Don’t think I like it.
Back to role
Madness for me!

Return to “[Mafia Win] Tongue-Tied Mafia”
I’ve really changed my tune on low posting. Whereas I used to just try and eliminate that as early as possible, low posting can still yield quality reads and it isn’t a defacto suspicion.fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 5:07 pm Thank you for hosting @Syn
I obviously had periods of inactivity due to RL. Glad I could be here for the end.
@Scotty was a major spanner in the mix lol he seemed to see right through all of us
I hated having to hammer @Roxy i still maintain that low posting isn’t necessarily evil
Damn. It made the most sense.fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 5:04 pmAbsolutely her ability to read me and Dennis, plus she’s just good. Biggest threat. We hated it, but it made the most sense
Nah. We almost had it. We flipped a coin and the coin landed wrong. It happens
Oh wow I didn’t even see thatfalcon45ca wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:46 pm I put Neon at 3, def in hammer range for a moment, and nothing happened.
By my estimation falcon is compatible. Splints is also compatible.Lemonfairy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:46 pmNeon pushed a low-poster? (is Roxy a low poster?)I don't really think Roxy is an easy slot to push
splints would be an easier push tbh
me on D1 was an easy push
who do you think are Neon's partners then?
if you can't find anyone, that might be indication that they're town
Tell me more about neonfingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:36 pmAll over the place falcon.I don’t want the mafia to manipulate this vote
Be careful
I think lemon is saying they’re not looking to read responses to suspicion. You had some moments today where you have been proactive in looking at other people, but outright defending yourself is what I think the bolded is talking aboutRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:31 pmwhy bother?Lemonfairy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:23 pmI was busy :cRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:21 pmare you even playing this game?Lemonfairy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:17 pm someone explain what is happening with the falcon/splits wagons lol
lol
what's your case on Neon?
you already said you would not be reading any of my posts because it was just me responding to suspicions. Which you said you would not read.
Lemonfairy wrote: ↑Fri Mar 31, 2023 12:11 pmI never really care about responses to suspicion tbh
I find it unhelpful most of the time
what I would like to know is probably who your top townreads are rn and why
and ig if there's been any change to your POE and reasons
plus if there's any relevant meta about you I should know that might have influenced my read, e.g., if there's anything you look for specifically, do you look for town first or scum first, etc.
I don't think that's true
I don't think I have been dismissive of you but I haven't tried to interact with you and that's my problem
I think the questions I asked above are probably a good start
if you have anything you want to ask of me, feel free to
I seem to remember Kate saying once that Roxy can be a bit more aggressive as town.Lemonfairy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:27 pmwhy?Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:25 pmI’m getting nervous there won’t be a toniteLemonfairy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:22 pm Scotty, if you live past tonight, I will suddenly paranoia-scumread you and build my next mafia team around you while ignoring all of my previous reads
I thought Roxy's reaction felt kind of outing
someone more familiar with Roxy's meta chime in and tell me if they usually react like this as town when being pushed or not
Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 8:36 amNeon wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 8:13 amHere we haveRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 6:12 am I am really getting tired of coming here time after time just to say I am town. Everyone seems to be after an easy miselim and thats ok if you just want to get the game over with, ya know, without actually trying to solve.
![]()
Neon's constant push on me without bothering to give real reasons or responses shows me she just does not gaf about the towns game state. If she was town she would look at my posts and reevaluate as she has been wrong about me in literally every game we have played together. You have very little content past your initial tunneling of Dennis then switched to me I guess believing I'll be easier to push bc I post less. You bad Neon.![]()
I am disappointed in Scotty as he hosted me and should completely understand my game style but alas he can't look past Neon's imv case against me.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
I will make a post about suspicions but quite frankly does it really fucking matter as you all claim I have no content but I guess Porscha has content bc she has more posts but zero content but ok.
I have tons of work but I'll be back asp.
