Downton Abbey Mafia (ENDGAME)

[Long Con]

RIP BeaBubb. Beelzebub?

Linki: Dom how do you know that Matt didn't ask for one? You are not making me feel awesome about you, can you clarify please?

What were you thinking here - that Dom and Matt are baddie teammates?

Linki - Illy - at least I have reasons for voting for you. The votes on me seem purely because I "haven't been around", and that's lame. Especially from MM, who somewhat knows my situation.

In fact, MM not changing his vote at all makes me think there might be a baddie between Faraday and Bubbles (if MM were bad, of course), and I'm wondering if I should vote one of them.

I concur, which is why I am not voting for you.

... but here you don't think he's bad.

Dr. Wilgy voting for me with no post. Awesome. Here comes to blitz ladies and gents.

Did you think there would be a sudden upswell of Illy votes?

• "Dear diary,
  
  I'm trusting Doms judgement and read. He seems to have a good head on his shoulders unlike I.
  
  A blitz on to Illy would be cool, but I don't expect this to happen."

*whatever ink was used to write that smells horrid*

• "p.s. RIP and welcome to the club"

I thought this was Edith's message post at first, and I was confused by the huge disparity of writing styles.

Speaking of Daisy, this the second time she has led us away from voting for DFaraday. I'll probably be voting for her tomorrow.

I was thinking similar thoughts about Daisy, but it makes more sense to me to lynch DFaraday first.

Still gonna be busier then normal, but I'll be around more peeps.

Not a great result today. Interesting, Wilgy broke the tie in Bubbles' favor by voting Illy. Hrm.

Anyway, peace

Or rather, I guess in DF's favor haha. But you know what I mean. Derp.

I can definitely see it both ways.

as for the second part about us being maipulated, i doubt it. long con (who i suspect still aslo) was someone that was budding her. it felt like his enitre play for the msot part was trying to get on her good side from what i recall.

Not true in the slightest.

hey sig would it be too far fetched that epi is the silencer?

I wouldn't say it was far fetched, but I wouldn't say there is any proof that he is.

well consdiering how he seemed to be beithcing about me being unslilenced?

doesnt any of his iso seem to lead to anything of thinking that?

I doubt that Epi would "beithc" about anything silence-related if he were the silencer.

Dr. Wilgy, are you going to insist on lurking?

Your sole contribution to the game so far has been "Let's not lynch anyone" or "let's lynch absent folks". You're pretty much lurking, disguised as playing.

This is my second mafia game. What do you expect from me?

Can we lynch this guy?

I'm not getting a baddie vibe from Polo.

So we didn't see any insanification today, which makes me wonder if Silver was the insanifier or if the insanifier was role blocked.

Why speculate about it? We'll see if anyone gets insanified tonight, otherwise this looks like pointless filler to me.

Speaking of Daisy, this the second time she has led us away from voting for DFaraday. I'll probably be voting for her tomorrow.

1) You were the last vote on Bubbles, so this is hypocrisy if I've ever seen it.

2) By your logic, should we not lynch DFaraday first, see if he's bad and THEN vote Daisy?

Not necessarily. Daisy could be leading the lynch away from DF for reasons other than being his teammate, but I'm pretty fine with either lynch candidate at this point.

A baddie can defend a Civvie for cred. I have a bit more Daisy suspish now than when I started this post, so I no longer base her lynchableness on the DF flip.

[Spacedaisy]

I have very good reason to speculate on it, but I don't have to share all my reasons for everything I ask. Eyeball me all you like Mr. Con, I don't have anything to hide.

[Long Con]

I have very good reason to speculate on it, but I don't have to share all my reasons for everything I ask. Eyeball me all you like Mr. Con, I don't have anything to hide.

If you are a Civ, then you can be happy to have some suspicion to ward off the Nightkill Boogeyman!

[Spacedaisy]

:nice nod:

[Spacedaisy]

[Spacedaisy]

Oh forget it

[Nerolunar]

About tieing a lynch:

Sure, the mechanic that a civ can decide it is great, but I would much rather avoid ties overall. That´s just my policy.

