The Witcher Mafia [Game Over]

[MacDougall]

Oh another point for 112 is the meme hardclaiming mafia in their opener. Not a major read but mafia usually just aren't quite that overt. Even if it's a meme. Wolves can't help but be cautious usually. 112 as mafia would only be doing that literally to get this read out of a weirdo like me or Tutuu and that's not really worth the immediate sus they'd receive from the rest of the cast.

[RondoDimBuckle]

[VOTE: syn] aubergine

in the words of made "why?"

[Made]

[VOTE: syn] aubergine

in the words of made "why?"

Based on yesterday’s vibe sesh, Syn was vibing, but didn’t pivot to play in a way that felt solve-y. I had that thought yesterday, but didn’t have the meta to scum read it—that Mac just gave. I figured the lack of actually content was NAI

[MacDougall]

I am changing my read on Poison. No longer strongly townreading her. I have them potentially aligned with 112. Their progression on 112 reads like either a town that is cautious but not confident they are seeing a wolf, or a wolf that is just trying to create some content to distance a teammate. It is not a wolf's read on a town. If 112 is town, Poison is probably also town. If 112 is mafia, Poison would be someone I'd immediately bring into focus as a possible teammate.

[Made]

[VOTE: syn] aubergine

in the words of made "why?"

Based on yesterday’s vibe sesh, Syn was vibing, but didn’t pivot to play in a way that felt solve-y. I had that thought yesterday, but didn’t have the meta to scum read it—that Mac just gave. I figured the lack of actually content was NAI

Actual**** I swr Im a native English speaker

[MacDougall]

I think Made is a LOT townier in their posts since I outed myself as town, which is a very good look for them.

[Made]

I am changing my read on Poison. No longer strongly townreading her. I have them potentially aligned with 112. Their progression on 112 reads like either a town that is cautious but not confident they are seeing a wolf, or a wolf that is just trying to create some content to distance a teammate. It is not a wolf's read on a town. If 112 is town, Poison is probably also town. If 112 is mafia, Poison would be someone I'd immediately bring into focus as a possible teammate.

I see it as pocketed by 112 before I see teammates tbh

[MacDougall]

I am changing my read on Poison. No longer strongly townreading her. I have them potentially aligned with 112. Their progression on 112 reads like either a town that is cautious but not confident they are seeing a wolf, or a wolf that is just trying to create some content to distance a teammate. It is not a wolf's read on a town. If 112 is town, Poison is probably also town. If 112 is mafia, Poison would be someone I'd immediately bring into focus as a possible teammate.

I see it as pocketed by 112 before I see teammates tbh

You've read Poison's ISO already?

[Made]

I am changing my read on Poison. No longer strongly townreading her. I have them potentially aligned with 112. Their progression on 112 reads like either a town that is cautious but not confident they are seeing a wolf, or a wolf that is just trying to create some content to distance a teammate. It is not a wolf's read on a town. If 112 is town, Poison is probably also town. If 112 is mafia, Poison would be someone I'd immediately bring into focus as a possible teammate.

I see it as pocketed by 112 before I see teammates tbh

You've read Poison's ISO already?

I was around for a lot of 112/poison’s banter last night, so read it all in context

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: Poison] aubergine

Had to copy format from another user. Also, I checked through Mac's ISO. Looks good TBH.

@Ruri you made this vote while talking about other things and didn't even talk about Poison at all either prior, during or afterwards. What caused this vote?

[Made]

If there’s new stuff from the passed 16 hours or so I wouldn’t know

[KZA]

ate too much let's battle

[MacDougall]

I think tedxtr maybe town. If so I'd love to see you get to work @tedxtr. If you up your output here it won't be good for the mafia.

[MacDougall]

I am changing my read on Poison. No longer strongly townreading her. I have them potentially aligned with 112. Their progression on 112 reads like either a town that is cautious but not confident they are seeing a wolf, or a wolf that is just trying to create some content to distance a teammate. It is not a wolf's read on a town. If 112 is town, Poison is probably also town. If 112 is mafia, Poison would be someone I'd immediately bring into focus as a possible teammate.

I see it as pocketed by 112 before I see teammates tbh

You've read Poison's ISO already?

I was around for a lot of 112/poison’s banter last night, so read it all in context

I only am basing the read off the first part of Poison's ISO tbh. I guess I should finish it.

[MacDougall]

DrWilgy is the first person I am reading that makes me confident they are town.

