epi than on hedgeowl anyway. I'll come back to epi later.
I doubt hedge has been placing the kills (would she need to?) She proclaimed llama was bad when everyone else did. Not much more to see.
Epignosis asked a question. He asked if a member of mafia is wearing a tiara.
And Hedgeowl would not have to be placing the kills. But note that she has showed up to post just after each deadline except for the last one, so she has certainly been around to send in a nightkill if she needed to.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 8:47 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
For the record, I did not try to deliberatetly change the intent of Golden's post, that was just how I understood it.timmer wrote:Day 2 Daisy questioned Golden about his case against MM that MM had deliberately tried to change the intent of Golden's post by selectively trimming it. She then made a "statement vote" against Golden.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 12:20 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Go get 'em tiger.Golden wrote:Hey everyone. Been fully involved in endgame of RYM87. Need a short mafia break but will be in here to catch up etc later tonight.
@linki - MM, I need at least a couple of hours to do some other stuff. But yes, I know, lylo, it's important, so once I've had my little break, all my attention is here.
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 12:19 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I am at a loss for words.Epignosis wrote:Now, a question for you, MM:
You seemed not to notice that I had voted for Hedgeowl, and proceeded with assumptions around timmer and nijuu. When I clarified about Hedgeowl, you insinuated that I don't care about this lynch, posted the eye, and then asked for the reason I voted Hedgeowl.
What are your current thoughts on Hedgeowl?
- Mon Jul 13, 2015 12:16 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Golden, get in here. This is lylo!
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 10:00 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Thank you.
What is your reason for voting for Hedgeowl?
What is your reason for voting for Hedgeowl?
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 9:58 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
You took the time to make a case on llama yesterday to justify your vote, even bringing up the fact that he never interacted with nijuukyugou until his late baddie list. You even voted late to observe other voters.Epignosis wrote:If that's what you take, then that's what you take.Metalmarsh89 wrote:I take it this lynch does not mean that much to you?
I am good with my vote.
But today you vote Hedgeowl early, with nary a previous suspicion of her.
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 9:52 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I take it this lynch does not mean that much to you?
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 9:46 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Did I misunderstand your previous post where you asked for amnesty for potentially being partially correct about a llama/nijuukyugou duo?
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 9:24 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Epignosis, remember when nijuu voted for Missing Person because of timmer's case on MP? You came in and pointed out your more original case on MP.
I think there's a connection there, and feel more strongly about it now than I did the other day.
I think there's a connection there, and feel more strongly about it now than I did the other day.
Metalmarsh89 wrote:Here, nijuu follows timmer's reasons that Missing Person could be a baddie, and later acknowledges Epignosis's case. My gut feeling here is that nijuu and timmer are baddie partners, and nijuu followed his read of Missing Person because of this, but I could be reading to far into it. Personally, I say bad look for nijuu, but you be the judge.
nijuukyugou wrote:That was easy. I like this:
as well as the other supporting points about MP (basically I'm seeing the same thing being said regarding defense of inactives and MP being inactive, etc.). I'll go ahead and vote that way, too.timmer wrote:Reading back further, the case that was brought out about DDL specifically mentioning that there would be a potential modkill of MP just adds to that. And Daisy suggested that MP should be given at least a day to get settled in, as well, so both of our baddies didn't seem to like the idea of people voting for MP. This may be enough for me to vote him today.nijuukyugou wrote:Epi's post is adequate. It'll do.
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 9:00 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
What about timmer?Epignosis wrote:My essay pairing llama and nijuukyugou together was unsatisfactory.
Needs improvement.
Please see the teacher.
Is partial credit allowed? Because I think the "silent partner" section of my paper is A+.
If anybody complains about my vote going for an inactive, I'll see you after school.
That's the bell.
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 8:24 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Oh crap, I switched time zones and forgot to adjust my mental clock. RIP Black Rock.
