1. This has nothing to do about me slanking this game. Using "you haven't done anything" against me is a non argument, and pure smearing. I've done what I can. I've tried to cooperate all I can. I used a track and tracked a roleblocker to Tutu.Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 3:39 am basically there's a lot of assumptions that would have to happen in the "tim got roleblocked" scenario and while I concede it's theoretically possible it always requires a lot of stuff to go haywire or act in odd ways.
and this is why you need to see that people are going to have to suspect you no matter what @Dyslexicon, there is no use complaining about how poor our logic is when you can't refute it, and going "I'm townie on play" when you've been slanking all game and "why would I make up such a stupid lie as mafia" when it seems obvious to me that for this gamestate to happen someone has to have made up a stupid lie (note: samu got caught because he made up a stupid lie) are just not good enough defenses to stop us from suspecting you when the POE is squeezes as tiny as it is.
also I don't know why you're so unhappy about being scumread given that you've self-admittedly not done much over the course of the game and there's a 50% chance we exe ted instead depending on night results anyway
2. I have refuted your "logic" up and down as far as I'm concerned. If you want to claim that it takes a lot of assumptions to say that Tim was roleblocked when I know for a fact that something happened to his block then right back at you times a hundred for your assumptions about me being mafia here. You have have to assume that 1) I'm an idiot that chose to lie for no reason. This IS a strong defence, and you shouldn't pretend it's not. 2) I chose to track Samu to Tutu and out the result because I hate my teammates. Notice also how hedgy Samu was about being clear about that result. 3) I'm an idiot who faked a role that gets verifiable results.
3. Why I care is if PoE is "You're about 50 % to be scum" then I know you're all about 50 % to be wrong about your PoE. I still hope you're not.
It's cool if it's Ted, I tend to think it's not. Sue me. Maybe it is. I trust Mac and Tutu to be absolute town, and I trust Juliets to be town. I don't know why SPF is town, but sure why not. You're probably town just due to the fact that faking cop is long term terrible. I have my doubts only because the claim just doesn't fit well to me. Whatever. Wilgy is town by your check. It might be Oddmerta tbh. Dya at least has a track. Mafia tracker, meh. I don't remember anyone else. LC. I don't know anything about him, I think maybe you checked him as well as Nanook.