The Rings of Power - Game Over

[Moonwink]

I take back my town read on srceen atm

Also trying to teach my phone srceen is the new screen

Is she talking about your scum-partner? :P

[DrWilgy]

As Scotty has not responded to my plea. Screenplay has received my vote. Let the 4 way tie commence.

[Moonwink]

As Scotty has not responded to my plea. Screenplay has received my vote. Let the 4 way tie commence.

Nah. I'm always voting Screenplay here, lol. Sorry friendo. <3

[VOTE: Screenplay] aubergine

[NotAnAxehole]

As Scotty has not responded to my plea. Screenplay has received my vote. Let the 4 way tie commence.

Nice dumbtell

[srceenplay]

blah
Creature interacting is not how I remember them playing. From what I remember they always scum coasted. Maybe town coasted as well. They dont feel bad though.

Dunya confident IDGAF what you think feels towny to me but what mac says makes me think twice about it.

Nanook can be voted off

Moonwink idk without going back and rereading.

As the player with the 2nd most votes, I take issue with you not having a read on me, especially when you have your vote on HK, which I feel is a cop out. :< Have I not given enough content yet compared to HK? What is HK doing that I'm not that's grabbing your attention?

I haven't really tried forming a read on you yet. ;-; I figured with Mac and others talking to/about you, I'll have stuff to make a read on you later,

Sassy response. :3 The difference between me and Dunya though is that Dunya isn't one of the top wagons, which is why I don't immediately feel pressured to give a read on her at the moment. I -am- a top wagon, even more so than HK was 12 hours ago, yet you had zero interest in really having any influence in the wagons. THAT is what is scummy to me, not singularly that you don't have a read on me. The latter is just a byproduct of the former.

other news,
I liked omega and wasn't excited about mac.

What don't you like about Mac? From reading page 6, I've locked him in as town.

just paranoid.
they feels forceful

Okay, for real, why haven't you given a read on me? It feels like you're paying attention to other going-ons, but when it comes to the people actually getting wagoned (I'm pretty sure I was the lead wagon at one point), you don't seem to have much interest in leading people to or away from certain wagons?

----

To all: I'd be okay with srceenplay being a secondary wagon instead of me. Put up Jack and srceen and let's see what happens.

you are a null/scum position. Overly explaining your actions sounds like someone who scared of what people think about them. on the flip side it could be you just want people to understand you. IDK never played with you so, so i can sit back and observe and watch it play out more.

You have talked about reaction testing players. What have you gathered from that?

You're still not taking a position on me. Which do you think it is right now? Do you think it's more likely that I'm scared of what people think about me, or do you I'm just trying to get people to understand me? Again, I'm the top wagon, and you look bad to me right now not having any sort of strong alignment read on me right now.

other news,
I liked omega and wasn't excited about mac.

What don't you like about Mac? From reading page 6, I've locked him in as town.

just paranoid.
they feels forceful

Okay, for real, why haven't you given a read on me? It feels like you're paying attention to other going-ons, but when it comes to the people actually getting wagoned (I'm pretty sure I was the lead wagon at one point), you don't seem to have much interest in leading people to or away from certain wagons?

----

To all: I'd be okay with srceenplay being a secondary wagon instead of me. Put up Jack and srceen and let's see what happens.

I’d be fine with it because it means Screen goes over.

That would be my hope, yes. Because I would certainly be voting Screen over you in that case.

You know why that sounded sassy? Because I copied pasted your reply from basically the same question asked of you.

I'm still indifferent on you and think you could go either way.
I don't want to vote on the same wagon as you because of my uneasiness.
Your not a top scum that I think need to be lynched.
I will vote you towards end of the day if thats what we need for a wagon to go through.

[DrWilgy]

As Scotty has not responded to my plea. Screenplay has received my vote. Let the 4 way tie commence.

Nah. I'm always voting Screenplay here, lol. Sorry friendo. <3

[VOTE: Screenplay] aubergine

I have voted JoH. Let the 4 way tie commence.

[DrWilgy]

As Scotty has not responded to my plea. Screenplay has received my vote. Let the 4 way tie commence.

Nice dumbtell

How's this a dumbtell?

[NotAnAxehole]

@srceenplay How do you feel about a Nanook vote?

