The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[RondoDimBuckle]

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

any paticular reason?

Sheeping Alison.

shouldnt do that, Alison votes people for sheeping her

[BoKnows]

How is this a slip?

He was voting DK.

DK was sussed hard.

"I don't read dead villagers."

Implies he knew it was town before the flip.

Seriously you're blind

Also: https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewt ... 54#p852354

thanks but you could of left out the insult

[falcon45ca]

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

any paticular reason?

Sheeping Alison.

shouldnt do that, Alison votes people for sheeping her

You looking out for my best interests? Awe, thats sweet of you

[RondoDimBuckle]

Dya replaced Creature, Rondo are you reading the game or not?

Thats even worse. no sub in and 26 posts in 144 hours and all of them meh

i actually have 27 posts...

well 28 now including this one!

Exactly, but lets get rid of a top poster who you can at least interact with instead of a low poster who is slanking(not sure if that is the nomenclature?)

Says the guy who didn't want to interact with me because i demanded it

I wasnt interacting with you but I was interacting with the other 20 people here, dont be pedantic

What if i am pedantic, is a crime?
I don't remember you interacting with everyone else tbh
And if this is true and you ignored me on purpose, then you did it because i put you questions you could not answer without exposing yourself as scum, otherwise i have no other explanation.. .

You love putting thoughts in and out of my mouth. I could be ignoring you because I didnt want to talk to you. Other people said they didnt want to read you because you were poisoned, you let them slide. I am going to go back to ignoring you now because this is becoming tedious

[RondoDimBuckle]

[VOTE: Rondo] aubergine

any paticular reason?

Sheeping Alison.

shouldnt do that, Alison votes people for sheeping her

You looking out for my best interests? Awe, thats sweet of you

no worries

[Alison]

Naw falcon is town.

[Alison]

@falcon45ca I am voting MR now btw.

Would love your thoughts on him and Bo since you're from the same community. 112 as well if you can read her.

[RondoDimBuckle]

@Urist since you're outed as doctor now, did you save Michelle from poison?

[tutuu]

Naw falcon is town.

Okiiii ur highness

[Michelle]

Eh I am in too many games anyway. Dying today is a blessing

Someone needs freedom i see

[Michelle]

I've read two Alison posts and she's mafia.

[VOTE: alison] aubergine

[Michelle]

Rondo taking his vote off me when I attacked him for it is scummy. In Batman he didn't give a fuck about being voted, and when he got voted out he ended with his vote on himself and his last post was "ignore everything I said I was just bullshitting". And he was town.

Now he gets skittish when he gets pressure and the tone of his "eh I'm going to die" seems resigned and disappointed rather than yolo which is what he does as town. Mac thought he was scummy too. And there is the "maybe the IC is actually mafia" crap which I struggle to believe is real.

Rondo definitely POE. Will look for more suspects today.

Dya SR him as well

[RondoDimBuckle]

Rondo taking his vote off me when I attacked him for it is scummy. In Batman he didn't give a fuck about being voted, and when he got voted out he ended with his vote on himself and his last post was "ignore everything I said I was just bullshitting". And he was town.

Now he gets skittish when he gets pressure and the tone of his "eh I'm going to die" seems resigned and disappointed rather than yolo which is what he does as town. Mac thought he was scummy too. And there is the "maybe the IC is actually mafia" crap which I struggle to believe is real.

Rondo definitely POE. Will look for more suspects today.

I still say this is a terrible way to try and read me

Mac did not think I was scummy, you can say you think I am but you cant say Mac did when he said I was town.

[Michelle]

Uh huh. Well show me Mac's townread on you then.

Give me the bullet point rundown on the case against BoSyn.

why wouldnt you iso your own slot?

Because I want to know what you, specifically, would respond with if pressed as to what Mac's townread on you constituted of.

thats fair

You wont get anything till I finish work

I hope you answered at this

[tutuu]

Im starting to think Epi is scum just coz there are too many townclears and i know im town. If yall knew im town id guess ud replace me with epi in ur poes

Not saying we should kill him soon, might be one of the last scum we chop. But ye

Maybe not epi but like. At least one of the people with towny mech has to be mafia by numbers

[RondoDimBuckle]

Uh huh. Well show me Mac's townread on you then.

Give me the bullet point rundown on the case against BoSyn.

why wouldnt you iso your own slot?

Because I want to know what you, specifically, would respond with if pressed as to what Mac's townread on you constituted of.

thats fair

You wont get anything till I finish work

I hope you answered at this

the fact that you are in my iso looking at my posts means you know I did, scum range omitting facts

[Alison]

Rondo taking his vote off me when I attacked him for it is scummy. In Batman he didn't give a fuck about being voted, and when he got voted out he ended with his vote on himself and his last post was "ignore everything I said I was just bullshitting". And he was town.

