I am not against lynching baddies, I am against wasting lynches on unlynchable roles. Yesterday Boomslang unlynchable. So forgive me if I didn't want to waste a day lynching him.
At this point, my big question marks are Hedgeowl, Elohcin, Spacedaisy, and DFaraday in order of most unsure of to unsure of but can see how they could be a civvie.
I was totally shocked that Mongoose was Penny. I didn't see that coming at all. And it sucks.
If Nev is right and Boomslang is Cohen then I don't see why he's such a threat. This is Cohen's role description:
Sander Cohen – [Bioshock] – Controller and head of Fort Frolic, Cohen is an artist gone mad, to say the least. Now that he has finished his masterpiece, the Quadytch, he is content, only angered by those who dare to doubt him. He survives the first two attempts on his life, whether by lynch or by nightkill. Every odd night, he may use his camera to take a picture of any deceased individual, revealing their role to him. Wins by surviving, but only if everyone else alive has never doubted him.
Only 3 people have voted for Boomslang this entire game--Mongoose, bea, and Elohcin. So he's only technically a threat to bea and Elohcin at this point, except not really because he has no night kill. He has to hope we lynch them. So I don't understand why he's such a threat if that is his role.
If he's actually Fetus, then he's not lynchable until BWT succeeds in his nightly search. And as I pointed out to Elohcin, unless BWT was lying yesterday (which would be strange for him to do as a civvie), then Fetus wasn't lynchable yesterday.
Since we've never lynched a member of a mafia team yet this game, it's much harder to draw connections.
Based on Creeper performing the last two kills, it appears the Manipulators are no more (tonight might further cement that theory). That means only Video Game baddies are still alive. We know Creeper is alive. And seems like Fetus probably is too. We have been working with the assumption that Epignosis was Pirahna Plant based on when we last saw the PP written into a lynch post and the timing of his death. If that is true, then SD seems unlikely to have been his teammate because she voted for him in past lynches. She voted for him on Day 5 and Day 6. Day 5 Epi had 6 votes to llama's 10. On Day 6 Epi received 5 votes to Vomps' 7 votes.
However, in looking at that, I noticed that Hedgeowl voted for Epignosis on Day 5 and gave him is 6th vote. But timing-wise, she was the last player to vote in the lynch and llama already had 10 votes. So perhaps she was placing a vote on a teammate since she knew he wouldn't get lynched by that point. So I think Hedgeowl is a likely candidate for Creeper or Fetus (note however, she voted to rezz me, not Kate, which is interesting, that gives me some pause).
Elohcin has been acting strange to me since she received a lot of votes a couple of days ago. I've already said that I think her reaction fits with her being Cohen, but Nev seems so sure Boomslang isn't Fetus and I can't figure out any other way Boomslang could have survived a lynch.
DFaraday is a big question mark for me. But there was something in the Night 9 post and his reaction to my questioning it makes me think he's probably a civvie.
So I guess if I had to suggest someone, I'm leaning towards Hedgeowl.
S~V~S, where are you looking? I know you voted for Bea yesterday. Does the reveal of Mongoose's role change that for you?