[Moonwink]

You know why that sounded sassy? Because I copied pasted your reply from basically the same question asked of you.

I'm still indifferent on you and think you could go either way.
I don't want to vote on the same wagon as you because of my uneasiness.
Your not a top scum that I think need to be lynched.
I will vote you towards end of the day if thats what we need for a wagon to go through.

Yes, I know it was copied and pasted from my reply to Dunya. That's why I explained in my post why it was appropriate in my case and super-scummy when you used it towards me. Again, Dunya is NOT a top wagon -- if she was, I would have formed a read on her right there and then. Since she's not at risk of being chopped, I've got time to make a read on her (unless she gets nightkilled n1, in which case, it doesn't really matter what my read on her is).

I, on the otherhand, AM a top wagon, and I don't want you to get away with not having an opinion on me and my alignment if I'm the one that gets chopped today. THAT is why I think your copy-pasted response is scummy when used towards me, but not so when I used it towards Dunya.

[NotAnAxehole]

[VOTE: Nanook] aubergine

[Scotty]

Where is Scotty?

I’m on my last cruise of my contract so I’ve got a lot of admin taking up my time but glad you miss me. I’ll iso you next

[Scotty]

@Scotty who's town in your eyes.

Me.
at page 7 in reread but still doom as top town.
Getting good vibes from srceen, osie, nook as I read on.
Dunya also seems good but only a lean. Need to develop those more cuz I’m all in the “feels good” category

[Scotty]

oh add creature to the pile with srceen osie and nook

[Scotty]

Also too many people are townreading me on D1- it’s weird. Stop plz

[Scotty]

NAA iso:

We should probably be focusing on killing Nanook today.

I have failed to see where this read was developed. I think he’s only voting there to be the first there and take the rings. Not because he actually thinks he is bad.

I'm going to rate all of my reads on a scale of 1 to 8, 1 being guaranteed mafia, 8 being guaranteed town.

Not rated:

Andres
Porscha
Creature
Moonwink
Marmot
DrWilgy


Nanook: 3
Jackofhearts: 6
MartinGG: 5
MacDougall: 6
DOO: 5
Hallowkat: 5
Scotty: 5
Osieorb: 4
Srceenplay: 4
Dunya: 4


I'm working on getting everyone on the list & tuning the list so that it's more meaningful.

ok I’ve been tninking about NAA’s shtick this game and I can call it nothing but safe. Safe is the word.

He claims his reads will be 100% accurate. Cool, ballsy, throws caution to the wind.

Here were are with some actual ‘reads’, and this post is laughable because not only does he offer no explanation of them, if you break down the numbers he penned in his scale, he has most people at 4/5, which is essentially a “null”. Is confident in no one. Super easy to call someone lean town or lean mafia, and especially since he has established this “I’m going to be completely accurate” persona this game, this kind of readlist is defensible logically.

But I don’t buy it. He can be scum. I’d rate him a pomegranate on a scale of pear (best fruit) to cantaloupe (worst fruit).

[srceenplay]

@srceenplay How do you feel about a Nanook vote?

Wouldn't bother me

[NotAnAxehole]

NAA iso:

We should probably be focusing on killing Nanook today.

I have failed to see where this read was developed. I think he’s only voting there to be the first there and take the rings. Not because he actually thinks he is bad.

I'm going to rate all of my reads on a scale of 1 to 8, 1 being guaranteed mafia, 8 being guaranteed town.

Not rated:

Andres
Porscha
Creature
Moonwink
Marmot
DrWilgy


Nanook: 3
Jackofhearts: 6
MartinGG: 5
MacDougall: 6
DOO: 5
Hallowkat: 5
Scotty: 5
Osieorb: 4
Srceenplay: 4
Dunya: 4


I'm working on getting everyone on the list & tuning the list so that it's more meaningful.

ok I’ve been tninking about NAA’s shtick this game and I can call it nothing but safe. Safe is the word.

He claims his reads will be 100% accurate. Cool, ballsy, throws caution to the wind.

Here were are with some actual ‘reads’, and this post is laughable because not only does he offer no explanation of them, if you break down the numbers he penned in his scale, he has most people at 4/5, which is essentially a “null”. Is confident in no one. Super easy to call someone lean town or lean mafia, and especially since he has established this “I’m going to be completely accurate” persona this game, this kind of readlist is defensible logically.

