Search found 25 matches
- Tue Jul 14, 2015 1:53 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Congrats winners and thanks for the game Elo.
- Wed Jul 08, 2015 6:00 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
My biggest suspect atm is still llama. I think that Epi is a misguided civvie. I'm also looking at Timmer for reasons stated shortly after Day 1 ended. (His throwaway D1 vote for SD)
I need to revisit this MM/Golden thing.
I need to revisit this MM/Golden thing.
- Tue Jul 07, 2015 6:05 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Voting spacedaisy before I forget
- Tue Jul 07, 2015 5:05 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
It just feels a bit like "IGNORE THE OTHER CIVVIE WHO SUSPECTED ME!!!!"thellama73 wrote:The big difference is that Rico was wrong and G-Man was right. Big difference. What's wrong with being convenient? Would you rather me be inconvenient?fingersplints wrote:I thought rico was pretty actively baddie hunting too though, so I'm not sure what makes the kills that much different to you. It seems convenient and that you want us to only look at who Gman suspected because rico was calling you out.
I don't know he was wrong.

keeping an eye on you is all
- Tue Jul 07, 2015 5:02 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I think that if SD had voted DDL at that point it would have looked even worse for her since she already said she didn't understand the case on him.Epignosis wrote:I don't believe spacedaisy is DDL's teammate. spacedaisy burned me bad in Death Note. She was devious, emotionally manipulative, and entirely deserving of the win. If she voted to save DDL Day 1, then what was the purpose of her voting Golden Day 2? What was their strategy as a team?
Makes no sense.
As I said earlier, I will be voting Black Rock or Missing Person.
Wish there was somebody to talk besides dead people.
- Tue Jul 07, 2015 12:49 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I thought rico was pretty actively baddie hunting too though, so I'm not sure what makes the kills that much different to you. It seems convenient and that you want us to only look at who Gman suspected because rico was calling you out.
- Tue Jul 07, 2015 12:29 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I read him giving me a "pass" as he couldn't get enough people on board to the suspicion of me. I thought Missing Person was less suspicious because he didn't back down when it was obviously not gaining momentum.
- Tue Jul 07, 2015 10:08 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
SD looks worse to me still, but the BR case makes sense to me too.
I know she responded to me like "see I told you I don't get the suspicion" but it still feels like brushing it off too me. And I think she voted off because it would have looked even worse to vote her teammate at that point.
Llama why do you think the kill of Gman was artless?
I know she responded to me like "see I told you I don't get the suspicion" but it still feels like brushing it off too me. And I think she voted off because it would have looked even worse to vote her teammate at that point.
Llama why do you think the kill of Gman was artless?
- Mon Jul 06, 2015 8:28 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
yes
I'm really sad I missed that vote because I meant to vote DDL again. I don't have a great excuse. I get really homesick on American holidays (especially the fourth that is also my nephews bday) I'll be more in a mafia mood later. sorry Elo though! 


- Fri Jul 03, 2015 10:49 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
RIP TH and rico

I don't really find you suspicious for it, but I don't also see it as changing the policy when she sees fit. Like I said earlier, I have never taken new as equaling one game. It all has to do with giving players time to be comfortable on this site. For one player that may take a game or two. For another it may take a couple seconds. The game MP played had heavy posting restrictions (He only had 12 posts that game and Rox had 3)Golden wrote:RIP Rico. I wanted to play with you too, sorry to see you go. You could consider subbing in to Dom's game, although I know that is tough at this stage.
@Roxy - All I can say, is that I hope you go back and read what you said and what I said again. I don't think you have been fair with your interpretation of your own words. If you come back civ in this game, I'll take it under advisement that you are entitled to change your newbie policy when you see fit. But I've seen your newbie policy a lot of times - like you say, I know it like the back of my hand, I've played with you enough - and you changed it this time. It was not the same newbie policy as usual.
I know you have a busy weekend with SVS, and make the most of it, I don't expect you to do this right away or anything. But please do it when you have time.
- Fri Jul 03, 2015 7:40 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I think your llama points are pretty good. If he is bad I could actually see a MP/llama distancing thing. They both mentioned suspicion of each other early but chose to pursue their other suspects instead with little to no reasoning. (MP was calling either me or llama bad. Now is focusing on me. When I am revealed as a civvie he can easily said "damn was wrong said llama OR splints". Llama as you said going with the weaker TH vote as you said)
- Fri Jul 03, 2015 7:32 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
If SD is bad, I will be eyeing Timmer as his vote on her was essentially a throw away.
- Fri Jul 03, 2015 7:31 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Sorry I should have reread that. SD said she didn't understand the case on DDL not TH
That's where my suspicion comes from. I think she misrepresented the points on him. My reason for suspecting him had nothing to do with what she said
That's where my suspicion comes from. I think she misrepresented the points on him. My reason for suspecting him had nothing to do with what she said
- Fri Jul 03, 2015 7:30 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I think SD's TH vote looks suspicious. She said she didn't understand the case on him at all, but the points on him wasn't at all why I was voting him even. Idk I think they are teammates and she jumped on the TH bandwagon to save DDL
Linki with Rico will read that now
Linki with Rico will read that now
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 8:00 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I did not realize this was 24 hour. I'm voting voting DDL now.
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 3:17 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Turnip Head has been absent in several games though, so I think this is a different situation.thellama73 wrote:People hate when I vote for non-participants or people who "have not had the chance to defend themselves."fingersplints wrote:Why would that piss everyone off?thellama73 wrote:I'm probably going to vote for Turnip Head just to piss everyone off.
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 2:41 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Why would that piss everyone off?thellama73 wrote:I'm probably going to vote for Turnip Head just to piss everyone off.
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 2:25 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I should say if MP continues to not get an avatar I would later vote him. I just think it's early to say that is suspicious given he has made it clear he is traveling.
I also don't really find llama suspicious for suggesting voting him for that reason because it's in character for llama regardless of his affiliation
I also don't really find llama suspicious for suggesting voting him for that reason because it's in character for llama regardless of his affiliation
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 2:17 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
I'm so glad you understand metimmer wrote:While I don't really like that Roxy and splints said they wouldn't vote MP due to a missing avatar (this game DOES revolve around having one, naturally) I would NOT say that splints' posts have been defeatist. Veteran players sometimes just know where they stand, and are happy to put it out there and make people vote them for it. Like, if splints is civ, and meant what she said, there is nothing for her to do or say at this moment than just hope for the best. Veteran players know that sometimes you get lynched on Day 1 for stupid things and tend not to take it personally.
It's not technically throwing in the towel, it's just being comfortable with what you've said and accepting that sometimes you get the heave ho early in a game and that's how mafia works.
I'm more interested in the people trying actively to stir shit up.

