Re: Mass Effect Mafia (Day 2)
Posted: Thu Apr 06, 2017 4:43 pm
I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
Can you explain a good reason for his claim as a baddie? For him to outright risk counter claim?Silver Lantern wrote:To be frank at this point hasn't there been enough back and forth (guessing here) that we will get solid info from any of these lynches.DrWilgy wrote:
To EVERYONE we will gain mpre info from a JoH lynch than an Epi lynch.
We would gain the most info from a gfish lynch.
Isn't info what all civs thirst for?
Cause if so, stop trying to make it seem like one is better than another. That just makes you seem like a team mate trying to protect Epi.
Might as well just quote at this point.Mordin Solus
You are the very model of a Salarian scientist! And since you were recruited by Shepard to stop the Reaper threat, you have a variety of abilities you can use during the game.
Incinerate - One shot roleblock with a chance to kill your target.
Neural Shock - One shot roleblock nexus (anyone targeting you fails in their action)
Salarian Scientist - Two shot alignment cop
Is Epi only after you cause you claimed to have blocked him?gfishfunk wrote:I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
I got some swampland in Florida to sell you.Silver Lantern wrote:I just read the Geth Role. Frankly, I don't have an issue with him. I think that the fact that he claimed obviously means he plans to side with the Alliance.
I think he's playing which is more likely to happen. Gfish refuses to vote for Jack, he's intransigent. Jack will vote for Gfish, Epi will vote for Gfish...so of the two options enough people can vote for Fish to force a non Epi lynch.Silver Lantern wrote:To be frank at this point hasn't there been enough back and forth (guessing here) that we will get solid info from any of these lynches.DrWilgy wrote:
To EVERYONE we will gain mpre info from a JoH lynch than an Epi lynch.
We would gain the most info from a gfish lynch.
Isn't info what all civs thirst for?
Cause if so, stop trying to make it seem like one is better than another. That just makes you seem like a team mate trying to protect Epi.
I am expecting some excellent info from the Epi lynch. I'm not convinced that what Epignosis is claiming is true.DrWilgy wrote:To EVERYONE we will gain mpre info from a JoH lynch than an Epi lynch.Fredwood wrote:DrWilgy wrote:Fred, JoH can both of you vote Gfish so we can give that wagon a chance.
To a point, but to me we're in the same position if we all switch from Jack to Gfish. I think either can go, I have less faith that either will at this point.
I just don't see how we need to play it safe at this point, we have leeway now. If you all think Epi is a safe lynch...doesn't it make more sense to save it for if we get in a situation where we need to be careful?
We would gain the most info from a gfish lynch.
Isn't info what all civs thirst for?
Not really...if you fucking copped him we would have bypassed the whole Vega debacle.gfishfunk wrote:Might as well just quote at this point.Mordin Solus
You are the very model of a Salarian scientist! And since you were recruited by Shepard to stop the Reaper threat, you have a variety of abilities you can use during the game.
Incinerate - One shot roleblock with a chance to kill your target.
Neural Shock - One shot roleblock nexus (anyone targeting you fails in their action)
Salarian Scientist - Two shot alignment cop
Incinerate. And before you give me hell for my choice of night action, I hit non-town damnit. It was a great night action.
Who is "HIS"/"HIM" and can you explain exactly WHAT he will not die from?DrWilgy wrote:Can you explain a good reason for his claim as a baddie? For him to outright risk counter claim?Silver Lantern wrote:To be frank at this point hasn't there been enough back and forth (guessing here) that we will get solid info from any of these lynches.DrWilgy wrote:
To EVERYONE we will gain mpre info from a JoH lynch than an Epi lynch.
We would gain the most info from a gfish lynch.
Isn't info what all civs thirst for?
Cause if so, stop trying to make it seem like one is better than another. That just makes you seem like a team mate trying to protect Epi.
He
will
not
die
from
this
Meaning we gain nothing.
No, epi wants LC to die. But he's going to vote for whoever has the greatest chance of being lynched of not being him.Silver Lantern wrote:Is Epi only after you cause you claimed to have blocked him?gfishfunk wrote:I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
Does a kill attempt appear on him in the write up?
Insert Siren Gif...Fredwood wrote:Not really...if you fucking copped him we would have bypassed the whole Vega debacle.gfishfunk wrote:Might as well just quote at this point.Mordin Solus
You are the very model of a Salarian scientist! And since you were recruited by Shepard to stop the Reaper threat, you have a variety of abilities you can use during the game.
Incinerate - One shot roleblock with a chance to kill your target.
Neural Shock - One shot roleblock nexus (anyone targeting you fails in their action)
Salarian Scientist - Two shot alignment cop
Incinerate. And before you give me hell for my choice of night action, I hit non-town damnit. It was a great night action.
Also...I don't see any kill protection in your roleblock.