AtE
AtE
Incorrect interpretations of my play
AtE
And attacks on my ability to read Roxy that aren't even really thar true.
Very towny reentry.
Here we have
AtE
AtE
Incorrect interpretations of my play
AtE
And attacks Neon's ability to read me which is ABSOLUTELY true. She cannot! Look it up!
Not a very towny post trying determine if what she thinks is actually true. She has NOT EVEN TRIED to once say "hey I could be wrong let me re-think this'
This is why she is bad. Her partners will be fs and lemon. HK/Dennis last choice.
splints bc believe it or not she has tried this game more than the last couple.
lemon bc they are not bothering to re-evaluate
ofc neither is Scotty or most of the thread how sad the wolves have lead every elim so far and the town is just like ok no prob you can win bc we won't bother trying.
I'll be easy bc I have an actual life and cannot hang on the computer all day and must work and spend time with people who matter in my life. I am an In the Mud veggie. LHF. Easy pickings.
Every fucking time.
Even with people who hosted me AND played with me are refusing to read me properly - you know properly - like reading my actual posts and suspicions.
I will never change wg=hy should I none of you do.
Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 8:41 am ]ot]lol now it'll be she is spicy, she is ate, she is yadda yadda yadda stfu
DO NOT READ EMOTIONS into my posts.
I am giggling and having fun always.
I have no need to appeal to anyone's emotions as I dgaf about them as this is a game and if you are so invested that you might cry or be insulted back slowly out of the thread and cry into your pillow instead bc I am playing a game and having a bit of fun.[/ot]
I’m getting nervous there won’t be a toniteLemonfairy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:22 pm Scotty, if you live past tonight, I will suddenly paranoia-scumread you and build my next mafia team around you while ignoring all of my previous reads
Neon isn’t as damning, personally. Which is why this is so hard.fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:22 pmI’m really torn about this but I think it’s Rox. This interaction:Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:14 pmCan you look into neon? It’s probably neon or Roxy. Who would you vote?fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:13 pmKid still crazy.who do you want my insight to? I’ll try to respond ASAP
I would love to still look at Neon a little more. If someone can please summarise the case. I’d love to compare more. This is crunch time
Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:20 pmwhere is the AtE? Point it out. BC I am deffo not doing that.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:16 pmUsing a ton of AtE. I think that’s a fair assessment todayRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:52 pmwtf does calling me prickly mean?Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:49 pmRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:43 pmbut she really only posted gif's in response to Kate's challenge against her with gifs.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:37 pm I’ve been doing some digging into Neon’s past few games.
Felt, Lawyers, Holes.
She feels more like Holes in this game. Which was her mafia game.
But there’s some doubts I have. Firstly, this is a low post cap game. I’m sure even town Neon would have a hard time flourishing, so using these as guideposts isn’t the best comparison.
In Holes she had a bit more of a shruggy stance with one liner posts- less malleable gif posting and less solving.
She has a good amount of gif posting here, and her solving is not as strong as her showings as the town Neon I see in those games. It’s a tough call.
Dennis voting for Neon here is freeing. I think Dennis is town
It lasted not even all of Day 1 and there has been zero gif posts by Neon since then.
Her gif posting stooped dead when Kate was Nk'ed.
Nice try at a possible save there Scotty now get off that fence and voteIf you think I’m trying to coordinate a save, you aren’t paying attention.
Conversely, I see in your iso a slight difference in tone in this game when compared to felt. You seem to be more verbose and not as prickly in that game where you were mafia compared to this one
Using a ton of AtE. I think that’s a fair assessment todayRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:52 pmwtf does calling me prickly mean?Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:49 pmRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:43 pmbut she really only posted gif's in response to Kate's challenge against her with gifs.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:37 pm I’ve been doing some digging into Neon’s past few games.
Felt, Lawyers, Holes.
She feels more like Holes in this game. Which was her mafia game.