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 1:30 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Oh, and I still have an ISO of you to do Golden. I will get around to that tomorrow.
Linki: And there's always the good old-fashioned scum-hunting.
Linki 2:
Linki: And there's always the good old-fashioned scum-hunting.
Linki 2:
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 1:27 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Snipped for relevance. This looks to me like a no go. I guess looking from signs from the players you have voted for (which we're also not allowed to talk about) is your best bet.Elohcin wrote:4. As you, the civilian, receive information about a player's avatar........ You may not use a player's avatar to discuss whether the player is civilian or mafia. Doing so will result in a mod-kill. If you are unsure about something you want to say, please PM the host before posting.
11. No posting the contents of PMs- period.
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 1:24 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I think we're not allowed to talk about it the questions we ask.
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 1:10 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Regardless, we have to get it right tomorrow. If we lynch the wrong player, mafia wins.
Also, lol at your question BR. How do you expect Golden to answer?
Also, lol at your question BR. How do you expect Golden to answer?
- Sun Jul 12, 2015 12:09 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I'm sorry llama. You looked bad to me. Sorry to put you down.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 5:52 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
My parents still like to fly me home for visits, so I take the free flights. And flying out of a small city, I always have at least one layover, and often two.
My current experience with United Airlines has been dreadful. Delta has been a better experience, amd they take better care of their customers.
The actual flying itself isn't bad at all. Waiting on the plane is much better than waiting in the airport.
My current experience with United Airlines has been dreadful. Delta has been a better experience, amd they take better care of their customers.
The actual flying itself isn't bad at all. Waiting on the plane is much better than waiting in the airport.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 5:27 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Florida --> Chicago --> San Fran --> Eugene. Though now I've got some down time because the flight is delayed.Epignosis wrote:Hey, where you flying?
I've never been on a plane in my life.
I don't recommend flying. It's expensive and usually not fun. Oh and it's near impossible to find a good meal.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 5:12 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Just because I called timmer the sexiest player in this game?Epignosis wrote:Now that you have voted, I will vote for you, and complete my master plan!Metalmarsh89 wrote:You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?Epignosis wrote:I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 5:07 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?Epignosis wrote:I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 4:53 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
In between flights and no time. I'm voting llama. It is between him and Golden for me right now, but I haven't given Golden a proper look yet.
So llama gets my vote.
So llama gets my vote.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 12:21 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I've got a plane to catch, but I'll be back on in a couple hours.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 12:11 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I won't deny that I think he is.thellama73 wrote:I'm actually not, believe it or not. But Golden is.Metalmarsh89 wrote: Linki: Llama, are you mafia?
I don't believe you. You now have Golden, myself, and Epignosis who have posted cases against you today, and you have not acknowledged any of them. Instead, you are waiting for one-liners to respond to. There are 6 players (if my math is correct) that want you dead today, so I believe you are a baddie, and helping to protect your last baddie mate.
But, You and Golden are suddenly going after each other today too. You haven't mentioned Golden since early on, and I don't think Golden had a read on you either way before today. I see this as hardcore distancing. Golden even said he wishes he had moved his vote. I doubt it's true. Why would he have voted so early for me if he was really that suspicious of you?
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 12:02 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
EBWOP: Well that was quite the /url fail.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 12:01 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
One thing I forgot to mention. Ricochet was nightkilled Night 1. Llama and Ricochet have had a grudge against each other since the day Ricochet joined the Syndicate.Epignosis wrote:I go to sleep and three people vote.
Ricochet suspected thellama73. Ricochet died.
G-Man listed thellama73 as a "maybe Mafia." G-Man died.
fingersplints named thellama73 as her biggest suspect. fingersplints died.
Roxy wanted to lynch thellama73. Roxy died.
I could see llama executing these four and then mocking the kills; the (secretly) self-depreciating humor would amuse him.
