The Syndicate

sig wrote:That wasn't very nice.

Long Con wrote:RIP sig. And welcome Zebra! What happened to sprityo?

Elohcin wrote:

Long Con wrote:

Elohcin wrote:It was 2/3 when I voted, and I'm sorry, I didn't think Soneji was bad. I am not going to vote for someone I don;t think is bad.

I was just thinking that I would expect a baddie to have avoided the lynch train on civ Soneji, and then I come in and see this post from you, Eloh. Who do you think are the baddies involved in the Soneji lynch, if any?

If I have to rank the Soneji voters, it would be Niju, Sorsha, Wilgy, SVS, then sig.

S~V~S wrote:I have to agree with Sorsha; removing Niju would appear to be somehow shenanigan related, but a quick double check of the roles does not see this as a baddie related power.

The power steatrer is a civ, and is also dead *shrug*

DFaraday wrote:

S~V~S wrote:I have to agree with Sorsha; removing Niju would appear to be somehow shenanigan related, but a quick double check of the roles does not see this as a baddie related power.

The power stealer is a civ, and is also dead *shrug*

There are a couple of secrets, but they're also civ (and indy I guess). There's no self-targeting, so she can't have been Oshira-sama or whoever did it. Which means whoever did it probably doesn't even know Ninja's role.

DFaraday wrote:

S~V~S wrote:I have to agree with Sorsha; removing Niju would appear to be somehow shenanigan related, but a quick double check of the roles does not see this as a baddie related power.

The power steatrer is a civ, and is also dead *shrug*

There are a couple of secrets, but they're also civ (and indy I guess). There's no self-targeting, so she can't have been Oshira-sama or whoever did it. Which means whoever did it probably doesn't even know Ninja's role.

Long Con wrote:

DFaraday wrote:

S~V~S wrote:I have to agree with Sorsha; removing Niju would appear to be somehow shenanigan related, but a quick double check of the roles does not see this as a baddie related power.

The power stealer is a civ, and is also dead *shrug*

There are a couple of secrets, but they're also civ (and indy I guess). There's no self-targeting, so she can't have been Oshira-sama or whoever did it. Which means whoever did it probably doesn't even know Ninja's role.

So we've got a Civ Nijuu-sympathizer. We also don't know what the bath tokens do... has anyone received one yet? Care to comment on their function? I have not gotten one.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:You all may speculate on what Bath Tokens do, but you may not state whether you have one or not. This does count as info-dumping.

DFaraday wrote:

S~V~S wrote:I have to agree with Sorsha; removing Niju would appear to be somehow shenanigan related, but a quick double check of the roles does not see this as a baddie related power.

The power steatrer is a civ, and is also dead *shrug*

There are a couple of secrets, but they're also civ (and indy I guess). There's no self-targeting, so she can't have been Oshira-sama or whoever did it. Which means whoever did it probably doesn't even know Ninja's role.

finally getting back up to running 3 miles, woo! 4-miler next Saturday, here I come!

Long Con wrote:I'm going to get confused between this game and the other one.

Long Con wrote:Ok, so how do we analyze G-Man's technicolour voting lists?

G-Man wrote:Technicolor vote
Analysis can provide
A new perspective

DAY 1

Spoiler: show

1. MATT (sig)
2. MATT (sprityo)
3. QUIN (Long Con)
4. THELLAMA73 (S~V~S)
5. THELLAMA73 (Sloonei)<---CIVVIE
6. DOM (DFaraday)
7. SIG (Matt) <---CIVVIE
8. MATT (Nijuukyugou)
9. THELLAMA73 (Bubbles)
10. DRWILGY (Elohcin)
11. BUBBLES (Scotty)<---CIVVIE
12. MATT (Quin)<---CIVVIE
13. THELLAMA73 (DrWilgy)
14. MATT (thellama73)<---BADDIE
15. DFARADY (Sorsha)
16. THELLAMA73 (G-Man)
17. THELLAMA73 (Dr. Wilgette)<---CIVVIE

