My scum suspects so far are:Ron Swanson wrote:Ann is dropping out of my radar as well. Her contribution to Day 2 turned out to be empty, since she never made it back to change anything. I'd inquire if she can sum up her suspects for right now, since I don't remember much of her stance upon perusing the posts. On the hand, I also felt that she had been bitting my ass because she's uncomfortable with the roleplay ratio. Nothing I can do about that, however, woman. I'm Ron ***ing Swanson. But at least it's good to get on the same page of all that messy exchange.
Chris has been my top read so far (sorry I know this seems like the easy way out). But I did voice my opinion earlier today, before the votes:
(I said Craig, but meant Chris)Ann Perkins wrote:I find it interesting that 2 of the people I am suspecting, Donna & Craig, voted to tie up to the vote on Leslie. But... Mafia wouldn't all vote to save Leslie, right? Has Donna/Craig/Leslie even communicated with eachother in this game?? I mean, if Mafia has a day chat, they might forget to talk in THIS day chat.
In any case, I'm going to start the day with a vote on Leslie. I wouldn't mind a Chris lynch today either.
Sorry I wasn't able to check in at the end of the day, was out with the fam. There was no "unvote" option yesterday, so I couldn't unvote Ron; Ron definitely has stepped it up yesterday, in my eyes, in towniness. I know other players always thought he was town, but I'm just not used to players roleplaying x.x throws me off. Ron questioning me, and accepting some answers but not others to things I have said/done really helped me getting over my tunnelvision on the guy. Sorry Ron
ps. you DID claim Citizen twice :P
Chris, can you give us a read on Leslie & Donna?
Donna, can you give a read on Chris & Leslie?
Leslie...? Same thing.
One reason I suspect Chris is one of the same reasons I suspected you, earlier, Ron: using roleplay as a crutch. Almost seems like it's occasionally used to brush off accusations or downplay the severity of the posts. In the posts there are isn't any roleplay, Chris seems really defensive, like when I questioned if him, Donna & Leslie even have communicated in the entire thread at all. He immediately shot down the thought, and accused it of being bad logic. I don't see how something like this is bad logic, as it is entirely possible. I'm not saying it guarantees those three being Mafia, was just trying to form some discussion around it.
I also don't really like how after I start a post stating I'm kind of on the fence w/ Chris, he does an ISO which miraculously changes his opinion on me. I see this as a mild form of buddying.
Also, for someone who posts massive walls of information, his reads on Leslie and Donna that he gave where lack luster.
"As far as Donna Meagle is concerned, she is an exemplary Parks Employee, but her performance this game has been lacking and I don't like that such a low poster came in and called me blendy. It seems too easy considering that Ron and April were very outspoken in their inaccurate accusations that I have only been role playing and not contributing anything to the game. More on that in a bit."
- This isn't really a read on Donna, it's just him stating some points about the slot. His read on Donna turns into a comment about Ron & April. Not cool
"Leslie's accusations have seemed to be too blatantly inaccurate for me to think she actually is mafia. With her activity in the thread, if she were bad I would expect her accusations to be something that could gain more traction. I mean clearly April was civ, her comments about it being a stretch to call her a confirmed civ were either an attempt to protect April from the inevitable night kill or just plain being obtuse. Either way, I don't see a case for her being a member of the mafia team."
- While this read is a little more than his read on Donna, is it still lacking. If anything, I would assume that playing in the "middle ground" of the game, attempting to look helpful, while not really bringing enough attention on herself as a Town Leader is more of a Mafia read than a Town read. But I guess we can have different opinions. Just personally find it odd that his read on someone who he saved with his vote is Town.
There are my opinions on the slots in this game:
Scummiest: Chris Traeger
Second: Donna Meagle
Third: Leslie Knope
Very close fourth: Andy Dwyer
Mid-ground, town lean: Ron Swanson
Reads like a Civ: Bobby Newport
Town read : Ben Wyatt
These three haven't really done much for me to really gather an opinion. I would say that these people are likely Civ, with max 1 being Mafia. If I had to choose the scummiest out of these three, it would be Jean-Ralphio.
Jean-Ralphio
Jerry Gergich
Tom Haverford