Traitors for Exile

[Wiml]

I wanna chop FAKE GENGAR

Would you remind me why you feel so strongly about this please?

[Long Con]

LC still voting Murphy after my sherlock speech. Smh.

@Long Con yooooooo

Hey, I have to check this Sherlock speech out. I'll look in your ISO.

[Long Con]

LC - LC revels in a randing weird adversarial 3p style things. In this game he isn't in his element with a town rand, and therefore his lack of enthusiasm is towny for him.

This man is my friend. What a great and accurate read.

It looks like this game is well under control. I saw Gira's plan, and I'm on board. Marmot's cop claim with a sweet red check is awesome, I believe that as well, and kudos Joseph for calling that.

[KZA]

What an irritating game

[KZA]

im a flop lol

You're capable of better shit posting than this

Sure I am.

Yeah, Mac knew

Damn Mac outed unreal

[KZA]

Day 1 End Vote Count

Wisdom (1) - KGMurphy
KGMurphy (1) - Long Con
Creature (1) - Wisdom
KZA (5) - Cat, Creature, Captain Falcon, Gira and 112
Debil - (7) - Auwt, WimI, Marmot, MissSparkles, Poison, KZA, Mac Dongull

Debil has been yeeted!

There were

Spoiler: show

Town

It is now Exile Phase

Is there some reason for these colour choices

[falcon45ca]

What an irritating game

How you feeling about Mac's turn around on you?

[KZA]

What an irritating game

How you feeling about Mac's turn around on you?

I have no idea what he's doing but I'm gonna let him do it

[falcon45ca]

What an irritating game

How you feeling about Mac's turn around on you?

I have no idea what he's doing but I'm gonna let him do it

Who do you want to exile?



How's work? I'm at work too, and it's totes lame right meow

[Marmot]

The best part is I called that Marmot was the cop lol

Yeah, you shoulda been quieter about that.

Although it really didn't matter, I was always going to claim tonight anyway.

[Marmot]

I'm also going to be relatively quiet this game for now. I'll be very actively following and reading, but at this moment, I think keeping my cards close to my chest is the best strategy.

[MissSparkles]

The best part is I called that Marmot was the cop lol

Yeah, you shoulda been quieter about that.

Although it really didn't matter, I was always going to claim tonight anyway.

And does him not being quiet about it make you feel a certain way? Cause it does to me.

[MissSparkles]

I'm also going to be relatively quiet this game for now. I'll be very actively following and reading, but at this moment, I think keeping my cards close to my chest is the best strategy.

A very sparkly strategy if u know what i mean

[MissSparkles]

I wanna chop FAKE GENGAR

Would you remind me why you feel so strongly about this please?

Because he’s been saying things and not following up on them which I think someone else pointed out.

The Humpty Dumpty nickname goes with that, he’s been sitting on a fence all day long and given some of the things he’s saying but with no action, I’d expect him to be more aggressive as town. He’s being more HUMPTY then GENGAR.

After 112’s take on his meta, and Mac’s take too I have a more solid basis from playera familiar with him to feel more confident re: my instincts, I didn’t wanna follow them to begin with deapite mentioning his vibe feeling scummy bcz I didn’t know him as a player.

However the thing giving me pause is those reports are coming from a player I don’t trust in Mac and someone who attempted at case on me in the beginning of the game but stopped when I shut it down and then expanded on the bad vibes I got from HUMPTY GENGAR, so it could be a play to manipulate my target but tgat makes more sense in an actual game where mafia know each other then here where they don’t so I’d be more comfortable following my instincts there.

[Creature]

Kinda hype for the guilty, but I understand it is better said only the next day. In fact, I think it'd be more productive for Marmot to not say it until like 6 hours away from the D2 deadline.

[KZA]

What an irritating game

How you feeling about Mac's turn around on you?

I have no idea what he's doing but I'm gonna let him do it

Who do you want to exile?



How's work? I'm at work too, and it's totes lame right meow

Work is stupid

I'll exile Sparkles for sanity reasons

[Gavial]

Day 1 End Vote Count

Wisdom (1) - KGMurphy
KGMurphy (1) - Long Con
Creature (1) - Wisdom
KZA (5) - Cat, Creature, Captain Falcon, Gira and 112
Debil - (7) - Auwt, WimI, Marmot, MissSparkles, Poison, KZA, Mac Dongull

Debil has been yeeted!

There were

Spoiler: show

Town

It is now Exile Phase

Is there some reason for these colour choices

Each wagon deserves a different colour!

[Gavial]

Just an FYI, Poll is a meanie but exile phase ends 6:30 AM my time and for me rn it’s like 11:16 AM

[112]

last night was epic

[Creature]

Who are we exiling?

[112]

i agree with not chopping kaz after seeing his posts at 3am today and then reading a few on this page

i don't actually recall any posts by debil so idk if it was a good yeet or not but it was probably better than kaz at that point so i'm not going to grandstand or complain.

[112]

Who are we exiling?

do we want to exile town or wolves?

[112]

nvm traitors can win by being sent to exile

tbh i wouldn't mind kicking mac out of dodge for a night

[Long Con]

If we exile Marmot, does he lose his cop powers for the next phase?

[Marmot]

If we exile Marmot, does he lose his cop powers for the next phase?

I do, so don't do that.

It counts as a roleblock (so I believe would do the same for the anti-cop)

[Creature]

Who are we exiling?

do we want to exile town or wolves?

Preferably town, but that we wouldn't mind silenced

[Creature]

If we exile Marmot, does he lose his cop powers for the next phase?