His first two votes were inconsequential, but the Day 3 vote tied it up between Black Rock and spacedaisy. After spacedaisy got lynched, llama reiterated his suspicion of Black Rock, and doesn't mention her again until here. In the meantime, he suddenly became convinced to vote for Missing Person.
I have other things rolling around upstairs, but they will have to wait until I get back.
Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go buy beer and dirt.
I noticed this trend and agree with your assessment. The first night periods, llama interacted with G-Man and Ricochet, calling them both civilian, and they each were nightkilled hours later. The fingersplints kill was a change from the norm, but as you say, she called llama her biggest suspect and continuing the trend would make things all the more obvious.
And you're buying dirt? Are you going to play {url=http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... f=30&t=565]Dirt Mafia[/url]?
Linki: Llama, are you mafia?
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 11:54 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
And now for Mr. timmer man, the dude with the sexiest avatar in this game. After my tin-foil hat theory in my ISO of nijuu, I'll try to keep this open-minded.
Timmer starts the game being rather noncommittal and diplomatic. But I won't fault him for such behaviors on Day 1.
Timmer goes after DDL on Day 1, but was corrected and backed off. This reads as sincere to me, but I could be wrong. Timmer was trying to connect MP to DDL, and later helped get Missing Person lynched. This would be a hard thing for a teammate of DDL today, and easier to see coming from a civilian.
Bad look for timmer here. I don't understand how one can suspect another player for voting to lynch an inactive, and go on to random-vote. It's even more suspicious because the player he voted ended up being a baddie. Maybe I am incorrect and timmer did try to set up the DDL-MP connection early on with nefarious reasons?
Timmer votes for Spacedaisy Day 3 after missing the Day 2 lynch. Let it be known that to this point, timmer has only voiced suspicion (one of them a misunderstanding) of DDL and Spacedaisy, both baddies. Either he has been spot on with his reads, or he knows things others don't. But in a game where information comes to civilians, I can't rule out the latter of these options still potentially making him civilian. Still, I don't think this is a good look for him.
Timmer is ambivalent about myself and Golden. Another noncommittal post.
Timmer revisits the early connection he pointed out between Missing Person and DDL. Missing Person went on to be lynched, but this is the only other player timmer has looked at throughout this game. After the successful lynch of DDL, I don't blame him for revisiting though. It does make sense, so this is a slightly good look for timmer.
Addendum: So the list of players timmer has suspected through this game includes just DDL, Spacedaisy, and Missing Person. All three are now dead, so I would love to hear more from timmer. I give him a neutral read right now.
Linki: Will read momentarily.
Timmer starts the game being rather noncommittal and diplomatic. But I won't fault him for such behaviors on Day 1.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Addendum: So the list of players timmer has suspected through this game includes just DDL, Spacedaisy, and Missing Person. All three are now dead, so I would love to hear more from timmer. I give him a neutral read right now.
Linki: Will read momentarily.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 11:34 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Guess what nijuukyugou, it's your turn!
12 posts from nijuu thus far, so this one will not take very long.
Nijuu's first post of the game. I know she is known for quality over quantity when it comes to post content, and she has not disappointed this game. She comments early on the DDL case, siding against him. She also was one of the few players to cut TH some slack for a day at least. TH only received 4 votes, but nijuu was one of the only ones to vote differently, placing her vote on DDL instead. She did miss the vote Day 2, the day DDL was lynched though.
nijuu calls me weird. Still, I suppose I'm used to that. But she did not pursue it, given the opportunity.
Nijuu posts after she missed the Day 2 vote in the lynch of DDL. I would expect she would have voted for DDL based on her Day 1 observations.
Nijuu calls me weird again. This time, she latches on to what Roxy said. I don't like this statement at all from nijuu. As I explained to Roxy, I never self-voted in this game. You can look at the vote records to prove it. Nijuu says she "suspects self-voters regardless of alignment". I don't know if she is trying to say she suspects me or not, but there is no reason to do so right now. Nijuu is either not paying attention, or I've misunderstood, or she is intentionally shrouding suspicion on me. Unless this is the second of these two, this post doesn't look good for nijuu.
