The Syndicate

Where I left off, but with a few more days of info.. Some thoughts before I go too in depth over the next day: - Elo is reading slightly civ for me right now. Whereas Day 1 was full of shenanigans and Jesus toast all around, I'm not convinced right now that she would have had a hand in Sloonei's dea...

Thanks Mr. Manhattan sir! I hope to not fail you in my return from hibernation! :srsnod: Hey all! Thought I was done for, so I've been only scanning the thread the past few days. I will indeed do some catchup for tomorrow and get the ball rolling on some general things I've been thinking, but first ...

Also, to FZ and Scotty. Sorry. FZ could legitimately be Jekyll & Hyde. Given MM's interpretation of the Night 8 kill, I thought that I couldn't with 100% certainly call Scotty civ either. Sloonei was the person whose alignment I felt most certain of. That was the deciding factor for me. All of ...

DharmaHelper wrote:Hey everybody who didn't vote : Fuck you guys

i voted

Elohcin wrote:I also wonder about Scotty for reasons others have stated.

I wonder about myself all the time, so don't sweat it

In the same boat as splints (except for the whole camping part). Would love for this to start soon before it picks up and gets busy again!!

Sigh. NK'd on night 1 again. Good luck all...

Well MM, are you mafia? Just an honest question looking for an honest answer.

Your involvement (or non-involvement in this case) is purely another facet of a case that you could be bad. You weren't the only person to not mention or interact with Sloonei, so that is a very minor point I was making. I don't understand how ninja can be one of your top suspects because she "...

I want to hear from: Golden on his name being brought up by GMan and others. LongCon to answer my question MP on my response to his last response. And if he has anything to say about being one of the first people to find something fishy on Sloonei, then completely pull back. MM, Link to Scotty's lon...

I'm voting for the Comedian’s gun. I also think I will be voting MM day one. He always seems like he is bad. lol Thats was a joke. That was a terrible joke. No offense. I'm looking forward to what you have to offer in Day 1, Bass. Oh hey, I forgot to address this. It's an inside joke, kind of. Bass...

I went through Scotty's posts to see what all the fuss is about. What I got is that he estabilished a method of choosing suspects from the start, which was looking at the list of players who had a low number of posts, and then picking the most suspicious one among them. He voted Elo because of that...

Also a heads up that I will be up to my neck in work in the mountains with spotty reception on Saturday from 6am to 3am. Call it- a suicide shift. That being said, I will only be able to come in on a bathroom break to vote. This is not where I want to be at this point in the game, as I feel like I ...

Also a heads up that I will be up to my neck in work in the mountains with spotty reception on Saturday from 6am to 3am. Call it- a suicide shift. That being said, I will only be able to come in on a bathroom break to vote. This is not where I want to be at this point in the game, as I feel like I ...

Link to Scotty's long post. I didn't feel like quoting the whole thing. Scotty, question for you. Do you just not trust me, or do you think that I am actually mafia? These two are very different things, and to take a leaf out of llama's book, that sounds like a "soft" accusation. You put ...

Did anyone else notice how Elo seemingly jumped onto a vibes-based suspicion of Sloonei (which I held), and then dropped it, after I dropped it? What do folks think of that? I'm not sure what to make of Elo right now. It did stand out to me that she worded her suspicion roughly the same way you did...

So at the risk of adding fuel to the engine of what may be a forming bandwagon, something Scotty said right before the lynch pinged me, but it wasn't any of the stuff MP was talking about. Here it is: I still don't understand the "buddying". If my offhand comment about agreeing with MP's ...

thellama73 wrote:Yes, but people who talked a lot at Night had a bad habit of dying in Guess WHo,so you'll have to wait to hear about them.

oops.

Looking at MM, since I don't trust him. I have to leave for work, so I will vote now so to not risk missing the deadline. I will vote nijuukyugou, but in reality I don't have any strong baddie reads on anyone. Understandable that he had to make work. At least he admits he felt wishy-washy over the w...

thellama73 wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Day 1's are a crapshoot.
Not when you have supatown llama on the case, they ain't.

Since you're probably the most civ-looking here, do you have any new suspects on your radar?

I will add that I am not attempting to tunnel into you, MP. I think it has been a lot of my defensive neurotics talking, but I do spot some hypocrisy in your vote for me. You very well may have made up your mind on me, but I can assure you that I am not mafia, and I suggest looking at other people a...

My responses in Purple (In spoiler because it's long) Here is my response to Scotty in bolded cyan : Here's the skivvy. Bass said I was buddying up with MP early on for giving an agreement on day 1 philosophies. Then I went to work. While I was away, Bass asked me why I haven't voted yet (that was w...

Holy cow. I was NOT expecting that. Wooooooooo good going guys! I didn't suspect Sloonei at all.

Which makes me feel worse that I didn't catch that read, but I guess that comes with the territory.

Nice picture, Llama! Scotty, my bad, didn't realize you were unfamiliar with the terminology. OMGUS and NO U are essentially the same. OMGUS stands for "Oh My God You Suck", which was popularized in the greater mafia community, whereas NO U tended to be what was always used in my mafia hi...

MovingPictures07 wrote:Nice OMGUS/NO U, Scotty.

Nonetheless, I appreciate your response. Let me address it.

I don't know what that means. No U= Reverse psychology?

linki- you look lovely, Agent Alpaca

Elo, thanks! How about: Where are you leaning for your vote today? Has it changed at all? Linki with Ninja If no one was finding me suspicious, I would most likely vote for G-man or sloonei (I know I said I would table my thoughts on sloonei). But, I am still back and forth on sloonei. He now finds...

