The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[112]

bk posting minimally is a worse look for him than anything MR has done since my working memory of this game starts

[112]

bk posting minimally is a worse look for him than anything MR has done since my working memory of this game starts

and by 'minimally' i do not mean posting sparsely but posting few words when he does

he's trying not to give anything of himself away imo

[112]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

I dont like cooperating with people who demand it

Are you demanding people not demand to cooperate with you?

Nope, the inverse of my statement is not true. People can do what they want, but if they want me to work with them its going to be a conversation I want to be a part of

You must be a lot of fun at parties

owned

are you going to post anything helpful? Allison reasons to lynch me could easily apply to you. Creature 0 posts and you have 26 posts worth nothing.

probably not just vibing tbh

i struggle to read this kind of stuff but do lean wolf here. why sub into a game if you're just going to vibe? if bo really doesn't care he probably just abandons the thread entirely. low-wim wolves are often still involved in the way bo is because they feel indebted to their teammates.

[BoKnows]

bk posting minimally is a worse look for him than anything MR has done since my working memory of this game starts

and by 'minimally' i do not mean posting sparsely but posting few words when he does

he's trying not to give anything of himself away imo

Not feeling it... wasn't gonna play originally but got asked to sub again so I did.

[Scotty]

112 says based on long time knowledge of playing with MR she scum reads him. but doesn't really deliver on that sight besides giving cheeky zingers (#5126).

im just clueless at whos the mafia lol

...syn? rondo? wilgy? radish? falcon?

MR likely
i haven't read a syn post in days
rondo plausible to probable
falc also likely

in conclusion if i have played with you extensively, you are scum

I also don't like the selfawareness in this post with no change in thoughts here, especially after Koba's flip she was equally confident on. 112 should be more lost right now imo

I went into this looking for a MR scum read but then I thought about it more: The telling thing here may be the read MR has on 112...

Unfortunately, MR claims not to be able to read 112 very well. That said, he gives more specific descriptions of 112 and her scum range, but doesn't land anywhere definite (#817 & #809)

112 harbouring a constant low-key suspicion of me probably a townie point for her tbh.

this complicates things however....Mafia is effing hard.

@112 is there ever a world where your interactions with MR right now are T/T?

@Master Radishes if there ever a world where 112 is just scum here?

i townread koba before their death. you're quoting earlier stuff and i am never wrong on my reads.

yes there is a world where we're t/t

You townreading Koba means nothing, especially if the wagons were t/t.

Also, made wasn’t even referring to Koba in this post you’re responding to

are you sure?

I see a bit of your confidence being high after Koba flip, but your answer doesn’t really reference the chunk of his post I thought

[112]

112 says based on long time knowledge of playing with MR she scum reads him. but doesn't really deliver on that sight besides giving cheeky zingers (#5126).

im just clueless at whos the mafia lol

...syn? rondo? wilgy? radish? falcon?

MR likely
i haven't read a syn post in days
rondo plausible to probable
falc also likely

in conclusion if i have played with you extensively, you are scum

I also don't like the selfawareness in this post with no change in thoughts here, especially after Koba's flip she was equally confident on. 112 should be more lost right now imo

I went into this looking for a MR scum read but then I thought about it more: The telling thing here may be the read MR has on 112...

Unfortunately, MR claims not to be able to read 112 very well. That said, he gives more specific descriptions of 112 and her scum range, but doesn't land anywhere definite (#817 & #809)

112 harbouring a constant low-key suspicion of me probably a townie point for her tbh.

this complicates things however....Mafia is effing hard.

@112 is there ever a world where your interactions with MR right now are T/T?

@Master Radishes if there ever a world where 112 is just scum here?

i townread koba before their death. you're quoting earlier stuff and i am never wrong on my reads.

yes there is a world where we're t/t

You townreading Koba means nothing, especially if the wagons were t/t.

Also, made wasn’t even referring to Koba in this post you’re responding to

are you sure?

I see a bit of your confidence being high after Koba flip, but your answer doesn’t really reference the chunk of his post I thought

made wrote that post with the idea in mind that i scum-read koba to their death.