[thellama73]

Submitted without further comment.

I have very good reason to speculate on it, but I don't have to share all my reasons for everything I ask. Eyeball me all you like Mr. Con, I don't have anything to hide.

Finally, what you feel doesn't change the truth. I commented on the only thing I felt worth commenting on, I didn't have any other thoughts at that point. Think or feel what you like about it, it doesn't change my alignment.

Oh you are allowed to have whatever reads you like, but the way you phrased that made it sound as though I was second on your list because of silver's reads you were going to push. You should listen to her read on me, she was right.

Epi didn't ever go after me for my posts that I recall.

Yep I was wrong on my theory regarding bubbles replacement, I sure it won't be the last time I'm wrong I my mafia career. It is what it is.

I wouldn't say I strongly suspect Matt, I didn't like any of the current wagons. But when I looked at the list and tried to decide who I would be more comfortable voting for, there was no one. I'm not saving DF, I can't read DF for shit and I have contributed to his mislynch a lot in the last year, it's making me gun shy and I don't see the case for him as being all that strong in the first place. Mistrust me all you want Llama, but those are the facts, I don't have any nefarious intentions.

[bea]

At least we lynched bea, a total no-show. Right?



Sorry bea. That was shit.

Just now got to my death in my catch up.

Fun game guys!

[Spacedaisy]

[thellama73]

At least we lynched bea, a total no-show. Right?



Sorry bea. That was shit.

Just now got to my death in my catch up.

Fun game guys!

Hahaha, oh man. I'm sorry bea. You made me fel bad.

[bea]

no worries llama and co. still love you all!

I may never let any of you live it down ever....but I still love you all!

[Marmot]

:Nicenod:

[Elohcin]

Just over an hour to get in your PMs.

[Elohcin]

Day 2


Black Rock
0
No votes

Bubbles
5
Sorsha (10), Spacedaisy (12), Epignosis (13), Polo (15), thellama73 (17)
26%

DFaraday
5
Nerolunar (5), sig (8), Bubbles (9), Long Con (14), Matt (19)
26%

Dom
0
No votes

DrWilgy
0
No votes

Illyria
2
Dom (11), DrWilgy (18)
11%

ika
0
No votes

Long Con
0
No votes

Lorab
1
Illyria (16)
5%

Matt
3
Scotty (2), Metalmarsh89 (3), DFaraday (6)
16%

Metalmarsh89
0
No votes

Nerolunar
0
No votes

Polo
0
No votes

Scotty
0
No votes

sig
0
No votes

Sorsha
0
No votes

Spacedaisy
0
No votes

thellama73
0
No votes

[Illyria]

RIP BeaBubb. Beelzebub?

Linki: Dom how do you know that Matt didn't ask for one? You are not making me feel awesome about you, can you clarify please?

What were you thinking here - that Dom and Matt are baddie teammates?

I don't know about Matt, Dom on the other hand, has been giving me mild pings and not just because he has been after me from the jump. That is the game, I will do a post later.

Linki - Illy - at least I have reasons for voting for you. The votes on me seem purely because I "haven't been around", and that's lame. Especially from MM, who somewhat knows my situation.

In fact, MM not changing his vote at all makes me think there might be a baddie between Faraday and Bubbles (if MM were bad, of course), and I'm wondering if I should vote one of them.

I concur, which is why I am not voting for you.

... but here you don't think he's bad.

I do not have an issue with Matt, YET. You got the wrong suspish perspective. I feel like either I have been unclear all game, or you are subtly trying to get me lynched without leading the pack. Since I am not sure which it is this is making me frustrated.

Dr. Wilgy voting for me with no post. Awesome. Here comes to blitz ladies and gents.

Did you think there would be a sudden upswell of Illy votes?

I think I am an easy target, because I was trying to get my feet underneath me. I have them now, and the game is on.With people talking about a CFD (which I had to go and look up since no one answered me in thread) for me at the end, then Wilgy saying "it would be cool" yeah, I had my concerns.

[Illyria]

MP not payin dem bills.