Now he gets skittish when he gets pressure and the tone of his "eh I'm going to die" seems resigned and disappointed rather than yolo which is what he does as town. Mac thought he was scummy too. And there is the "maybe the IC is actually mafia" crap which I struggle to believe is real.

Rondo definitely POE. Will look for more suspects today.

I still say this is a terrible way to try and read me

Mac did not think I was scummy, you can say you think I am but you cant say Mac did when he said I was town.

Mac scumread you for much of Day 1. His reversal on you was eh and he said himself that he was likely to be wrong on it.

[Alison]

Im starting to think Epi is scum just coz there are too many townclears and i know im town. If yall knew im town id guess ud replace me with epi in ur poes

Not saying we should kill him soon, might be one of the last scum we chop. But ye

Maybe not epi but like. At least one of the people with towny mech has to be mafia by numbers

This is a good point.

I am not clearing Epi any more.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Im starting to think Epi is scum just coz there are too many townclears and i know im town. If yall knew im town id guess ud replace me with epi in ur poes

Not saying we should kill him soon, might be one of the last scum we chop. But ye

Maybe not epi but like. At least one of the people with towny mech has to be mafia by numbers

You had me as town hard up in the town area and you havent defended me once against the Alison onslaught. Explain

[Michelle]

Also reads are not set in stone and anyone can have wrong reads. Putting 'Mac TR me' as defence doesn't give you towny points Rondo.
You say you cannot be read like a normal FM player, that means we should check your AI as long as you are not cooperative as is a nornal town FM player

[tutuu]

Im starting to think Epi is scum just coz there are too many townclears and i know im town. If yall knew im town id guess ud replace me with epi in ur poes

Not saying we should kill him soon, might be one of the last scum we chop. But ye

Maybe not epi but like. At least one of the people with towny mech has to be mafia by numbers

You had me as town hard up in the town area and you havent defended me once against the Alison onslaught. Explain

Alison = boss

Me = obey

[RondoDimBuckle]

Rondo taking his vote off me when I attacked him for it is scummy. In Batman he didn't give a fuck about being voted, and when he got voted out he ended with his vote on himself and his last post was "ignore everything I said I was just bullshitting". And he was town.

Now he gets skittish when he gets pressure and the tone of his "eh I'm going to die" seems resigned and disappointed rather than yolo which is what he does as town. Mac thought he was scummy too. And there is the "maybe the IC is actually mafia" crap which I struggle to believe is real.

Rondo definitely POE. Will look for more suspects today.

I still say this is a terrible way to try and read me

Mac did not think I was scummy, you can say you think I am but you cant say Mac did when he said I was town.

Mac scumread you for much of Day 1. His reversal on you was eh and he said himself that he was likely to be wrong on it.

You kept moving the goal post you asked me to prove to you mac said I was town, I proved that, then you say its eh. Then I continue to be have as much fun till I die rondo cause youve made up your mind

[RondoDimBuckle]

Im starting to think Epi is scum just coz there are too many townclears and i know im town. If yall knew im town id guess ud replace me with epi in ur poes

Not saying we should kill him soon, might be one of the last scum we chop. But ye

Maybe not epi but like. At least one of the people with towny mech has to be mafia by numbers

You had me as town hard up in the town area and you havent defended me once against the Alison onslaught. Explain

Alison = boss

Me = obey

which is exactly the same reason I got scum read from alison, watch out

[Michelle]

Uh huh. Well show me Mac's townread on you then.

Give me the bullet point rundown on the case against BoSyn.

why wouldnt you iso your own slot?

Because I want to know what you, specifically, would respond with if pressed as to what Mac's townread on you constituted of.

thats fair

You wont get anything till I finish work

I hope you answered at this

the fact that you are in my iso looking at my posts means you know I did, scum range omitting facts

You jump too fast with conclusions, evidence shows i am finally catching up, and i previously quoted 112, so i am not on your iso

[RondoDimBuckle]

Uh huh. Well show me Mac's townread on you then.

Give me the bullet point rundown on the case against BoSyn.

why wouldnt you iso your own slot?

Because I want to know what you, specifically, would respond with if pressed as to what Mac's townread on you constituted of.

thats fair

You wont get anything till I finish work

I hope you answered at this

the fact that you are in my iso looking at my posts means you know I did, scum range omitting facts

You jump too fast with conclusions, evidence shows i am finally catching up, and i previously quoted 112, so i am not on your iso

how do you quote something in 112's ISO with me as the base quote? If you were quoting from 112 it would go 112 saying something, then me, instead its me first that you are responding to. Caught?

