The Syndicate

Sloonei wrote: ↑Sat Sep 26, 2020 3:46 pm I don't know if anyone even paid attention to this during the game, but the numbers at the top of each start-of-day post reflected the number of players belonging to each alignment that day. 1651 on Day 1 = 16/5/1. 701 on Day 9 = 7/0/1.

That's very nice in hindsight, but I can't believe you actually thought anyone would get it, lol

well at least my clears were good lol

GGs, this game is gonna bring me straight into retirement

If we lose this, it's called losing the lottery

not a game of mafia anymore ever since scum died

It's not a throw

this isn't a game of mafia anymore

It's not a throw if the 3p is in the PoE

Nanook you village whisperer, silver tongued ensign.

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 1:15 pm Idk, I think if I were 3p claiming “I can’t claim” I would not be worried at all about getting NKed in that gamestate, is all I’m saying

More compelling to me is that Mac helped bury the last mafia when 3p probably wants to drag the game out a bit longer usually

I'm talking about his mentality on D1.

There were no claims D1, no watcher outs, no cop outs, nothing.

He started going for mafia hard since D1.

Sure, you can make that argument, but it isn't really reasonable.

If me, you, juliets, anybody would've been 3p, how could they have known about the roles in game and how the game state would shift so easily, lol.

Like, from Mac's 3p perspective, he doesn't know there's a watcher and a cop that can't die and keeps mowing through checks.

It's a lot of assuming.

The point is that he gunned for mafia since Day 1 and put himself in the kill pool.

oh like mafia is supposed to get rid of clears

meh I think that is an outcome oriented argument, really

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 1:10 pm
tedxtr wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 1:09 pm The thing is, if he's 3p, being that active and gunning down for mafia does exactly this thing

1) Makes him a kill target

Which 3p would avoid under any and all circumstances.
It doesn’t in this game with an outed watcher then a cop with green checks

The watcher was outed D2, Mac puts himself in the killpool regardless?

I don't know what your cop argument is refuting, elaborate?

I mean, it shouldn't be weird. We have 2 other unclaimed roles.

It isn't to say there can't be 3, it's just that he doesn't have a clearing action going on for him.

Oddmerta technically didn't get cleared off his role either, it was Herm's role.

I wouldn't feel bad if Mac got flipped, it's PoE, it's mechanics, it's whatever.

But he does have a point regardless, gunning for mafia like he did is pretty anti-3p.

The thing is, if he's 3p, being that active and gunning down for mafia does exactly this thing

1) Makes him a kill target

Which 3p would avoid under any and all circumstances.

The thing is, even if we do flip his ability, I don't know how that can help us other than just making sure he wasn't the 3p, lol.

9 day phases are pretty exhausting.

Mac has a role, we just don't know what he can do.

We do know he has more abilities iirc. Or he was bluffing or something. Probably bluffing about his other ability.

I'd vote Mac solely because of not knowing his role and to be sure he is not the 3p that wins today.

Poison Chan wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 12:54 pm @tedxtr how sure are we about nanook?
Also. What do you think about Mac?

@Oddmerta why are you voting mac over nanook.

The thing is I'm paranoid and even if I have tunneling vision at the moment but I don't like Mac. Although if we go by PoE either Mac or Nanook is fine. But still would like to know the opinions.

Not sure at all.

If people didn't realise until now, all I'm doing is placing votes in the PoE.

Well deserved, then :P

I do think he has somewhat of a point w/r/t activity and caring about alignments. He could be lying but, it's a good defence. Can't really ignore it.

rest well frand

[VOTE: Nanook ] aubergine

mowing through PoE

Nanook was trying to clear himself from the PoE by suggesting he targeted Poison the night SPF also did

But he didn’t even target her, he was just alluding to it

And still, that doesn’t even work because it was completely irrelevant lol

Idk about this game

Just end my suffering

I’m paranoid of pockets, ergo juliets rn

Nutella wanted to do the same thing

Nice try Nanook, attempt respected and all

You and SPF targeted her on the same night, and it was the night she used her last shot.

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 8:16 am Yeah I mean that’s the idea

Suck it bitches, and by bitches I mean Mac

You aren’t though.

As I see it, would’ve taken Poison the following night in order to see whether she had the songs or not, and seeing that she ran out of shots after she used it on Dizzy that night, it doesn’t clear you in the slightest.

juliets wrote: ↑Mon Sep 21, 2020 7:00 am Good Morning Mr. Magpie.

Ted I look forward to your thoughts this morning. Also, @Oddmerta we really need your participation. The more thoughts the better given our game state.

I’m sorry but I don’t have anything new :P

I thought you wanted to argue you weren’t 3P off that

But it wouldn’t have made much of a difference either way.

“Light another candle and release me”

You know, I don’t like that. I really don’t.

I don’t wanna light another candle.

Votes cast by and against my target are exactly 1.

I’d like if we could get opinions on who my ability should be used on before I pass out

Wow spock is no true vulcan

He has feelings

Please take me out 3p

Assuming you have a factional and Poison is a town, she’s not a threat to you anymore

Beam me up scotty

...to DVC

That’s to Mac

So who’s it going to be between juliets and nanook?

It wouldn't be helpful if we were racing against the clock.

We don't know that.

why shouldn't we look in Mac's direction?

Do we have suggestions on who we eliminate tomorrow?

Assuming game doesn't end tonight.

The Original Series, started with The Voyager for like 2 episodes then I google'd in what order I should look at them

still kind of unclear, but right now I'm at the Charlie X episode from the original series and uhhhh, I thought it'd be hard to follow until the end but it's going a slightly less cringe way, at least for now

juliets wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:48 pm If Poison is going to lie detect she needs someone's song but I'm kind of scared for anyone to give her one because those known songs might be the key for the 3P.

That would seem like a good call.

I played a star trek themed mafia game and I started watching the series

very cool

MacDougall wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:36 pm I am pretty frustrated that I am even in the POE tbh. I don't even think I should be and I think the only reason that I am is because people haven't bothered to ISO me.

Have you heard the word of the "Mechanics"

he's a kind of overlord :P

Something tells me this doesn't get to F4

Game probably ends either tomorrow or the next day after tomorrow.

The loophole is if he's 3p that role copped him and tried to let him know he knew his role and I may misinterpret that as him receiving a notification and him being on Amnesiac.

Like, that's pretty much the only loophole.

Why would a 3p do that though?...

yeah, no, just rechecked lol.

I am definitely not looking at Odd until everyone in the PoE gets flipped. The point is strong.

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sun Sep 20, 2020 2:17 pm If it goes to f3 with odd/ted/spf then just kill odd obviously

Otherwise he’s more clear than anyone else so it’s fine imo

not more clear but the idea remains lol

I think you do have a semi good point, as in my theory about it does have some loop holes (mainly one - but I'd have to stretch a lot of things in order to confirm that), but it's enough to not worry about it for a while.

If we were to question every good looking thing, we wouldn't have a PoE.

Poison, you should've had the songs sent, no?

confirm?

Search found 853 matches