The Syndicate

I think he's a recruited cyber.

Dom wrote:

S~V~S wrote:I agree re Hedge tbh; like Ninjuju I would have expected more involvement from a civ Hedge.

I can see the case against Faraday, and agree it is probably true. My initial issue with it was that the initial case presented was based totally on blendiness, and Faraday is the blendiest person I have ever played with, bad or good. But yeah, subsequent points have been good ones.

Having had a lot of experience with DFaraday-- I would say his baddie game generally comes with a lot more posts about solely defending himself or zero actual content. His civvie game play is much more productive in that sense.

And what do you see here? I have never learned to qualify his blendiness.

I agree re Hedge tbh; like Ninjuju I would have expected more involvement from a civ Hedge.

I can see the case against Faraday, and agree it is probably true. My initial issue with it was that the initial case presented was based totally on blendiness, and Faraday is the blendiest person I have ever played with, bad or good. But yeah, subsequent points have been good ones.

Well, if I were an unrecruited Cybermen killer, I would kill MM. He is still a recruit, and a threat to them as well as to us on a purely numbers basis, and cannot win with them.

If they do NOT kill him, it would be my guess that MM is in the same chatroom with the Cyber Killer.

And yeah, Dom. I expect both Eloh & Ninjajujube to be more present, especially Ninjaju. I have seen civ Eloh fall off the radar when she is not engaged in a game. And Gotrees is an enigma; he (She? I think MM called Gotrees "she" at some point, I don't recall that it was specifically mentioned elsewhere, although I may have missed it) is new and perhaps thought initially that participating via the night polls was enough, but efforts have been made by Gotrees since then to at least give lip service to standard participation, but not much, although it is easy to get lost in this thread. I went looking for Juliets last most, thinkng it was days since I had seen her post, onlyto find that she had posted this AM.

You don't have to stop, lol. You don't agree with me and I have not stopped.

Ebwop, having a secret recruiter role that goes unknown until a recruit is lynched is powerful enough~ having that role be able to recruit any role would be seriously unbalanced, and Bea is a very good balancer. I just don't see a secret recruiter than can recruit Dr Who or the master.

Chris wrote:The general consensus is that Bass is bad though, right?

Here's what I was thinking.

Strax could take a shot at Bass tonight. 1 of 2 things will happen. Bass will live, or Bass will die. (Far out, right? )

If Bass dies, he's not The Master, but we're all fairly sure he's bad, so done and done.

If Bass lives, that just further's the idea that he's The Master, and we lynch him tomorrow. (But he'll live if he's The Master)

If we were to get really lucky, both Strax and the Cybers target Bass tonight, using up the rest of his protections (if he's The Master) and then when we lynch him tomorrow, he'll finally die.


Just some thoughts.


LINKI @ SVS: What do you think about this then? ^^^

I don't think he's the Master. I don't think the Master is recruitable, and I believe he is recruited. But I think we should go one cycle at a time. Lets see what Strax & the Cybers do (I doubt the cybers will target Bass, since I think he is one of them). Planning too far ahead when there are too many unknowns is pointless, IMO. Especially when Faraday is the Master was the thought you had yesterday, now it is Bass.

If Bass dies tonight, then we are free to discuss the Master. If not, I want to lynch him again. I don't think he is the Master, and I think he has to be out of tricks eventually.

keys56000000000 wrote:

Chris wrote:keys & MP, what would you opinion be on where to proceed if Bass came back as a recruited Master, once lynched?

My guess is that The Master can't be recruited, and at any rate, I don't think Bass is The Master. But I firmly believe Bass will come back bad, and then I say we look at the other people we suspect. My suspects remain the same, I say we lynch DF next.

And I completely agree about ignoring MM. He hasn't given us any infomation on this recruiting team, which is more worrying than reassuring.

I agree totally with this. My guess is that Dr Who and the Master are unrecruitable. I think Bass is both Cyber & a recruit, and I would not be surprised to find more than one Cyber recruited. So I doubt that Bass will come back as the Master.