[Michelle]

The no kill is nice but I am currently doubting everything I think I know.

Remember: Socrates didn't know anything either but they still sentenced him to death.

I love this post

[Michelle]

why wouldnt you iso your own slot?

Because I want to know what you, specifically, would respond with if pressed as to what Mac's townread on you constituted of.

thats fair

You wont get anything till I finish work

I hope you answered at this

the fact that you are in my iso looking at my posts means you know I did, scum range omitting facts

You jump too fast with conclusions, evidence shows i am finally catching up, and i previously quoted 112, so i am not on your iso

how do you quote something in 112's ISO with me as the base quote? If you were quoting from 112 it would go 112 saying something, then me, instead its me first that you are responding to. Caught?

Helooooo!!!!! i am reading the thread in order or posts, can you understand this?

[RondoDimBuckle]

Because I want to know what you, specifically, would respond with if pressed as to what Mac's townread on you constituted of.

thats fair

You wont get anything till I finish work

I hope you answered at this

the fact that you are in my iso looking at my posts means you know I did, scum range omitting facts

You jump too fast with conclusions, evidence shows i am finally catching up, and i previously quoted 112, so i am not on your iso

how do you quote something in 112's ISO with me as the base quote? If you were quoting from 112 it would go 112 saying something, then me, instead its me first that you are responding to. Caught?

Helooooo!!!!! i am reading the thread in order or posts, can you understand this?

Yeah. I just like poking you

[Alison]

2. Michelle
3. NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
5. sig
6. tutuu
7. MacDougall/alison
8. falcon45ca
9. Urist
10. RondoDimBuckle
11. EnderWiggin
12. Master Radishes
13. Epignosis
15. Made
16. Syn/BoKnows
17. 112
18. Poison
19. Ruri
21. DrWilgy
22. Scotty
24. TonyStarkPrime

Alive players. Clear Scotty and myself for being hard confirmed town.

2. Michelle
3. NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
5. sig
6. tutuu
8. falcon45ca
9. Urist
10. RondoDimBuckle
11. EnderWiggin
12. Master Radishes
13. Epignosis
15. Made
16. Syn/BoKnows
17. 112
18. Poison
19. Ruri
21. DrWilgy
24. TonyStarkPrime

Clear Ender, Poison, Urist, and Made for convincing and townie roleclaims.

2. Michelle
3. NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
5. sig
6. tutuu
8. falcon45ca
10. RondoDimBuckle
12. Master Radishes
13. Epignosis
16. Syn/BoKnows
17. 112
19. Ruri
21. DrWilgy
24. TonyStarkPrime

Clear sig/TSP and Rondo/Wilgy, not because they're totally out of the POE but because their mech on each other means that it's inadvisable to touch them today until we see how that pans out.

2. Michelle
3. NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
6. tutuu
8. falcon45ca
12. Master Radishes
13. Epignosis
16. Syn/BoKnows
17. 112
19. Ruri

Of these, I think Michelle has been playing extremely townie. Nanook has been posting reasonably well and his annoyance/conviction about Epi rang genuine. I also have a very small mech-related reason to think he's town which I won't disclose atm. It's not very reliable, but it's the cherry on top. falcon has been posting medium today, but I liked the early pushes in his ISO. Falling off in complicated mech situations isn't out of his town range, and if I just assessed his posts then... they're townie. Even his posts today have been nullish and not scummy.

So we clear Michelle, Nook and Falcon for townie posting.

6. tutuu
12. Master Radishes
13. Epignosis
16. Syn/BoKnows
17. 112
19. Ruri

That leaves these people as potential exes today.

112's claim is too vague to be of any help. I have a townlean on 112's prior posting, but they swung down and Ender's hard scumread of them means I can't clear them today. Ruri's posts are extremely unmemorable. tutuu's posting has actually been ok but she was targeted for death by Koba and we all know this is well within her scum range. Epignosis, eh, sig testifies he could have made that shot as either alignment. So we put him in the POE, that's fine. MR and Bo are obviously the big suspects.

This is my POE for the D3 exe. Come day 4, if I'm dead, you'll want to reopen the question of TSP/sig and Wilgy/Rondo. You might also want to doublecheck the townie roleclaims against known mech that comes out N3, and make sure that the townie posters aren't skating by. It's a good start though.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Anyway time for bed. Enjoy

[Michelle]

Mafia is most likely in shambles right now. Their kill got stopped and an important misexe, Made, has just made a very townie roleclaim. This is a good chance to halt their momentum after a bad D1 and D2 and turn the tides on mafia. Put in effort into your solving today.

