Search found 287 matches

by Alison
Tue Mar 07, 2023 8:18 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol

Like tone and vibe stuff... it's not even AI for Dizzy. Why are you reading him off it. Don't try, just kill him for being in an F3 he has no business being in
by Alison
Tue Mar 07, 2023 8:17 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol

Just policy Dizzy in endgame and don't overthink it
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:54 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Golden wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:44 pm If Sean lets the town control his vig kills but he's wolf, that's still advantageous. I don't understand the drive to kill Seanzie with immediacy when we have a known mechanical basis to test him.

For me, I'd reach a consensus on who Sean should shoot and policy elim him if he refused, given he's been asking the town all day who he should shoot.
I worry that if he is indeed mafia KP we're just kicking the can down the road for another day phase while he gets a free vig shot on Mac or me.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:39 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:36 pm
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:34 pm
nutella wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:32 pm
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:29 pm Oh lol I just realized Scotty and Kate are on the SVS wagon.

Not voting with those two if I can help it. Seanzie it is.
Kate voting SVS is from my perspective actually a good sign for SVS being a hit but I recognize that my perspective on Kate is very different from yours.
That relies on Kate being town which I am really not convinced of. Frankly I am just refraining from tunnelling her because I recognize that other people who know her well think she is in her town meta and I'd rather pursue some level of cohesion and try to hammer out something consensus and orderly instead of tear off on my own to pursue my own desires. If it wasn't for that adamant shielding of her I would have her as bottom POE frankly.
I have a very nearly mechanical reason to believe kate is town but I don't want to go into it
Alright I'll trust you then
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:34 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:32 pm
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:29 pm Oh lol I just realized Scotty and Kate are on the SVS wagon.

Not voting with those two if I can help it. Seanzie it is.
Kate voting SVS is from my perspective actually a good sign for SVS being a hit but I recognize that my perspective on Kate is very different from yours.
That relies on Kate being town which I am really not convinced of. Frankly I am just refraining from tunnelling her because I recognize that other people who know her well think she is in her town meta and I'd rather pursue some level of cohesion and try to hammer out something consensus and orderly instead of tear off on my own to pursue my own desires. If it wasn't for that adamant shielding of her I would have her as bottom POE frankly.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:32 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

If Sean is mafia KP I think we turbo Rondo

Timing of his big attention grabbing slapfight that tried to bait Mac into voting him when Seanzie was in danger would be much too suspicious
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:30 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

I continue to be worried about HK and 112. They have somehow accrued 0 pressure - even when 112 was put into the POE nobody wanted to vote her - while doing absolutely fucking nothing. Even Kate has more pressure than them and she got hard shielded by Golden D1.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:29 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Oh lol I just realized Scotty and Kate are on the SVS wagon.

Not voting with those two if I can help it. Seanzie it is.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:28 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:24 pm
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:20 pm Why does mafia Rondo get into a slapfight with Mac and put himself at risk instead of just chilling and letting us vote out SVS or Seanzie or whoever?
Because Sean is mafia kp
Possible. And in that situation I don't think we can effectively leash his shot. We can say "shoot SVS or you're an outed mafia", and he'll just shrug, shoot Mac or myself, and be outed, not like it changes his situation.

Also you and Mac were kinda right that the Seanzie wagon comp is so much purer than SVS'.

Ok, ignore what I said a post ago, I think Seanzie might be correct now.

[VOTE: Seanzie] aubergine
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:26 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

SVS, 112
Seanzie
Rondo

Is my vote preference, top being more preferred, bottom being less. Seanzie did fuck all with the space he was given so I'm not really inclined to shield him any more, but I would still vote SVS/112 over him.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:23 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Kate has done absolutely nothing all day. Like take a look at her ISO. She has contributed nothing townie the entirety of D2 and frankly the entirety of D1 as well. She is coasting by on being toneread as town by someone that knows her D1.

