Lost Again Mafia (season 1) - Day 6

#401

Long Con wrote:
Typhoony wrote:You go first, LC.
I don't like roleclaiming at all in open mafia games, but in closed games, .
*ping*

Ha ha, wait. I forgot about the "you not dying" thing. I rescind the ping unless some evidence comes up that there's been a deception on that front.

#402

Long Con wrote:
Typhoony wrote:You go first, LC.
I don't like roleclaiming at all in open mafia games, but in closed games, .
*ping*

Ping how? Someone basically cleared me, why would I not claim as one of the last few?

#403

I'm asking everyone to claim Scotty. Does that make you suspicious of me?

#404

Scotty, no, I have never played a closed setup. I think. You think it would turn bad if we all claimed?

Are we allowed to list players who have claimed and what role they claimed? I don't know if Golden has safeguards. I don't see how it could turn against the Civs to all claim, isn't the worst outcome that we all claim a different Lostie role and then we're back at square 1? Detective work?

#405

I'm not claiming.

#406

Typhoony wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Typhoony wrote:You go first, LC.
I don't like roleclaiming at all in open mafia games, but in closed games, .
*ping*
Ping how? Someone basically cleared me, why would I not claim as one of the last few?

My thoughts were that a baddie would want to wait for all the Civs to claim, and then claim the leftover not-in-the-game Lostie identity.

#407

a2thezebra wrote:I'm not claiming.

Why not?

#408

Long Con wrote:Scotty, no, I have never played a closed setup. I think. You think it would turn bad if we all claimed?

Are we allowed to list players who have claimed and what role they claimed? I don't know if Golden has safeguards. I don't see how it could turn against the Civs to all claim, isn't the worst outcome that we all claim a different Lostie role and then we're back at square 1? Detective work?

There are 40+ survivors from Oceanic Flight 815.

Role claiming isn't going to break anything.

But it might make the Others a little more nervous, wouldn't it, Someone Who Sounds Very Familiar To Me But I Can't Quite Put My Finger On Where I've Heard of Him Before?

#409

Long Con wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I'm not claiming.
Why not?

Nothing good will come of it. Not for me, not for anyone.

#410

I agree with LC on this. I see no issue with claiming.

#411

Scotty might not be bad. Perhaps Matt / Wilgy / Sorsha is a more likely team.

#412

Epignosis wrote:
Long Con wrote:Scotty, no, I have never played a closed setup. I think. You think it would turn bad if we all claimed?

Are we allowed to list players who have claimed and what role they claimed? I don't know if Golden has safeguards. I don't see how it could turn against the Civs to all claim, isn't the worst outcome that we all claim a different Lostie role and then we're back at square 1? Detective work?
There are 40+ survivors from Oceanic Flight 815.

Role claiming isn't going to break anything.

But it might make the Others a little more nervous, wouldn't it, Someone Who Sounds Very Familiar To Me But I Can't Quite Put My Finger On Where I've Heard of Him Before?

That's what it seemed like to me. I want to know all the negative possibilities of all-claiming.

#413

Normally, all-claiming would make it easier for the baddies to pick off who they think have a powerrole(s).

But someone has already claimed a powerrole, so that is less of an issue.

**http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23** · #414

I'm voting for Zebra. I believe Matt's claim and I'd very much prefer that he not die

and besides I find myself not trusting a word from Zebra lately.

I am fine with role claiming if you guys make up your mind about it. Tbh I sorta hinted at my role way at the beginning

#415

Epignosis wrote:
Scotty wrote:I do not wish to claim my role...yet. Suspect me for that if you like, but I am immediately suspicious of anyone that asks everyone to claim.
I already know your role.

Same to you, cowboy.

Matt wrote:Yo peeps! Well I'll be smack in the middle of my ten hour shift when the lynch takes place. I PMed Golden to see if I could do this and he said yes sooooo

I am not the moon. That is all.

Peace and good luck town!

I don't remember the moon being a big part of the lore. What am I missing here?

#416

Scotty could you elaborate on the things that can go wrong if we all claim?

You seem to be against it the most.

#417

Scotty wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Scotty wrote:I do not wish to claim my role...yet. Suspect me for that if you like, but I am immediately suspicious of anyone that asks everyone to claim.
I already know your role.
Same to you, cowboy.

Matt wrote:Yo peeps! Well I'll be smack in the middle of my ten hour shift when the lynch takes place. I PMed Golden to see if I could do this and he said yes sooooo

I am not the moon. That is all.

Peace and good luck town!
I don't remember the moon being a big part of the lore. What am I missing here?

He's not "the moon". He's "NOT-the-moon".

You know, wife of "not-rum-or-vodka"?

#418

Typhoony wrote:Scotty could you elaborate on the things that can go wrong if we all claim?

You seem to be against it the most.

I have reason to believe that I am against it the most.

#419

I'm going to guess that you're not willing to explain why?

#420

Because it would jeopardize the civilians' victory.

#421

You gotta give me more than that Zebra. You're making it seem like you are the only role that the baddies must kill to win.