MISSING VOTES: Dom, Soneji

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

4. THELLAMA73 (S~V~S)
5. THELLAMA73 (Sloonei)<---CIVVIE
9. THELLAMA73 (Bubbles)
13. THELLAMA73 (DrWilgy)
16. THELLAMA73 (G-Man)
17. THELLAMA73 (Dr. Wilgette)<---CIVVIE

1. MATT (sig)
2. MATT (sprityo)
8. MATT (Nijuukyugou)
12. MATT (Quin)<---CIVVIE
14. MATT (thellama73)<---BADDIE

3. QUIN (Long Con)

6. DOM (DFaraday)

7. SIG (Matt) <---CIVVIE

10. DRWILGY (Elohcin)

11. BUBBLES (Scotty)<---CIVVIE

15. DFARADY (Sorsha)


MISSING VOTES:
Dom
Soneji<---CIVVIE

Day 1 tells us that SVS, Wilgy, G-Man and Bubbles are unlikely to be bad, unless they were bussing a teammate. Sorsha's vote stands out as coming at a pivotal time but not going for either major candidate (and for being on me ). LC's vote doesn't give any indication of his alignment. Dom missed, so it's hard to glean anything from that. Ninja voted for Matt in the middle of the pack, so it could be a save attempt.

DAY 2

Spoiler: show

1. MATT (sig)
2. DRWILGETTE (Bubbles)
3. MATT (Elohcin)
4. MATT (Scotty)<---CIVVIE
5. MATT (Quin)<---CIVVIE
6. SIG (Matt)<---CIVVIE
7. MATT (Dom)
8. ELOHCIN (DrWilgy)
9. DRWILGY (S~V~S)
10. MATT (Sorsha)
11. ELOHCIN (DFaraday)
12. MATT (Nijuukyugou)
13. ELOHCIN (DrWilgette)<---CIVVIE
14. MATT (Soneji)<---CIVVIE
15. MATT (G-Man)

MISSING VOTES: sprityo
SILENCED: Long Con

---------------------------------------------------------------

1. MATT (sig)
3. MATT (Elohcin)
4. MATT (Scotty)<---CIVVIE
5. MATT (Quin)<---CIVVIE
7. MATT (Dom)
10. MATT (Sorsha)
12. MATT (Nijuukyugou)
14. MATT (Soneji)<---CIVVIE
15. MATT (G-Man)

8. ELOHCIN (DrWilgy)
11. ELOHCIN (DFaraday)
13. ELOHCIN (DrWilgette)<---CIVVIE

2. DRWILGETTE (Bubbles)

6. SIG (Matt)<---CIVVIE

9. DRWILGY (S~V~S)

MISSING VOTES: sprityo
SILENCED: Long Con

Ninja, Dom, G-Man, and Eloh voted on the Matt train, but Ninja and G-Man's votes came so late as to feel like a better place to hide. Bubbles, Wilgy, and SVS all voted in different places, so it's hard to make anything out of them just from the voting pattern. SVS was pretty consistent in suspecting Wilgy though. Sprit missed, so that's a null read.

DAY 3

Spoiler: show

1. LONG CON (Quin)<---CIVVIE
2. QUIN (Long Con)
3. ELOHCIN (sprityo)
4. QUIN (soneji)<---CIVVIE
5. SONEJI (sig)
6. DRWILGY (Elohcin)
7. QUIN (Nijuukyugou)
8. DRWILGY (Dom)
9. QUIN (DFaraday)
10. ELOHCIN (DrWilgy)
11. G-MAN (Sorsha)
12. QUIN (G-Man)

MISSING VOTES: Bubbles, DrWilgette
SILENCED: S~V~S

----------------------------------------------------------------------

2. QUIN (Long Con)
4. QUIN (soneji)<---CIVVIE
7. QUIN (Nijuukyugou)
9. QUIN (DFaraday)
12. QUIN (G-Man)

3. ELOHCIN (sprityo)
10. ELOHCIN (DrWilgy)

6. DRWILGY (Elohcin)
8. DRWILGY (Dom)

1. LONG CON (Quin)<---CIVVIE

5. SONEJI (sig)

11. G-MAN (Sorsha)

MISSING VOTES:
Bubbles
DrWilgette<---CIVVIE

SILENCED:
S~V~S

G-Man again with the late vote, after the lynch was a runaway. Eloh going back to her Wilgy suspicion is a good look for her, and likewise for Wilgy voting Eloh. I don't agree with either one's suspicion, but consistent reads typically make me feel better about people. And Sorsha, like before, votes late and irrelevantly.

