The Syndicate

Secret: nobody knows how to play mafia. We just pretend.

I have some rules too, like I don't lynch or kill site newcomers in the first cycle. But that's more of a courtesy thing. And I'm willing to throw that rule away if it becomes clear it's critical to the gameplay, but normally it's not.

If you are mafia you should be willing to lie and fool people. You should also be willing to kill everyone in the player list, as well as spare them if it's necessary. That's the premise of the game. If you blow those things on purpose you are kind of breaking the game's balance.

In case it wasn't clear my previous post wasn't meant at anyone in specific. I kind of fell in here with a parachute.

Long Con wrote: ↑Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:47 pm

dunya wrote: ↑Tue Oct 16, 2018 7:24 pm Uh, I don't think a person's integrity should ever be questioned when lying as a mafioso.

And I don't think a mafia team's win should ever be questioned because they didn't kill off inactives instead of active players. That's a load of poop, I'm sorry

Then no one should be cleared for the idea that they would never kill active players or something like that. That's what was happening in this game. I agree with you 100%.

Well, I supposed you should drop the "I would never do X as a mafioso" stuff then. A lot of people have certain things they say they'd never do, and it kind of breaks the immersion of the game. That's akin to having a truth meta.

Hey people, don't forget to sign up for the next Full Game: Hogwarts Mafia! The Harry Potter game that's not actually a Harry Potter game.

http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 68#p488468