I don't want to vote her out today because I have bigger fish to fry. But please pay attention to her tomorrow, especially if you have KP.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:22 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:20 pm Why does mafia Rondo get into a slapfight with Mac and put himself at risk instead of just chilling and letting us vote out SVS or Seanzie or whoever?
Like even if they're mafia partners, Rondo has to be far better positioned than either of them, so it makes sense to sacrifice them before him. He's not gonna get Mac killed ever so... what's his agenda exactly?

It's kinda undermining the orderly structure of the POE which is my top theory for his agenda if he is a wolf, but it's in a way that compromises him personally?
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:20 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Why does mafia Rondo get into a slapfight with Mac and put himself at risk instead of just chilling and letting us vote out SVS or Seanzie or whoever?
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 7:02 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

I townread ender
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 6:17 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

RondoDimBuckle wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 5:47 am Just accept I am not going to late game and this is all fine. You are definitely transferring warmth. The best read on my slot is Ender and he cant even get me right so its ok
The phrasing here implies you think Ender is town. Have you elaborated on this?

Why this attitude when you shaded Mac for scumreading you like 5 posts ago?
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 6:09 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

MacDougall wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 4:13 am
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 1:51 am @MacDougall You were the one who originally said you thought HK was town and wanted to take him out of the POE, right? What did you see in him?
he told someone to fuck off
Is that really a towntell for him?
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:09 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 2:08 am I think I might shoot Nutella.
1) If you do this I will policy you twice.
2) What changed your mind? Didn't you say you didn't want to shoot her earlier?
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 1:51 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

@MacDougall You were the one who originally said you thought HK was town and wanted to take him out of the POE, right? What did you see in him?
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 1:05 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 1:02 am
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:56 am
Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:55 am
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:55 am
Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:52 am I might shoot Golden.
I will policy you if you do this. Shoot in the POE if you are town.
What is the PoE?
112 or SVS are my bottom POE. Everyone else has something going for them. We can only exe one of these today, so shoot the other.
Why does your poe have only two people?
It has more people than that. 112 and SVS are at the bottom of it, ie. I think they're scummier than the other POE members.

Radish, sig, hollowkatt, maybe Rondo are four other names that are in the wider POE.

Scotty and Kate are people I personally find suspicious but which others are shielding and I am deferring to them.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:57 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

[VOTE: SVS] aubergine

I am currently meditating on Rondo. He may or may not be moved into the POE after I finish doing so.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:56 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:55 am
Alison wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:55 am
Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:52 am I might shoot Golden.
I will policy you if you do this. Shoot in the POE if you are town.
What is the PoE?
112 or SVS are my bottom POE. Everyone else has something going for them. We can only exe one of these today, so shoot the other.
by Alison
Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:55 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Seanzie wrote: Tue Feb 21, 2023 12:52 am I might shoot Golden.
I will policy you if you do this. Shoot in the POE if you are town.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:58 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

RondoDimBuckle wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:55 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:49 pm
nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:36 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:33 pm I do think the Sabi spew on Seanzie looks good for him and would prefer SVS/112 at this time
What is it
Sabiplz wrote: Fri Feb 17, 2023 7:19 pm Side eyeing Seanzie and Creature joining that Dennis wagon like that
This feels a lot like Sabi knows Dennis is town and is preparing in advance to shade Seanzie and Creature for voting him.
Could be she is trying to hide a fox among the chickens for her flip and if one of them is wolf and one is town it would be seanzie/creature(town) for me
Sure, that's possible. But given that Sabi seems to have been trying to get townies killed I lean towards believing that people they are shading are townie. Furthermore, if this is WIFOM, it is predicated on Dennis flipping town, which Sabi couldn't have predicted would happen. Ergo from a probability based standpoint it's more likely that this is just a straightforward attempt at killing two townies.