[MacDougall]

I'm reserving judgement on Scotty.

[MacDougall]

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

[MacDougall]

TSP is probably town for not trying. This read is pretty high percentage sadly. Mafia shouldn't be like this.

[112]

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

[112]

iso'd sig and agree with the mafia reads

kind of want to read into the emoji post he made but emojianalysis is an infant science so i'll just leave it at he's >rand maf.

[MacDougall]

Toppest
KZA
DrWilgy

I think townie but could be maybe wrong but would be a bit surprised
EnderWiggin
Urist
falcon45ca
Made
Michelle
tedxtr

I think townie but wouldn't be surprised if wrong
Epignosis
NotAnAxehole
Scotty
TonyStarkPrime
DkKoba

I think townie but in certain worlds they could easily be mafia based on the play I've seen here
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison
112

I think wolfy but if I had some additional facts I could very easily flip this read
Ruri

Tutuu is here because I think she is mafia but I also don't want to kill her
tutuu

Meh just kill them
Master Radishes
sig
RondoDimBuckle
Syn

[MacDougall]

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

In case you missed it I am a mod confirmed town.

[112]

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

In case you missed it I am a mod confirmed town.

you're town, but let's not push it.

[MacDougall]

KZA is also a reasonable confident townread.

you and him are the players i normally read well and am pretty sure are town

In case you missed it I am a mod confirmed town.

you're town, but let's not push it.

No really I am a mod confirmed town. I am an inno child and the mod confirmed it.

[MacDougall]

MacDougall has revealed himself to be an innocent child.

Right here.

[112]

MacDougall has revealed himself to be an innocent child.

Right here.

How do I know that's not just a really epic diss?

[RondoDimBuckle]

Toppest
KZA
DrWilgy

I think townie but could be maybe wrong but would be a bit surprised
EnderWiggin
Urist
falcon45ca
Made
Michelle
tedxtr

I think townie but wouldn't be surprised if wrong
Epignosis
NotAnAxehole
Scotty
TonyStarkPrime
DkKoba

I think townie but in certain worlds they could easily be mafia based on the play I've seen here
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Poison
112

I think wolfy but if I had some additional facts I could very easily flip this read
Ruri

Tutuu is here because I think she is mafia but I also don't want to kill her
tutuu

Meh just kill them
Master Radishes
sig
RondoDimBuckle
Syn

well now I dont want to share my syn iso

[MacDougall]

You don't want to share your syn iso because I reiterated my read on you as part of a broader readslist, a read you already were aware of when you started it?

[MacDougall]

When syn themselves is in the same group as you?

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: Syn] aubergine

[RondoDimBuckle]

You don't want to share your syn iso because I reiterated my read on you as part of a broader readslist, a read you already were aware of when you started it?

Thats fair

Spoiler: show

1: Disredits Mac - If wolf this is TMI but your inno child post ruins any setup
1: meme post
2: meme post
3: meme post
4: meme post
5: discredit tedxtr
6: discredit tutuu
7: meme post at tutuu
8: meme post
9: meme post with made
10:meme post with made + michelle
11:meme post with axe
12:meme post directly referencing wolves
13:wolf callout - KZA
14:meme post
15:meme post
16:Sad smily at tutuu
17:meme post
18:exit
19:meme post
20:callout forced posts between ender and 112 or calling out 112's posts as forced
21:meme post at Rondo
22:vote 112 for meme post quoted
23:discredit made calling 112 town
24:discredit 112 - Also I dont know why 112 quoted me here?
25:unvote - meme post?
26:meme post at epi - +Equity? [scotty/epi/tutuu]
27:discredit scotty in favour of made [Scotty vote made]
28:mech talk - telling people to read rules
29:meme post
30:meme post
31:meme post
32:meme post
33:meme post
34:meme post
35:meme post
36:credit Rondo to KZA
37:asking why talking about TSP
38:nothing post about asking who made KZA agro at no one in paticular
39:meme post
40:meme post - exit
41:meme post possible discredit of mac
42:meme post
43:meme post?
44:meme/nothing post - exit
45:meme post at Ruri
46:meme post at Rondo
47:meme post at Scotty
48:Vote Ender - meme vote?
49:confirm meme vote on ender "itll be funny"
50:nothing post at DrWigly
51:discredit scotty/asking for explination [First real post] - Scotty: calling KZA/Rondo one of wolf. KZA town Rondo Powerwolf
52:meme post about not being town leader - soft push for town leader?
53:discredit scotty without quote [Second real post] - unlinking post count with alignment
54:nothing post at self
55:meme post at KZA
56:meme vote at no one
57:discredit scotty [Third real post] - unlinking top posters with town leaders
58:discredit scotty
59:meme post at Ruri
60:discredit scotty [Fourth real post] - tells scotty to top linking top posters and leaders and to dunk on someone instead
61:meme post at scotty/radish
62:meme post at radish/scotty
63:meme post soft discredit/scum read ender?
64:dead air dead villager meme post
65:meme post at rondo
66:meme post at DrWiggly and DrKorba
67:discredit sig
68:lead in to next post
69:meme post - calls sig wolf
70:discredit tutuu - calling mac town
71:meme post? - calls mac town
72:soft discredit mac? - doesnt work since he is claim inno child
73:soft discredit mac? - ^
74:meme post at mac claiming
75:discredit tutuu - gth + town = same
76:discredit tutuu - novelty of town lists
77:meme post
78:meme post
79:meme post at tutuu for @ing everyone
80:hardclaim kza - Not sure if this is saying town or wolf. If town, its hard clearing someone for explaining mechanics.
81:Disredits Mac - town must mean reads are right big brain

