The Great Gatsby [Day 5]

[DrWilgy]

They can, but they would be wrong. I did kill Rico.

Besides, I do not count numberwise towards their win condition.

[Epignosis]

Day 4

Dom has been killed. He was Catherine, a vanilla civilian.

It is now Day 4. You have 48 hours to lynch someone.

[Elohcin]

We're winding down here. I'm thinking tony, made, or neverwhere by process of elimination.

I'm civ. I feel good about LC, which is odd for me. Boom's responses to accusations make me feel better about him. Also, mafia killed blooper. And, I believe wilgy is the indi.

[Dom]

boo.

[Long Con]

We're winding down here. I'm thinking tony, made, or neverwhere by process of elimination.

I'm civ. I feel good about LC, which is odd for me. Boom's responses to accusations make me feel better about him. Also, mafia killed blooper. And, I believe wilgy is the indi.

I'm not so differently-minded about Boomslang, but I am Civ and I believe in you as well, Eloh. How do we decide Neverwhere is the one? Tough to lynch a no-show when every lynch counts more and more.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Assuming 2 Maf left

Boomslang - could be Maf with
DrWilgy - Could be a very smart maf
Elohcin - could be Maf with LC or Boom
Long Con - could be Maf with Elo
Made - could be Maf with anyone
Neverwhere - could be Maf with anyone
TonyStarkPrime - town

Wilgy, I'll make sure you get your tie today but you have to call who's going to die before it happens.

[Long Con]

Assuming 2 Maf left

Boomslang - could be Maf with
DrWilgy - Could be a very smart maf
Elohcin - could be Maf with LC or Boom
Long Con - could be Maf with Elo
Made - could be Maf with anyone
Neverwhere - could be Maf with anyone
TonyStarkPrime - town

Wilgy, I'll make sure you get your tie today but you have to call who's going to die before it happens.

I like this plan, I also want to move forward with a Wilgy-test scenario.

I typed that, but then I thought about how it's a closed setup game, and a baddie extra vote would negatively implicate Wilgy. If Wilgy is tested and is wrong, do we then lynch him?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Assuming 2 Maf left

Boomslang - could be Maf with
DrWilgy - Could be a very smart maf
Elohcin - could be Maf with LC or Boom
Long Con - could be Maf with Elo
Made - could be Maf with anyone
Neverwhere - could be Maf with anyone
TonyStarkPrime - town

Wilgy, I'll make sure you get your tie today but you have to call who's going to die before it happens.

I like this plan, I also want to move forward with a Wilgy-test scenario.

I typed that, but then I thought about how it's a closed setup game, and a baddie extra vote would negatively implicate Wilgy. If Wilgy is tested and is wrong, do we then lynch him?

I think we wait for that situation when it comes up, but I don't think it will because reasons. I want to lynch Made today.

[Elohcin]

We're winding down here. I'm thinking tony, made, or neverwhere by process of elimination.

I'm civ. I feel good about LC, which is odd for me. Boom's responses to accusations make me feel better about him. Also, mafia killed blooper. And, I believe wilgy is the indi.

I'm not so differently-minded about Boomslang, but I am Civ and I believe in you as well, Eloh. How do we decide Neverwhere is the one? Tough to lynch a no-show when every lynch counts more and more.

Right... difficult to push a neverwhere ltnch even if she is mafia. My thoughts exactly.

[Elohcin]

Tony, much of your most recent list makes sense if i put myself in your shoes and if you're civ.

I'd be willing to vote made today. He is high on my list of probable mafia. He says things like, he isnt here because life. It could just be he's afraid to participate because he's alone. Idk.

[Boomslang]

Two things: TSP, you never specified who I could be Mafia with. And Elo, what do you mean by Made being alone? There's only one Mafia down... Unless you're forgetting to count yourself

[DrWilgy]

I wouldn't mind being retested.

