Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[dyachei]

i don't think nutella is necessarily villa, i think their claim buys them a night

i do think you're independently wolfy

[Long Con]

NANOOK U JUST DOXXED URSELF LMAO thanks for ur IP buddy

All according to plan...

[MacDougall]

Didn't someone already claim Karma Police?

[tutuu]

how can nutella prove herself if proving herself requires ppl to flavor claim which sounds ridiculous to do. well tim did but. i aint claiming SHIT BOIIIIIIIIIII

[juliets]

Is there a reason to believe Colin is town?

[staypositivefriend]

i don't prescribe to the idea that a persons claim in a role madness setup should influence how we read them, unless they are specifically providing alignment-relevant information. it's silly to counterwagon a consensus scumread because they claimed doctor, and i'll stand by that

if youre going to counterwagon then i too would vote tim or spirit atm, but i dont agree that one needs to exist

[Timsup2nothin]

nutella's claim requires both the song + the role that people have for her ability to work correctly, and since this is a role madness setup, it means that the roles in this setup are so hyper-specific that i highly doubt her ability could ever work without having people outright claim

i just dont really buy it tbh

no just the song title, also i should have clarified but i have a full list of the song titles that are in the game so im not just shooting in the dark in the whole discog lmao

So by matching their song you get them in the boat, and then once they are in the boat you can choose one to protect, is that it?

i protect the whole boat

so it's actually p good if i get multiple people

Let Down

I'm in.

This is actually a scum claim fmpov. Who would be unafraid to roleclaim if not someone aware of why it is not safe to do so?

Because I think I don't really care about the whole "but what about soup killers" paranoia that infests this site.

PS I didn't role claim. Near as I can make out the associated song title has little to nothing to do with the actual role.

[tutuu]

NANOOK U JUST DOXXED URSELF LMAO thanks for ur IP buddy

All according to plan...

party in nanook's house after this game ends see u there LC

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Is there a reason to believe Colin is town?

He had a townie moment with Nutella earlier, something about how he responded to a phrasing thing

Maybe that was with Mac idr

[Hally]

Yeah if you want to just tunnel her you can just say "Nutella would do this as mafia" and be right almost always though Hally.

What you are presenting is about 1% likely vs. the 99% likely reality which is that she just wouldn't do what you're saying lol.

ok

im just honestly not convinced but i might be dumb

[MacDougall]

If someone already claimed then Nutella already has someone to protect. What if she puts scum on the boat?

Nutella wait. You are saying that if you get it right, they go on the boat and then you protect the whole boat every single night? That role is broken.

[MacDougall]

nutella's claim requires both the song + the role that people have for her ability to work correctly, and since this is a role madness setup, it means that the roles in this setup are so hyper-specific that i highly doubt her ability could ever work without having people outright claim

i just dont really buy it tbh

no just the song title, also i should have clarified but i have a full list of the song titles that are in the game so im not just shooting in the dark in the whole discog lmao

So by matching their song you get them in the boat, and then once they are in the boat you can choose one to protect, is that it?

i protect the whole boat

so it's actually p good if i get multiple people

Let Down

I'm in.

This is actually a scum claim fmpov. Who would be unafraid to roleclaim if not someone aware of why it is not safe to do so?

Because I think I don't really care about the whole "but what about soup killers" paranoia that infests this site.

PS I didn't role claim. Near as I can make out the associated song title has little to nothing to do with the actual role.

It's nothing to do with the paranoia. The host specifically said that claiming is dangerous.

[Hally]

nutella's claim requires both the song + the role that people have for her ability to work correctly, and since this is a role madness setup, it means that the roles in this setup are so hyper-specific that i highly doubt her ability could ever work without having people outright claim

i just dont really buy it tbh

no just the song title, also i should have clarified but i have a full list of the song titles that are in the game so im not just shooting in the dark in the whole discog lmao

So by matching their song you get them in the boat, and then once they are in the boat you can choose one to protect, is that it?

i protect the whole boat

so it's actually p good if i get multiple people

Let Down

I'm in.

This is actually a scum claim fmpov. Who would be unafraid to roleclaim if not someone aware of why it is not safe to do so?

mindmeld

but also its tim so

[nutella]

If someone already claimed then Nutella already has someone to protect. What if she puts scum on the boat?

Nutella wait. You are saying that if you get it right, they go on the boat and then you protect the whole boat every single night? That role is broken.

well i can only either guess to add people or protect each night

[Timsup2nothin]

If someone already claimed then Nutella already has someone to protect. What if she puts scum on the boat?

Nutella wait. You are saying that if you get it right, they go on the boat and then you protect the whole boat every single night? That role is broken.

That role gets Nutella NKed bloody fast is what it does.