But there’s some doubts I have. Firstly, this is a low post cap game. I’m sure even town Neon would have a hard time flourishing, so using these as guideposts isn’t the best comparison.
In Holes she had a bit more of a shruggy stance with one liner posts- less malleable gif posting and less solving.
She has a good amount of gif posting here, and her solving is not as strong as her showings as the town Neon I see in those games. It’s a tough call.
Dennis voting for Neon here is freeing. I think Dennis is town
It lasted not even all of Day 1 and there has been zero gif posts by Neon since then.
Her gif posting stooped dead when Kate was Nk'ed.
Nice try at a possible save there Scotty now get off that fence and voteIf you think I’m trying to coordinate a save, you aren’t paying attention.
Conversely, I see in your iso a slight difference in tone in this game when compared to felt. You seem to be more verbose and not as prickly in that game where you were mafia compared to this one
Can you look into neon? It’s probably neon or Roxy. Who would you vote?fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 4:13 pmKid still crazy.who do you want my insight to? I’ll try to respond ASAP
I mean it’s not like no gifs = wolf neon. It’s a bit of a simplistic generalization of the games I was looking at, but her lack of gesticulation and bouncing around on reads is different for sureRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:50 pm @Scotty my post was tragically mauled by spellchecker.
summary:
Stop trying to save Neon.
She never posted ANY gif's after Kate was NK'ed
She only posted 10 gif's out of 50+ posts Day 1
She has not posted gif's since then.
Get off the fence and show your true alignment Scotty.
Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:43 pmbut she really only posted gif's in response to Kate's challenge against her with gifs.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 3:37 pm I’ve been doing some digging into Neon’s past few games.
Felt, Lawyers, Holes.
She feels more like Holes in this game. Which was her mafia game.
But there’s some doubts I have. Firstly, this is a low post cap game. I’m sure even town Neon would have a hard time flourishing, so using these as guideposts isn’t the best comparison.
In Holes she had a bit more of a shruggy stance with one liner posts- less malleable gif posting and less solving.
She has a good amount of gif posting here, and her solving is not as strong as her showings as the town Neon I see in those games. It’s a tough call.
Dennis voting for Neon here is freeing. I think Dennis is town
It lasted not even all of Day 1 and there has been zero gif posts by Neon since then.
Her gif posting stooped dead when Kate was Nk'ed.
Nice try at a possible save there Scotty now get off that fence and vote
Falcon’s not going over today, bub.
Yes.
I think the thread state doesn’t allow for both of them to be t/t.Dennis wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 2:55 pmI believe they said they're going to be busy today last night and the prospect of someone lying for a reason to avoid talking feels dirty as hellScotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:38 pm What would y’all do if I just voted lemonfairy here?
They’ve been very vocal all game, and we get to mylo just to hang back?
Lemon is not bad in a world where Roxy is bad.
This is why it’s very important that we figure out Roxy.
Lemon suspects Roxy
Neon suspects Roxy
Those 2 have been a block consolidation since D2 in that regard. This would fit with HK and falcon’s theory that Wilgy was killed to frame Roxy today.
Dennis, splints and HK, I need your further input on Roxy
She has been mostly on the defensive. The problem is I want to read her how she is asking us to-her reads and the like. She gave one reads list today that felt somewhat shallow compared to what I normally see from her but unfortunately that's kind of it other than her Neon blitz, which we can only really get so much from
She told me to read her posts about lemon and I haven't gotten to it yet but I really do wish people could just like, summarize their case instead of telling me to go searching
And while you're here, what's your read of Neon, independent from roxy's alignment? Cause I think your townread relies almost entirely on Roxy being bad
I agree. I think one of you are bad, and the town needs to either select you or neon. Gonna do more of a deep dive into neon’s isoRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:51 pmok then.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:44 pmI feel like I want honesty, honestlyRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:41 pmdo you want an hoest answer here or do you want to care about.....feelings?Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:38 pm What would y’all do if I just voted lemonfairy here?