I'm voting Scotty . G-Man and Ninja can wait. I feel most comfortable with this. I am doing my best in the time frame, but unfortunately I will nto be able to explain myself further in the matter of 5 minutes. I will link more to attempt to explain myself in a bit, if i don;t get killed STOP LINKI

Because LC is not necessarily a no-show. He hasn't posted today, for sure, but I feel like there is more to be said of how little quality Ehlo has posted, and considering her doublespeak when it comes to Day 1 philosophies, where she is committing the thing she talked about disagreeing with.

I'm going to go ahead and vote Scotty. His buddying up to MP pinged me at first. MP pointed out that Scotty has been part of the discussion with out throwing out any of his own suspects. He also made a big deal about me voting late in B.O.B and he has yet to vote so I found that odd. I'll give you ...

I'm still combing through 5 more pages to respond to, and I will, but for now, I'm voting Ehlo. Someone asked if DDL seemed "comfortable" and I don't really know what that means in respect to DDL because no one was really suspecting him. But ehlo's recent response seems comfortable and jok...

Guys, I think G-Man is bad. Discuss. Things that start with G: Guilty-Man Greedy-Man Ghastly-Man Gestapo-Man Glib-Man Good-Man I'd wager one of those is right. Also, he hasn't posted many pictures this game. Like 1 or so. Isn't he known for pictures? Or am I just getting bad info? From where are yo...

Scotty, you have been active in the discussion and prodded a lot of people. Surely you must have quite a few things to say about players at this point. Who are your suspectd in this early phase? Why? It appears I will be gone for work by the time you get back to answer this. Still reading, and feel...

Woah. I just got off work and didn't realize that day ended at 9p! Thought it was at 10...I'm catching up now

If espers shows up, I want to know if he (she?) also received something, since they both voted for Manhattan's lab.

Bathroom break over, back to work.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Ricochet wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Golden wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:So did anyone get anything from the day zero poll?
I did not.
I did.
Anything you can share with us?
No.

There's the MM I remember from BoB. Intentionally vague and unhelpful when questioned about outside information.

Why even comment about it at all?

for instance, if a talkative player was contributing a lot on Day 1 but says something fishy, isn't there merit in lynching that person over someone who posts little more than "yay game" and "catching up"? I'm not suggesting lynching a "good player" because they are a ...

G-Man wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
G-Man wrote:I've got about 10 more minutes before I unplug for the night. Any questions?
Are you a member of mafia?
I am not a member of the mafia.
I am not Moloch.
My role does not pose a threat to the civvies.

If you're going to be straight up, why phrase it like that? Are you trying to be NK'd?

A policy lynch of a complete no-show is practically the only one I will support. I hope that doesn't happen here though. You're telling me you've never voted low posters for the sake of them being low posters? Personally, I have a "policy no-lynch". Which is, I avoid lynching on d1 people...

So hey Epi, I don't know if it's possible but can we get a post on the front page with the players' full post in the thread like we had in BoB? I'm not entirely sure how to format that. Of course. I fathered that trend, after all. :) I generally do it once Day 1 is underway. mahhh neighbah :slick: ...

I don't think G-Man is suspicious because, at this point, I don't suspect anyone's posts to be suspicious. Also, I don't remember who's posted what in the thread because there are so many people to keep track of, therefore, anyone who might have been suspicious would have been more memorable (or th...

Llama , I agree that G-Man's phrasing in several posts, including this one, have been odd, as if he can't justify lying outright. However, wouldn't that quickly sink him if he actually is mafia? Would he play it that riskily? In addition, is it possible that G-Man has rather unconventional and lite...

Hey MP! I see you're one of those wordy, verbose types always with a smile on your face. You remind me of that big-eyed, bushy-tailed front desk attendant at the gym today. She was positively beaming when I walked in, so I asked her if she was recently hired, and she said she was the manager of tha...

Hey MP! I see you're one of those wordy, verbose types always with a smile on your face. You remind me of that big-eyed, bushy-tailed front desk attendant at the gym today. She was positively beaming when I walked in, so I asked her if she was recently hired, and she said she was the manager of tha...

nijuukyugou wrote:WHAT HAVE YOU ALL DONE WHY ARE THERE ALREADY 7 PAGES

I'm going to bed. I'll catch up with this tomorrow

You know, I've been in bed now for 2 hours. One of the biggest mistakes I ever made was bringing my laptop with me. Good on you, ninja

Hey MP! I see you're one of those wordy, verbose types always with a smile on your face. You remind me of that big-eyed, bushy-tailed front desk attendant at the gym today. She was positively beaming when I walked in, so I asked her if she was recently hired, and she said she was the manager of that...

That feel when you know all the answers but you can't do anything about it

Gosh darn it. And right before trivia too :/

Thanks for a fun game Dom! Have fun everyone!

The answer to the 3rd trivia question is 3. 3 Tony Nominations and 3 half-assed double pirouettes during the 11 oclock number

Gonna look into Hedgeowl. So many creepy quiet players in this game. She sorta disappeared after Day 6. Most of her game was her dealing with the anxiety of catching up every time she'd come in. I had her as genuinely flustered all the time, and light civ. Probably on the play level of Tiny Bubbles...

I no longer suspect MM

Search found 16824 matches