Here, nijuu follows timmer's reasons that Missing Person could be a baddie, and later acknowledges Epignosis's case. My gut feeling here is that nijuu and timmer are baddie partners, and nijuu followed his read of Missing Person because of this, but I could be reading to far into it. Personally, I say bad look for nijuu, but you be the judge.
Addendum: Nijuu appears the opposite as Black Rock to me. BR looked bad at the beginning, but better as the game went on. Nijuu on the other hand had a great Day 1, but has looked worse as the game goes on. I'd put her behind llama on my baddie list.
12 posts from nijuu thus far, so this one will not take very long.
Nijuu's first post of the game. I know she is known for quality over quantity when it comes to post content, and she has not disappointed this game. She comments early on the DDL case, siding against him. She also was one of the few players to cut TH some slack for a day at least. TH only received 4 votes, but nijuu was one of the only ones to vote differently, placing her vote on DDL instead. She did miss the vote Day 2, the day DDL was lynched though.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Addendum: Nijuu appears the opposite as Black Rock to me. BR looked bad at the beginning, but better as the game went on. Nijuu on the other hand had a great Day 1, but has looked worse as the game goes on. I'd put her behind llama on my baddie list.
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 11:05 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
BR, what do you think about Golden being mafia?
- Sat Jul 11, 2015 8:21 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Hooray! People are talking; this is great news. By popular request, thellama73 is next up.
Llama interacts with DDL on Day 1, discussing whether or not we should lynch Missing Person for not having an avatar. Typical llama banter, but this idea proposed by llama, coupled with MP's lack of participation, may be the strongest driving force for what was to become MP's lynch on Day 4.
According to llama, asking questions about avatars is the only way that we can discover who is bad, thread interactions and vote counts be damned. This also looks like a comment from a player who doesn't know how the civilian role power works. However, this observation was made on Day 1, so no player would have more knowledge than another as to how it worked.
Llama continues his Day 1 interactions with DDL. Good look for llama here. He points out the inaccuracy in DDL's comment, while still sticking to his own reads (if you call it that). The second half of the post doesn't really affect the read so much. Llama offers a more Syndicate-beneficial reason for lynching Missing Person.
Llama says we have a 33% chance of lynching a baddie. Bad look for llama I think. He says there is a 4 / 12 chance that we lynch a baddie, when there are 12 civilians, not 12 total players.
Llama explains that there are still several players to check in. Quite the turnaround considering he was endorsing lynching inactives just a few hours before. 35 minutes later, llama turns around and says he's going to vote for Turnip Head, the only player who had not checked in yet (after being doubly corrected by G-Man). Very bad look for llama.
Here, llama responds to Ricochet's massive case with this two-liner. In llama's defense, he was out of town for Fourth of July, so may not have been able to make a proper response. Still, Ricochet was killed Night 1, saving llama from having to give a proper address to the case.
Llama votes for DDL Day 2. Not much to say about his vote, as it put DDL up 5-1 over Black Rock.
Llama comes back from his vacation, says he's all caught up, and only addresses Spacedaisy (a "Maybe mafia") in his new rainbow list. No mention of the three "Probably Mafia" that he listed in this post, nor before this post, aside from Golden.
Also noteworthy, Missing Person has made his way into llama's "Probably Not Mafia" list.
Llama's first mention of Black Rock. Considering BR is his number 1 mafia read, this post isn't very convincing.
Llama calls out the mafia for being absent and unthoughtful. The absentness seems to match up with his Rainbow List. Convenient. Llama offers some thoughts on Black Rock and comments on Spacedaisy, indifferently. Llama also chose to comment on myself and Golden. He says he did a reread of both of us, but said little more than he doesn't suspect either of us. Considering the length of this post, there is not much going on. Llama is clearly pushing a lynch in the direction of Black Rock here.
