Well this clears up that.
I have mixed feels on a DDL lynch myself, I feel he could be a specific role *for reasons of my own* that may or may not be a civ role based solely on speculation. His thread has not given me much to go on, so I have hesitated to join the "let's lynch person X becasue there is a Y% chance they are bad" wagon we seem to have going on in this game.Tranq wrote: ↑Wed Dec 19, 2018 6:51 amSo let's assume Savage Pixie didn't kill nutella then.Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Dec 18, 2018 9:11 pmi don't believe the savage pixie would do that.Tranq wrote: ↑Tue Dec 18, 2018 9:11 pmWhy would the Savage Pixie, if civ, use their one time kill on nutella Night 1?Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Dec 17, 2018 10:29 pm if everything we've been told and everything we're assuming is true is true, and also DDL killed nutella, then DDL is one of the following, ranked from most civ to least civ:
savage pixie: i think this role is the most likely of these to be civ, since it can identify corpses.
Sakana Sashimi: i think this is probably an indie role since their kill count was increased for balance purposes, this possibility only applies if nutella died in the water
Dark Woshipper: DDL himself described this role as a probable hostile indie role, and it seems apt, since
a member of the mafia who just happened to carry out the kill on nutella, if Turnip Head was the one killed by the mafia then that makes this one obsolete.
i don't think i'd consider DDL an immediate priority for lynching specifically unless he's mafia, the Dark Worshipper does look dangerous and would be good to be rid of sooner or later for sure, but sakana sashimi can basically only kill people who decide to go swimming for some reason, and savage pixie has clear posititve utility.
nutella was far from a strong suspect of anyone
nutella is a smart player who's usually well aware of the roles so i think she would try to avoid the water squares.
From your POV, that leaves DDL as Dark Worshipper or random mafia member. Why isn't he an immediate priority lynching again?
[mention]Dragon D. Luffy[/mention] do you have any reads on Kyle?
This has been said before, it needs to be said again. Everyone in this game seems mainly in love with their own idea and the town needs to start listening to each other. We seem to have some ace manipulators in this thread, and we need to stop pushing so many different agendas. There lies insanity, and being overrun by Mafia. But thinking more than one person could be bad does not automatically mean people are "saving" someone when the vote is 9-8 in a game with 22 players left [mention]Enrique[/mention].
While I am sorry to see Novas role go, he wasn't playing so his cool role was of no use to the town. I am a bit surprised that he did not flip as either Malingerer or Darkness, and I wonder why those roles are inactive? That said, I still think TH was who he flipped as being.
OK.