Is it a green check? No. But it's something solid and meaningful in Seanzie's favor. 112 and SVS do not have anything at all in their favor.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:50 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Seanzie wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:43 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:11 pm
nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:01 pm I want everyone to talk about Seanzie, go
I think he is cleared off Sabi spew and his latest posts seem like standard town Seanzie. Don't know what he gains as mafia from that weird push on you.
Which posts are that, exactly?
The ones where you push nutella, as indicated by my last sentence
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:50 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

RondoDimBuckle wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:37 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:11 pm
nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:01 pm I want everyone to talk about Seanzie, go
I think he is cleared off Sabi spew and his latest posts seem like standard town Seanzie. Don't know what he gains as mafia from that weird push on you.
Ok then if you were to take my reads list and make Seanzie town who would you flip to wolf? Or do you think that I am spot on the money with everyone else?
Spoiler: show
even I doubt that
Spoiler: show
RondoDimBuckle wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 8:35 pm 112 - Unknown - Mafia
Alison - Town
Cape90 - Dead - Town
Creature - Town
Dennis - Dead - Town
DrWilgy - Town
Dyslexicon - Town
EnderWiggin - Town
falcon45ca - Town
Golden - Town
Guillotine - Unknown - Mafia
hollowkatt - Unknown - Mafia
ilario - Dead - 3P - MOD SQUAD
inawordyes - Dead - Town
Kate - Unknown - Town
Le petit poussin - Dead - Town
Lilypetal - Town
lucy - Dead - Town
MacDougall - Town
Marmot - Unknown - Mafia
master radishes - Town
Michelle - Town
Neon - Town
nutella - Town
Party Crasher - 3P
Porscha - Town
pyxxy - Dead - Town
RondoDimBuckle - Town
S~V~S - Mafi
sabiplz - Dead - SOUP MAFIA
Scotty - Unknown - Mafia
Seanzie - Mafia
sig - Unknown - Mafia
Sloonei - Town
TonyStarkPrime - Dead Town
Urist - Unknown - Town
Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:14 pm
nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:03 pm If we kill marmot and theyre town it would be so fucking bad and cringe bc they are a beast when they can get into solving so let us give them space to do so when IRL isn't in the way
Counterpoint- a lot of people are beast when they’re town too.

But I’m not leading the charge

[VOTE: Seanzie] aubergine
Interesting 3rd vote on Seanzie. Does that make him more or less likely a wolf?
What do you mean "flip to wolf"? Why am I operating off your readslist suddenly?
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:49 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:36 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:33 pm I do think the Sabi spew on Seanzie looks good for him and would prefer SVS/112 at this time
What is it
Sabiplz wrote: Fri Feb 17, 2023 7:19 pm Side eyeing Seanzie and Creature joining that Dennis wagon like that
This feels a lot like Sabi knows Dennis is town and is preparing in advance to shade Seanzie and Creature for voting him.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:33 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

I do think the Sabi spew on Seanzie looks good for him and would prefer SVS/112 at this time
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:30 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

MacDougall wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:17 pm Nutella's defense of Marmot is fine and makes sense but I don't love how she's flinging random shade at players like Seanzie and Falcon while trying to kill the wagon.

The posts Marmot made to defend himself are not out of his range and don't undo what made him suspicious.
I don't think Marmot's defense was convincing at all but nutella has essentially claimed that he gave her a beneficial item. She hasn't said what it is but if its nature makes her strongly flip around on Marmot I'm willing to take that on faith and pursue other members of the POE who have nothing at all going for them. Such as SVS and 112.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:28 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

My catchup was long and boring and largely skimmed. My main conclusion is that I no longer have a townread on Rondo because it is starting to feel like he is not just causing chaos to be a goblin but instead using it as a strategic lever to undermine a POE I believe in. And honestly even if he is town he's kinda a liability to town cohesion. Attacking Mac for agreeing with Dizzy's reads makes very little sense to me and felt more like a forcible attempt to shove Dizzy back in the POE than an actual read on Mac.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:25 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 10:54 pm
Marmot wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 9:55 pm [VOTE: Scotty] aubergine for now.