It would be awesome, but it is very unlikely.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

S~V~S wrote:No, based on Daisys opinion of Dana, coupled with MPs opinion of Daisy, I have a civ role in mind for Dana/LC. Recruiting is a possibility for anyone, but I doubt Dana would have been recruited due to inactivity, so I doubt LC is anything but a civ.

Nice try bad newt

Only one of two players could be the Dalek #2, and I believe that Daisy is the one. I can't recall, who does MP think that Daisy is, and why did his mind change from early on?

He firmly believed Daisy to be civ, and Daisy aggressively defended Dana. You can draw your own lines, I believe. I doubt she was a Dalek. Who was it that proposed MR for the missing Dalek? Chris, maybe? I agree with that. You would have to ask him why he changed his mind, but I think you could draw your own lines there as well

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Chris wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Btw Chris.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Chris wrote:I think Bass is the Cyber team role checker. I've been saying that. I haven't seen any reason to think otherwise.

I coulda sworn sabie was the role checker though.

Btw MetalMarsh.

Chris wrote:Oh yeah, Bass is the role BLOCKER, not checker. Fucked that up last night.

I think you mean Sabie is the role checker, and Bass might be the role blocker.

I'd almost look at Dana (LC) as the role blocker, since Strax and the Master have continued to kill players without being stopped.

No, based on Daisys opinion of Dana, coupled with MPs opinion of Daisy, I have a civ role in mind for Dana/LC. Recruiting is a possibility for anyone, but I doubt Dana would have been recruited due to inactivity, so I doubt LC is anything but a civ.

Nice try bad newt

Snow Dog wrote:Three Amigos. MP, SVS and....who was it?

Chris wrote:keys.

I have no has BTSC with either MP or Keys. I have not had BTSC with ANYONE. I am a civvie; I am not recruited. You need to give this one up. I guess your insistence on this one point is why I am not taking your theories very seriously overall~ because one of your lynchpins, the so called Three Amigos, is so wrong. As LC said, we are all wrong sometimes, I have been very seriously wrong about almost everyone in this thread (except the people I have not played with before ) one time or another.

You are very wrong about me this time.

I still think you're fear mongering Chris. The last few bits of that last post were over the top even for you.

His role does nor mention that either.

Yeas, Bass is Roxys son IRL.

Wow, person not whatever that words is lol

Chris wrote:I think it makes no sense to recruit Bass or Snow Dog. They've been in the spotlight since the Sabie lynch. Why would you recruit someone who would stand such a chance of being lynched?

You wouldn't.

S~V~S wrote: LINKI, An NK recruitment death is also possible.

A what?

An NK of a recruited pwersob. An NK recruitment death.

And perhaps Roxys son was recruited early, since Roxy was a recruit herself.

Link I, so can you.

Be careful what you wish for, Chris

Welcome back, LC

I think eliminating cybers will eliminate recruits. It is totally possible that they recruited, or tried or will try, to recruit the whole cyber team, like we did with the cops in Fight Club. We don't know.


LINKI, An NK recruitment death is also possible.

Its weird, I feel like both Epi & Chris are trying to scare us into voting for who they want us to vote for.

Also nothing is a fact unless Bea or bwt posted it.

But I have never seen a game where there isn't a possibility of failed recruitments. Blocks, some roles unrecruitable, etc.

Bass is a sure thing, plus I think he's a recruit. If the recruiters conditions are standard cult conditions, like in AG & Fight Club, they just need to outnumber us to win. So keeping cult numbers down is important as well.

Linki, and yeah, theres that. This theory is based on a lot of supposition. And I can tell you that at least one supposition is wrong. So Faraday could be the Master, but it is also possible he is not.

Chris wrote:The poll ends in just under 5.5 hours...

Think of all the posts you can make in that time

And maybe you should reread Elo some more~

zeek wrote:

Chris wrote:If Elo is Sarah Jane, then her 50/50 could have saved her.

That's not who I have as Sarah Jane.

Thats not who I have as Sarah Jane, either

Also I defended Roxy becasue she was having a HORRBLE HORRIBLE RL experience that day, and I hate lynching people who aren't available for defending. And I knew she was not. I did not defend whether she was bad or good; I asked that we not lynch her while she was going through hell.