I know that isn't what happened, but that tickled me nonetheless.

No, you spent the game with civs going after civs. It wasn't just one or two. The baddies didn't have to do a thing because the civs were doing their job for them. I was there and watching it all, so I am very aware of how it went down. Llama is suggesting I am bad and sticking my neck out in order to protect someone I know is civ just in order to keep people talking about him. Which would be about the stupidest thing I could do as a baddie in this game. Numbers are not in their favor, they are not going to stick their necks out in such a manner.

You know, I had not been thinking about it like this. Which shifts my lists just a tad.

While I am not going to lynch someone who has been quiet just for that reason. I want to see if I can find people who have been "participating". What I mean is someone who has been posting with little substance or someone who has been posting with the crowd over and over. Does that make sense?

[Epignosis]

Going into Day 3:

Three people I won't be voting, in semi-alphabetical order: Polo, Black Rock, Illyria

Three people I would vote for, in semi-alphabetical order: Dom, Long Con, DrWilgy

[Epignosis]

Toss Lorab in that second list.

[Elohcin]

No one has been nightkilled.
It is now Day 3. You have 48 hours to lynch someone.

[Long Con]

Going into Day 3:

One person I won't be sending a Christmas card to: Epignosis

I'll decide tomorrow if I think he's Civ or not.

Linki: NICE!!

[Polo]

Nice job to whoever is Robert Crawley!

[Dom]

that's what i'm talking about.

[Epignosis]

Going into Day 3:

One person I won't be sending a Christmas card to: Epignosis

I'll decide tomorrow if I think he's Civ or not.

I don't want any Christmas card from you. It could be laced with arsenic.

Linki: NICE!!

Was it?

[Nerolunar]

Excellent!

[Scotty]

yippee! Now to see who is silenced and insanified, if any.

[thellama73]

That's the kind of night I like to see!

I'm putting my vote on Daisy for now. For someone who keeps insisting she doesn't mind getting attention, she seems to mind it quite a bit.

[Scotty]

For now, placing a vote on LoRab.

I'll be looking to her, MM, Dom and several others this phase.

[Dom]

For now, placing a vote on LoRab.

I'll be looking to her, MM, Dom and several others this phase.

why

[Illyria]

Hot damn! Well done Lord Crawley!

[ika]

so im removed from lycnh todday and doc pulled off a save.

nice

scotty i seocnd that why lorab why not dom or daisy or something like that i need to read your lsit again

[thellama73]

so im removed from lycnh todday and doc pulled off a save.

nice

scotty i seocnd that why lorab why not dom or daisy or something like that i need to read your lsit again

Why would anyone remove you from the lynch poll? No one is even thinking about lynching you, are they?

[ika]

so im removed from lycnh todday and doc pulled off a save.

nice

scotty i seocnd that why lorab why not dom or daisy or something like that i need to read your lsit again

Why would anyone remove you from the lynch poll? No one is even thinking about lynching you, are they?

beats me.

i mean i could theory redirced but meh

[Elohcin]

All PMs have been sent. Please let me know if you didn't get one but think you should have.

[Epignosis]

With no message from Lady Edith, that means Edith was blocked, could not muster the inspiration to write a solitary word, or the poor girl is dead somewhere in the English wilderness, her body probably consumed by wolves of silver.

[Black Rock]

Alright I missed the end of the lynch and apparently a whole entire night went by. It was a beautiful weekend and I spent it working. I was going to vote and was reading over everything Saturday when I got called in early and I've only just sat down (except for sleeping last night). I was undecided when I left and I have not caught up yet.

[Epignosis]

Lorab may end up with my vote.

hey sig would it be too far fetched that epi is the silencer?

Why are you speculating in the thread about who has a civilian role?

Why is that worth giving someone the eye?

Why didn't you give Polo the eye?

I believe you are Mr. Carson, Epignosis.

This guy basically called me an old, overweight servant who is married in real life to Dolores Umbridge.

[Scotty]

For now, placing a vote on LoRab.