Lol Silver = ReaverLong Con wrote:I got some swampland in Florida to sell you.Silver Lantern wrote:I just read the Geth Role. Frankly, I don't have an issue with him. I think that the fact that he claimed obviously means he plans to side with the Alliance.
I blocked him. He claimed a town role.Silver Lantern wrote:Is Epi only after you cause you claimed to have blocked him?gfishfunk wrote:I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
Does a kill attempt appear on him in the write up?
Y tho?Long Con wrote:I am expecting some excellent info from the Epi lynch. I'm not convinced that what Epignosis is claiming is true.DrWilgy wrote:To EVERYONE we will gain mpre info from a JoH lynch than an Epi lynch.Fredwood wrote:DrWilgy wrote:Fred, JoH can both of you vote Gfish so we can give that wagon a chance.
To a point, but to me we're in the same position if we all switch from Jack to Gfish. I think either can go, I have less faith that either will at this point.
I just don't see how we need to play it safe at this point, we have leeway now. If you all think Epi is a safe lynch...doesn't it make more sense to save it for if we get in a situation where we need to be careful?
We would gain the most info from a gfish lynch.
Isn't info what all civs thirst for?
What's the alternative? Why did I ditch my Vega claim that got most of the votes off me?Long Con wrote:I am expecting some excellent info from the Epi lynch. I'm not convinced that what Epignosis is claiming is true.DrWilgy wrote:To EVERYONE we will gain mpre info from a JoH lynch than an Epi lynch.Fredwood wrote:DrWilgy wrote:Fred, JoH can both of you vote Gfish so we can give that wagon a chance.
To a point, but to me we're in the same position if we all switch from Jack to Gfish. I think either can go, I have less faith that either will at this point.
I just don't see how we need to play it safe at this point, we have leeway now. If you all think Epi is a safe lynch...doesn't it make more sense to save it for if we get in a situation where we need to be careful?
We would gain the most info from a gfish lynch.
Isn't info what all civs thirst for?
Protection. Not a role block with protection at the same time. A role block, and I am not worried because I have protection. As in, I don't care if I draw some unwanted night attention.gfishfunk wrote:Might as well just quote at this point.Mordin Solus
You are the very model of a Salarian scientist! And since you were recruited by Shepard to stop the Reaper threat, you have a variety of abilities you can use during the game.
Incinerate - One shot roleblock with a chance to kill your target.
Neural Shock - One shot roleblock nexus (anyone targeting you fails in their action)
Salarian Scientist - Two shot alignment cop
Incinerate. And before you give me hell for my choice of night action, I hit non-town damnit. It was a great night action.
Because of the potential nightkill on it. How badass would that be?Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
Woulda been great had you used that alignment check or SELF PROTECTgfishfunk wrote:Might as well just quote at this point.Mordin Solus
You are the very model of a Salarian scientist! And since you were recruited by Shepard to stop the Reaper threat, you have a variety of abilities you can use during the game.
Incinerate - One shot roleblock with a chance to kill your target.
Neural Shock - One shot roleblock nexus (anyone targeting you fails in their action)
Salarian Scientist - Two shot alignment cop
Incinerate. And before you give me hell for my choice of night action, I hit non-town damnit. It was a great night action.
ThisCaptainNifty wrote:I now feel way more confident about voting for you.
If you are Mordin, you did this badly.
However, I'll be surprised if you are Mordin.
If I were Mafia Jack, you wouldn't have lived past N1.Jackofhearts2005 wrote:Lol Silver = ReaverLong Con wrote:I got some swampland in Florida to sell you.Silver Lantern wrote:I just read the Geth Role. Frankly, I don't have an issue with him. I think that the fact that he claimed obviously means he plans to side with the Alliance.
There aren't going to be any counters for anybody. I went over this. There are more roles than players. His role is either his role or it's a fake role. I lean the latter.Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
lol we're down to Jack or Fish at this point. I don't like Fish's claim because as you said, Cop makes an infinite amount of more sense on N1 then a gut RB. Jack hasn't claimed yet, and Fish has done the whole I'm a RB from early on thing. So info dump supports Fish currently. It really comes down to how flexible people are to vote for which people.Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
That's not accurate. If I get lynched, so be it, and I side with the Reapers because the civilians are fucked if they think lynching me is in their best interest.Fredwood wrote:No, epi wants LC to die. But he's going to vote for whoever has the greatest chance of being lynched of not being him.Silver Lantern wrote:Is Epi only after you cause you claimed to have blocked him?gfishfunk wrote:I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
Does a kill attempt appear on him in the write up?
Alright, sorry for not being caught up. To be clear: You hit Epi with a kill chance block because you were certain enough he was scum instead of using a cop check first? Is this what you're saying?gfishfunk wrote:Because of the potential nightkill on it. How badass would that be?Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
And once again, I didn't hit town with it.
I never said I was good at this game.CaptainNifty wrote:I now feel way more confident about voting for you.
If you are Mordin, you did this badly.
However, I'll be surprised if you are Mordin.