Reposting this, town should know it

[RondoDimBuckle]

I am not paired with wiggly at least from my end btw. I am just pointing him town for self pres

[falcon45ca]

@falcon45ca I am voting MR now btw.

Would love your thoughts on him and Bo since you're from the same community. 112 as well if you can read her.

MR had a "I now doubt everything" post that doesn't sit well with me...like, sure there are times when gamestate is fucked, but MR is excellent at seeing what town can learn from seemingly hopeless situations. A defeatist attitude isn't at all what I'd expect from him.

BK looks to be in his fledgling town state, where he's trying to figure things out bit by bit. He's a lot more involved and solvy when he's scum.

112...I need to look at wagons she's pushed. I'm lousy at reading her off posts alone.

[VOTE: MR] aubergine

[Alison]

Rondo taking his vote off me when I attacked him for it is scummy. In Batman he didn't give a fuck about being voted, and when he got voted out he ended with his vote on himself and his last post was "ignore everything I said I was just bullshitting". And he was town.

Now he gets skittish when he gets pressure and the tone of his "eh I'm going to die" seems resigned and disappointed rather than yolo which is what he does as town. Mac thought he was scummy too. And there is the "maybe the IC is actually mafia" crap which I struggle to believe is real.

Rondo definitely POE. Will look for more suspects today.

I still say this is a terrible way to try and read me

Mac did not think I was scummy, you can say you think I am but you cant say Mac did when he said I was town.

Mac scumread you for much of Day 1. His reversal on you was eh and he said himself that he was likely to be wrong on it.

You kept moving the goal post you asked me to prove to you mac said I was town, I proved that, then you say its eh. Then I continue to be have as much fun till I die rondo cause youve made up your mind

This is a lie.

Show me where Mac townread you and his reasoning. If it's good I'll sheep him. Else you go into the POE for clowning around all day playing up your meme status and acting like a jester while people are trying to solve.

Exact quote.

Mac's reasoning was not good.

No shifting goal posts. I did what I said. You have failed to furnish sufficient evidence that you are town.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Rondo taking his vote off me when I attacked him for it is scummy. In Batman he didn't give a fuck about being voted, and when he got voted out he ended with his vote on himself and his last post was "ignore everything I said I was just bullshitting". And he was town.

Now he gets skittish when he gets pressure and the tone of his "eh I'm going to die" seems resigned and disappointed rather than yolo which is what he does as town. Mac thought he was scummy too. And there is the "maybe the IC is actually mafia" crap which I struggle to believe is real.

Rondo definitely POE. Will look for more suspects today.

I still say this is a terrible way to try and read me

Mac did not think I was scummy, you can say you think I am but you cant say Mac did when he said I was town.

Mac scumread you for much of Day 1. His reversal on you was eh and he said himself that he was likely to be wrong on it.

You kept moving the goal post you asked me to prove to you mac said I was town, I proved that, then you say its eh. Then I continue to be have as much fun till I die rondo cause youve made up your mind

This is a lie.

Show me where Mac townread you and his reasoning. If it's good I'll sheep him. Else you go into the POE for clowning around all day playing up your meme status and acting like a jester while people are trying to solve.

Exact quote.

Mac's reasoning was not good.

No shifting goal posts. I did what I said. You have failed to furnish sufficient evidence that you are town.

Hard disagree.

[RondoDimBuckle]

Now bed

[Alison]

Im starting to think Epi is scum just coz there are too many townclears and i know im town. If yall knew im town id guess ud replace me with epi in ur poes

Not saying we should kill him soon, might be one of the last scum we chop. But ye

Maybe not epi but like. At least one of the people with towny mech has to be mafia by numbers

You had me as town hard up in the town area and you havent defended me once against the Alison onslaught. Explain

Alison = boss

Me = obey

which is exactly the same reason I got scum read from alison, watch out

Also untrue.

You got scumread because you've been doing nothing to help town. And when you are directly asked to do more in your solving, you throw a temper tantrum and whine about how you refuse to cooperate with people if they ask you to do so. You have self-voted or pretended to self-vote during a tight EOD which is scummy. You have voted confirmed town which is scummy. You have voted townie people like Michelle at the slightest opening which is scummy. You have played up your jester status and used it as an excuse to avoid doing actually townie things.

This is why you are being scumread. Not because you sheeped me. I generally townread people for sheeping me, and I don't think negatively of either tutuu or falcon for doing so. Because they aren't acting like chaotic jesters disrupting town solving in favor of filling the thread with drivel.