I'll be back closer to EOD.


I gave nutella a magical item last night, ask her about it.
It's extremely lovely
[VOTE: SVS] aubergine
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:16 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

sig wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:26 pm I’m just saying the POE being thrown around don’t make much sense and are filled with low hanging fruit so someone pushing said POE is mafia
Do you have an actual idea who it is or are you just shading the POE without giving reasons why
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:12 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

MacDougall wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:06 pm
Dyslexicon wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:04 pm
nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:01 pm I want everyone to talk about Seanzie, go
He has a wonderful beard.

Idk, I kind of think he's town. I've been right on him in about every game we've played, but I also have never actually played a game where he was mafia. I don't think him being off-beat is wolfy for him.
My expectation is that by now Town Seanzie would have 1 to 2 pet wolfreads he's aggressively pursuing while nobody pays attention which actively discourages him from playing democratically. I don't think Seanzie is trying to solve the game or using his full town process in this game and that makes him lean wolf. Not lock wolf cuz he might just not give a fuck, but I can't townread him for it.
I actually read the push on nutella as being his pet wolfread.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:11 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 7:01 pm I want everyone to talk about Seanzie, go
I think he is cleared off Sabi spew and his latest posts seem like standard town Seanzie. Don't know what he gains as mafia from that weird push on you.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:10 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Dyslexicon wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 6:55 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 6:15 pm You know what annoys me? It's that a bunch of players who have the capacity to be loud, obvious, extremely solvey town have decided this game to not do much. I don't think they're all mafia so some of them are just being lazy town, and I guess real life is a thing and I've done that as town before too but it is annoying that there happen to be so many this game.

Examples include Dizzy, Ender, Seanzie, Sloonei.
I don't think this is fully fair. I have literally used my entire free time this night reading up on 40 pages of mafia. I think I'm contributing to a satisfactory degree. It's unfortunate that phase changes happens right when I've just fallen asleep, which means I will fall way behind and play catchup. Not that it's anyone's fault, also not mine.

You can un-ironically lock town me because I'm incapable of mid-posting as mafia.
Your content post catchup has been fine. I am not willing to towncore you but I would never vote you out over a slot like Marmot or SVS at this point.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 11:08 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

nutella wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 6:36 pm Tbh I keep forgetting falcon is in the game. Maybe a similar drop-off concern there where I thought he had enough towny moments d1 but isn't keeping it up
As the resident falcon godreader I still think he is town
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 6:15 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

You know what annoys me? It's that a bunch of players who have the capacity to be loud, obvious, extremely solvey town have decided this game to not do much. I don't think they're all mafia so some of them are just being lazy town, and I guess real life is a thing and I've done that as town before too but it is annoying that there happen to be so many this game.

Examples include Dizzy, Ender, Seanzie, Sloonei.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 6:13 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

See I told Guillo to stop talking nonsense and he got there on Mac

I'm so good at controlling him
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:38 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

I would like @Sloonei to comment on how he feels about the POE of 4 that me/Mac/Golden hashed out last night (112, Radishes, Marmot, SVS). Do you agree with it, do you think we're misclearing someone, do you think one of these people should be cleared, etc.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:36 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

MacDougall wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:34 pm Creature is entitled to think we are possibly wolves. Though at this juncture I think it strongly benefits town if our team stopped dwelling on possibilities and started focusing more on probabilities. Genuinely think all town need to start analysing their play through that lens.
Personally I felt like we had some extremely good solving going on last night and a really solid POE with solid reasoning and then people came back into the thread and started causing chaos for no fucking reason and throwing random reads around instead of just playing the game in an orderly manner. Unfortunately this is not AI because that is just how some people are (Guillo and tutuu especially) but it annoys me.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:32 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Guillotine wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:22 pm @Alison why do you townread me?
Because your push on Mac early D2 is the exact same "latch onto something random and tinfoil a strong consenus town player" move that you do every single town game. As mafia I think you'd find it difficult to replicate that energy and more importantly you'd be less inclined to antagonize Mac because the backlash would undermine your thread position for no real gain (since you are never going to misexe him), whereas as town you're more likely to speak your mind if you think someone is mafia backlash or not.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:29 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

MacDougall wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:22 pm @Alison you are the one protecting Guillo so can you please make it your job to control the impact hes having on the threadstate?
Ok!