Yes. A Marmot exile feels terrible here.

[Long Con]

Who are we exiling?

do we want to exile town or wolves?

Preferably town, but that we wouldn't mind silenced

I can volunteer.

[falcon45ca]

Who are we exiling?

do we want to exile town or wolves?

Preferably town, but that we wouldn't mind silenced

I can volunteer.

[Creature]

Who are we exiling?

do we want to exile town or wolves?

Preferably town, but that we wouldn't mind silenced

I can volunteer.

Thought you would be a good idea for an exile, but I need to be sure you're town.

[Creature]

On the other hand tomorrow Marmot may get a green peek tomorrow and we can exile them next and one traitor exiled won't hurt us.

[Wiml]

I think we should just exile the person we're most confident on being town honestly. It'll probably only be for one phase until Marmot gets another town check (and if he gets another red peek then lol but that's probably overall advantageous for us regardless).

[Wiml]

On the other hand tomorrow Marmot may get a green peek tomorrow and we can exile them next and one traitor exiled won't hurt us.

I've got no idea why you would willingly exile somebody you think might be a traitor though???

[Creature]

!	Message from: Creature

On the other hand tomorrow Marmot may get a green peek tomorrow and we can exile them next and one traitor exiled won't hurt us.

I've got no idea why you would willingly exile somebody you think might be a traitor though???

Not really. It is mostly pointing that even if we exile a traitor it won't hurt us that much as long we don't exile any more traitors.

[Creature]

Dafuq did I press now?

[Wiml]

!	Message from: Creature

On the other hand tomorrow Marmot may get a green peek tomorrow and we can exile them next and one traitor exiled won't hurt us.

I've got no idea why you would willingly exile somebody you think might be a traitor though???

Not really. It is mostly pointing that even if we exile a traitor it won't hurt us that much as long we don't exile any more traitors.

If we mischop another town then it won't hurt us as long as we don't mischop amy more towns!

[Creature]

I was saying if we exile traitor tonight and we get a green peek we can always exile the green peek and it won't further traitor's wincon as they'll always be stuck at 1/3 on their exile wincon. Obviously it would be the most optimal to not exile traitor tonight, but even if we do that won't hurt us much because of the reason above.

[Wiml]

I was saying if we exile traitor tonight and we get a green peek we can always exile the green peek and it won't further traitor's wincon as they'll always be stuck at 1/3 on their exile wincon. Obviously it would be the most optimal to not exile traitor tonight, but even if we do that won't hurt us much because of the reason above.

I still think we should go out of our way to avoid it, it's a loss condition at the end of the day and there isn't really a downside to just exiling somebody we think is very likely town over somebody we aren't sure on?

[Creature]

I was saying if we exile traitor tonight and we get a green peek we can always exile the green peek and it won't further traitor's wincon as they'll always be stuck at 1/3 on their exile wincon. Obviously it would be the most optimal to not exile traitor tonight, but even if we do that won't hurt us much because of the reason above.

I still think we should go out of our way to avoid it, it's a loss condition at the end of the day and there isn't really a downside to just exiling somebody we think is very likely town over somebody we aren't sure on?

I'm hesitant to exile someone like Mac because he's a fairly important voice and, even if we can just autovote the guilty tomorrow, it'd be useful to have Mac around.

[Creature]

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

[Wiml]

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

Not at all tbh.

If you want to exile somebody who is a relatively low poster, 112 and Gira are much more likely to be town.

[falcon45ca]

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

No, and the fact he volunteered himself is total garbage

[falcon45ca]

I was saying if we exile traitor tonight and we get a green peek we can always exile the green peek and it won't further traitor's wincon as they'll always be stuck at 1/3 on their exile wincon. Obviously it would be the most optimal to not exile traitor tonight, but even if we do that won't hurt us much because of the reason above.

I still think we should go out of our way to avoid it, it's a loss condition at the end of the day and there isn't really a downside to just exiling somebody we think is very likely town over somebody we aren't sure on?

I'm hesitant to exile someone like Mac because he's a fairly important voice and, even if we can just autovote the guilty tomorrow, it'd be useful to have Mac around.

We shouldn't exile Mac. If he's town, as you say he's an important voice, and if he's a Traitor, well obvs we shouldn't be exiling Traitors.


112, Poison, Wiml IMO

[Creature]

I think 112 or Gira then

[MacDougall]

im a flop lol

You're capable of better shit posting than this

Sure I am.

Yeah, Mac knew

I dunno what to say man. At the time that I asked whether you were Captain Falcon it was a genuine thought...

[MacDougall]

The best part is I called that Marmot was the cop lol

Yeah, you shoulda been quieter about that.

Although it really didn't matter, I was always going to claim tonight anyway.

why though? there is like no utility from the cop not being public knowledge...

[MacDougall]

I want to exile KGMurphy. I think he is obvious town but he is also slanking and just here for the meme. He's perfect.

[Long Con]

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

Not at all tbh.

If you want to exile somebody who is a relatively low poster, 112 and Gira are much more likely to be town.

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

No, and the fact he volunteered himself is total garbage

Suit yourselves.

[falcon45ca]

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

Not at all tbh.

If you want to exile somebody who is a relatively low poster, 112 and Gira are much more likely to be town.

Do you think LC is a fine exile?

No, and the fact he volunteered himself is total garbage

Suit yourselves.

Now you're trying to use reverse psychology on us, it won't work

[Creature]

What an irritating game

I agree