[Elohcin]

Two things: TSP, you never specified who I could be Mafia with. And Elo, what do you mean by Made being alone? There's only one Mafia down... Unless you're forgetting to count yourself

No. I'm thinking the other can be neverwhere. I thought I mentioned that.

[Boomslang]

Assuming 2 Maf left

Boomslang - could be Maf with
DrWilgy - Could be a very smart maf
Elohcin - could be Maf with LC or Boom
Long Con - could be Maf with Elo
Made - could be Maf with anyone
Neverwhere - could be Maf with anyone
TonyStarkPrime - town

Wilgy, I'll make sure you get your tie today but you have to call who's going to die before it happens.

I like this plan, I also want to move forward with a Wilgy-test scenario.

I typed that, but then I thought about how it's a closed setup game, and a baddie extra vote would negatively implicate Wilgy. If Wilgy is tested and is wrong, do we then lynch him?

Heists have a maximum of 3 non-vanilla roles. Two of them are dead; if Wilgy doesn't call the tie correctly, we know he's vanilla something, but it wouldn't necessarily implicate him as bad.

[Long Con]

Ok then. I'll vote Neverwhere, with the understanding that people will try to make this a tie.

However, with 7 of us here and Neverwhere not voting, I doubt Made will agree to allow a tie if he's the lynchee. Perhaps he can vote Neverwhere and Wilgy can direct the tie to Neverwhere this time.

[DrWilgy]

Yeah sure.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Ok then. I'll vote Neverwhere, with the understanding that people will try to make this a tie.

However, with 7 of us here and Neverwhere not voting, I doubt Made will agree to allow a tie if he's the lynchee. Perhaps he can vote Neverwhere and Wilgy can direct the tie to Neverwhere this time.

I don't like this. If Made doesn't agree to a tie then he gets lynched. He would have to agree for it to work. There's no reason for Neverwhere to get lynched, he isn't doing anything.

[Elohcin]

Neverwhere is a SHE!!!!

[Long Con]

Ok then. I'll vote Neverwhere, with the understanding that people will try to make this a tie.

However, with 7 of us here and Neverwhere not voting, I doubt Made will agree to allow a tie if he's the lynchee. Perhaps he can vote Neverwhere and Wilgy can direct the tie to Neverwhere this time.

I don't like this. If Made doesn't agree to a tie then he gets lynched. He would have to agree for it to work. There's no reason for Neverwhere to get lynched, he isn't doing anything.

Ok, lay out the voting scenario for everyone to get on track.

[Elohcin]

Yeah... I'm a little confused too.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Neverwhere is a SHE!!!!

Still learning.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Ok then. I'll vote Neverwhere, with the understanding that people will try to make this a tie.

However, with 7 of us here and Neverwhere not voting, I doubt Made will agree to allow a tie if he's the lynchee. Perhaps he can vote Neverwhere and Wilgy can direct the tie to Neverwhere this time.

I don't like this. If Made doesn't agree to a tie then he gets lynched. He would have to agree for it to work. There's no reason for Neverwhere to get lynched, he isn't doing anything.

Ok, lay out the voting scenario for everyone to get on track.

7 players. 1 is Wilgy, two are being lynched. The other four divide into two groups. 2 vote for Made, two vote for Never. Made votes for Never. Wilgy votes for Made. Wilgy chooses who dies (or Never dies, I haven't figured out how the power works yet). If Made doesn't help, there are three votes on Made and he dies.

[DrWilgy]

I mean. I don't haaaave to vote.

[Elohcin]

Okay...sound good. And if wilgy doesn't vote, it should be easy to carry out this plan.

[Elohcin]

I will go ahead and vote made.

[DrWilgy]

Sluuuurmp.

Hmm... I think its understandable why I'm not super invested in this game.

Where the hell is everyone else.

Snooooooorefestamirite?

[speedchuck]

It's because I died. I am the life of the party.

[speedchuck]

I was supposed to use these, my bad

[TonyStarkPrime]

Sluuuurmp.