[Alison]

Hard disagree.

Hard disagree - but where is the counterpoint?

I say you have failed to furnish sufficient evidence that you are town. You have said Mac townreads you. Well and good. But we looked into that townread and it was a townread that Mac himself was uncertain of. It was also a townread that had very little reasoning behind it other than volume.

Where is the sufficient evidence? Point it out to me or be proven a liar.

[falcon45ca]

Rondo seems like a wolf in a snare right now, all twisty and bitey

[Michelle]

Rondo seems like the go to chop here imo. When I was baiting commital reads on my slot, Rondo tried to slip away harder than I'd expect from town

Looks like i am not the only one avoided by Rondo

[Made]

GTH, Michelle was healed by scum. No way town saves her here

what's the purpose of speculating this?
Let's say is true, it's Wifom anyway.
You said it like wolves can't frame a player to obtain an easy ML, it happened recently in Guillo's game where wolves flipped me red and made town to dig in my posts after spew when i was in fact villager.
This game is not bastard but it contains for sure mechanics we are not aware of

Re: Made @Made Why do you think Town won't save her exactly? Can you recall people scum reading Michelle that they might avoid healing her?

Me Mac(?), tutuu and DK off the top

Mac didn't SR me, tutuu didn't SR me.
You didn't express it iirc
About DK yes, i agree

well anyway:

i think michelle is mafia and the poisoner is town-aligned so good job poisoner

let me write up the thing i was finna write

i also thing syn is town and there was nothing but town on town violence day 1, will also write up on that

This is the post i was refering to @Michelle when i said tutuu scum read you

[tutuu]

That was the very start of d2 throughout the day i townread her

[Made]

and yeah, i didn't scum read, but I thought the consensus was that you dying would get rid of the question mark-- and I agreed with that. tbh, you're reading town, but not as town as Scotty/Alison. In my experience poison heals are 2 shot max, so using that on you feels odd to me in this situation. Given the theory that KZA was poisoner, it was the right move to save you, but from my pov, it's odd

That all said, i don't see how this line of thought helps so imma just drop it if that's cool /w you

[Alison]

and yeah, i didn't scum read, but I thought the consensus was that you dying would get rid of the question mark-- and I agreed with that. tbh, you're reading town, but not as town as Scotty/Alison. In my experience poison heals are 2 shot max, so using that on you feels odd to me in this situation. Given the theory that KZA was poisoner, it was the right move to save you, but from my pov, it's odd

That all said, i don't see how this line of thought helps so imma just drop it if that's cool /w you

Poison healing anyone you think is town is optimal because you can get killed.

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Submit to the dungeons
Poll runs till Fri Sep 03, 2021 11:00 pm
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


112
0
No votes
Voters: None
Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
1
4%
Voters: DrWilgy
DrWilgy
4
16%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, Ruri, Scotty, sig
EnderWiggin
0
No votes
Voters: None
Epignosis
1
4%
Voters: Urist
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
Made
0
No votes
Voters: None
MasterRadishes
6
24%
Voters: EnderWiggin, Alison, tutuu, Epignosis, falcon45ca, RondoDimBuckle
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Poison
0
No votes
Voters: None
RondoDimBuckle
3
12%
Voters: Made, Michelle, BoKnows
Ruri
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
0
No votes
Voters: None
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes
Voters: None
tutuu
0
No votes
Voters: None
Urist
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Vote
1
4%
Voters: 112
No Lynch
0
No votes
Voters: None
Non (host, mod, spec, dead, etc)
9
36%
Voters: JaggedJimmyJay, juliets, Justplayingitcool, MacDougall, DkKoba, KZA, Lime Coke, sabie12, Syn
Total votes: 25

VC

[Michelle]

[VOTE: Mr. Radishes] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Haven't caught up, why is radish the wagon now and what happened to the red check?


Also rondo is likely town lol

[Made]

Haven't caught up, why is radish the wagon now and what happened to the red check?


Also rondo is likely town lol

y tho?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Haven't caught up, why is radish the wagon now and what happened to the red check?


Also rondo is likely town lol

y tho?

I'm good at reading him idk what to tell you

[tutuu]

Haven't caught up, why is radish the wagon now and what happened to the red check?


Also rondo is likely town lol

Wilgy claimed to be a cop, n1 copped syn but unsuccessful, n2 peeked rondo not-a-threat (town or 3p)

Also host announced an error in night actions then urist said his protect on scotty didnt fail like he was told it did initially

Ender isnt certain if his action takes priority over urists

112 claims to have potentially disrupted the kill which gives ender 33% to have stopped the kill and red peeked wilgy