Re: Watchmen [Day 3]
Posted: Mon Jul 20, 2015 9:30 pm
And no, MP, I'm not implying that you don't have other reasons to suspect me, I just think the Golden one is utter and complete BS.
I never said you should be lynched today.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:Honestly anyone who lynches me because "Golden said so" should be quick-lynched afterwards.
Quote Golden's posts and say you agree with them if you want. Elaborate on that. But form your own opinions, please.
I saw Cookie doing this and now I'm seeing MP doing this. Stop.
MovingPictures07 wrote:Elo is bouncing all over the place, isn't she?Ricochet wrote:Well "doesn't truly care who gets lynched" sounds very Molochian to me. If you think LoRab fits the description, I'm thinking Eloh does as well.
I'm having a lot of trouble understanding exactly what her rainbow list of players-with-highest-propensity-to-receive-my-vote today looks like.
Yup, DDL and Espers are the only two I suspect and they are not really that strong. However, I see that DDL feels strong about DH being suspect and I think I missed why. Can anyone link me?[/quote]Cookie wrote:Would you be willing and able to make a rainbow list of ONLY the players you are considering for a vote in this lynch?
Ok, fine, sorry for the sudden outburst.MovingPictures07 wrote:I dropped you from my list some time ago, DDL. You're going to be a heavy place of examination for me going into D4, but not for today.
I'm considering:
Cookie
espers
LoRab
You literally have no idea of where you're voting?Elohcin wrote:dun dun dun
Don't sweat it. I understand you'd be MEGA pissed if I didn't even address your posts, or give you a proper chance. I would be too. :PDragon D. Luffy wrote:Ok, fine, sorry for the sudden outburst.MovingPictures07 wrote:I dropped you from my list some time ago, DDL. You're going to be a heavy place of examination for me going into D4, but not for today.
I'm considering:
Cookie
espers
LoRab
"On the one hand, back in the day (when GMan was a regular) on LP/Piano, lie detector roles and statements became a thing and how people phrase statements and asking everyone to make "An LD Statement" became something of a controversy. In addition/as a result, in many games, "I am a civie" wasn't a detectable statement, so people would often not use it and got in the habit of not just saying that."LoRab wrote:On quickly and skimmed up. I do care who is lynched. I'm posting based on my suspicions. Day 2 I didn't really like any of the choices at that moment. I may seem suspicious to some but I am not bad. I am not Indy. I am not neutral. I'm civ this game. I'm voting gman because I still suspect him. And for those saying I was bringing up his old games that is not true. Read my posts. It's how people post with an ld in game in general. Although I still don't see how gman' statement of thinking that saying he was civie would be role outing still doesn't make sense to me and his explanations for it don't ring true. If that makes me seem suspish, so be it. I find him suspicious. That hasn't changed. Voting him. I hope to live to actually defend myself from specific posts.
My wording may have been slightly off, but I meant the LD on previous websites, not the LD of G-Man on previous websites. This was what I was referencing.Ricochet wrote:LoRab - Short and sweet, I ultimately don't like her LD debate build-up and push on G-Man, because I remember somebody pointing out (although I fail to remember who, right now) that the issues she had - with the lie detectability of statements such as those made by G-Man on previous websites or with G-Man way of wording and careful gameplay on the same previous website - were actually no issues at all, which makes me not understand why she would bring them up as issues.
I don't like this at all. I firmly believe Cookie is making up suspects.Cookie wrote:Thanks for the link to that. I had to make a quick decision but I've vote for DH because of DDL.
At the same time, I'm trusting someone who I originally suspected so if they turn out to be wrong, it's just going to add to my suspicions.
Cookie wrote:It wasn't as much as I was hoping. I really have no strong suspicions on anyone and I feel like I'm reaching for straws.MovingPictures07 wrote:Yay, a wild Cookie appears! Welcome, Cookie!
Can't wait to hear what you have to say.
I only found you suspicious at the time because I thought you were trying to save a teammate. Like I said, I no longer find you suspicious.Elohcin wrote:Cookie - Why would you find me suspicious when I tied u the vote if it was in favor of the civs?
Yup, DDL and Espers are the only two I suspect and they are not really that strong. However, I see that DDL feels strong about DH being suspect and I think I missed why. Can anyone link me?MovingPictures07 wrote:Would you be willing and able to make a rainbow list of ONLY the players you are considering for a vote in this lynch?Cookie wrote:Oh, I forgot about Espers. I am suspicious of him because of his voting patterns day one. Nothing he has said specifically has made me feel suspicious of him. I'm not sure if that's enough to go on, considering that was a similar reasoning for my vote against Golden.
How much time is left? Is there anywhere I can see when Day ends?
Right there with you. I should have voted espers, but I didn't realize how the rest of the votes were going to land.DharmaHelper wrote:If I'm lynched I'll fucking flip.
Not on the scoreboard.G-Man wrote:I just got home 10 minutes ago. Didn't read back. Saw the poll with DH in the lead. I voted to protect him. I hope it worked. If it does, I hope it was worth it.
You've said multiple times in this game that you think I'm really civilian, yet you cast your vote for me.Elohcin wrote:B/c you held a watergun to my head.
BruhG-Man wrote:I just got home 10 minutes ago. Didn't read back. Saw the poll with DH in the lead. I voted to protect him. I hope it worked. If it does, I hope it was worth it.
MovingPictures07 wrote:I think the remaining two mafia members very well may be some combination of:
Cookie and espers
Cookie and DDL
Cookie and Elohcin
DDL and Elohcin
Discuss.
Ricochet wrote:Not on the scoreboard.G-Man wrote:I just got home 10 minutes ago. Didn't read back. Saw the poll with DH in the lead. I voted to protect him. I hope it worked. If it does, I hope it was worth it.
100% agree.Dragon D. Luffy wrote:I agree that Cookie's vote is probably the most suspicious thing that happened in this phase.
"If DH flips town I'm suspecting DDL?" Really? What about YOUR responsibility for YOUR own vote?
I'm actually thinking that as well.DharmaHelper wrote:MovingPictures07 wrote:I think the remaining two mafia members very well may be some combination of:
Cookie and espers
Cookie and DDL
Cookie and Elohcin
DDL and Elohcin
Discuss.
Misunderstood that entirely. Sorry.G-Man wrote:Ricochet wrote:Not on the scoreboard.G-Man wrote:I just got home 10 minutes ago. Didn't read back. Saw the poll with DH in the lead. I voted to protect him. I hope it worked. If it does, I hope it was worth it.
I really do think you are civ. I won't let you gt lynched for real.MovingPictures07 wrote:You've said multiple times in this game that you think I'm really civilian, yet you cast your vote for me.Elohcin wrote:B/c you held a watergun to my head.
I'm really hoping for an espers flip, as much as I'm afraid this may be a civilian loss either way.DharmaHelper wrote:If I die at least I played 1 Day legit :P
Shoulda kept my mouth shut I guess.
EBWOP: Espers/Cookie or Cookie/Eloh guys.