

Return to “Pirate Mafia [END GAME]”
hell even after the kyle and speedchuck and colonialbob no lynch, there was a point the next day where I saw everyone possibly directed to speedchuck and I thought shit this could still work.MovingPictures07 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 15, 2017 12:39 pm Numerous town players really deserve some accolades for their performances this game, IMO, despite the loss. There was some seriously incredible town play on D1 especially -- LC, Daisy, dunya, and Kyle in particular, though there were many of you all giving a genuine effort. I can say it was really tough for me personally to fabricate content amid all of that, especially being rusty (somehow I haven't been mafia-aligned in forever) and lower on time than I would have liked. I thought we were likely screwed after how much attention (some of it rightfully so) I received on D1 leading to my lynch and having an inactive on our team.
Don't let the game slipping away from you all keep you from seeing what you did right as well, because town looked good at the start of this game.
Sorry. In retrospect I didnt know your age and Kyle was convincingDragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Thu Nov 09, 2017 7:17 am I'm insulted that people think I could have a 20yo son.
I'm only 26 godanmit.![]()
Btw [mention]MovingPictures07[/mention] you sucj fr thisMovingPictures07 wrote: ↑Wed Nov 01, 2017 5:54 pmI don't even know what those suspicions are, for fuck's sake, I said this multiple times: I'm still on page 4 or whatever. I've been in here generating reads with every ounce of my being. If you have a beef with me, state it now, and I'll address it however I can, but if my recent efforts haven't moved you, I'm not sure what I can say. Sorry you don't believe me for whatever reason.
I know. The total disconnect is a form of condemnation as well. Are you getting that?Kylemii wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2017 5:49 pmbut they didn't condemn each other that was the entire point, they went out of their way to not condemn each other
Quin believed MP was his supporter when everyone was dishing accusations his way, then there's MP ISOing him when he's on the chopping block then moving to someone else because he realized Quin doesn't suspect him and in a very tight EOD lynch, he needs every vote. They're both not voting each other off. It can be one but not both. You'll rarely ever see things so easily fall into place so effortlessly; when that happens you're missing some details. Especially when it's such an easy bandwagon without actual hard evidence (like a cop or tracker claim).
Because of the voting patterns and total disconnect from each other. When one mafia is totally sinking, the others sink him down, not dance ballet around him. Quin and MP aren't beginners in this, they wouldn't condemn themselves so openly and easily.
why? Why are you so worried to just throw it out there on day 1? Pot stirring. Testing waters. Are you scared to garner a negative reaction? You applauded Wilgy's rainbow reads, so Day 1 reads are not uncommon to you.
Is NT your current favorite for a lynch?
I saw that, I saw that as backtracking or covering your arse to make it seem like that. Like the blurb on SpaiceDaisy, that does not read as a "suspect". That reads as who didn't I compliment TOO much and I can get away with naming as a suspect to speedchuck now so it seems like I have a real scumspect list. IMO.Kylemii wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2017 3:28 pmI already explained that the scale was 1-5. In this post I listed Quin, Daisy, and DDL as suspects.dunya wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2017 3:17 pmDidn't like this post at all. A townie has no problem at least naming 1 or 2 suspects. MP couldn't pinpoint one this game as scum. Kyle went and basically said everyone was fine and dandy. Reads too much of "I am giving helpful reads and blending in" without actually offering much. Didn't want to cause any backlash from anyone. I consider that a very big mafia read. Townie's don't give two shits who they piss off because they have nothing to hide.Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Oct 31, 2017 4:39 pm alright. it's business time. 1 - 5, 5 being definitely good, 1 being definitely bad, and 3 being average.
DDL: 2.5
Most of his posts are about game mechanics, he notes to MP that he was lacking baddie reads even though he'd provided none himself, voted sig for asking the cop to play recklessly proactively... just generally ping-y. Like it's mostly gut feel and maybe it's just how he is regularly but there's a definite general pingy-ness there for me. I had him with a lower score before Speedchuck's point about nosebops, i can see how the same tactic could be used as a townie to stir the pot and open up discussion
Dr. Wilgy: ???
LIterally has only posted emoticons? is this normal for Wilgy?
Dunya: 3.5
My gut feel on her is good. Her posts read authentic to me. It's not much more than gut.
Long Con: 3.25
Very thorough and generally positive influence on the thread. He'd be higher but i believe he's very well capable of smoke-screening as a baddie.
MP: 3
he has a lot of posts because of the 1 quote per post thing he did. he's doing work and making shit happen but there's not enough there to sway me either way on him.
NewTraditionist: Null
Only post is about the day 0 vote. Please speak up.