@Guillotine stop talking nonsense

I'm sure he will listen
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:23 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:48 pm
Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:47 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:39 pm
Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:42 pm Huh.

This isn’t so much a gotcha as it is a logical fallacy from my POV.
>“Iawy has decent reads in general” is pretty subjective. Who’s to say mine aren’t decent?
> “POE members tend to have better reads because they have a green check on themselves and so have slightly better perspective than everyone else in the thread”
Ok, so. I have a green check on myself.
>”This is enough to put him in the POE”


To put it another way: ‘I like the taste of beef burgers’
‘If someone makes a beef burger, odds are it’ll be good’
‘Someone made a fake beef burger’
‘I’m not even going to bother trying that garbage’
It doesn't matter how good your reads are if I think you are mafia. I only care about the goodness of your reads if I think you are town in the first place.

IAWY flipped town so I can trust him. What reasons have you provided me to trust you? Mac and Sloonei see something in your posting which is the only reason I'm keeping you out of the POE, but I haven't seen you do anything pro town other than shoot IAWY... which could easily have been a loud shot you are pretending is a silent one for cred.

I see that someone mentioned you were gifted a shot. Why do you think you out of all people were selected for that gift?
You’re twisting your own words tho. Of course you can trust iawy because he flipped. You literally said because he was in the poe (implying before being flipped) he had better reads in general.

But we’re talking in circles
Oh, as to your last point- I don’t know- last time I got 2 guns, I shot and killed you in endgame to win. So…there’s that? :smile:
In that game you were randomly given the gun by a redirected night action, and you used it well because the mechanical gamestate meant that BlueKang had to be mafia from your point of view. The hypothetical gun giver in this game would have no reason to trust you were town (nobody had you as top town iirc) and no reason to trust that your reads would be particularly good. Someone like nutella is far more consensus town and also far more likely to have good reads - so I am wondering why this gun giver chose to give you the gun and not her.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 5:20 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:47 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:39 pm
Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:42 pm Huh.

This isn’t so much a gotcha as it is a logical fallacy from my POV.
>“Iawy has decent reads in general” is pretty subjective. Who’s to say mine aren’t decent?
> “POE members tend to have better reads because they have a green check on themselves and so have slightly better perspective than everyone else in the thread”
Ok, so. I have a green check on myself.
>”This is enough to put him in the POE”


To put it another way: ‘I like the taste of beef burgers’
‘If someone makes a beef burger, odds are it’ll be good’
‘Someone made a fake beef burger’
‘I’m not even going to bother trying that garbage’
It doesn't matter how good your reads are if I think you are mafia. I only care about the goodness of your reads if I think you are town in the first place.

IAWY flipped town so I can trust him. What reasons have you provided me to trust you? Mac and Sloonei see something in your posting which is the only reason I'm keeping you out of the POE, but I haven't seen you do anything pro town other than shoot IAWY... which could easily have been a loud shot you are pretending is a silent one for cred.

I see that someone mentioned you were gifted a shot. Why do you think you out of all people were selected for that gift?
You’re twisting your own words tho. Of course you can trust iawy because he flipped. You literally said because he was in the poe (implying before being flipped) he had better reads in general.