Overall NIA leaning towards scum

[RondoDimBuckle]

ignore the first 1, I started reading backwards and it didnt delete correctly when I copy pasted

[Made]

I really like that iso format, might steal it in the future

[MacDougall]

I really like that iso format, might steal it in the future

It'd be great if it had links to the posts lol.

[RondoDimBuckle]

I really like that iso format, might steal it in the future

All we are is a combination of what we have stolen from others

[RondoDimBuckle]

I really like that iso format, might steal it in the future

It'd be great if it had links to the posts lol.

ITS LITERALLY IN ORDER, JUST OPEN THE ISO AND READ

[112]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

oh boy are you going to be surprised. I guess I am leaning towards axe being right in saying you are wrong. You did so well in bonk, why mac? why?

Not saying it's outright scummy but this is a weird af post lol

[RondoDimBuckle]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

oh boy are you going to be surprised. I guess I am leaning towards axe being right in saying you are wrong. You did so well in bonk, why mac? why?

Not saying it's outright scummy but this is a weird af post lol

Thanks

[MacDougall]

1: Disredits Mac - If wolf this is TMI but your inno child post ruins any setup
6: discredit tutuu
7: meme post at tutuu
13:wolf callout - KZA
16:Sad smily at tutuu
20:callout forced posts between ender and 112 or calling out 112's posts as forced
22:vote 112 for meme post quoted
23:discredit made calling 112 town
24:discredit 112 - Also I dont know why 112 quoted me here?
26:meme post at epi - +Equity? [scotty/epi/tutuu]
27:discredit scotty in favour of made [Scotty vote made]
49:confirm meme vote on ender "itll be funny"
51:discredit scotty/asking for explination [First real post] - Scotty: calling KZA/Rondo one of wolf. KZA town Rondo Powerwolf
57:discredit scotty [Third real post] - unlinking top posters with town leaders
58:discredit scotty
60:discredit scotty [Fourth real post] - tells scotty to top linking top posters and leaders and to dunk on someone instead
69:meme post - calls sig wolf
70:discredit tutuu - calling mac town
71:meme post? - calls mac town
75:discredit tutuu - gth + town = same
76:discredit tutuu - novelty of town lists
79:meme post at tutuu for @ing everyone

Bolded are bits I'd really love to see you actually analyse and tell me how they make you feel.

But without looking at it, there appears to be a volume of genuine shade of Scotty and tutuu which probably makes them not t/w.

I'm particularly interested in you bringing to light the "discredit of made calling 112 town". I'd love to talk about that.

[MacDougall]

I really like that iso format, might steal it in the future

It'd be great if it had links to the posts lol.

ITS LITERALLY IN ORDER, JUST OPEN THE ISO AND READ

I wasn't trying to be critical. It just would be.

[MacDougall]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

oh boy are you going to be surprised. I guess I am leaning towards axe being right in saying you are wrong. You did so well in bonk, why mac? why?

Not saying it's outright scummy but this is a weird af post lol

What's particularly weird about it is that my reads on Bonk sucked ass and the only thing Rondo probably even remembers from that game is me giving them a PR in order to force the mafia to kill him.

[MacDougall]

I am like literally here trying to baby Rondo into looking like a town and he's reacting like I'm threatening to steal his toys.