Again, llama fits the nightkill of G-man into his own definition of baddieness. Llama says the baddies are scared and disorganized. Epignosis offered a more accurate observation I believe. Epignosis said it made sense for the mafia to kill an analytical player. Ricochet Night 1, G-Man Night 2. The trend is short, but clear. Another trend I've noticed, both players to be nightkilled to this point both had gone after llama the night they were killed.
"Mafia is running scared"? That's what he said after the logical nightkill of G-Man. Maybe I have my blinders on, but llama is looking worse and worse as this game goes on.
Llama finally makes a real mention of Hedgeowl. But this mention is hardly anything to sneeze at.
Also llama says that the baddies are not voting to save their members. Let's look at Black Rock's and Spacedaisy's votes. I'd look at Hedgeowl's too, llama's other top suspect, but she has not voted yet this game...
Anyway, Day 1, both Spacedaisy and Black Rock vote for Turnip Head to put him 4-3 over DDL. We don't know about Black Rock, but Spacedaisy, an obvious baddie, voted to save DDL.
Day 2, Spacedaisy voted for Golden and Black Rock missed the vote in a landslide DDL lynch. That's about as close to a save as could have happened.
Day 3, Black Rock voted Spacedaisy who flipped bad. Black Rock voted out of self-preservation, so one can't fault her for it, nor was there even a situation to go for a save. Spacedaisy missed the vote.
Day 4, Missing Person won in a landslide victory, so no save required. Anyway, Black Rock voted for llama.
Baddies are not voting to save their members? These are llama's top two suspects right?
Llama says one of the people who wants him dead is likely mafia. This looks to me like another scenario to fit his Rainbow List that doesn't have any actual support to it.
Suddenly, llama wants to go after Golden again, even with BR and Hedgeowl still alive. It is good that he is revisiting a previous read. Brownie point for llama.
Llama goes after Golden with the most conviction he's had all game, even giving him an early vote. Well, llama's had conviction before, but he's hardly backed anything up with quotes and evidence before this.
Addendum: I think llama looks bad. There's a large portion of his game that looks bad, and there is not enough good actions to counter that. Through my ISO's thus far, llama is definitely my strongest mafia read.
Llama interacts with DDL on Day 1, discussing whether or not we should lynch Missing Person for not having an avatar. Typical llama banter, but this idea proposed by llama, coupled with MP's lack of participation, may be the strongest driving force for what was to become MP's lynch on Day 4.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Also noteworthy, Missing Person has made his way into llama's "Probably Not Mafia" list.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Also llama says that the baddies are not voting to save their members. Let's look at Black Rock's and Spacedaisy's votes. I'd look at Hedgeowl's too, llama's other top suspect, but she has not voted yet this game...
Anyway, Day 1, both Spacedaisy and Black Rock vote for Turnip Head to put him 4-3 over DDL. We don't know about Black Rock, but Spacedaisy, an obvious baddie, voted to save DDL.
Day 2, Spacedaisy voted for Golden and Black Rock missed the vote in a landslide DDL lynch. That's about as close to a save as could have happened.
Day 3, Black Rock voted Spacedaisy who flipped bad. Black Rock voted out of self-preservation, so one can't fault her for it, nor was there even a situation to go for a save. Spacedaisy missed the vote.
Day 4, Missing Person won in a landslide victory, so no save required. Anyway, Black Rock voted for llama.
Baddies are not voting to save their members? These are llama's top two suspects right?
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Addendum: I think llama looks bad. There's a large portion of his game that looks bad, and there is not enough good actions to counter that. Through my ISO's thus far, llama is definitely my strongest mafia read.
- Fri Jul 10, 2015 11:50 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I'm off to bed. I will continue tomorrow. Hopefully this can kickstart some discussion.
- Fri Jul 10, 2015 11:46 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Skipping Golden for now because I'm getting tired. Here comes Hedgeowl. 9 posts!
