Sloonei wrote:sig wrote:Dyslexicon wrote:Hi!
Hello.
Sloonei wrote:Sig came in and tried to drag as much content out of things as he could. I'd like that if it didn't feel like such an effort to distance oneself from the label of low participation or scumminess.
Let's VOTE SIG
You'd usually like it but, don't this time? That doesn't make much sense.Also it is weird seeing how this is the beginning of day 1 so how would I be labeled as low participation if I hadn't had made any posts after my first one?
So why is it scummy that I'm posting and trying to get some content, since from where I sit it looks like your trying to stifle discussion.
![Eye :eye:](./images/smilies/Eye.png)
I am not trying to stifle any discussion. That is a strange thing to accuse me of. What I didn't like about your posts is that they seemed like an easy opportunistic set of early observations when there wasn't a whole lot of content to analyze. It's a good and easy way to establish yourself early on as a town leader. I don't feel like the content in the thread prior to your string of posts warranted everything you said.
Okay I understand your point here, however I'd disagree that I'm asd mafia trying to establish myself as a town leader, for two reasons. One I'm not mafia and two I'm not trying to be a leader, they always get Nk'd and I like living. :P
Sloonei wrote:Zexy wrote:I’m not that sure IAWY’s entrance in the thread was towny, sig. But it’s not necessarily scummy either. Thanks for the meta advice on MP.
Can someone give us meta on Long Con? That’s a strange entrance they make there, but it feels like it’s their thing.
Sloonei, do you know sig well enough to consider their actions as scummy? I can see your points, but if it’s something sig does regardless of alignment we need to cut some slack. Sig gave thoughts on Sloonei and I can't say I disagree either.
sig is usually an active player, but I can't recall any time he's made that many early posts with so little content preceding him.
I think you're right here, on TS I don't usually make so many quick fire posts that early. However, I had some things I wanted to talk about and was gauging people so I decided to do it. Besides I enjoyed EST mafia where I was slightly more involved and did some real game solving so I want to play the same way here. Also something more important to keep in mind, we usually start with Day 0 and I rarely post on Day 0s.
Frog wrote:Sup! I randed Town so GG.
I'll read what you guys have posted so far, but insofar as tempo control to immediately move out of the RVS stage, I'm going to bring up a polarizing strategy related question:
I've JUST finished a C12 match on MU where many vanillagers were fake claiming TPRs, and fake counter claiming TPRs all over the place. Some of them worked, some of them didn't. Those that didn't work were because of a cognitive dissonance between players. With this in mind, if you are town reading a player, and they fake claim a power role, would you counter claim them?
Furthermore, with respect to claims, I'm planning on following this format every day:
If I'm X role, I did this N1, N2, N3, etc.
If I'm Y role, I did this N1, N2, N3, etc.
If I'm Z role, I did this N1, N2, N3, etc.
So in most games TS will punish role claiming with death
(thanks Mp/Daisy
:P) while this isn't the case in this game I'd say it is something to keep in mind. While discussing claiming.
I myself am very against claiming in almost all cases. Especially fake claims. This throws the thread into chaos and would help the mafia when those who truly have the role your claiming counterclaim and get Nk'd or lynched. Even if this doesn't happen if people claim and divert the thread it will aid the mafia/ So the fact you're suggesting this does ping me a bit. However, I do recognize that it isn't necessary scummy to be pro claiming.
To answer your question, if someone I'm town reading claims my role I'd suspect them to be mafia, role hunting. The only time it is okay to claim is if you're about to get lynched, or if you've got a red check on a player.
Dyslexicon is funny so far, I mistrust that. Will be keeping an eye on him.
Also I don't find it strange he claimed town, I do dislike his role claiming idea.