Hmm... I think its understandable why I'm not super invested in this game.

Where the hell is everyone else.

Snooooooorefestamirite?

I think with this game no one wants to jump in and talk so there isn't a lot to bounce off of.

[Boomslang]

Long Con, are you still on board with leaving one of the most important lynches in the game to Wilgy?

[Boomslang]

For that matter, TSP, why are you so keen to leave this decision to Wilgy? Could it be because you know both Made and Neverwhere are civ, and that either way will make Wilgy look bad?

[Ricochet]

It's because I died. I am the life of the party.

Nay, it's because you shot the pianist and killed the music of this soiree. Pat yourself on the back for that, old sport.

[Quin]

I was supposed to use these, my bad

speedchuck has been modkilled. He was already dead.

[Boomslang]

This is so aggravating. I'm drunk and voting Neverwhere to punish all the nonparticipants. Odds are one of you is bad.

[Elohcin]

The participation is so bad this game. Come on people.... what's going on?

Boomslang, you may have a point about the lynch. I'm treating this as a vote-for-who-I-think-is-bad lynch. If they want to use it to seek out if wilgy is legit...that works. I do hope we aren't voting for two civs here though.

Linki....now we have a drunk participant...never good.

[Elohcin]

And now the day is over. This is some shit right here.

[Elohcin]

I hope neverwhere is a mafia...i really do.

[Epignosis]

Night 4

I'll make this quick.

Neverwhere has been lynched. She (he?) was Michaelis, a vanilla civilian.

It is now Night 4.

[Epignosis]

Who killed her sister Catherine?

Poll ended at Fri Aug 11, 2017 9:26 pmPlease note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

Boomslang
0
No votes


Voters: None

DrWilgy
0
No votes


Voters: None

Elohcin
0
No votes


Voters: None

Long Con
0
No votes


Voters: None

Made
1
14%


Voters: Elohcin

Neverwhere
2
29%


Voters: Long Con, Boomslang

TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes


Voters: None

Mrs. McKee (The Host, the Non, the Dead)
4
57%


Voters: sprityo, nijuukyugou, JaggedJimmyJay, Epignosis


Total votes: 7

[Elohcin]

GAH!!!

[Elohcin]

There's no way to solve a game with this little chatter. We're just sitting around waiting to be plucked off one by one during the night.

[Boomslang]

In the words of Malcom Reynolds, gorramit.

[DrWilgy]

What the hell, I thought the goal was to test me?

W/e Neverwhere was gonna die anyways.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Okay, there are five left after tonight. I'm pretty sure Elo is town. If she isn't, she's fooled me. Made and Boom seem most likely but I'm not sure on it. I'm growing to be less sure on Wilgy, but we can't prove it necessarily untrue. I just find it unlikely that there would be two non-vanilla town roles and a non-vanilla neutral. LC is pinging me but not in a standard LC way.

[Spacedaisy]

In the words of Malcom Reynolds, gorramit.

I knew there was a reason I liked you. Well I mean besides the fact you're a cool dude... and if Blooper likes you, you must be ok!

[Long Con]

GAH!!!

[Long Con]

Ok, so Wilgy didn't vote.... he could have made it a tie... and made the plan work... and then has the nerve to say:

What the hell, I thought the goal was to test me?

Hey Wilgy: maybe vote and make it a tie if you want the plan to work! WTF? Like, really, WTF????!!

[Elohcin]

Yes. I'm beginning to think wilgy's whole role is made up.

[Elohcin]

He threatened the civs and the baddies though, when he revealed his role. And no one stepped up and went against him right off the bat. What does that say? One might think the actual independent would say something against wilgy at that time. Or perhaps not if the independent xan very well win with either faction. I think I'm just talking myself into more confusion.

[Elohcin]

The sad thing is... I'm really into this game deapite all the lack of participation and I want to get these baddies but I have no clue who to look at. I think I trust LC right now and possibly Tony. That's it.