Re: The Donner Party - Day 3
Posted: Wed Feb 11, 2015 1:21 am
Rezz please.
@ FZ - You were right about Tricer yesterday so I am more inclined to trust your opinion. If Splints is telling the truth and didn't change roles, then I think we should be eating fingers for our next lunch.FZ. wrote:Yeah, I'm good.fingersplints wrote:Are you happy with it FZ?
Roxy, you said we can talk about who we were, right? Splints, were you Hunger last day?
I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints.
I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.FZ. wrote:I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints.
Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.Long Con wrote:I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.FZ. wrote:I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints.
Good question.FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
No.FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
I think you have made some incorrect eliminations.FZ. wrote:Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.Long Con wrote:I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.FZ. wrote:I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?
There's only one person who could have been Hunger, and that's Russ. Since it appeared like he had some people defending him, it left only youfingersplints wrote:I think you have made some incorrect eliminations.FZ. wrote:Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.Long Con wrote:I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.FZ. wrote:I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?I have the same civvie role I had before.
*sigh*FZ. wrote: There's only one person who could have been Hunger, and that's Russ. Since it appeared like he had some people defending him, it left only you
MovingPictures07 wrote:WTF!!!! Screw you, James Reed.![]()
Oh well, go civvies! And thanks for the awesome game Rox!
FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...
I think there were only two - Llama and MPBlack Rock wrote:FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...
Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
Loads? Like who? I'm just looking at you and Blooper.fingersplints wrote:Well you definitely overlooked something because I don't think Russ is hunger either.There are loads more people who could have been hunger.
Wasn't Epi killed by Levina?Black Rock wrote:FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...
Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
Since Weather (Epi) killed MM - I assumed that the other baddie team (Wasatch, GSLD, and Freemont) killed Weather (Epi). Both teams are supposed to kill each night.FZ. wrote:Wasn't Epi killed by Levina?Black Rock wrote:FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...
Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
I don't see MP as a confirmed civvie. He could have been bad.FZ. wrote:I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day.We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.
Well good luck with that.Zomberella12 wrote:Loads? Like who? I'm just looking at you and Blooper.fingersplints wrote:Well you definitely overlooked something because I don't think Russ is hunger either.There are loads more people who could have been hunger.
The story says he was Peggy Breen.fingersplints wrote:I don't see MP as a confirmed civvie. He could have been bad.FZ. wrote:I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day.We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.
Ah, I didn't get a chance to read the story just the end. Well that's too bad then. I really thought we might have gotten one.FZ. wrote:The story says he was Peggy Breen.fingersplints wrote:I don't see MP as a confirmed civvie. He could have been bad.FZ. wrote:I really don't understand what why it was so urgent to kill MP so early in the day.We were doing so good before that. Now we have 3 civvies dead. Unless Rico became Hunger during the night, but I doubt we wouldn't know they've been eliminated.
Booooooooo!Roxy wrote:No.FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya
Are you going to do an early vote again?Snowman wrote:Booooooooo!Roxy wrote:No.FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya
...urns.
Why am/was I Hunger, according to you? I'm getting confused about who is accusing me of doing what when.FZ. wrote:There's only one person who could have been Hunger, and that's Russ. Since it appeared like he had some people defending him, it left only youfingersplints wrote:I think you have made some incorrect eliminations.FZ. wrote:Well, I think that from a process of elimination, it is likely that she was a baddie, and if she still has the same role, I don't get why that would change. I didn't see her related to anyone last day.Long Con wrote:I think his points about her are opportunistic and weak, actually. I'd be surprised if fingersplints turned out to be Epig's teammate, I don't get that read at all from going over her posts. It looks more like MP07 is cleverly trying to put together various far-fetched points into a cobbled case.FZ. wrote:I don't get why. I also think Splints was very likely Hunger last round, and I do wonder if she's lying about it now.Long Con wrote:That analysis made me more suspicious of MovingPictures07 than fingersplints.
Do you think she's good, or is it more that you think MP is bad?I have the same civvie role I had before.
My Spidey-sense must be off, because I'm just not pinging on anyone yet.Zomberella12 wrote:Are you going to do an early vote again?Snowman wrote:Booooooooo!Roxy wrote:No.FZ. wrote:Roxy, is it possible for civvie roles to become bad?
maybe
Paranoia will destroy ya
...urns.
I thought the same. It was really hard by the post to know who did I thought but I assumed the other baddie team.Zomberella12 wrote:Since Weather (Epi) killed MM - I assumed that the other baddie team (Wasatch, GSLD, and Freemont) killed Weather (Epi). Both teams are supposed to kill each night.FZ. wrote:Wasn't Epi killed by Levina?Black Rock wrote:FZ. wrote:Obviously Reed got Levina's power and used the third kill. And they killed Rico for nothing...
Third kill? I knew about one but did I miss another one?
Just catching up at the moment but something Splints has said has me thinking she is civvie.FZ. wrote:BR, what are your thoughts at the moment? What do you think about Splints?
I will have to go back and read blooper, she has not made any impression on me so far this game, one way or the other.Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?
@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
I don't know about Bass, Ty is either evil or disinterested, and I definitely think Snowman's a civie, civvie, civvilian, sivlein, good guyBlack Rock wrote:Ok, so my biggest suspicions are Bass, Snowman and TySlayer.
I felt like someone disagreed with me about Bass so I'm less sure about him.
I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?
@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
Yeah...really sparse and bland posts. Not much info. Sounds like Bloops might be a bad guy trying to fly (or swim?) under the radar.Snowman wrote:I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?
@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.
...SHE'S posted. My bad.Snowman wrote:I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?
@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.
If I recall correctly, Bloops has been known to do this in the past when bad.Zomberella12 wrote:Yeah...really sparse and bland posts. Not much info. Sounds like Bloops might be a bad guy trying to fly (or swim?) under the radar.Snowman wrote:I have no idea about the Karate Squid, he says like two words a day...Zomberella12 wrote:Snowman - I think you might be wrong about Splints. What do you think about Blooper?
@Bass and BR - Do you have any opinions about NinjaBloops?
...also, I haven't read anything he's posted.