But I don’t buy it. He can be scum. I’d rate him a pomegranate on a scale of pear (best fruit) to cantaloupe (worst fruit).

I haven't even had time to compile the first 1/3 of the data.

[DaughterOfOmega]

some probable mafia

creature
scotty
nanook
moonwink

I mean if that's all town,take me back behind the woodshed

[DrWilgy]

some probable mafia

creature
scotty
nanook
moonwink

I mean if that's all town,take me back behind the woodshed

[Jackofhearts2005]

We should probably be focusing on killing Nanook today.

o.O

Nanook is actually the one person who, like, most of all seems willing to work with anybody just to make sure we actually get someone yeeted today. That's absolutely pro-town, I feel, in this setup. Everybody else seems to just wanna vote wherever they please and not convince anybody else to join their wagons. Like, do you and everyone else realize that we need 50% of players to vote on a wagon to chop someone? No one is going to get eliminated with these small wagons.

I don't know where any of this is coming from.

[srceenplay]

Dunya Doom Star Andres, hypothetically, if they are all town we would need to vote perfectly to lynch mafia. That unachievable.

[Creature]

oh add creature to the pile with srceen osie and nook

Is that your pile for town or for wolves?

[Jackofhearts2005]

FYI, the later a vote stays on me, the more likely it is to be from a wolf.

[NotAnAxehole]

Dunya Doom Star Andres, hypothetically, if they are all town we would need to vote perfectly to lynch mafia. That unachievable.

Not all town.

[DaughterOfOmega]

One of my mafia is on every wagon :o

[Jackofhearts2005]

I'd switch from Screen to Nanook tbh.

[Jackofhearts2005]

It would be great if anyone besides Moonwink would explain their read on Nanook, regardless of what it is. There's a lot of people putting him as town or highest wolf and I have no idea why.

[NotAnAxehole]

There are no mafia on Nanook.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Moonwink wagon most pure fwiw. I'm not sure I understand the case on Moonwink either except for vague w/w possibilities with Nanook.

My main suspicion of Nanook atp is how flacid his push on me seems to be. Like I understand why Marmot and Mac expressed some suspicion on me. That feels town. Wilgy is playing wagonomics. That's whatever. Nanook and Moonwink pushed on me because ??? and Moonwink's switch to Screen and assurances to me that she wants Screen gone over me is pretty pockety feeling. Dunya's suspicion on me is ??? and basically unstated but whatever. There's lots of reasons I don't have a good Dunya read atp and they've kinda been beaten to death.

So basically, I'm seeing players I think are town suspect Nanook and Moonwink and I suspect Nanook and Moonwink for very self centered vote movement related reasons. I doubt those are the same reasons other players suspect them.

[DaughterOfOmega]

Moonwink wagon most pure fwiw. I'm not sure I understand the case on Moonwink either except for vague w/w possibilities with Nanook.

My main suspicion of Nanook atp is how flacid his push on me seems to be. Like I understand why Marmot and Mac expressed some suspicion on me. That feels town. Wilgy is playing wagonomics. That's whatever. Nanook and Moonwink pushed on me because ??? and Moonwink's switch to Screen and assurances to me that she wants Screen gone over me is pretty pockety feeling. Dunya's suspicion on me is ??? and basically unstated but whatever. There's lots of reasons I don't have a good Dunya read atp and they've kinda been beaten to death.

So basically, I'm seeing players I think are town suspect Nanook and Moonwink and I suspect Nanook and Moonwink for very self centered vote movement related reasons. I doubt those are the same reasons other players suspect them.

How do you feel about my posts toward Moonwink since you don't understand the case on them.

[MacDougall]

osie is not solving the game osie just grandstanding

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: nanook] aubergine

I think it's time to just let axe have his d1 chop. I feel like if we did that in most games we'd kill mafia.

[Creature]

[VOTE: NANOOK] aubergine

[Creature]

some probable mafia

creature
scotty
nanook
moonwink

I mean if that's all town,take me back behind the woodshed

I'm only seeing NANOOK here as possible mafia tbh.

[Creature]

Slightly unhappy with Marmot's ISO so far.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We should probably be focusing on killing Nanook today.

Doom currently has no votes on them, just saying

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

@srceenplay How do you feel about a Nanook vote?