[112]

bk posting minimally is a worse look for him than anything MR has done since my working memory of this game starts

and by 'minimally' i do not mean posting sparsely but posting few words when he does

he's trying not to give anything of himself away imo

Not feeling it... wasn't gonna play originally but got asked to sub again so I did.

idk

[112]

Bo voting Rondo is definitely a Bo vote.

[112]

honestly the dirty bird theory may well be the way to go here with falcon the most suspicious canuck whilst also receiving the least amount of attention

[112]

@Urist - looking at the wagons and your vote sticks out because it's not a gametheory i've seen being pushed much here. i don't mean to ask in a critical way - actually interested in the vote - but can you summarize your thoughts on epi for me?

[Scotty]

@112 what is your opinion of the other semi wagon right now (tutuu)?

Last I checked in your iso was you saying she was maybe scum- then taking her word that she was not- at face value.

Now?

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Submit to the dungeons
Poll runs till Fri Sep 03, 2021 11:00 pm
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


112
0
No votes
Voters: None
Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
6
21%
Voters: Scotty, Ruri, Poison, Michelle, DrWilgy, EnderWiggin
DrWilgy
2
7%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, sig
EnderWiggin
0
No votes
Voters: None
Epignosis
1
4%
Voters: Urist
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
Made
0
No votes
Voters: None
MasterRadishes
5
18%
Voters: 112, Alison, TonyStarkPrime, tutuu, Epignosis
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
0
No votes
Voters: None
Poison
0
No votes
Voters: None
RondoDimBuckle
1
4%
Voters: BoKnows
Ruri
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
0
No votes
Voters: None
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes
Voters: None
tutuu
3
11%
Voters: Made, RondoDimBuckle, falcon45ca
Urist
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Vote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Lynch
0
No votes
Voters: None
Non (host, mod, spec, dead, etc)
10
36%
Voters: JaggedJimmyJay, juliets, Justplayingitcool, MacDougall, DkKoba, dunya, KZA, Lime Coke, sabie12, Syn
Total votes: 28

VC

BoKnows. 6. 21%. Voters: Scotty, Ruri, Poison, Michelle, DrWilgy, EnderWiggin

DrWilgy. 2. 7%. Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, sig

Epignosis. 1. 4%. Voters: Urist

MasterRadishes. 5. 18%. Voters: 112, Alison, TonyStarkPrime, tutuu, Epignosis

RondoDimBuckle. 1. 4% Voters: BoKnows

tutuu. 3. 11%. Voters: Made, RondoDimBuckle, falcon45ca

[tutuu]

i picked protect

i will find out more during the night

[Michelle]

TSP and sig gave each other a town mech read, i see they don't agree on the vote and i wonder why

[112]

@112 what is your opinion of the other semi wagon right now (tutuu)?

Last I checked in your iso was you saying she was maybe scum- then taking her word that she was not- at face value.

Now?

i think she's town and don't remember saying she might not be

[Scotty]

By my calculations we have a minimum 35.3% chance of hitting a non-town-aligned lynching blindly into the void today if you take me and Mac out of the equation, using the metric of 6 non towns at minimum in this player count.

If you take away Made, then it’s a 41.2% chance.

I like our odds and think we’re probably right about 1-2 of the current wagons

[Scotty]

TSP and sig gave each other a town mech read, i see they don't agree on the vote and i wonder why

HMMMMMMMMM

That is interesting

[Scotty]

@112 what is your opinion of the other semi wagon right now (tutuu)?

Last I checked in your iso was you saying she was maybe scum- then taking her word that she was not- at face value.

Now?

i think she's town and don't remember saying she might not be

Early D1. Couldn’t find any other indication in your iso that you had a read on her since

[112]

@112 what is your opinion of the other semi wagon right now (tutuu)?

Last I checked in your iso was you saying she was maybe scum- then taking her word that she was not- at face value.

Now?

i think she's town and don't remember saying she might not be

Early D1. Couldn’t find any other indication in your iso that you had a read on her since

D1 was several years ago.

[112]

[VOTE: falcon] aubergine

prefer this to bk but agree with bk as the other wagon

[Scotty]

[VOTE: falcon] aubergine

prefer this to bk but agree with bk as the other wagon

You sold on MR being a bad lynch?

