"Amazing. Crime is down and no one wants to take any credit. What is wrong with this picture?"
[Major] - As the commanding officer of the Homicide Unit, you have several detectives under your command. During the day, you may give instructions to one of them by choosing the target of their active abilities. If they refuse your order, you may strip them of their abilities and assign them to someone else.
----Detective Mcnulty: Secret
----Detective Moreland: Secret
Wincon - Eliminate all threats to Town.
Day 5 starts.
You have 48 hours to decide on a lynch.
The town list is in some random mindscrew order, but the scum are 2 and 4, while the town are all higher numbers. It must be ordered by alignment! Sig and TH, place your votes now.
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Fri Dec 20, 2019 11:11 pm
I guess it’s between LC, Sig, TH AND MAYBE Speedchuck.
I was planning on just voting Dunya and seeing how things went from there but now that’s shot.
I know this is ironic but it's still salad.
I was also going to vote Dunya. Guess I telegraphed that too hard.
Would you mind explaining, in show, what 'clears' the non-salad players for you?
Okay.
I'm clearing Nanook for the Colin/Sloonei POE. Creature for volume/tone on D3 given his meta. DDL for generally feeling pure and townDDLish and also for being on Rej early and often.
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Fri Dec 20, 2019 11:11 pm
I guess it’s between LC, Sig, TH AND MAYBE Speedchuck.
I was planning on just voting Dunya and seeing how things went from there but now that’s shot.
I know this is ironic but it's still salad.
I was also going to vote Dunya. Guess I telegraphed that too hard.
Would you mind explaining, in show, what 'clears' the non-salad players for you?
Okay.
I'm clearing Nanook for the Colin/Sloonei POE. Creature for volume/tone on D3 given his meta. DDL for generally feeling pure and townDDLish and also for being on Rej early and often.
Thanks. I have less to go on with Creature, less experience with his meta, but I can roll with those.
The town list is in some random mindscrew order, but the scum are 2 and 4, while the town are all higher numbers. It must be ordered by alignment! Sig and TH, place your votes now.
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Fri Dec 20, 2019 11:11 pm
I guess it’s between LC, Sig, TH AND MAYBE Speedchuck.
I was planning on just voting Dunya and seeing how things went from there but now that’s shot.
I know this is ironic but it's still salad.
I was also going to vote Dunya. Guess I telegraphed that too hard.
Would you mind explaining, in show, what 'clears' the non-salad players for you?
Okay.
I'm clearing Nanook for the Colin/Sloonei POE. Creature for volume/tone on D3 given his meta. DDL for generally feeling pure and townDDLish and also for being on Rej early and often.
Thanks. I have less to go on with Creature, less experience with his meta, but I can roll with those.
A better way to read my POE is "I've cleared 3 players and I kinda think Speedchuck is town." Here's everybody else and I'm not entirely clearing Speed.
speedchuck wrote: ↑Sat Dec 21, 2019 12:05 amThe town list is in some random mindscrew order, but the scum are 2 and 4, while the town are all higher numbers. It must be ordered by alignment! Sig and TH, place your votes now.
Remember when I said I had an angleshooting possibility earlier in the game? I was thinking that the last players in the list might be the baddies. That was debunked, but now...
Technicolor Vote Analysis (aka that thing I copied from G-Man a few years ago)
Note: votes were tallied using aubergines. I'm not bothering to check every post to see if anyone sneaked an aubergine-less vote in them. I did, however, doublecheck the final votes with the poll results, so at least the ones that remained unchanged until the end of the day are guaranteed to be right.
Day 1
Dom
Creature - sig MacDougall Creature Speedchuck Nutella Jack
Creature - LC Dunya JJJ
Speedchuck - Macdougall DDL Rej Jack Sloonei
Dom - Jack Rej Dunya Long Con
DDL
Jack Speedchuck
Nanook - dunya
Boo - colin
Sig - Nanook Nanook
Sloonei - Boo Colin Sloonei Boo Nutella
KEY:
Dom Dragomir Rej Nutella DDL Speedchuck
Others
Corrections:
[mention]Dragomir[/mention] never called his votes. We know he made a vote for Rej in the middle of day 1. Based on his and Rej's posts, it happened somewhere around Jack's vote to Rej and Rej's vote to Drago. The fact we can't know for sure whether Sloonei joined the DDL wagon before or after the Rej wagon gained a third vote makes me want to facepalm. Bad Drago.
Sig called a vote on nanook, but did not aubergine. Bad Sig!
Creature made an early vote for Sig, then was the 2nd vote on Drago, but later changed that to LC. All of his votes were early in the day.
LC was the first vote on Dom (besides dunya who had changed away). He never changed from it.
Speed was the 2nd vote on the early nutella wagon. Not ong after, he dropped it and went for a lone Mac vote. Later on, he decided to be the 2nd vote on Rej (aside from Jack who had changed from it). He did not change his vote again.
Nanook voted Sig. Then he went and became the 4th vote on Dom.
Sig voted for Nanook later in the phase. I didn't see if he voted for anyone before since he doesn't use aubergines.
Jack was the 3rd vote on nutella, then the 2nd vote on Rej, then the 3rd vote on Dom.
DDL was the 1st vote on Rej, then later became the 2nd vote on Dom.
It seems I'll have to do this one manually. Time to skim 700+ posts. Fml.