Apologizes for not being around for the Day 1 lynch. Nothing else to see here really.
Misses another vote. Day 1 all over again.
Day 3 vote fail. I don't think she has figured out the vote deadline yet.
Day 4, same thing. That's four posts in a row of no contribution and apologizing for missing the deadline.
But this next post is good. I think Hedgeowl hit the nail on the head with llama. The lynch of Missing Person was a failure; if we learned something please someone point it out. I will look at it later if I get a chance. Anyway, after lynching an inactive for a slightly good reason, why go after a non-voter for no good reason? I have not seen anyone offer a good reason to lynch Hedgeowl, and I know llama wants to lynch her the most. So I think Hedgeowl is right in her reaction, though it does not excuse her four days of sub-par play. We need to hear more from her.
Addendum: We would love to hear more from Hedgeowl. If I were forced to choose, I would list her as a civilian read.
Apologizes for not being around for the Day 1 lynch. Nothing else to see here really.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Addendum: We would love to hear more from Hedgeowl. If I were forced to choose, I would list her as a civilian read.
- Fri Jul 10, 2015 11:28 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Up next, Epignosis.
Epignosis was the first player to go after DDL, and did so early on Day 1. Epignosis placed the first vote on DDL on Day 1 as well.
Epignosis responds to Golden's accusations of being quiet with a tired-sounding response, and a good reason case for lynching DDL later. I'm feeling good about Epignosis thus far, as well as his vote later on Day 1.
After the lynch and a bunch of OT posts, Epignosis calls Black Rock's vote out from the group, mainly because of her forgetting to vote. The circumstances look bad for BR, but I still believe her. She did post when she had planned on voting rather than doing a drive-by. I disagree with Epignosis here.
DDL does the same as Epignosis, and paints a bad light on BR for her vote, but for different reasons. Epignosis calls him out and pursues him for this. Another good look for Epignosis, and a bad one for Black Rock.
After DDL flipped mafia, Epignosis decided to focus his attention solely on Black Rock and Missing Person. Epignosis pursues his original case on DDL that was related to MP. MP ultimately has flipped civilian, proving Epignosis wrong. However, I do not think Epignosis looks bad for this. After the correct read of DDL, a look down this avenue of thought makes sense.
Epignosis offers a defence of Spacedaisy here the day she is lynched. I did witness the amazing game Daisy played in Death Note and can attribute that this was game was not quite on par with that one. Null read here for Epignosis.
Side note: Epignosis mentioned that DDL was lurking at this moment. The list of players online around that time (based on post times) includes: thellama73, Golden, nijuukyugou, Epignosis, and Black Rock.
Epignosis defends Roxy, mainly because of an assessment Roxy made of Epignosis. I feel good about this statement from him.
Epignosis looks good to me this game. A lot of good baddie-hunting and nothing that stands out not in his favor. I know Black Rock has accused him of closed-mindedness, but that's hardly indicative of a baddie, nor is it even outside of his realm of behaviour. See Death Note with regards to FZ.
Epignosis was the first player to go after DDL, and did so early on Day 1. Epignosis placed the first vote on DDL on Day 1 as well.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Side note: Epignosis mentioned that DDL was lurking at this moment. The list of players online around that time (based on post times) includes: thellama73, Golden, nijuukyugou, Epignosis, and Black Rock.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Epignosis looks good to me this game. A lot of good baddie-hunting and nothing that stands out not in his favor. I know Black Rock has accused him of closed-mindedness, but that's hardly indicative of a baddie, nor is it even outside of his realm of behaviour. See Death Note with regards to FZ.
- Fri Jul 10, 2015 10:46 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 27092
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Nope, a resort in Florida. Not my idea for a vacation, but at least I get to hang out with my family since I only see them twice or so a year.Roxy wrote:vacation sounds cool, are you camping?
Annd RIP Roxy.