The Syndicate

nutellaphant

Kylemii wrote: ↑Fri Jan 19, 2018 5:55 am what is the truth? do you know why there wasn't a kill ermac?

We believe (on the balance of probability) the reason why there was no night kill. The question here however is do you?

nutellaphant

Wait Ermac is a role. I feel dumb. Ermac, you keep saying "we." Are you one person, or more? Are you the person with the role Ermac, or someone else somehow affected by that role? We don’t know what we are. We are lost in this nether-world between life and death. Our sole purpose is to fu...

nutellaphant

I think Ermac is suggesting that the actual mechanic by which there was no death was something that you didn't mention. I haven't looked at the roles closely enough to know whether you missed anything, but it could be something that's not public and perhaps Ermac is suggesting you know something? :...

nutellaphant

dunya wrote: ↑Fri Jan 19, 2018 3:42 am Kyle gets townie points for being the first one trying to make a defense on why the kill failed.

Does he retain those townie points if he were deliberately misrepresenting the actual events?

nutellaphant

Sloonei wrote: ↑Fri Jan 19, 2018 2:58 am what's an ermac? Like Mac but more prone to error?

Dis us at your peril, Sloonei

nutellaphant

okay cool no death and also Sloonei is here again and also we seem to have a new friend? I have thoughts on the no-kill. we have no protective roles, at least among the visible powers. technically speaking there could be a role with a bp vest or something but epi has stated his dislike for that mec...

nutellaphant

okay cool no death and also Sloonei is here again and also we seem to have a new friend? I have thoughts on the no-kill. we have no protective roles, at least among the visible powers. technically speaking there could be a role with a bp vest or something but epi has stated his dislike for that mec...

nutellaphant

Sloonei wrote: ↑Thu Jan 18, 2018 10:11 pmBoo!

Behold, friend Sloonei. We are pleased once again to make your acquaintance.

nutellaphant

Ermac wrote: ↑Thu Jan 18, 2018 10:56 pm We are kin of Diogenes. We are looking for someone with a clue.

And we continue to search in vain

nutellaphant

We are kin of Diogenes. We are looking for someone with a clue.

nutellaphant

speedchuck wrote: ↑Thu Jan 18, 2018 10:50 pm Did Ermac sub in?

Oh, FFS!

nutellaphant

JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Thu Jan 18, 2018 10:49 pm Ermac is the legendary creator of The Cones of Dunshire.

Say what?

nutellaphant

We are astounded...

nutellaphant

nutellaphant

Behold, WE are here!

nutellaphant

If Jerry isn't bad, and I will honestly be shocked if he is, I'd pursue Donna primarily during Day 6. But, if she makes some logical and persuasive cases against another player, or a fellow citizen does something especially shady, I'd definitely be up for lynching them instead. fixed dammit fixed 2...

nutellaphant

Ben Wyatt wrote:
Ben Wyatt wrote:If Jerry is bad, and I will honestly be shocked if he ISN'T, I'd pursue Donna primarily. But, if she makes some logical and persuasive cases against another player, or a fellow citizen does something especially shady, I'd definitely be up for lynching them instead.
fixed

dammit

fixed 2.0

nutellaphant

Ben Wyatt wrote:If Jerry is bad, and I will honestly be shocked if he was NOT, I'd pursue Donna primarily. But, if she makes some logical and persuasive cases against another player, or a fellow citizen does something especially shady, I'd definitely be up for lynching them instead.

fixed

nutellaphant

Ironically, how Tom is now acting towards Andy is pretty much the same way Andy acted towards Leslie. Tunnel vision and a stout refusal to interpret things in ways that don't lead up to baddie. I view both Tom and Andy at this point as confused civs. Jean-Ralphio also gets some brownie points from m...

nutellaphant

My trust of Jerry stems from something April said about him. I agree with most of what April has said. She seems like a sweet kid. I will try to do a better job of posting more. I just get so forgetful. Chris would probably be my next suspect after Ben, as he shares the trying too hard vibe and hel...

nutellaphant

Tom, you haven't really said anything specific about why you don't trust Andy. If there's something more to that other than gut, I'd like to hear it, because my gut is only reading civilian for him.

nutellaphant

I trust Ben, so far. Ben looks best to me. Bobby looks good too. You guys may be at odds, but you both talk like civs. I think you should work together. Jean-Ralphio would be my third pick for a civ, I really like the specticism he is bringing to the Ben/Andy dynamic. I don't trust Andy. Ben, why d...

nutellaphant

My trust of Jerry stems from something April said about him. I agree with most of what April has said. She seems like a sweet kid. I will try to do a better job of posting more. I just get so forgetful. Chris would probably be my next suspect after Ben, as he shares the trying too hard vibe and hel...

nutellaphant

Ah ha, now I see what it was. It was the way you were quick to smear April for that time she said she was a Miller (like, what even is that? Is it like a Mason?), and I didn't like the way you treated Bill for taking the same stance you took regarding April's claim. Whenever anyone makes a bold cla...

nutellaphant

Andy Dwyer wrote:Didn't even see your screw up, dude!

My secret identity remains a mystery...

nutellaphant

Reposting for Bobby to see.

Ben Wyatt wrote:QUESTION TIME!

Bobby, why do you suspect me? Is there anything I can respond to? What's your impression of one mister Jerry Gergich?

nutellaphant

(Please delete the above post. I knew I'd screw up at some point.)

Andy, GTH, if Donna is civ, who is the baddie out of Tom, Bobby, and Jean-Ralphio?