Obviously you have never played with Gfish...Epignosis wrote:Yeah, gfishfunk is a liar. Who the hell uses a block / kill BEFORE an alignment check.
Lies.
This is 100 percent not what happened. He said he targeted himself and LC and I jumped to the Vega conclusion and then you backed off along with Adam, IR and Nifty, he never actually claimed Vega. LC then jumped on and Epi thought he caught scum and dropped the Geth bomb on us. Diz did not vote for Epi until much later in the discussion when I told Diz the best two options for a lynch at that time.gfishfunk wrote:I blocked him. He claimed a town role.Silver Lantern wrote:Is Epi only after you cause you claimed to have blocked him?gfishfunk wrote:I claimed a role block with self protection.Fredwood wrote:He claimed one of 28 roleblocks
Does a kill attempt appear on him in the write up?
I relented and moved my vote off. Long Con and Dyslexicon moved their votes on Epi. Epi then said it was all a trap and he is really Gesh! He was testing to see if people would buy the claim because he thought it was a ploy because one of us hit him with a kill.
I put my vote back on him. I think its a safe lynch. I think the claim could provide cover for a Reaper role. I think Epi is the type of player that would likely join Reaper anyway out of a 'hell, why not?' attitude.
Change vote to self preservation. Yep.Dyslexicon wrote:Alright, sorry for not being caught up. To be clear: You hit Epi with a kill chance block because you were certain enough he was scum instead of using a cop check first? Is this what you're saying?gfishfunk wrote:Because of the potential nightkill on it. How badass would that be?Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
And once again, I didn't hit town with it.
How in the world would you know the alignment of who you hit?gfishfunk wrote:Because of the potential nightkill on it. How badass would that be?Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
And once again, I didn't hit town with it.
He did claim, albeit roundabout. Here is his claim Fred.Epignosis wrote:Tuck and roll bitches.
I didn't. It was a guess. And damnit if it wasn't a fantastic one because I was right.CaptainNifty wrote:How in the world would you know the alignment of who you hit?gfishfunk wrote:Because of the potential nightkill on it. How badass would that be?Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
And once again, I didn't hit town with it.
Yeah, that claim doesn't make sense to me at all. And I don't think I buy he's the type of player who would make such a decision because "how badass would it be". Honestly I have no read on Jack, he could go either way. Still see no point in having Epi hanging around, BUT if Gfish is likelier to be actual scum than (for now) neutral then he is a better lynch. Lynches are valuable in this setup. I'd be fine with both of these lynches, but Gifhs' story doesn't strike me as a truthful one. But I haven't read much of this game day (sorryyyy) which is why I'm asking you specifically lol.Fredwood wrote:lol we're down to Jack or Fish at this point. I don't like Fish's claim because as you said, Cop makes an infinite amount of more sense on N1 then a gut RB. Jack hasn't claimed yet, and Fish has done the whole I'm a RB from early on thing. So info dump supports Fish currently. It really comes down to how flexible people are to vote for which people.
lol sigh I guess....I don't like that I'm on it with only one green ping, a null, two flaming spicy read and a known neutral...but w/e.DrWilgy wrote:Fredwood, can you change your vote?
I'd prefer a lack of shenanigans.
Tell me: How demoralizing is it to have your first kill of the game wasted on someone you don't need dead to win...and you couldn't even succeed at that?gfishfunk wrote:I didn't. It was a guess. And damnit if it wasn't a fantastic one because I was right.CaptainNifty wrote:How in the world would you know the alignment of who you hit?gfishfunk wrote:Because of the potential nightkill on it. How badass would that be?Dyslexicon wrote:@Fred, My sanity and my soul. Should I join on Jack?
I see Gfish claiming. Why on earth would you not use a cop action the first night if this is your role? Any counters to this?
And once again, I didn't hit town with it.
The sheer amount of horror from you all is astounding.
True but that was after LC and I gave him an out.gfishfunk wrote:He did claim, albeit roundabout. Here is his claim Fred.Epignosis wrote:Tuck and roll bitches.
I really want to like you Epi, cause you used a really cool line like "tuck and roll bitches", but if you could not be such a dickbag to the people from my home site, that would be cool...Epignosis wrote: Tell me: How demoralizing is it to have your first kill of the game wasted on someone you don't need dead to win...and you couldn't even succeed at that?
Lulz.Silver Lantern wrote:Mainly cause that's my job...
What are you whining on about? Can you quote what role has vote shenanigans that you're concerned about? So that others can understand without stirring up a panic for no reason?Dyslexicon wrote:I'm still afraid that vote shenanigans will fuck up having a lynch.
Dyslexicon wrote:I'm still afraid that vote shenanigans will fuck up having a lynch.
Silver Lantern wrote:What are you whining on about? Can you quote what role has vote shenanigans that you're concerned about? So that others can understand without stirring up a panic for no reason?Dyslexicon wrote:I'm still afraid that vote shenanigans will fuck up having a lynch.