#422

I don't mean to give off that impression...but your hunger for specifics as to why I'm against this raises an eyebrow in itself.

#423

You realize that this is an easy way for a baddie to not go along with outing right?

That's why I want more specifics.

#424

Typhoony wrote:I agree with LC on this. I see no issue with claiming.

Ok mister wise pants. Sorsha just claimed Jack, the doctor.

She just out a gigantic target on her back.

once everyone claims their respective role, assuming that baddies can just claim like fucking Vincent or something, it won't take a genius to figure out what power roles they could be.

#425

Long Con wrote:
Scotty wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Scotty wrote:I do not wish to claim my role...yet. Suspect me for that if you like, but I am immediately suspicious of anyone that asks everyone to claim.
I already know your role.
Same to you, cowboy.

Matt wrote:Yo peeps! Well I'll be smack in the middle of my ten hour shift when the lynch takes place. I PMed Golden to see if I could do this and he said yes sooooo

I am not the moon. That is all.

Peace and good luck town!
I don't remember the moon being a big part of the lore. What am I missing here?
He's not "the moon". He's "NOT-the-moon". You know, wife of "not-rum-or-vodka"?

Holy hatch!. This took me way too long.

#426

Typhoony wrote:You realize that this is an easy way for a baddie to not go along with outing right?

That's why I want more specifics.

And do you realize that, if you're bad, which I am unaware of, what you're doing is an easy way to find out whether or not I'm a serious threat to you?

#427

a2thezebra wrote:
Typhoony wrote:You realize that this is an easy way for a baddie to not go along with outing right?

That's why I want more specifics.
And do you realize that, if you're bad, which I am unaware of, what you're doing is an easy way to find out whether or not I'm a serious threat to you?

Nope. You're acting very much like you have a power role, so you're doing a good enough job of acting like you are a serious threat to the baddies all by yourself. Problem is that I'm not sure I believe this, since you are really over the top. But I have no interest in lynching you right now, let that be very clear.

Claiming a role in itself is not that big. I'm pretty sure I can come up with useful powers for most of the Losties that I can think of, so then it is up to the baddies to figure out what roles Golden actually gave a power. I think that is worth tradeoff with everybody claiming a role.

The role in itself doesn't mean that much. Look at the rules:

There are only three power roles, but it is not known what they are. It should not be presumed that they are all necessarily useful.

If we assume that Sorsha's claim is true, that's one power role that actually is useful. Maybe your role is useless.

Are you still suspicious of Matt Zebra?

Scotty wrote:
Typhoony wrote:I agree with LC on this. I see no issue with claiming.
Ok mister wise pants. Sorsha just claimed Jack, the doctor.

She just out a gigantic target on her back.

once everyone claims their respective role, assuming that baddies can just claim like fucking Vincent or something, it won't take a genius to figure out what power roles they could be.

Again, I think it's worth the tradeoff. The baddies do not know what roles have powers, so they would have to think of potential powers for every roleclaim and work around that.

LC, why don't you be the leading man and claim your role?

#428

"Suspicious" of Matt doesn't quite cover it.

#429

So you don't believe his claim?

#430

Typhoony wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Typhoony wrote:You realize that this is an easy way for a baddie to not go along with outing right?

That's why I want more specifics.
And do you realize that, if you're bad, which I am unaware of, what you're doing is an easy way to find out whether or not I'm a serious threat to you?
Nope. You're acting very much like you have a power role, so you're doing a good enough job of acting like you are a serious threat to the baddies all by yourself. Problem is that I'm not sure I believe this, since you are really over the top. But I have no interest in lynching you right now, let that be very clear.

Claiming a role in itself is not that big. I'm pretty sure I can come up with useful powers for most of the Losties that I can think of, so then it is up to the baddies to figure out what roles Golden actually gave a power. I think that is worth tradeoff with everybody claiming a role.

The role in itself doesn't mean that much. Look at the rules:
There are only three power roles, but it is not known what they are. It should not be presumed that they are all necessarily useful.
If we assume that Sorsha's claim is true, that's one power role that actually is useful. Maybe your role is useless.

Are you still suspicious of Matt Zebra?

Scotty wrote:
Typhoony wrote:I agree with LC on this. I see no issue with claiming.
Ok mister wise pants. Sorsha just claimed Jack, the doctor.

She just out a gigantic target on her back.

once everyone claims their respective role, assuming that baddies can just claim like fucking Vincent or something, it won't take a genius to figure out what power roles they could be.
Again, I think it's worth the tradeoff. The baddies do not know what roles have powers, so they would have to think of potential powers for every roleclaim and work around that.

LC, why don't you be the leading man and claim your role?

Typhoony, I really want to believe that you are civ and were saved last night as Sorsha claims, but there are only several characters that I can see as having any relevancy, and would very much prefer you didn't entice people into giving out chocolate like it's free. Chocolate is never free. If it is, it's probably riddled with salmonella.

#431

I really have trouble seeing how someone can be so against the idea. It pings the shit out of me honestly.

Do you know why Epignosis knows your role?