Quin: 2.75
Uneasy but nothing concrete. they say a lot without saying much. throwing out "townie points" is.... i just don't trust that at all. i don't trust that metric
sig: 3.25
actually reads kind of civ to me??? i get where people are coming from with the copclaim suggestion thing but the thing is, he's right. it's mathematically the best choice in a vacuum. other variables exist as well if the cop can reliably wait a cycle and possibly catch a second badboy then like... that's a different matter.
Spacedaisy: 2.5
She's one of the 4 players with only 1 post but she's different in that i usually expect her to be more active than this. she's been around and posting in other places here. I wouldn't vote her over it because i don't think she'd use inactivity as a baddiestrat, but i guess what i'm saying is, hey spacedaisy, come plaaaaay with us. in this space we've made.
Spankgangsta: Null
he's newer, right? come plaaaaaayyyyyyyyy. with us. come out and plaaaaaaaaay
Speedchuck: 3.5
very blunt. I think good? i disagree with some/most of the stuff he says but his posts read as a townie who is trying hard
I see that my reads on Sig and DDL aren't concurrent with the rest of the thread so i'm going to review those two as well as LC
You made the same mistake here as.... Was it Speedchuck or MP?
The only player he actually seemed indifferent about was MP. He tells MP your posts don't sway me either way (but gives him a 3 rating). He posts a huge DDL read and then finishes it off with "i can see how the same tactic could be used as a townie to stir the pot and open up discussion". The only person he was negative about was Quin.dunya wrote: ↑Wed Nov 08, 2017 3:17 pmDidn't like this post at all. A townie has no problem at least naming 1 or 2 suspects. MP couldn't pinpoint one this game as scum. Kyle went and basically said everyone was fine and dandy. Reads too much of "I am giving helpful reads and blending in" without actually offering much. Didn't want to cause any backlash from anyone. I consider that a very big mafia read. Townie's don't give two shits who they piss off because they have nothing to hide.Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Oct 31, 2017 4:39 pm alright. it's business time. 1 - 5, 5 being definitely good, 1 being definitely bad, and 3 being average.
DDL: 2.5
Most of his posts are about game mechanics, he notes to MP that he was lacking baddie reads even though he'd provided none himself, voted sig for asking the cop to play recklessly proactively... just generally ping-y. Like it's mostly gut feel and maybe it's just how he is regularly but there's a definite general pingy-ness there for me. I had him with a lower score before Speedchuck's point about nosebops, i can see how the same tactic could be used as a townie to stir the pot and open up discussion
Dr. Wilgy: ???
LIterally has only posted emoticons? is this normal for Wilgy?
Dunya: 3.5
My gut feel on her is good. Her posts read authentic to me. It's not much more than gut.
Long Con: 3.25
Very thorough and generally positive influence on the thread.
MP: 3
he has a lot of posts because of the 1 quote per post thing he did. he's doing work and making shit happen but there's not enough there to sway me either way on him.
NewTraditionist: Null
Only post is about the day 0 vote. Please speak up.
Quin: 2.75
Uneasy but nothing concrete. they say a lot without saying much. throwing out "townie points" is.... i just don't trust that at all. i don't trust that metric
sig: 3.25
actually reads kind of civ to me??? i get where people are coming from with the copclaim suggestion thing but the thing is, he's right. it's mathematically the best choice in a vacuum. other variables exist as well if the cop can reliably wait a cycle and possibly catch a second badboy then like... that's a different matter.
Spacedaisy: 2.5
She's one of the 4 players with only 1 post but she's different in that i usually expect her to be more active than this. she's been around and posting in other places here. I wouldn't vote her over it because i don't think she'd use inactivity as a baddiestrat, but i guess what i'm saying is, hey spacedaisy, come plaaaaay with us. in this space we've made.
Spankgangsta: Null
he's newer, right? come plaaaaaayyyyyyyyy. with us. come out and plaaaaaaaaay
Speedchuck: 3.5
very blunt. I think good? i disagree with some/most of the stuff he says but his posts read as a townie who is trying hard
I see that my reads on Sig and DDL aren't concurrent with the rest of the thread so i'm going to review those two as well as LC
Didn't like this post at all. A townie has no problem at least naming 1 or 2 suspects. MP couldn't pinpoint one this game as scum. Kyle went and basically said everyone was fine and dandy. Reads too much of "I am giving helpful reads and blending in" without actually offering much. Didn't want to cause any backlash from anyone. I consider that a very big mafia read. Townie's don't give two shits who they piss off because they have nothing to hide.Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Oct 31, 2017 4:39 pm alright. it's business time. 1 - 5, 5 being definitely good, 1 being definitely bad, and 3 being average.
