You said something similar about me having a role in Chicka Chicka 1, 2, 3 that gradually insanified most of the players.
I think you need to pick your battles better.

One of the ideas that I thought of doing was adding punctuation to the game title as it progressed. It would have gone this way:JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 10:59 pm I think the psychology experiment here is more effective or less design biased if it isn’t run on a Mafia website with the name Mafia.
Flavor (and by extension, theme) is the very reason I host. I don't host mafia games just to assemble a bunch of weird roles for the sake of assembling a bunch of weird roles. I host mafia in order to tell a story. Mafia is my mistress, but it is also my only creative outlet at this time.
Remember that time recently on Discord when I told you that I only ever created one game that I would readily consider 'bastard'? You signed up for it.JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Thu Mar 11, 2021 10:19 pm This is, to be clear, the epitome of a bastard game. So if folks are upset I don’t blame them either. There was a time when I’d have been pissed.
I’m getting too old for this.
You are LUCA FONTANA, a civvie. You were recently forced into retirement from the police force for a few too many instances of bad paperwork. You're sure of your instincts, even if they aren't the best. Each night you can check one player of your choice to see if they are mafia. You have a 50% chance of the result being correct.
You are ROBERT VITALE, a civvie. You are such a kind neighbor that an elderly homeowner in Piano Estates has asked you to be their proxy vote any time the need arises. As such, your vote is worth two each day.
You are FRANK CALABRESE, a civvie. You are the neighborhood handyman and a jack of all trades. You have three one-shot abilities- a block, a protect, and vote strip. Each night, you may choose to use one of these one-shot powers until all three have been used up.
You are SYLVIA PUGLIESE, a civvie. You are the neighborhood hottie capable of stopping traffic. Each night you use your good looks to stop any player of your choice in their tracks, blocking them from using their power for the night.
You are VIC MAGAZINO, a civvie. You are a bodyguard. Each night you may select one player to protect. All powers used on that player during the night will hit you instead.
You are MICHAEL GAGLIARDI, a civvie. You are the cowardly neighbor in Piano Estates. As such, you will pick one person each night to hide behind. The first power submitted against you hit them instead. If a second (or third, fourth, etc) power targets you on the same night, it will hit you.
You are PHILLIP RICCI, a civvie. You are the newly appointed president of the Piano Estates Homeowners Association. You have the ability to halt one eviction from taking place. To do so, you must PM the host before the eviction vote deadline. You may not submit a conditional request that is contingent upon a certain player being the poll leader. Your decision must be a full-on committment to stop the eviction no matter who is leading in the poll.
You are MARTIN DELUCA, a civvie. You are an up-and-comer who is trying to fit in. As such, you tend to be a copycat of everyone else around you in order to fit in. Each day phase, you may select one player whose power you would like to copy. After the eviction post, you will be told what power you have copied and you may use it on any other player you like that night only.
You are VINCE GAROFALO, a civvie. You are newly retired and bored out of your mind. As such, you have taken up people-watching. Each night, you can watch any player of your choice, thereby learning the names of any players targeting them that night.
You are ANTHONY TESTA, a civvie. You are a successful doctor, and you can use your skills to protect one player each night. Your protection will shield your target from any other powers targetting them that night.
You are SOFIA MANCINI, a civvie. You've listened to too many true-crime and cold-case podcasts and now think you know enough to be an amateur sleuth. Each night, you can track one player of your choice and learn the name of any player they used a power on that night.
You are DOMINIC MARASCO, a civvie. You don't want any trouble in the neighborhood, so you take it upon yourself to patrol the neighborhood from time to time while armed. You are a one-shot civvie-aligned vigilante. You must use your one-shot power on or before Night 3 o else you will be rendered vanilla.
ROBERT VITALE, a civvie. You are such a kind neighbor that an elderly homeowner in Piano Estates has asked you to be their proxy vote any time the need arises. As such, your vote is worth two each day.
DOMINIC MARASCO, a civvie. You don't want any trouble in the neighborhood, so you take it upon yourself to patrol the neighborhood from time to time while armed. You are a one-shot civvie-aligned vigilante. You must use your one-shot power on or before Night 3 or else you will be rendered vanilla.
VIC MAGAZINO, a civvie. You are a bodyguard. Each night you may select one player to protect. All powers used on that player during the night will hit you instead.
LUCA FONTANA, a civvie. You were recently forced into retirement from the police force for a few too many instances of bad paperwork. You're sure of your instincts, even if they aren't the best. Each night you can check one player of your choice to see if they are mafia. You have a 50% chance of the result being correct.
MARTIN DELUCA, a civvie. You are an up-and-comer who is trying to fit in. As such, you tend to be a copycat of everyone else around you in order to fit in. Each day phase, you may select one player whose power you would like to copy. After the eviction post, you will be told what power you have copied and you may use it on any other player you like that night only.
VINCE GAROFALO, a civvie. You are newly retired and bored out of your mind. As such, you have taken up people-watching. Each night, you can watch any player of your choice, thereby learning the names of any players targeting them that night.
ANTHONY TESTA, a civvie. You are a successful doctor, and you can use your skills to protect one player each night. Your protection will shield your target from any other powers targeting them that night.