#432

Typhoony wrote:I really have trouble seeing how someone can be so against the idea. It pings the shit out of me honestly.

Do you know why Epignosis knows your role?

Because if you were paying attention I've probably hinted at it several times early on.

I'm sorry that pings you that I don't like giving baddies ammo to pull from.

Now all of this is to say that we believe each other in our claims. It still dumbfounds me that Sorsha came out so early against a little pressure from Epi as a really useful role. Let's say you're Rose. What good is Rose? She isn't. If Golden gave Rose a role or a place in this game, then I would also be dumbfounded. Because Rose is hardly an important character. So if you were to come out and say that you were Rose, what are the chances that the smoke monster would say, "Oh, she needs to die next!"

0%. Because it's Rose.

#433

What a coincidence, I have trouble seeing how anyone can be so in favor of it. Unless of course...

#434

I actually agree with zebra on this matter, but also know that even a baddie could have a similar viewpoint. So I'm conflicted.

@Wilgy man, what are your thoughts?

#435

a2thezebra wrote:What a coincidence, I have trouble seeing how anyone can be so in favor of it. Unless of course...

You forgot to finish your sentence.

#436

Oh, and happy birthday, Bullzeye! I'd sing the happy birthday song, but it's copyrighted.

So I guess I'll just dance on the beach.

#437

Scotty wrote:Oh, and happy birthday, Bullzeye! I'd sing the happy birthday song, but it's copyrighted.

Since last year somewhere, the song is no longer copyrighted. You are free to sing it!

#438

Typhoony wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:What a coincidence, I have trouble seeing how anyone can be so in favor of it. Unless of course...
You forgot to finish your sentence.

...they're bad.

#439

Ok Zebra, convince me that Matt is bad.

I looked through your posts. I don't see a case on him. All you do is say that you've given him enough free passes and then you claim that you are certain that he is bad without actually saying why, except for the fact that you don't believe both D1 bandwagons were civ. Somehow that has given him 4 votes.

Hell, you said earlier on that you weren't even familiar with Matt's baddie game but that his gameplay in this game is in tune with his civ or indy game.

Make a case on Matt. Why is this his baddie game?

#440

Scotty wrote:Oh, and happy birthday, Bullzeye! I'd sing the happy birthday song, but it's copyrighted.

So I guess I'll just dance on the beach.

Sing away, Scotty.

#441

Typhoony wrote:Ok Zebra, convince me that Matt is bad.

I looked through your posts. I don't see a case on him. All you do is say that you've given him enough free passes and then you claim that you are certain that he is bad without actually saying why, except for the fact that you don't believe both D1 bandwagons were civ. Somehow that has given him 4 votes.

Hell, you said earlier on that you weren't even familiar with Matt's baddie game but that his gameplay in this game is in tune with his civ or indy game.

Make a case on Matt. Why is this his baddie game?

The underlined portion is something to think about, wouldn't you agree?

#442

I'm out of here in about ten minutes, and I don't think I'll be back at camp until after dark. So I need to figure out what I'm going to do before I go.

#443

a2thezebra wrote:
Typhoony wrote:Ok Zebra, convince me that Matt is bad.

I looked through your posts. I don't see a case on him. All you do is say that you've given him enough free passes and then you claim that you are certain that he is bad without actually saying why, except for the fact that you don't believe both D1 bandwagons were civ. Somehow that has given him 4 votes.

Hell, you said earlier on that you weren't even familiar with Matt's baddie game but that his gameplay in this game is in tune with his civ or indy game.

Make a case on Matt. Why is this his baddie game?
The underlined portion is something to think about, wouldn't you agree?

Yes. It shows that people are lazy fuckers in general.

Case? Reason as to why Matt is bad? Pretty please?

#444

Do you have any runner-up lynch candidates after Sorsha, Epi? If so, may I inquire as to who they may be?

linki -

#445

Are you cursed to get Matt lynched without providing a single reason as to why he is bad?

#446

At this moment, Stink Floyd would be my top pick to be lynched. His vote against Tuft-Head makes no sense to me.

#447

Typhoony wrote:Scotty could you elaborate on the things that can go wrong if we all claim?

You seem to be against it the most.

Are we all claiming? I kind of already did leave a gross big hint, more than one actually.

This is why I probably will not play more of these ha ha.

I really do not want to see Zeebs lynched. I should have some time this after noon to catch back up, Saturdays are already a bitch for me, plus the post a thon I am cohosting.
So Typh, you really actually think I would kill you Night 1? That surprises me, fun> win in my books, and a challenging game is more fun. But OK.

#448

I don't think you would bring up my name as a target, but if someone would bring up my name in a game like this, I don't think you'd forbid them from killing me.

#449

Again, I'm talking about a Heist game. I think you would fight really hard if someone wanted to kill me if it was a normal 30+ player game.

#450

Nah, I am pleased you have been playing again. You are pretty much always safe from me on night 1. You know I don't play a strategy game like whether it is a small game of a large one.

But this is WIFOM, so whatever, I get it. But for future reference keep it in mind; if someone kills you on Night One, it was not me.

Who wasn't on the plane?