But twist it as you like.

Bye.

I am still waiting for you to say the same thing to me that you said to MP. If you did, I missed it.

Now, shopping

And I am out for the day. Toodles folks

Whatever, I disagree. I think Bass is recruited and potentially Cyber to boot.

We'll see

Linki~ Um, no. I voted right out of the gate because I don't want us to get distracted from who that last switch saved: Bass.

Yeah, Faraday is always blendy. I have seen him get lynched for it bad or good.

Oh well, that would be a different scenario than if he were bad and someone on his team had one. And prizes etc., Just cause something is not in the roles doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Plus totally secret roles, who knows what they have? He would make an awesome secret recruiting team recruit (and he seemed to have knowledge of the recruiting schedule) especially with Roxy on the recruit team.

But yeah, how he acted as a lone civ would be totally different than how he acted as a baddie. I have done baddie with Bass, and he does not waste his assets when he's bad. Maybe he was afraid of, "Use it or lose it" in Clue? I have a tendency to use that stuff too earlier than i should when a civ myself.

Who were his teammates in Clue? Generally that is considered a team asset and if he had more conservative teammates they may have held onto it.

Faraday, the fact that i gotba vouch from mp, one of the people you trust the most doesn't phase you?

I tend to lose interest when individuals dominate the thread, and we have had a few instances of that here.

My top 3 are MM, Epi & Bass. I voted Bass today because we need to clear up what happened yesterday, Andi votedBass yesterday because we need to stick together as much as possible until we make inroads into the cybermen numbers IMO.

Also also you are not willing to put the same level of commitment to ME being bad as you are to MP.

Good to know.

Or is this like you saying MP never vouched for me only to have it come to light that you did not read his posts?

Or you quoting BR to bolster one suspicion, but ignoring her when she said you were wrong about me? And iirc she voted Bass yesterday.

Chris, I do it "alot"?

I think I did it once or twice? Can you back this up please?

zeek wrote:Chris, you got a complaint, put it in a PM.

I am. Put it in a PM.

I can't wait to hear Epi 2.0s case on Juliets 2.0

And Chris, I think Bass was being saved yesterday. I am very wary of those trying to distract from that.

And I am no more recruited or recruiter today than I was yesterday. Waiting to see if you back up your belief in me like your belief on MP.

Wow that totally sucks.

Voting Bass for now.

You're no fun.

I am not the recruiter, though. Just like I am not recruited.

Chris wrote:If MP is not recruited when lynched or at the end of the game, I'll forever quit mafia.

Quote this to use if I'm wrong, and I ever try to play mafia again.

Are you going to say the same thing about me? I could use a new sig :P

Please keep discussion about complaints out of the thread, please.

Linki, that's the point. Baddies lynch switch to civvies.

It gives the team another day to reposition, another night to enjoy the use of Bass' power. They would all benefit from keeping him alive.

If they had a switch or other manipulation it would be surprising if they did not use it. You never know what tomorrow may bring.

Why are you quitting? Because people are pushing back against you? This is the whole point of the internet~ Person A) Post Conspiracy Theory, Person B) Poke holes in conspiracy theory

Also, tbh, you have been doing well with the hosts answering; I would not have answered any of those, probably, had I been hosting.

keys56000000000 wrote:

Chris wrote:By the way. TH suspects SVS is the recruiter, and 12 hours later, he's dead from some mysterious lynch switch.

How am I supposed to let that go?

By appreciating that it is complely possible that that is coincidental? That maybe something fucking else happened?

I laughed.

Voted Vulcan, we could use some logic.

I am voting Bass, going with the people I trust.

Chris wrote:And then there's BR saying that... which makes me worry I'm wrong.

You should worry about that, because you are wrong.

I don't think anyone has the time to quote 524 posts.

Lol

He=Epi

Too muck linki

Chris wrote:
Also, lynching a civ wouldn't really help you much, would it.

I wouldn't imagine anyone, good or bad, would WANT to lynch a civ...

No I don't either

Linki, yeah I have. And I still think he is bad tbh.