Eh, okay. Yeah, I got through like a page and a half of Dizzy and felt good.
I was hoping to essentially have an ordered PoE of Achromatic, Nanook, Dizzy, Ender (more by popular vote than my own misgivings), Wilgy (more by popular vote than my own misgivings). Dizzy is there because I didn't get the early good feelz from him that I have gotten from him as town in a few games recently and usually don't get from him as scum, but I'm not going to say I can 100% read him quite that early, and I don't feel like I'm being super bamboozled right now.
Looking at the player list for a fifth... Vivax, Lucy and Stupid Sexy Vulgard are the only others I see myself possibly reconsidering. Vivax I don't actually remember anything from but everyone else is pretty convinced they're fine. Stupid Sexy Vulgard had some slightly out-of-character play (in particular lack of activity) early on, but I chalk that up to game overload, and Vulgard's catchup looked good, but maybe should keep an eye on that slot as time goes on, making sure they still look good and didn't just have enough info from wolfchat to know that people were sussing Achromatic today. Lucy though is perhaps the person I don't really know if the thread is fully clearling them, and I only have a very weak Porscha anti-read on them, so maybe they'll be my temporary fifth until I can investigate futher.