DDL: 2.5
Most of his posts are about game mechanics, he notes to MP that he was lacking baddie reads even though he'd provided none himself, voted sig for asking the cop to play recklessly proactively... just generally ping-y. Like it's mostly gut feel and maybe it's just how he is regularly but there's a definite general pingy-ness there for me. I had him with a lower score before Speedchuck's point about nosebops, i can see how the same tactic could be used as a townie to stir the pot and open up discussion
Dr. Wilgy: ???
LIterally has only posted emoticons? is this normal for Wilgy?
Dunya: 3.5
My gut feel on her is good. Her posts read authentic to me. It's not much more than gut.
Long Con: 3.25
Very thorough and generally positive influence on the thread. He'd be higher but i believe he's very well capable of smoke-screening as a baddie.
MP: 3
he has a lot of posts because of the 1 quote per post thing he did. he's doing work and making shit happen but there's not enough there to sway me either way on him.
NewTraditionist: Null
Only post is about the day 0 vote. Please speak up.
Quin: 2.75
Uneasy but nothing concrete. they say a lot without saying much. throwing out "townie points" is.... i just don't trust that at all. i don't trust that metric
sig: 3.25
actually reads kind of civ to me??? i get where people are coming from with the copclaim suggestion thing but the thing is, he's right. it's mathematically the best choice in a vacuum. other variables exist as well if the cop can reliably wait a cycle and possibly catch a second badboy then like... that's a different matter.
Spacedaisy: 2.5
She's one of the 4 players with only 1 post but she's different in that i usually expect her to be more active than this. she's been around and posting in other places here. I wouldn't vote her over it because i don't think she'd use inactivity as a baddiestrat, but i guess what i'm saying is, hey spacedaisy, come plaaaaay with us. in this space we've made.
Spankgangsta: Null
he's newer, right? come plaaaaaayyyyyyyyy. with us. come out and plaaaaaaaaay
Speedchuck: 3.5
very blunt. I think good? i disagree with some/most of the stuff he says but his posts read as a townie who is trying hard
I see that my reads on Sig and DDL aren't concurrent with the rest of the thread so i'm going to review those two as well as LC
shrug. Those are my reads. I'll say what I think.
were you not at all moved to change it to a tie between quin and someone who hasn't contributed anything to the game whatsoever?
I hear what you're saying, but I mean...a scum team of two remaining, with one completely inactive.Quin wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 7:04 pmI don't think it's wise to read into replacement order as a scum tactic. That could be determined in a lot of ways.dunya wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 6:58 pm I don't feel comfortable being part of the apparently easy Quin bandwagon. Sorry to do this, but moving to NewTraditionalist although it's statistically more likely Jack replaced the nonactive scum than the nonactive vanilla townie, I would think.
I do trust sig, but I'm not feeling as great about DDL as I was on the first day. Will try to review my notes.
I'm town, LC is town. Daisy...not sure, but not leaning bad anymore.Quin wrote: ↑Sat Nov 04, 2017 7:33 pmRule of threes, boys.MovingPictures07 wrote: ↑Sat Nov 04, 2017 6:54 pm Baddies are probably dunya, LC, and Daisy, I guess? I wish I had more time to play this cycle. Sorry to let you all down.
speedchuck is a town read for me.Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 3:38 pm Reads so far:
Kyle, Wilgy supatown
Would eat my hat if Speed, Sig, DDL, Quin all townies. Generally read that list as bad to good with some no w/w in the middle
agreed. Another dog basher like MP and look how MP flipped.Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 1:05 pmHurtful.Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 11:32 amKyle: Blah blah dags (Unhelpful imo but I don't know Kyle enough to say if this is alignment indicative.
yes positive, Quin changed his vote to me first, then MP/speedchuck not sure which order. It stood as me with 3 and ther other 2 with two each.Kylemii wrote: ↑Sat Nov 04, 2017 6:45 pmhang on, are you sure about this?dunya wrote: ↑Sat Nov 04, 2017 6:41 pmWhy? He was my second suspect. Kyle was my first. I made that pretty clear. I voted for Kyle and stuck with Kyle all the way through until I led the vote tally with 3 votes against me suddenly started by MP and Quin and speedchuck, who followed.Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Sat Nov 04, 2017 6:22 pm Ok I'm generally feeling good but Dunya's posts but I'm pinged that she came and started buddying me on my suspicion of MP and repeating the same arguments as me without actually voting for MP herself. Reeks of bandwagoning.
Kyle was the only one I voted for, MP was the one my spped vote was locked on at the end.
You agreed with Daisy, but I explained the misinterpretation to Daisy. Did you read my explanation too?Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Sat Nov 04, 2017 6:24 pm Also kind of agree with Daisy on dunya apologizing for MP vote. Same point I made about chuck.