[tutuu]

i think solving day 1 wagons and flipping bo is good

ill keep on MR for now so it doesnt disappear

[Scotty]

112 has done nothing to bring her out of my scum read.

Above all other players, I don’t have a strong reason to scum read her off of her play. It’s just this intangible feeling I have. I know you can defend against my gut feeling 112, so

Talked herself off of MR, and doesn’t intend to vote for Bo, even though she agrees with it. Vanity wagon an hour before EoD. Came up with reasons to townread both leading wagons, and gets to keep her hands clean in case one of MR or Bo is town

[Scotty]

Back to the sig/TSP conundrum. Neither is voting the same.

Which…ok, if they’re trying to hide out as separate entities, then that makes sense. sig is against claiming for fear of the soup nazi, so that makes sense.

But they’re linked and they’ve all but corroborated that.

Unless they’re not really masons, because they don’t have BTSC communication.

Or tsp just voted and sig hasn’t been around to follow suit yet.

But the problem with that is- neither have ever voted together yet. Breakdown in communication?

Either they forgot their narrative, or they never had BTSC, got a random check, and are living their own lives. Which I guess is possible, but I still don’t trust that

[Scotty]

I’m just over here reading the New York Post while the rest of the thread bought a NY Times subscription don’t mind me

[Master Radishes]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

No I will not take any questions nor provide receipts on this team

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

[Master Radishes]

Count my vote as being self-pres btw.

Actually may as well [VOTE: Bo] aubergine.

[Scotty]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

No I will not take any questions nor provide receipts on this team

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

[Scotty]

Count my vote as being self-pres btw.

Actually may as well [VOTE: Bo] aubergine.

Your first line and second line are diametrically opposed.

The second implies that you have a reason to suspect Bo and it’s not just a self pres

[Master Radishes]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

No I will not take any questions nor provide receipts on this team

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

The way he gives his own read on TSP is different than how TSP reads him though.

Like TSP hinted at mech knowledge. Sig has a slight tone of hesitance and suggests it's not for a reason we'd think.

I think there are conclusions to draw and I think we don't need to draw them at this stage.

[Scotty]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

No I will not take any questions nor provide receipts on this team

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

The way he gives his own read on TSP is different than how TSP reads him though.

Like TSP hinted at mech knowledge. Sig has a slight tone of hesitance and suggests it's not for a reason we'd think.

I think there are conclusions to draw and I think we don't need to draw them at this stage.

When should we draw them? At MYLO?

[Master Radishes]

Count my vote as being self-pres btw.

Actually may as well [VOTE: Bo] aubergine.

Your first line and second line are diametrically opposed.

The second implies that you have a reason to suspect Bo and it’s not just a self pres

I think GTH Bo is probably just scum. Or at the very least I doubt my earlier reasons for thinking otherwise.

But my primary motivation for voting this EoD is going to be self-pres if you idiots insist on keeping my wagon a thing.

[EnderWiggin]

[VOTE: MR] aubergine

[Master Radishes]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

No I will not take any questions nor provide receipts on this team

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

The way he gives his own read on TSP is different than how TSP reads him though.

Like TSP hinted at mech knowledge. Sig has a slight tone of hesitance and suggests it's not for a reason we'd think.

I think there are conclusions to draw and I think we don't need to draw them at this stage.

When should we draw them? At MYLO?

If they're scum they haven't properly coordinated on this gambit.

Unless you think one is scum and needs pushing, this isn't really an EoD discussion imo.

[EnderWiggin]

Now this is podracing

[Master Radishes]

I was gonna be mad but I do appreciate a good podrace.

[Scotty]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

The way he gives his own read on TSP is different than how TSP reads him though.

Like TSP hinted at mech knowledge. Sig has a slight tone of hesitance and suggests it's not for a reason we'd think.

I think there are conclusions to draw and I think we don't need to draw them at this stage.

When should we draw them? At MYLO?

If they're scum they haven't properly coordinated on this gambit.

Unless you think one is scum and needs pushing, this isn't really an EoD discussion imo.

Didn’t you say you would claim if you needed to?
Do you just think it not in town’s best interest?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Back to the sig/TSP conundrum. Neither is voting the same.

Which…ok, if they’re trying to hide out as separate entities, then that makes sense. sig is against claiming for fear of the soup nazi, so that makes sense.