This is like asking a toddler how they feel about eating chocolate

[Jackofhearts2005]

Moonwink wagon most pure fwiw. I'm not sure I understand the case on Moonwink either except for vague w/w possibilities with Nanook.

My main suspicion of Nanook atp is how flacid his push on me seems to be. Like I understand why Marmot and Mac expressed some suspicion on me. That feels town. Wilgy is playing wagonomics. That's whatever. Nanook and Moonwink pushed on me because ??? and Moonwink's switch to Screen and assurances to me that she wants Screen gone over me is pretty pockety feeling. Dunya's suspicion on me is ??? and basically unstated but whatever. There's lots of reasons I don't have a good Dunya read atp and they've kinda been beaten to death.

So basically, I'm seeing players I think are town suspect Nanook and Moonwink and I suspect Nanook and Moonwink for very self centered vote movement related reasons. I doubt those are the same reasons other players suspect them.

How do you feel about my posts toward Moonwink since you don't understand the case on them.

I understand what you're saying but it doesn't really move the needle much. Sorry.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Hi, @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

[VOTE: Nanook] aubergine

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Hi, @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME

[VOTE: Nanook] aubergine

Hello

[hollowkatt]

hi

[Scotty]

I’m gonna be swamped rest of night and my isos are going to have to wait until I have some off time tomorrow.

Can someone sum up why he is being voted that isn’t named NAA?

[Scotty]

[VOTE: NAA] aubergine

[Jackofhearts2005]

I’m gonna be swamped rest of night and my isos are going to have to wait until I have some off time tomorrow.

Can someone sum up why he is being voted that isn’t named NAA?

I'm voting Nanook because he has stated that I am mafia multiple times with zero reasoning to the point that I thought he was joking but here we are approaching eod and he's still voting for me, which all feels scummy.

Also because players I trust have poked there.

[Scotty]

I’m gonna be swamped rest of night and my isos are going to have to wait until I have some off time tomorrow.

Can someone sum up why he is being voted that isn’t named NAA?

I'm voting Nanook because he has stated that I am mafia multiple times with zero reasoning to the point that I thought he was joking but here we are approaching eod and he's still voting for me, which all feels scummy.

Also because players I trust have poked there.

I was in the middle of ISOing you because I don’t have a read on you yet. Half of your posts seem blendy.

Who do you trust the most?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’m gonna be swamped rest of night and my isos are going to have to wait until I have some off time tomorrow.

Can someone sum up why he is being voted that isn’t named NAA?

I'm voting Nanook because he has stated that I am mafia multiple times with zero reasoning to the point that I thought he was joking but here we are approaching eod and he's still voting for me, which all feels scummy.

Also because players I trust have poked there.

Yeah that sounds scummy

[Jackofhearts2005]

I’m gonna be swamped rest of night and my isos are going to have to wait until I have some off time tomorrow.

Can someone sum up why he is being voted that isn’t named NAA?

I'm voting Nanook because he has stated that I am mafia multiple times with zero reasoning to the point that I thought he was joking but here we are approaching eod and he's still voting for me, which all feels scummy.

Also because players I trust have poked there.

I was in the middle of ISOing you because I don’t have a read on you yet. Half of your posts seem blendy.

Who do you trust the most?

Blendy?

I trust Mac the most.

[osieorb18]

[VOTE: hollowkatt] aubergine

I'mma go back through and figure out why people are voting for Nanook but in the meantime, this is where I see my vote doing the most good.

[osieorb18]

other news,
I liked omega and wasn't excited about mac.

What don't you like about Mac? From reading page 6, I've locked him in as town.

just paranoid.
they feels forceful

Okay, for real, why haven't you given a read on me? It feels like you're paying attention to other going-ons, but when it comes to the people actually getting wagoned (I'm pretty sure I was the lead wagon at one point), you don't seem to have much interest in leading people to or away from certain wagons?

----

To all: I'd be okay with srceenplay being a secondary wagon instead of me. Put up Jack and srceen and let's see what happens.

Jack and srceen? Are we playing the same game?

[hollowkatt]

am I shadowbanned or something? Marmot wrote up a case on me, I said it was junk with reasons, and crickets.
I know I'm not "omg it's teh HK taking over" but also I'm not like just chopped liver.