I myself would have to say Bobby.

nutellaphant

Jerry Gergich wrote:If you guys would trust me just this one time, you would see that I am not mafia and Ben is. When I flip civ, go after Ben next. Don't let him weasel his way out of it.

nutellaphant

Hey peeps. I'm subbing in. No chance I'll read the game, so who wants to make the most convincing case for who I should vote for? I want the town to win, so I'm relying on you guys to link me to some good cases! I can't believe anyone lynched Leslie Knope. LESLIE KNOPE! That right there is where yo...

nutellaphant

I am here. Not avoiding answering Ben or Andy's questions, I just haven't been able to get here to speak. Joe's charity work as well as my real estate business has kept me quite busy the past two weeks. I did then, and do now believe that one of the two of Leslie and Jerry were bad. At the time I v...

nutellaphant

notsawyer540 wrote:
Ben Wyatt wrote:I just found this, and it needs to be shared.
Awesome.

by the way, you did a fantastic job in this game, and I can't wait to play with you again in the future.

nutellaphant

I'm an auditor- or at least, I used to be one. I come into failing towns, and I fix them. Right now, we're failing this game. I know I may not be as inspiring as Leslie or Ron, but I must implore all of you to start talking and help to solve this game instead of lapsing into complacency or wacky RP....

nutellaphant

QUESTION TIME! Andy, who do you believe to be Jerry's teammate, and what's your impression of Jean-Ralphio and Bobby? Bobby, why do you suspect me? Is there anything I can respond to? What's your impression of one mister Jerry Gergich? Donna, do you care to explain your Day 4 vote any further? You ...

nutellaphant

I just found this, and it needs to be shared.

nutellaphant

TL;DR VERSION: Chris, the only confirmed mafia saved Jerry's ass Day 2. Donna saved Jerry's ass Day 4. Jerry very rarely actually discusses any of his suspicions in actual detail. Or really anything at all. He's been tunneling me since Day 1, and none of his arguments hold any water. Jerry is not an...

nutellaphant

THE TRIAL OF JEROME GERGICH DAY 1 Gosh, you are all so nice. I don't want to lynch any of you. But Ben and Chris are new around here, and Ben seems to be trying a little too hard, plus he didn't cry at L'il Sebastian's funeral, and he also made me play Cones of Dunshire with him. Sorry Ben. Jerry c...

nutellaphant

Alright, I've loaded up on calzones and coffee from JJ's diner, (The coffee is from JJ's, the low-cal calzones are my own creation.) let's do this thing. There are seven of us left, and two baddies. Tom is AWOL, and for some reason hasn't been replaced despite not posting since Day 2. I've half a mi...

nutellaphant

And it looks like the swing vote's going to be...Tom Haverford.

Terrific.

nutellaphant

Looking at our numbers there 9 players remaining. 2 of them are Mafia. So at this moment in time, we have 7 civs to 2 mafia. If we lynch a mafia, we get to be 7 civs to 1 mafia. Mafia Night kill and we are down 6 civs 1 Mafia. If by some sad twist of fate, we lynch a civ, we are down 8 civs 2 mafia...

nutellaphant

Now tell me why your Day 1 casemaking appears so much of a stinker. I assumed that if April was lying about her Miller claim, either a fellow civ would know so and attempt to fight it, or the mafia would try and cast doubt on it. I looked for the person with the biggest negative knee-jerk reaction,...

nutellaphant

It just seems so rude to argue with you fine people. Just this once, I'll allow you to. I won't laugh in your face, or bring up the whole "fart attack" incident, or anything else. Man to man, civilian to ostensible civilian: What is your defense against the people voting against you? Can ...

nutellaphant

Jerry's line of thinking seems to be that a true civilian wouldn't bother trying to defend himself. Or explain himself. Or try to convince others of his opinions. Or really elaborate on his own opinions. Or do anything other than smugly flick his nose at everyone else from the corner. Truly, the par...

nutellaphant

If Jerry doesn't actually address his accusers or actually describe his case against me, I'm just going to assume he's a baddie who has given up.

Until he decides to give playing the game a shot, he's where my vote's going to be.

nutellaphant

Well, it seems inevitable that all you lovely people are going to make the mistake of lynching me. I'll vote for Jerry Gergich . Oh! And I see that My good friend Ben Wyatt has voted there as well! Good choice old pal! Once I flip civ I recommend you all give some serious scrutiny to the people who...

nutellaphant

The near unanimous (excepting Chris himself and Andy) in-thread condemnation of Chris is giving me pause. I also may have been the only person who actually appreciated his ISO's and thread analysis. It's enough for me to hesitate before adding my vote to the woodpile. Leslie's still being, well, Les...

nutellaphant

Hmm. I have to say, the results of Day 2 casts the most shade on Chris. His well-timed vote saved Jerry and almost doomed Leslie. I agree, Leslie changing her stances like, well, a politician isn't great, but I'd see a Chris + Jerry team as more likely, and Leslie doesn't fit in at all with that duo...

nutellaphant

Leslie Knope wrote:I don't know, Ron. What I do know is that three people I've been calling out pretty consistently all voted for me and two of them waited till the last minute.

That's not a good look.

nutellaphant

Can we all agree that locked-thread nights are BS?

nutellaphant

Andy Dwyer wrote:leslie has yet to name a suspect who hasn't suspected her first

when did Jerry suspect Leslie?

nutellaphant

Oh geez, I can't believe Craig is dead. That's so sad! You know, when I'm feeling a little down, my beautiful wife and daughters always cheer me up. But right now all I really want to do is find the killer. Ben was awful quick to get in here after the kill. I wonder if he was expecting it. I'm sorr...

Search found 226 matches