Clue: The Movie [Day 10]

#501

I have to go, but I'll be back before the vote deadline, even if it isn't too much before it's over. I don't feel comfortable voting now, haven't had time to look back yet.

#502

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:well we dont even know if the indie has a kill yet or not so why worry about epig ?
Oh ffs.
well I wouldnt know how to be the last man standing without a kill.

This. I'm not sure it would even be possible. Not just unlikely -- sheer impossible. Usually when the indie doesn't have a kill, it seems like that role can win with either civs or mafia. but LMS?

#503

I think I have to drop out, I can't keep up with the game right now, sorry about joining the game and leaving like that.

#504

Well then... :/ Hope you come back for another game, kp!

So I'm looking at Canuck and Kev right now.

Kev has 1 post for the entire game. Canuck has been around enough to kill, but not enough to formulate a plan before/when sabie got in trouble imo. So I'm still leaning Canuck.

#505

Im going to go ahead and vote ninja blooper.

#506

Bass_the_Clever wrote:Im going to go ahead and vote ninja blooper.

I can't get my head around why she would put a 3rd vote on sabie Day 1 and break the tie if she were her teammate?

Like, maybe she's the Night 1 killer and needed to participate to guarantee her night action...and was also in a rush. But that's a lot of maybes.

#507

I'll put my faith in a Canuck vote again. I wish she were here to partake in debate, but that's where my hunch comes from. Crossing fingers!

*votes Canuck*

#508

I'm not sure which way I'll go today. Gonna stick around and read another 2 hours.

I made this in college.

#509

Mister Rearranger wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:Im going to go ahead and vote ninja blooper.
I can't get my head around why she would put a 3rd vote on sabie Day 1 and break the tie if she were her teammate?

Like, maybe she's the Night 1 killer and needed to participate to guarantee her night action...and was also in a rush. But that's a lot of maybes.

Ok , internet back up and baby in bed. The way I reread the posts during the lynch it felt like Ninjablue was waiting to save a teammate and then gave up. She voted with 2 minutes left to go it appears and then 5 more votes came in right after hers. I agree that the third vote to break a tie seems unlikely, but with so many people possibly about to vote she may have panicked. However, her vote for you again made no sense to me since sabie had also voted you early with no threat to herself. That said, I am thinking it is much more likely that it's an absentee at this point. Idk what llama will do about kpence, so kevin and canuck are where I am looking today. Going to reread whatever there may even be.

Linki pretty stars :yay:

#510

Mister Rearranger wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote: Wait, why lynch Epi?

I'd say there's nothing to think about regarding the Mr. Boddy role until we see evidence of it. Until then, I'm going to assume it's relatively harmless in the fact that it doesn't kill and doesn't say "secrets" by it.
To address both lines:

The LMS can't win with the civs.

Like I said though (and in agreement with you), the priority shouldn't be on figuring out anything about Mr. Boddy quite yet.

How do you feel about Canuck this game? I know she's checked in and said she's busy/struggling to get into the game, but the way Day 1 went down leads me to believe that sabie's team hasn't been all that active to begin with.

I agree with this as well. It definitely says last man standing, so I read that as not-civ aligned. To me that means whoever Mr.Boddy may be, although I can only see one option at this point, I would take any advice with a grain of salt. He would be motivated to kill baddies first for fear of being killed himself I'd assume, but it's also no loss to lose civs in the mean time. I have no intention of voting for a Boddy suspect over a baddie suspect though. I think it is important to eliminate those with kill powers first fo sho. Especially since without a kill last night it looks like we can eliminate the frequency of kills if we find a teammate.

#511

I'm sorry everyone, but I have to drop out too. I really didn't anticipate being so busy these past couple of days and I think it would be best if I dropped out now rather than continue not really doing anything.

#512

Well, my suspects are dropping like flies...

I read Canuck's 8 posts this game and it appears she may have voted MR or kpence. I think if your teammate had just been lynched and voted MR, you'd be unlikely to agree that's where your vote would go too, but who knows. Her posts don't give me much suspicion atm.

Canucklehead wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I am going to look like a total skeez for saying this, but sabie WAS my top suspect. I held my vote just in case, and then once it was safe, I voted elsewhere.
Why?

Also, sorry llama and everyone for missing the vote. Glancing through, I probably would've voted for MR or kspence had I been around but who knows what I would have done if I'd actually been here in real time...

She didn't vote Day 2 either, so we have little or nothing to go on there. I am honestly thinking I will vote Epi today as my Boddy suspect as the next best option until Llama can give us an idea of whether there will be replacements. It seems pretty likely that one of these two is bad, so I look forward to replacements giving us more to engage with if that may be the case.

Votes Epi

#513

I am in the process of lining up replacements now, yes.

#514

thellama73 wrote:I am in the process of lining up replacements now, yes.

OK, thanks.

#515

I can now cross Hedgeowl off a certain civilian role.

#516

Did we discuss The Cook's role in all of this?

#517

Mongoose wrote:Did we discuss The Cook's role in all of this?

No, but you can vote for me if you like. Hedgeowl is not the Cook.