I used to get lynched a lot Day 1. It's been a long time, and I think I am probably due. I'm going to still post, I just don't see it as the end of the world. It's gotta be someone
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 2:14 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Actually you were also proven wrong because I'm pretty sure you accused me of giving up then too and were wrong.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:On the contrary, I was proven right. We got both Roxy and Bass lynched in that game and they were calling it quits when it happened. Arguably Roxy was having real life issues, but Bass pulled the same thing when he was being taken to the gallows.fingersplints wrote:When did Gman make this point you are agreeing with about my "defeatist post"Dragon D. Luffy wrote:G-Man did not vote, though. Guess he was trying to pressure her.
He has a point though, defeatist posts like this one splints made usually point out to mafia. Townies don't give up that easily.
also when did I give up? All I said was I was never going to agree with that
I disagree that they usually point to mafia. you have made a similar point in other games (economics) and were proven wrong there too
You will probably be getting my vote.
Linki
I agreed with this:
Though it seems G-Man wasn't being serious about it, but I still think it was worth pointing out.G-Man wrote:Glad you're okay with getting lynched early.
You didn't give up? Fine. But that was the vibe I got from your post, and when I see anything suspicious, I'll point it out, even if it is probably not an useful clue. Sooner or later something will be.
Roxy and Bass giving up because they had RL stuff doesn't make your theory that baddies give up more correct at all to me.
I never said you couldn't suspect me (actually I said just the opposite

- Thu Jul 02, 2015 1:52 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
When did Gman make this point you are agreeing with about my "defeatist post"Dragon D. Luffy wrote:G-Man did not vote, though. Guess he was trying to pressure her.
He has a point though, defeatist posts like this one splints made usually point out to mafia. Townies don't give up that easily.
also when did I give up? All I said was I was never going to agree with that
I disagree that they usually point to mafia. you have made a similar point in other games (economics) and were proven wrong there too
You will probably be getting my vote.
Linki
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 11:25 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
If I am suspicious for thinking it is unfair to vote a newer player for a silly reason like he hasn't been able to upload an avatar yet then so be it. If that is how we will be hunting baddies probably for the best to get rid of me now anyways because I will never agree that that is a good way to go about it 

- Thu Jul 02, 2015 10:01 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Having only played one game with extreme posting restrictions is still new to me. When did I say that new means the first game? 

- Thu Jul 02, 2015 9:56 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Not leaping to get on anyone's good side. I've made it clear I don't like voting new or returning players, so I said its pretty unsurprising for me to agree with Roxy about not to like voting for someone just for not having an avatar immediatelyMissing Person wrote:This seems odd.fingersplints wrote:Yay game. I don't plan on voting MP for not having an avatar.
Why this leap to get on Roxy's good side?
I think the better line would be just simply not vote for me. Announcing it looks like a clamor for attention.
Looks scummy.
I would have made the same point, and Rox would have agreed with me had I been a bit earlier to the thread. Same discussion different game
- Thu Jul 02, 2015 8:22 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: Guess Who? Mafia
- Replies: 785
- Views: 31900
Re: Guess Who? Mafia
Yay game. I don't plan on voting MP for not having an avatar. 