Sloonei Dunya
Dunya DDL Boo Sloonei
Boo LC nutella nutella Nanook Speedchuck Speedchuck Long Con Long Con TonyStarkPrime nutella TonyStarkPrime Jack
Jack dunya DDL DDL DDL Dunya DDL
Dunya nutella Long Con Long Con
DDL Sig Boo Boo Speed Speed Creature Sloonei Sloonei Nanook Rej Rej Sloonei Sloonei Nutella Nutella Long Con Long Con DDL Sig DDL dunya nutella dunya Jack dunya Jack Sloonei
Sloonei LC Long Con Long Con TonyStarkPrime TonyStarkPrime TonyStarkPrime ??? TonyStarkPrime Rej Rej Boo LC Boo nutella nutella DDL
DDL Sig Colin Colin nutella nutella Sig Sig Nanook Nanook dunya dunya Sloonei LC sloonei DDL Sig DDL Boo Boo nutella nutella nutella nutella Colin Colin
KEY
Rej TonyStarkPrime Sloonei Colin Boo Jack Speedchuck Zemmi
Other
Striked voted mean removed votes.
[mention]TonyStarkPrime[/mention] voted for two players near the start of the phase, and called neither. We know one of them is nutella because he declared changing it to Rej. We don't know who the other one is, but he presumably stayed on them for the whole day before changing it to Colin. Bad TSP for making my life hard. Please DON'T post to correct this, TSP.
Creature came here near the end, made a gazillion posts and dropped the 4th vote on Sloonei. No other votes.
LC voted for Sloonei (2nd vote) and Zemmi (3rd vote). Changed the Zemmi vote to Boo (3rd). Changed from Boo to TSP (4th). Changed from TSP to Jack (3rd). Never chaged from Sloonei.
Nanook voted for Zemmi (2nd). Later on he put his second vote on Sloonei (5th). Then changed his Zemmi vote to Colin (4th).
Speed voted for Rej (2nd) and Jack (1st). Then he changed his Jack vote to TSP (1st)
Jack voted for Rej (4th) and dunya (1st). Then he changed his dunya vote to Colin (2nd)
Sig just came later in the phase, dropped his votes on Rej and Sloonei, and left. Sig is the MVP of Day 2, hands down. Or the busser of the year.
DDL voted for Boo (3rd vote). Changed it to Rej (5th vote). Finally made my second vote, to Sig (1st vote). Changed the Sig vote to Jack (2nd vote). Changed the Jack vote back to Sig (still 1st vote). Changed the Sig vote to TSP (6th vote).
Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Sat Dec 21, 2019 11:05 am
Sig just came later in the phase, dropped his votes on Rej and Sloonei, and left. Sig is the MVP of Day 2, hands down. Or the busser of the year.
Long Con wrote: ↑Sat Dec 21, 2019 2:54 am
It's really nice that sig and TH were already main suspects before this came up. Thank you, Jack.
Since when?
It’s a joke.
I threw out a poe that included the two of you in the form of a salad as a joke (the salad, not the poe). We talked about why that poe and it’s not that I even suspect the players that much but thatI’ve cleared the other 3 players.
Then Speed notices that Sloonei and Rej are at the top of the player list. The player list isn’t in alphabetical order. He jokingly says that you and TH have to be wolves because the player list is in role order with the wolves all at the top.
So LC is joking that we never would have figured out Speed’s (joke) solve that you two are mafia if I hadn’t first put “strong suspicion” on you two by putting you in my POE.
Gonna change my undertitle to “explainer of jokes.”
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sat Dec 21, 2019 12:20 pm
But yes please continue to tell me how me being better than you at finding scum must make me scum
We shall be lynching speedchuck today. You are proud of catching scum. Speedchuck seems almost ashamed of it.
Dom votes Nutella
Creature - sig MacDougall votes Drago Creature votes Drago Speedchuck votes Nutella Nutella votes Speedchuck Jack votes Nutella
Creature - LC Dunya votes Dom JJJ votes Speedchuck
Speedchuck - Macdougall DDL votes Rej Rej votes DDL Jack votes Rej Sloonei votes DDL
Dom - Jack Rej voted Drago Dunya votes DDL Long Con votes Dom
DDL votes Dom
Jack votes Dom Speedchuck votes Rej
Nanook - dunya
Boo - colin
Sig - Nanook Nanook votes Dom
Sloonei - Boo Colin votes Dom Sloonei votes Drag Boo votes Drago Nutella votes Drago
KEY:
Dom Dragomir Rej Nutella DDL Speedchuck
Others
Corrections:
@Dragomir never called his votes. We know he made a vote for Rej in the middle of day 1. Based on his and Rej's posts, it happened somewhere around Jack's vote to Rej and Rej's vote to Drago. The fact we can't know for sure whether Sloonei joined the DDL wagon before or after the Rej wagon gained a third vote makes me want to facepalm. Bad Drago.
Sig called a vote on nanook, but did not aubergine. Bad Sig!
Sloonei was never in danger of being lynched.
Rej has 3 votes (Jack, DDL, Drago) at one point, competing with wagons on Drago Mac, Rej) and DDL (Rej, Sloonei, Dunya) and Speedchuck (Jay, Nutella.)
Sloonei speedchuck DDL
TH Jack Nanook Creature Boo dunya Colin DDL TH dunya Sig DDL Creature DDL DDL Creature Long Con Jack Speed Sloonei Sloonei Sloonei Boo Speed Creature Sloonei Long Con Nanook
KEY
Colin Sloonei Long Con Jack Sig Creature Speedchuck
dunya
Thanks. I have less to go on with Creature, less experience with his meta, but I can roll with those.
I was thinking that the last players in the list might be the baddies. That was debunked, but now... 