#518

To reiterate on what Hedgeowl said on the previous page, it just seems way more likely like The Cook is responsible for the SVS death and not a lynch switch. We don't even know if there are lynch switches this early in the game.

There's only been the one contest so far.

linki wait what. I wasn't intimating she was btw.

#519

Mongoose wrote:To reiterate on what Hedgeowl said on the previous page, it just seems way more likely like The Cook is responsible for the SVS death and not a lynch switch. We don't even know if there are lynch switches this early in the game.

There's only been the one contest so far.

linki wait what. I wasn't intimating she was btw.

There have been two contests so far - the numbers game, and the recipe game.

#520

Mongoose wrote:To reiterate on what Hedgeowl said on the previous page, it just seems way more likely like The Cook is responsible for the SVS death and not a lynch switch. We don't even know if there are lynch switches this early in the game.

There's only been the one contest so far.

linki wait what. I wasn't intimating she was btw.

"We don't even know if there are lynch switches this early in the game?"

I don't like people telling me what "we" know. There is no collective consciousness. If there was, Mafia would be pointless.

Behold:

thellama73 wrote:The Chief

One lynch stop and one lynch switch.

#521

Does anyone have thoughts on Boogs? He's been absent, but his first vote could possibly point to baddieness. My only reservation is that his weird vote for Mongoose wasn't a great attempt at a save for sabie since there were two votes on MR at the time, too.

This is a difficult decision and I need to go to bed soon

#522

Nota bene:

I have died and come back from a kill (not "survived") and someone still sees fit to vote for me.

nijuu has lived and someone else lynched in her place and someone still sees fit to vote for her.

Foolishness. But that's OK.

#523

Epignosis wrote:Nota bene:

I have died and come back from a kill (not "survived") and someone still sees fit to vote for me.

nijuu has lived and someone else lynched in her place and someone still sees fit to vote for her.

Foolishness. But that's OK.

I tend to agree. Problem is..I know who I DON'T want to vote for, but I don't know who I WANT to vote for, and my eyes are getting very tired :/

#524

Elohcin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Nota bene:

I have died and come back from a kill (not "survived") and someone still sees fit to vote for me.

nijuu has lived and someone else lynched in her place and someone still sees fit to vote for her.

Foolishness. But that's OK.
I tend to agree. Problem is..I know who I DON'T want to vote for, but I don't know who I WANT to vote for, and my eyes are getting very tired :/

You can do one of two things if you want my advice.

You can vote for me (I won't be lynched today).

Or you can vote for MP. Recall your time with him in The Hobbit. Was he around and helpful? I think sabie fucked up and he made the most of it.

#525

#526

Hmm...in the hobbit he pretty much called out his teammates. What do you think of his posts on niju?

#527

Elohcin wrote:Hmm...in the hobbit he pretty much called out his teammates. What do you think of his posts on niju?

Bullshit.

#528

I, of course, agree. I guess I will go ahead and vote in that direction and see what happens. Goodnight Mafia friends.

#529

So now we have a vote spread 4 ways among 12 players. 2 are likely to not return to vote since they've dropped out. 2-3 more are hit/miss with participation so may not vote.

Hopefully the other 2 killers are among those 5, otherwise, this lynch seems quite destined for failure. :/

#530

Ebwop: I guess that's not something I should complain about though, given my track record with participation and hiatuses. >.<

#531

thellama73 wrote:I'm going out for a while. Just a reminder that those who don't vote in the lynch poll, don't get to use their night powers. If you want to use your night power, please vote in the lynch poll.

So who wants to kill somebody? Hmm?

Go ahead and vote.

Oh! Some of you already did!

#532

Epignosis wrote:
Elohcin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Nota bene:

I have died and come back from a kill (not "survived") and someone still sees fit to vote for me.

nijuu has lived and someone else lynched in her place and someone still sees fit to vote for her.

Foolishness. But that's OK.
I tend to agree. Problem is..I know who I DON'T want to vote for, but I don't know who I WANT to vote for, and my eyes are getting very tired :/
You can do one of two things if you want my advice.

You can vote for me (I won't be lynched today).

Or you can vote for MP. Recall your time with him in The Hobbit. Was he around and helpful? I think sabie fucked up and he made the most of it.

Dammit, Epi, why do you bring up this point so late in the day?? And I was just thinking in the back of my mind that it was odd how MP has been asking a lot of people's thoughts (especially mine) but offering hardly anything of his own. I wasn't thinking much of it...

And now I AM thinking of it. Fuck. I want to go to bed! Has MP been hoodwinking me this whole time??

#533

Only four people have voted. That means only four people get to use their night actions (including kill).

I plan on voting, by the way. I would like you to vote as well, because I don't think you are bad.

#534

Epignosis wrote:Only four people have voted. That means only four people get to use their night actions (including kill).

I plan on voting, by the way. I would like you to vote as well, because I don't think you are bad.

Don't kill me!

#535

You know what? Screw it. I can see MP throwing his teammate under the bus, then accusing a voter after him (namely, ME) for doing just that, and steering the thread. He's sure backed off and buddied up really quick in the last couple of days, too

Interesting and ballsy strategy. Plus, it's not like I wasn't thinking his behavior was off; it was just more subtly off and not as noticeable as missed votes or weird votes. I want and need to go to bed, so voting MP. Say what you want

#536

That gives me eight minutes to analyze your vote with others. See you tomorrow.