They’ve been very vocal all game, and we get to mylo just to hang back?
Lemon is not bad in a world where Roxy is bad.
This is why it’s very important that we figure out Roxy.
Lemon suspects Roxy
Neon suspects Roxy
Those 2 have been a block consolidation since D2 in that regard. This would fit with HK and falcon’s theory that Wilgy was killed to frame Roxy today.
Dennis, splints and HK, I need your further input on Roxy
I feel like if you go after fairy BEFORE Neon you are kind of a chicken.
Why, you may ask?
Bc Neon was the first to vote me for no reasons then fairy glommed on. Both have no reasons. Neon just says it's bc of AtE but I have consistently, constantly asked why with zero fucks given from her only to get AtE AtE AtE.
Since when is wanting a reason for a vote an AtE??
I am appealing to REASONING!
Neon need to be solved first bc fairy is lhf and can be easily elimmed next if/when Neon is proven bad.
I feel like I want honesty, honestlyRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:41 pmdo you want an hoest answer here or do you want to care about.....feelings?Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:38 pm What would y’all do if I just voted lemonfairy here?
They’ve been very vocal all game, and we get to mylo just to hang back?
Lemon is not bad in a world where Roxy is bad.
This is why it’s very important that we figure out Roxy.
Lemon suspects Roxy
Neon suspects Roxy
Those 2 have been a block consolidation since D2 in that regard. This would fit with HK and falcon’s theory that Wilgy was killed to frame Roxy today.
Dennis, splints and HK, I need your further input on Roxy
Hi splints!fingersplints wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:37 pmYou know I’m town. No one can read me better than you. And yes the reality it seems is that we will always be the “LHF” because of the amount we post. My performance has been less than stellar this game, due to RL reasons which I obvi don’t want to get into again as I’m playing, or attempting to play, as a distraction. I’ve low posted (which is completely normal for me). And I’ve made some bad votes, but I don’t think I was ever the deciding vote on any of those and I can further explain my mindset in voting those later if it is so desired. We haven’t collectively had a good vote this game and while I know I’m late to the party, we can still work togetherRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:51 pm fingersplints - I think you are town but it has come down to one of us and I know I am town without having to think about it. TBF tho I think this proposition from the town about lhf will *always* bite them in the ass. I never want to call you bad in any game bc I enjoy playing with you this ius why I will mostly keep my suspicions to my self inre: You.
I love that Scotty has come in this game. I think this fresh mindset is just what the town needed. And I see I have mentions but I’m preparing dinner and what not. Should be around soon.will try to answer what I can but if it’s really important just mention me again so I see it quicker
I do want to say quickly. Do not sleep. Doesn’t that just give the wolves an extra night? I always hate the sleep option but especially when we are in this condition.
You expounded on it *after* I questioned your reads and after you told me in no uncertain terms ‘I already explained my suspicions, just look in the thread’Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:23 pmbut I did expound on it within my new list even tho my reasoning is still the same tbh.Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:21 pmAbsolutely not being mean. It’s a gross exaggeration of how far back these suspicions have been in the scope of this short game.Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:16 pmI didn't say it was against my low posting but you acted like it was a great trial to read my 35 posts. And what about the "quality" as of late??Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:04 pmIt’s not an indictment on the *quantity* of posts. It’s the *quality* of them as of late.Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:57 pmScotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:14 pmyou…did?
Ok let me comb through your posts from 78 years ago
Somewhere in the bowels of D2:Your only mention of HK
Early in D1:Is that it?my poe:
…
Dennis bc of your convo with Neon felt forced when questioned you back tracked and gave non response answers. It is like sig said you seem to be trying to find a suspicion with tmi…
dude I literally only have 35 posts it's not like I had a 1000![]()
You literally just said your opinions have changed over the game RE saying you had Neon town feels, and are getting defensive for mentioning some distant suspicions that you haven’t talked about since the start of the Byzantine Empire was still around
hence my new list honestly I do not what more you expect of me, you keep making remarks about how far back you had to go to read a few posts you do realize this only D 3 and you are being quite dramatic about having to read an iso or three.
