Page 21 of 30

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:21 am
by Marmot
Rezz please.

Re: The Donner Party - Night 2

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:37 am
by Zombarella
FZ. wrote:
fingersplints wrote:Are you happy with it FZ?
Yeah, I'm good.

Roxy, you said we can talk about who we were, right? Splints, were you Hunger last day?
@ FZ - You were right about Tricer yesterday so I am more inclined to trust your opinion. If Splints is telling the truth and didn't change roles, then I think we should be eating fingers for our next lunch.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 5:12 am
by fingersplints
any reason why?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 10:16 am
by Long Con
That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:15 am
by FZ.
Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:27 am
by Bass_the_Clever
I think Mp made a good analysis. It sucks for splints but I could see dom wanting to be replaced if he did get that role.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:28 am
by Long Con
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.
I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 12:46 pm
by FZ.
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.
I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.
Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 12:48 pm
by FZ.
Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:29 pm
by Zombarella
FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
Good question.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:39 pm
by Roxy
FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
No.
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya ;)

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:42 pm
by fingersplints
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.
I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.
Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?
I think you have made some incorrect eliminations. :) I have the same civvie role I had before.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:50 pm
by FZ.
fingersplints wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.
I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.
Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?
I think you have made some incorrect eliminations. :) I have the same civvie role I had before.
There's only one person who could have been Hunger, and that's Russ. Since it appeared like he had some people defending him, it left only you

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:55 pm
by Ricochet
FZ. wrote: There's only one person who could have been Hunger, and that's Russ. Since it appeared like he had some people defending him, it left only you
*sigh*

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:56 pm
by fingersplints
Well you definitely overlooked something because I don't think Russ is hunger either. :shrug: There are loads more people who could have been hunger.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:59 pm
by Roxy
July Morning

Peggy Breen had started a facination with James Reed. She was singing softly when she spied him walking through the woods.She hid behind a shubbery that was neither too large or too small. She was lost to her own thoughts singing to herself. Too bad she was hiding from him as he was hunting for food.

James heard a branch snap and turned and shot Peggy right between the eyes.
when he realized what he had done his only thought was too bad she took the shot to head now there would no brains to make a stew out of.

He walked in the direction of his camp to let his family know what had happened.

MovingPictures has been killed by James Reed.
It is still Day 3 and you still have time left for a proper Lunch.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:02 pm
by Tangrowth
WTF!!!! Screw you, James Reed. :mad:

Oh well, go civvies! And thanks for the awesome game Rox!

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:04 pm
by thellama73
:huh:

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:18 pm
by FZ.
What the hell is wrong with Reed? :mad:

RIP MP :(

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:19 pm
by FZ.
Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:33 pm
by Zombarella
MovingPictures07 wrote:WTF!!!! Screw you, James Reed. :mad:

Oh well, go civvies! And thanks for the awesome game Rox!
:overreact:

MP all of us civvies will miss you.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:33 pm
by Black Rock
FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...

Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:36 pm
by Zombarella
Black Rock wrote:
FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...

Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
I think there were only two - Llama and MP

MM and Epi were killed by baddies I thought.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:38 pm
by Zombarella
fingersplints wrote:Well you definitely overlooked something because I don't think Russ is hunger either. :shrug: There are loads more people who could have been hunger.
Loads? Like who? I'm just looking at you and Blooper.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:42 pm
by FZ.
Black Rock wrote:
FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...

Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
Wasn't Epi killed by Levina?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:46 pm
by FZ.
I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day. :sigh: We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:52 pm
by Zombarella
FZ. wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...

Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
Wasn't Epi killed by Levina?
Since Weather (Epi) killed MM - I assumed that the other baddie team (Wasatch, GSLD, and Freemont) killed Weather (Epi). Both teams are supposed to kill each night.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:53 pm
by fingersplints
FZ. wrote:I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day. :sigh: We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.
I don't see MP as a confirmed civvie. He could have been bad.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:53 pm
by fingersplints
I was looking forward to hearing him reply who had a different role that he was sure of since no one seems to be admitting to that.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 2:59 pm
by fingersplints
Zomberella12 wrote:
fingersplints wrote:Well you definitely overlooked something because I don't think Russ is hunger either. :shrug: There are loads more people who could have been hunger.
Loads? Like who? I'm just looking at you and Blooper.
Well good luck with that. :) Considering there are more then 2 baddies left I would think that seems like you should broaden your search horizons.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 3:02 pm
by fingersplints
And ninjablooper is on my ? list fwiw.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 3:04 pm
by FZ.
fingersplints wrote:
FZ. wrote:I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day. :sigh: We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.
I don't see MP as a confirmed civvie. He could have been bad.
The story says he was Peggy Breen.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 3:12 pm
by fingersplints
FZ. wrote:
fingersplints wrote:
FZ. wrote:I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day. :sigh: We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.
I don't see MP as a confirmed civvie. He could have been bad.
The story says he was Peggy Breen.
Ah, I didn't get a chance to read the story just the end. Well that's too bad then. I really thought we might have gotten one.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 3:14 pm
by fingersplints
Well then, I am looking at ninja and bass atm. I still don't like Ty's inactivity, but it's really hard to get a proper read on someone who has posted so little.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 3:31 pm
by FZ.
BR, what are your thoughts at the moment? What do you think about Splints?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 5:26 pm
by Snowman
Roxy wrote:
FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
No.
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya ;)
Booooooooo!

Image

...urns.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 5:53 pm
by Zombarella
Snowman wrote:
Roxy wrote:
FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
No.
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya ;)
Booooooooo!

Image

...urns.
Are you going to do an early vote again?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 6:31 pm
by Russtifinko
FZ. wrote:
fingersplints wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints. :shrug:
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.
I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.
Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?
I think you have made some incorrect eliminations. :) I have the same civvie role I had before.
There's only one person who could have been Hunger, and that's Russ. Since it appeared like he had some people defending him, it left only you
Why am/was I Hunger, according to you? I'm getting confused about who is accusing me of doing what when.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 9:06 pm
by Snowman
Zomberella12 wrote:
Snowman wrote:
Roxy wrote:
FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
No.
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya ;)
Booooooooo!

Image

...urns.
Are you going to do an early vote again?
My Spidey-sense must be off, because I'm just not pinging on anyone yet. :|

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 10:27 pm
by Snowman
Russ, FZ, Zomba, and the dearly departed MP have me convinced. I'm voting now.
If I wake up dead, I don't meant to point fingers, but it was...
Image

and I'll be like

Image

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 10:34 pm
by Zombarella
Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?

@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 10:59 pm
by Black Rock
Zomberella12 wrote:
FZ. wrote:
Black Rock wrote:
FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...

Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
Wasn't Epi killed by Levina?
Since Weather (Epi) killed MM - I assumed that the other baddie team (Wasatch, GSLD, and Freemont) killed Weather (Epi). Both teams are supposed to kill each night.
I thought the same. It was really hard by the post to know who did I thought but I assumed the other baddie team.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:00 pm
by Black Rock
FZ. wrote:BR, what are your thoughts at the moment? What do you think about Splints?
Just catching up at the moment but something Splints has said has me thinking she is civvie.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:02 pm
by Black Rock
Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?

@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
I will have to go back and read blooper, she has not made any impression on me so far this game, one way or the other.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:13 pm
by Black Rock
Ok, so my biggest suspicions are Bass, Snowman and TySlayer.

I felt like someone disagreed with me about Bass so I'm less sure about him.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 11:58 pm
by Snowman
Black Rock wrote:Ok, so my biggest suspicions are Bass, Snowman and TySlayer.

I felt like someone disagreed with me about Bass so I'm less sure about him.
I don't know about Bass, Ty is either evil or disinterested, and I definitely think Snowman's a civie, civvie, civvilian, sivlein, good guy

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2015 12:01 am
by Snowman
Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?

@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...

...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2015 12:03 am
by Zombarella
Snowman wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?

@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...

...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.
Yeah...really sparse and bland posts. Not much info. Sounds like Bloops might be a bad guy trying to fly (or swim?) under the radar.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2015 12:05 am
by Snowman
Snowman wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?

@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...

...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.
...SHE'S posted. My bad.

Re: The Donner Party - Day 3

Posted: Thu Feb 12, 2015 1:04 am
by Russtifinko
Zomberella12 wrote:
Snowman wrote:
Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?

@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...

...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.
Yeah...really sparse and bland posts. Not much info. Sounds like Bloops might be a bad guy trying to fly (or swim?) under the radar.
If I recall correctly, Bloops has been known to do this in the past when bad.