DAY 4

Spoiler: show

1. DRWILGY (Bubbles)
2. NIJUUKYUGOU (Long Con)
3. SONEJI (S~V~S)
4. SONEJI (DrWilgy)
5. NIJUUKYUGOU (G-Man)
6. DFARADAY (Dom)
7. SONEJI (sig)
8. NIJUUKYUGOU (Elohcin)
9. SONEJI (Nijuukyugou)
10. NIJUUKYUGOU (Soneji)<---CIVVIE
11. SONEJI (Sorsha)
12. DOM (DFaraday)

MISSING VOTES: sprityo

------------------------------------------------------------------

3. SONEJI (S~V~S)
4. SONEJI (DrWilgy)
7. SONEJI (sig)
9. SONEJI (Nijuukyugou)
11. SONEJI (Sorsha)

2. NIJUUKYUGOU (Long Con)
5. NIJUUKYUGOU (G-Man)
8. NIJUUKYUGOU (Elohcin)
10. NIJUUKYUGOU (Soneji)<---CIVVIE

1. DRWILGY (Bubbles)

6. DFARADAY (Dom)

12. DOM (DFaraday)

MISSING VOTES:
sprityo

Day 4 Sorsha casts the deciding vote on Soneji, who turns out to be civ. This seems worse to me since she left her G-Man suspicion to vote Soneji. LC, Eloh, and G-Man look better just by virtue of not voting a civ. Sprit missing again continues to give no read.

Just going off the votes, I'd say the last three baddies are among Sorsha, Ninja, G-Man, LC, and Sprit, in that order of suspicion.

DFaraday wrote:Dom, since you've literally suspected me since Day 1, I appreciate it if you made a coherent case on me. As it is, I'm still not entirely sure what has you keep gunning for me beyond having a weak Day 1 vote.

DFaraday wrote:Dom, since you've literally suspected me since Day 1, I appreciate it if you made a coherent case on me. As it is, I'm still not entirely sure what has you keep gunning for me beyond having a weak Day 1 vote.

Sorsha wrote:I could get behind a DF lynch today. His defense of G-Man has got me thinking of a couple of scenarios. One: based on DF defending him and attacking me, that maybe I am wrong about G-Man. Its possible that DF knows G-Man is good because DF himself is bad. By attacking me he's trying to gain G-Man's favor, (or anyone's really who thinks that G-Man is good.) Or perhaps they are teammates and DF feels comfortable enough defending him since no one else is really agreeing with my G-Man suspicion.

I still find G-Man's actions this game suspicious and the fact that G-Man really hasn't even addressed them also bothers me. And I'm irritated that he is silenced today because it's just a lame free pass. Am I missing something on why no one else finds anything G-Man has done as suspicious?

Anyway- for now I'm going with a DF vote.

S~V~S wrote:

DFaraday wrote:Dom, since you've literally suspected me since Day 1, I appreciate it if you made a coherent case on me. As it is, I'm still not entirely sure what has you keep gunning for me beyond having a weak Day 1 vote.

For me it is also the people you have defended, the suspicions you have and have not gotten.

snip from day 2 purple text wrote:Ninja, Dom, G-Man, and Eloh voted on the Matt train, but Ninja and G-Man's votes came so late as to feel like a better place to hide.

another snip from day 2 purple text wrote:SVS was pretty consistent in suspecting Wilgy though.

S~V~S wrote:I specifically did NOT suspect Wilgy. Faraday, way to misinterpret the data.

S~V~S wrote:I specifically did NOT suspect Wilgy. Faraday, way to misinterpret the data.

DrWilgy wrote:A sorta... pickin at straws comment... I feel like we are in a good territory if we bop Elo, DF, Sriracha, or Dom on the nose today...

DFaraday wrote:My analysis was almost entirely concerned with the voting record, not the posts people have made, so apologies if that part is fuzzier.