S~V~S wrote:<snip>
Three civ roles appear to have the ability to potentially survive an NK on their own; Mickey, Sarah Jane and Captain Jack. So what makes it so suspish? Plus the person who attempted to kill Elo was a civvie. I am curious why her survival does not seem as bad to you.
S~V~S wrote:<snip>
There is Sarah Jane, Mickey Smith & Captain Jack. One implies immunity (flip of a coin), one says he is "hard to kill" and the third says 50/50 of night targets failing. Bad Elo is s lot flail-ier when shes cornered, this Elo is not.
<snip>
By the time that SVS posted this, on day 3, Mickey Smith was still alive, and as far as I can tell, the secret section of his role had not been revealed yet. How did SVS know about this role's secrets? (HINT: She's not Mickey Smith. That was Snow Dog, who was lynched that same day.)
I found nothing to tell me how SVS knew about Mickey's role secret before it was revealed.
I also found it odd that after days and days of suspecting both Dana and Daisy, SVS suddenly abandons all suspicion of them both.
Something's not adding up. I know I've said forever that I think SVS is the recruiter, and that's not going to change here. And I think Dana/LC is someone that we should all be concerned about.
I was told by a host that they would permit a teammate to send in the PMs for a non playing teammate.
Something is VERY fishy here...
Also, for extra reading fun:
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/search ... =281&ch=-1
Turnip Head wrote:SVS, where do you fall on the Chris+LC vs. Epi+Sabie spectrum?
Turnip Head wrote:What does everyone think of SVS so far? I've not seen her take any heat yet but I also don't see anyone vouching for her or trusting her. It feels like something is missing from her game but I can't quite place my finger on it. Less conducive to open discussion? Her posts seem to go down carefully mapped avenues of thought, unlike those of a freewheeling baddie hunter.
I'm probably voting for Bass but that seems like yesterday's news already. Bass hasn't said or done anything to make me doubt the evidence against him. I brought up a point about Bass saying he went back and read old games of Made's and Enrique's in order to figure out they were bad. It sounded like bulloney to me and he never responded to it. I think he got rolechecker info on one or both of them and dressed it up as his own research. Especially considering Bass doesn't have many contributions to the discussion this game, that point really sticks out.
Turnip Head wrote:Click this link to be taken to all of SVS's posts. Enter "Roxy" into the Search box. Hit Enter. Roxy's name will be highlighted every time that SVS typed it in this thread.
I think this is definitely worth a discussion... and I definitely think SVS would recruit Roxy if she had the chance.
Turnip Head wrote:It cannot be unseen. I think SVS is the recruiter. Normally in a game of mafia, SVS will have plenty to say about Roxy, she's not afraid to offer her own opinion on the matter, she'll tell you the way she sees things. SVS will analyze Roxy's tone, word choice, level of snark etc to determine if she believes Roxy to be bad or not.
None of that thought process showed up at all in this game. And yet, almost all mentions of Roxy in those 13 posts are a defense of Roxy. Or rather, SVS decided to talk about the players who were talking about Roxy, questioning their intentions... she did not discuss Roxy herself.
And in case any of you forgot... TH said this the day of the lynch. This is the lynch where MP suddenly has an epiphany on TH being The Master, and puts a vote on him. Less than 30 minutes later, TH is mysteriously dead with a lynch switch. A switch that Bass didn't have because he was the "princess" role. A switch that the Cyber team, or anyone in the game for that matter, doesn't have according to the role descriptions. A switch that really seems like the sort of thing a secret role would have.
*Voting SVS*