Unless your jokes about 78 years ago.... and Byzantine Empire are you just being mean.
You get what I’m saying tho right? Like when you say you distantly suspect Dennis today and indirectly reference a read you had of him towards the beginning of D1 instead of expounding on that read, that is worth a![]()
k, so in that case you would never suspect splints here. She should be a townlockRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:18 pmScotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:56 pmThanks. This was a nice comprehensive listRoxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:51 pm Dennis - idk, but I have a bad feeling you are bad. It just feels like you are trying without any effort.
falcon45ca - usually when we are town together I find I agree with you on most everything you post but alas you are voting me even tho you think I am town. Now I ask is that really townie?
fingersplints - I think you are town but it has come down to one of us and I know I am town without having to think about it. TBF tho I think this proposition from the town about lhf will *always* bite them in the ass. I never want to call you bad in any game bc I enjoy playing with you this ius why I will mostly keep my suspicions to my self inre: You.
hollowkatt - I felt you were bad with the opening post of yours Day 1 but since then (btw you never responded to my suspicion) you have posted things I find myself agreeing with more often than not.
Lemonfairy - no real substance just glossing over things. Thats your style so who am I to tell you how to play? But I do think you are a bad fairy.
Neon - if you do not know by now are we even playing the same game? She thinks I have called her town when I never have. I said townish feels on D 1 we are now D 3 and things have changed bc I thread educate myself every new day.
sig / Scotty - was unsure about sig all game and only threw him into town based on feels on D 1 bc we have played so many times together. I needed a minute to gauge him correctly. I am now even more unsure than I was.
No I am deffo not sure who the baddies are I think Neon and fairy bc they have never given actual reasons for their read on me. Fairy even said they will not read my responses as they do not help them or change their mind.
do I know the last one? Not really just a shot in the dark which I am not ready to make yet.
When you said on D2 that mafia would be avoiding the pyxxy wagon on D1 at all costs, are you still behind that?
Absolutely not being mean. It’s a gross exaggeration of how far back these suspicions have been in the scope of this short game.Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:16 pmI didn't say it was against my low posting but you acted like it was a great trial to read my 35 posts. And what about the "quality" as of late??Scotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 1:04 pmIt’s not an indictment on the *quantity* of posts. It’s the *quality* of them as of late.Roxy wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:57 pmScotty wrote: ↑Mon Apr 03, 2023 12:14 pmyou…did?
Ok let me comb through your posts from 78 years ago
Somewhere in the bowels of D2:Your only mention of HKRoxy wrote: ↑Thu Mar 30, 2023 11:01 amThis reminds me of another game with Creature who made these sort of posts. I called them out I was mis-elimmed and Creature ended winning with his mafia pals. This post makes me think you are bad also.hollowkatt wrote: ↑Wed Mar 29, 2023 5:54 pm wow bold shows up for dirt on this forum. anyways it's porscha, wigly, sig, lemon, roxy, falcon, finger and of those I'm inclined to think sig and wigly are the most town![]()
Early in D1:Is that it?my poe:
…
Dennis bc of your convo with Neon felt forced when questioned you back tracked and gave non response answers. It is like sig said you seem to be trying to find a suspicion with tmi…
dude I literally only have 35 posts it's not like I had a 1000![]()
You literally just said your opinions have changed over the game RE saying you had Neon town feels, and are getting defensive for mentioning some distant suspicions that you haven’t talked about since the start of the Byzantine Empire was still around
hence my new list honestly I do not what more you expect of me, you keep making remarks about how far back you had to go to read a few posts you do realize this only D 3 and you are being quite dramatic about having to read an iso or three.
Unless your jokes about 78 years ago.... and Byzantine Empire are you just being mean.