But we’re talking in circles
Being town and in the POE makes you have better reads.
The problem is that being in the POE in the first place makes me unable to trust you.
But if you are in the POE and then flip town, now I can go back to your old reads (that I didn't trust) and have more faith in them knowing you are trustworthy and have good reads.
This is what happened to IAWY.
His legacy was that you and Kate were mafia.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:41 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Golden wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:56 pm Votes for people in Mac's PoE currently:

MR 4 - Falcon, Creature, 112, Urist
112 3 - Mac, nutella, Michelle
SVS 3 - sig, alison, neon
Marmot 2 - golden, Party Crasher
I thought I was on Marmot - I must have forgotten to record my vote

[VOTE: Marmot] aubergine
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 4:39 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:42 pm Huh.

This isn’t so much a gotcha as it is a logical fallacy from my POV.
>“Iawy has decent reads in general” is pretty subjective. Who’s to say mine aren’t decent?
> “POE members tend to have better reads because they have a green check on themselves and so have slightly better perspective than everyone else in the thread”
Ok, so. I have a green check on myself.
>”This is enough to put him in the POE”


To put it another way: ‘I like the taste of beef burgers’
‘If someone makes a beef burger, odds are it’ll be good’
‘Someone made a fake beef burger’
‘I’m not even going to bother trying that garbage’
It doesn't matter how good your reads are if I think you are mafia. I only care about the goodness of your reads if I think you are town in the first place.

IAWY flipped town so I can trust him. What reasons have you provided me to trust you? Mac and Sloonei see something in your posting which is the only reason I'm keeping you out of the POE, but I haven't seen you do anything pro town other than shoot IAWY... which could easily have been a loud shot you are pretending is a silent one for cred.

I see that someone mentioned you were gifted a shot. Why do you think you out of all people were selected for that gift?
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:01 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Master Radishes wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 2:57 pm
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 2:56 pm The POE turning on each other immediately (SVS scumreading Marmot, 112 and MR getting into a fight) is extremely funny
The fact you think this is a fight is extremely funny mildly amusing.
112 called you mafia and then you caleld their post scummy and started interrogating them about their D1 votes

What I mean is that the members of the POE seem more concerned with getting another member of the POE killed over them rather than complaining about how the POE itself sucks, which suggests it isn't entirely off the mark.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 2:56 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

The POE turning on each other immediately (SVS scumreading Marmot, 112 and MR getting into a fight) is extremely funny
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 2:30 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 12:23 pm also why does me having multiple shots change you wanting to elim me today?

If you think I’m bad, get rid of me

Like what?
Multiple shots = you can prove your shot is silent = you can prove you shooting IAWY was in good faith (since as mafia with a silent shot you can just kill Mac or something and not say anything)
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 2:27 pm
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Scotty wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 10:24 am
Alison wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:48 am
Sloonei wrote: Mon Feb 20, 2023 3:44 am There's a certain calmness to his presence in this thread in the few moments we've crossed paths. Like there is nothing premeditated about any of the things he says or does, and he is just existing naturally in the game. I don't actually recall many reads he has given, but his posture feels authentic.
This is a tone read then basically?

My take on Scotty is that he has done fuck all this game and IAWY scumread him. I don't hold the IAWY shot against him, I would have done it too if I had a dayvig, but I do think that IAWY has decent reads in general and is particularly likely to have good reads because he is a member of the POE (POE members tend to have better reads because they have a green check on themselves and so have slightly better perspective than everyone else in the thread). I am not to-the-death convinced that Scotty is scum, but I don't see what you do in his tone and his actual solving has been kinda nonexistent. This is enough to put him in the POE - coupled with IAWY's conviction that he's mafia, I'm happy to vote him out.
“Iawy was in the POE”
“People in the POE tend to have better reads”
“Scotty is in the POE”
“I’m happy to vote him out”
Town in the POE tend to have better reads. If I vote you obviously I don't think you're town. This is a disingenuous gotcha.
by Alison
Mon Feb 20, 2023 6:01 am
Forum: Previous Sit Downs
Topic: Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol
Replies: 13644
Views: 191062

Re: Game of Champions 2022 D2

Going to try to sleep again, gn

Return to “Game of Champions 2022 mafia win lol”