But they’re linked and they’ve all but corroborated that.

Unless they’re not really masons, because they don’t have BTSC communication.

Or tsp just voted and sig hasn’t been around to follow suit yet.

But the problem with that is- neither have ever voted together yet. Breakdown in communication?

Either they forgot their narrative, or they never had BTSC, got a random check, and are living their own lives. Which I guess is possible, but I still don’t trust that

Masons don't always vote together

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Vpte mr btw, I forgot to call it

[Master Radishes]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

The way he gives his own read on TSP is different than how TSP reads him though.

Like TSP hinted at mech knowledge. Sig has a slight tone of hesitance and suggests it's not for a reason we'd think.

I think there are conclusions to draw and I think we don't need to draw them at this stage.

When should we draw them? At MYLO?

If they're scum they haven't properly coordinated on this gambit.

Unless you think one is scum and needs pushing, this isn't really an EoD discussion imo.

Didn’t you say you would claim if you needed to?
Do you just think it not in town’s best interest?

If the crowd wants me to claim I will. Tbh I don't think it saves me if I'm destined to go over.

[Michelle]

Count my vote as being self-pres btw.

Actually may as well [VOTE: Bo] aubergine.

Your first line and second line are diametrically opposed.

The second implies that you have a reason to suspect Bo and it’s not just a self pres

I think GTH Bo is probably just scum. Or at the very least I doubt my earlier reasons for thinking otherwise.

But my primary motivation for voting this EoD is going to be self-pres if you idiots insist on keeping my wagon a thing.

Should i feel not like an idiot for changing wagon during the day?

[Master Radishes]

Ngl @tutuu, I'm just looking at my wagon and I kinda wish I was you in this game right now.

[Michelle]

Mr. R, I claimed because I was convinced you are scum so the wolves should know my role and so it would be in town's interest to claim.

[Alison]

Back to the sig/TSP conundrum. Neither is voting the same.

Which…ok, if they’re trying to hide out as separate entities, then that makes sense. sig is against claiming for fear of the soup nazi, so that makes sense.

But they’re linked and they’ve all but corroborated that.

Unless they’re not really masons, because they don’t have BTSC communication.

Or tsp just voted and sig hasn’t been around to follow suit yet.

But the problem with that is- neither have ever voted together yet. Breakdown in communication?

Either they forgot their narrative, or they never had BTSC, got a random check, and are living their own lives. Which I guess is possible, but I still don’t trust that

or they just have different reads lolll.

[Michelle]

The silence itt is very odd, what kind of Eod is this?

[Alison]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

No I will not take any questions nor provide receipts on this team

Do you think or know or don't know TSP is town by the way?

I’m gonna go with a solid yes, but not for the reason you’d think/been floated it’s something else.

Won’t go into roles further at this time since I’ve been very anti claim this game.

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

It means the clear is one sided. TSP has mech info that sig is town. Sig does not have mech info that TSP is town ("it's not for the reasons you'd think"), but has some other unrelated reason to townread him.

[DrWilgy]

The silence itt is very odd, what kind of Eod is this?

Work real busy today

[Scotty]

Not fully present here (making and soon eating dinner) but in regards to TSP/Sig,

Yep I read this, and it tells me nothing of note, just that sig is corroborating

The way he gives his own read on TSP is different than how TSP reads him though.

Like TSP hinted at mech knowledge. Sig has a slight tone of hesitance and suggests it's not for a reason we'd think.

I think there are conclusions to draw and I think we don't need to draw them at this stage.

When should we draw them? At MYLO?

If they're scum they haven't properly coordinated on this gambit.

Unless you think one is scum and needs pushing, this isn't really an EoD discussion imo.

Didn’t you say you would claim if you needed to?
Do you just think it not in town’s best interest?

If the crowd wants me to claim I will. Tbh I don't think it saves me if I'm destined to go over.

Saving aside, if you have any info that might help town, it would help, since role reveals give nothing but alignment.

This response has me convinced you’re just bad tho

[VOTE: MR] aubergine

[Alison]

The main argument for voting Bo over MR is that MR is more helpful to town.

[Alison]

I find it hard to care which one of them goes over though.