[nutella]

like i can't protect anyone until at least n2

[MacDougall]

It sounds like you're making it up as you go along friendo

[Long Con]

My instincts tell me nutella's claim is a trap, so it's probably actually legit.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I hate EOD shuffles but this is so townie imo

[MacDougall]

Also I think Tim is absolutely lock mafia if Nutella flips mafia

[nutella]

It sounds like you're making it up as you go along friendo

no it's just weird and has a lot of details i had to read it like several times

[nutella]

My instincts tell me nutella's claim is a trap, so it's probably actually legit.

h o y a

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I don’t love a tim vote but it’s better than Nutella

[Hally]

If someone already claimed then Nutella already has someone to protect. What if she puts scum on the boat?

Nutella wait. You are saying that if you get it right, they go on the boat and then you protect the whole boat every single night? That role is broken.

yea because she can protect you, tutuu and alison every single night so scum can never kill you guys unless they block her

i don’t buy it really. i also don’t buy theres a protective role that needs such specific info to work when there’s probably downsides to claiming in the setup

[tutuu]

there are 4 minutes until eod

nutella-chan ur still sitting on a 1-vote juliets wagon?

[MacDougall]

My instincts tell me nutella's claim is a trap, so it's probably actually legit.

I was already getting some doubts on her wagon before this claim. She held it too long for it to be fake right? Like if she was gonna fake claim as mafia you'd do it ages ago when there's a chance you live?

[staypositivefriend]

personally im not changing my vote

[nutella]

[VOTE: tim] aubergine guess this is my best shot lol

[Long Con]

My instincts tell me nutella's claim is a trap, so it's probably actually legit.

h o y a

wait is that an acronym or just a sound to make?

[Hally]

If someone already claimed then Nutella already has someone to protect. What if she puts scum on the boat?

Nutella wait. You are saying that if you get it right, they go on the boat and then you protect the whole boat every single night? That role is broken.

well i can only either guess to add people or protect each night

so you cant add ppl and protect the same night?

[Long Con]

Ok [VOTE: Tim] aubergine

[Timsup2nothin]

no just the song title, also i should have clarified but i have a full list of the song titles that are in the game so im not just shooting in the dark in the whole discog lmao

So by matching their song you get them in the boat, and then once they are in the boat you can choose one to protect, is that it?

i protect the whole boat

so it's actually p good if i get multiple people

Let Down

I'm in.

This is actually a scum claim fmpov. Who would be unafraid to roleclaim if not someone aware of why it is not safe to do so?

Because I think I don't really care about the whole "but what about soup killers" paranoia that infests this site.

PS I didn't role claim. Near as I can make out the associated song title has little to nothing to do with the actual role.

It's nothing to do with the paranoia. The host specifically said that claiming is dangerous.

I'm not currently finding that in the rules, tbh.

[Hally]

like i can't protect anyone until at least n2

oh

hmm

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Inb4 Nutella flips mafia/rogue with a soup kill

[MacDougall]

Nah Nutella is mafia. That role is stupidly town and it'd be obvious but earlier she claimed to have a weak role. Her story isn't straight.

[nutella]

My instincts tell me nutella's claim is a trap, so it's probably actually legit.

h o y a

wait is that an acronym or just a sound to make?

it's a name. "hoya theorem" is one of them silly mu terms, basically means that scum fake claims are the ones that sound clean and make sense while the real town claims are messy/sloppy

[Hally]

Also I think Tim is absolutely lock mafia if Nutella flips mafia

i already had the thought they could be w/w but i have no idea what prompted it

[MacDougall]

Mechanics exist which make roleclaiming and infodumping potentially dangerous. Proceed with caution.

[Hally]

Also I think Tim is absolutely lock mafia if Nutella flips mafia

i already had the thought they could be w/w but i have no idea what prompted it

[tutuu]

Nah Nutella is mafia. That role is stupidly town and it'd be obvious but earlier she claimed to have a weak role. Her story isn't straight.

lc claimed the weak role

[staypositivefriend]

gg i was maf

[Long Con]

Inb4 Nutella flips mafia/rogue with a soup kill

10 bucks on rogue with the Win-con of knowing everyone's role.

[MacDougall]

I'm frozen coffee

[nutella]

If someone already claimed then Nutella already has someone to protect. What if she puts scum on the boat?

Nutella wait. You are saying that if you get it right, they go on the boat and then you protect the whole boat every single night? That role is broken.

well i can only either guess to add people or protect each night

so you cant add ppl and protect the same night?

correct

[Long Con]

Nah Nutella is mafia. That role is stupidly town and it'd be obvious but earlier she claimed to have a weak role. Her story isn't straight.

lc claimed the weak role

yeah that was me

[MacDougall]

Nah Nutella is mafia. That role is stupidly town and it'd be obvious but earlier she claimed to have a weak role. Her story isn't straight.

lc claimed the weak role

P SURE NUT SAID SHE DID TOO

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Inb4 Nutella flips mafia/rogue with a soup kill

10 bucks on rogue with the Win-con of knowing everyone's role.

I’ll take that action tbh

[MacDougall]

nutella is town

but then again she is not

but she is

but she is not

she is Schrodinger's town

[nutella]

site is dying lol

[Hally]

im probably just staying idk