#537

I also voted MP. He posed some empty questions early on, got angry when I suggested he be lynched, and he isn't around right now to vote. Eloh was bad with him in The Hobbit. I think he threw sabie under the bus.

Even if I'm wrong, so what? The point of this poll means that if Peacock kills, she will be obvious.

#538

I disagree, but I understand your reason for voting him. And I didn't get to play Hobbit; I hope you're right.

#539

Mister Rearranger wrote:I disagree, but I understand your reason for voting him. And I didn't get to play Hobbit; I hope you're right.

You disagree about what?

#540

Who is a fiendish fiend?

Poll runs till Sun Sep 28, 2014 11:06:28 pm

Bass_the_Clever
0
No votes

Boogs
0
No votes

Canucklehead
1
Mister Rearranger (6)
9%

Elohcin
0
No votes

Epignosis
1
Hedgeowl (7)
9%

Hedgeowl
0
No votes

kevin
0
No votes

kpence
0
No votes

Mister Rearranger
0
No votes

Mongoose
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
3
Elohcin (8), nijuukyugou (10), Epignosis (11)
27%

Ninja Blooper
1
Bass_the_Clever (5)
9%

Someone who is not even playing this game (Host/Mod/Dead/Non)
5
thellama73 (1), Made (2), sabie12 (3), zeek (4), Enrique (9)
45%

Total votes : 11

#541

Well, it seems clear that there is at least one murderer in our midst, and under the circumstances, I think the best thing to do is to retire to one of the adjoining rooms and set about deducing who it is. I would have called the police, but I fear the storm has knocked out the phone lines, and it simply wouldn't do to let you all leave while one of you is a killer.

Where shall we go to become the most comfortable, hm? The lounge? The ballroom? The study? Or maybe stay here in the dining room?

Oh, hey! You guys! I said deduce! Not just randomly kill people. Geez. Now there's blood all over all the nice furniture. C'mon.

Ninja Blooper has been lynched. She was The Cop.
You have 24 hours to send in your Night Actions.
Actually, let's roll back the poll time a little bit before it creeps too late. You have 23 hours.

#542

That's bullshit.

#543

WTF!!! I thought I still had time?!?!!?

#544

MovingPictures07 wrote:WTF!!! I thought I still had time?!?!!?

Hai! OMG! What a surprise!

#545

Sorry everyone, I had dinner with my PhD cohorts and then had to stop by the grocery store and I thought I'd be back a bit sooner.

RIP Blooper. WTF EVERYONE! How could you lynch Blooper?!?! Will catch up in a second.

#546

RIP Blooper

#547

MovingPictures07 wrote:Sorry everyone, I had dinner with my PhD cohorts and then had to stop by the grocery store and I thought I'd be back a bit sooner.

RIP Blooper. WTF EVERYONE! How could you lynch Blooper?!?! Will catch up in a second.

#548

Seriously, what the hell, guys??? Was it not obvious she was that role and why I backed off of her??? Wow, WTF.

Epignosis wrote:
Elohcin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Nota bene:

I have died and come back from a kill (not "survived") and someone still sees fit to vote for me.

nijuu has lived and someone else lynched in her place and someone still sees fit to vote for her.

Foolishness. But that's OK.
I tend to agree. Problem is..I know who I DON'T want to vote for, but I don't know who I WANT to vote for, and my eyes are getting very tired :/
You can do one of two things if you want my advice.

You can vote for me (I won't be lynched today).

Or you can vote for MP. Recall your time with him in The Hobbit. Was he around and helpful? I think sabie fucked up and he made the most of it.

Sorry, but since you've never been on a team of mine before you'd never know, but I would NEVER be absent for a teammate. I bug the fuck out of my teammates.

Linki: Eye me all you want but it's all true.

#549

Wow, whatever, I can't believe both Epig and Elo apparently think my posts are "bullshit". Whatever, just lynch me next and lose another civvie. That'll sure help you. Where's the roll eyes smiley?

#550

MovingPictures07 wrote:Seriously, what the hell, guys??? Was it not obvious she was that role and why I backed off of her??? Wow, WTF.

Epignosis wrote:
Elohcin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Nota bene:

I have died and come back from a kill (not "survived") and someone still sees fit to vote for me.

nijuu has lived and someone else lynched in her place and someone still sees fit to vote for her.

Foolishness. But that's OK.
I tend to agree. Problem is..I know who I DON'T want to vote for, but I don't know who I WANT to vote for, and my eyes are getting very tired :/
You can do one of two things if you want my advice.

You can vote for me (I won't be lynched today).

Or you can vote for MP. Recall your time with him in The Hobbit. Was he around and helpful? I think sabie fucked up and he made the most of it.
Sorry, but since you've never been on a team of mine before you'd never know, but I would NEVER be absent for a teammate. I bug the fuck out of my teammates.

Linki: Eye me all you want but it's all true.

How was it obvious that she was that role?

Who is not supatown?