I'll be looking to her, MM, Dom and several others this phase.

why

because

[Spacedaisy]

Llama, so I should not point out someone's lack of logic because I told you tosuspect me all you like? Riiiiiight. You just aren't use to such an engaged Daisy. Regardless what you think, I'm civ.

Ika did you say why sorsha?

[ika]

Llama, so I should not point out someone's lack of logic because I told you tosuspect me all you like? Riiiiiight. You just aren't use to such an engaged Daisy. Regardless what you think, I'm civ.

Ika did you say why sorsha?

no reason offhand.

i do find it odd that you keep empatizig your a civ, any reason? it makes me doubt you more

[Scotty]

so im removed from lycnh todday and doc pulled off a save.

nice

scotty i seocnd that why lorab why not dom or daisy or something like that i need to read your lsit again

Well you read my list then and get back to me why you think those 2 deserve more of a

[ika]

so im removed from lycnh todday and doc pulled off a save.

nice

scotty i seocnd that why lorab why not dom or daisy or something like that i need to read your lsit again

Well you read my list then and get back to me why you think those 2 deserve more of a

i read it and understand now

did you defar read change at all

[Scotty]

so im removed from lycnh todday and doc pulled off a save.

nice

scotty i seocnd that why lorab why not dom or daisy or something like that i need to read your lsit again

Well you read my list then and get back to me why you think those 2 deserve more of a

i read it and understand now

did you defar read change at all

I can't wrap my head around what you are asking here.
Did my reads change between 6 hours ago and now? No.

[Scotty]

Ika what do you think of:
Dom
Daisy
DFaraday
Dip n' dots

[Long Con]

With no message from Lady Edith, that means Edith was blocked, could not muster the inspiration to write a solitary word, or the poor girl is dead somewhere in the English wilderness, her body probably consumed by wolves of silver.

I doubt Edith was blocked, I think it's more likely that she missed sending in her PM. The killer could have been blocked as well, instead of a successful protection.

[ika]

With no message from Lady Edith, that means Edith was blocked, could not muster the inspiration to write a solitary word, or the poor girl is dead somewhere in the English wilderness, her body probably consumed by wolves of silver.

I doubt Edith was blocked, I think it's more likely that she missed sending in her PM. The killer could have been blocked as well, instead of a successful protection.

which would imply thats black rock based on her not being around no?

[ika]

Ika what do you think of:
Dom
Daisy
DFaraday
Dip n' dots

i would lynch them all if i had multi-lynching powers. if you asking for reasons then i need more time for that and that can be done in a little bit

[Long Con]

With no message from Lady Edith, that means Edith was blocked, could not muster the inspiration to write a solitary word, or the poor girl is dead somewhere in the English wilderness, her body probably consumed by wolves of silver.

I doubt Edith was blocked, I think it's more likely that she missed sending in her PM. The killer could have been blocked as well, instead of a successful protection.

which would imply thats black rock based on her not being around no?

That's my assumption, yes.

[ika]

With no message from Lady Edith, that means Edith was blocked, could not muster the inspiration to write a solitary word, or the poor girl is dead somewhere in the English wilderness, her body probably consumed by wolves of silver.

I doubt Edith was blocked, I think it's more likely that she missed sending in her PM. The killer could have been blocked as well, instead of a successful protection.

which would imply thats black rock based on her not being around no?

That's my assumption, yes.

fair enough

[Scotty]

With no message from Lady Edith, that means Edith was blocked, could not muster the inspiration to write a solitary word, or the poor girl is dead somewhere in the English wilderness, her body probably consumed by wolves of silver.

I doubt Edith was blocked, I think it's more likely that she missed sending in her PM. The killer could have been blocked as well, instead of a successful protection.

which would imply thats black rock based on her not being around no?

Thing is, I find garnering evidence from the timing of player's posting to be generally a red herring and can't trust it. I know that when I have night powers, I often send in things towards the end of the cycle, even though I may be posting all day.
Inversely, the act of not posting does not mean a Mafia member has gone fishing. So I can't indict BR from being a role not seen in action today exclusively from her absence from the thread