[RondoDimBuckle]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

oh boy are you going to be surprised. I guess I am leaning towards axe being right in saying you are wrong. You did so well in bonk, why mac? why?

Not saying it's outright scummy but this is a weird af post lol

What's particularly weird about it is that my reads on Bonk sucked ass and the only thing Rondo probably even remembers from that game is me giving them a PR in order to force the mafia to kill him.

lol that was hilarious, wasnt even mad about it

[RondoDimBuckle]

I am like literally here trying to baby Rondo into looking like a town and he's reacting like I'm threatening to steal his toys.

Because in a way you are.

[MacDougall]

sig
tutuu
Rondo
made

all maf

oh boy are you going to be surprised. I guess I am leaning towards axe being right in saying you are wrong. You did so well in bonk, why mac? why?

Not saying it's outright scummy but this is a weird af post lol

What's particularly weird about it is that my reads on Bonk sucked ass and the only thing Rondo probably even remembers from that game is me giving them a PR in order to force the mafia to kill him.

lol that was hilarious, wasnt even mad about it

For the record I only did that because it was a playerlist that the town just wins if the mafia are never allowed to make optimal kills. It isn't always how I'd play that role.

[MacDougall]

I am like literally here trying to baby Rondo into looking like a town and he's reacting like I'm threatening to steal his toys.

Because in a way you are.

How?

[Ruri]

Kinda lazy to backread. Starting here.

Hi Ruri. Tell me a story you might tell a tired band of adventurers around the fire

@Ruri

Ah, I remember seeing that while backreading. Honestly, I don't know. Never told stories in my life.

Try

It’s like when people I talk to say they can’t sing.
They *can* sing, just probably not *well*.

A hungry begger was looking for food and stole some from the bakery. He was ran out of town and found a leprechaun and pot of gold, at the end of a big rainbow. After the leprechaun left, he snuck some gold out of that pot at the end of the rainbow, thinking he'd pay it back after he managed to get some bread. Over time, the man snuck more gold out and bought more things. One day, when the leprechaun was returning to check on his pot of gold, he chanced upon a well-dressed man and an empty pot. He was never heard from again.

The narrator closed his book, with some last words: "never steal from a leprechaun's pot of gold". A knock sounded at the door, to which the narrator barked "get back to work".

Excerpt from one of my stories.

Is this an allegory about Henry Ford’s origins?

You ain’t getting my vote today, well done.

It's an original!

A bit surprised you would ask me to tell you a story and then use it as a reason to not vote.. But it also seems like shallow reasoning that I doubt a wolf would use it.

Kingmaker me. I'll shoot Ruri in the face.

Then I'd probably shoot Wiggin.

Then If Wiggin's corpse has tattoos of little caterpillars on it I'd shoot Rondo in the hip and watch them bleed out.

Why?

i searched for some more stuff said by our host on the discord for clues for his game design preferences

he doesnt consider cult bastard, but difficult to balance

godfather being called bastard grinds his gears, so yall watch out for a godfather please

(and as previously mentioned i think he has put a neutal serial killer in)

sorry but imma ping u all so my conscience can relax, i dont want this biting us in the arse (addendum that he said there's no alignment changing so no cult. but im feeling it that he put a godfather in, i feel it in my bones im telling yall)

@Creature @Michelle @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME @NotAnAxehole @sig @MacDougall @falcon45ca @Urist @RondoDimBuckle @EnderWiggin @Master Radishes @Epignosis @DkKoba @Made @Syn @112 @Poison @Ruri @tedxtr @DrWilgy @Scotty @KZA @TonyStarkPrime

Noted.

I'm literally just here to say Mac that was a dumb move to make

NOBODY ELSE CLAIM

there is obviously some sort of soup role given what Jay said in the rules like seriously. We gonna have a repeat of last game where mafia soups everyone and wins.

It was worth it cuz of the meme tbh.

I mean, he says its for the memes but is there a world where a wolf has a role where he can fake claim inno child with a mod backup? :think: Its ballsy but I still think Mac is inno town till someone else has the same thought as me, this is tinfoil for day 3 or something

Okay so basically you had me as strong town anyway, I was being uber townread by everyone ... but now that the mod confirms it you tinfoil?

And people are townreading this dude?

Hmm.. Interesting. I didn't notice that slot, other than a lot of posts.

I would say Tutuu is probably mafia here also. Her reads don't feel genuine to me. I can't point at any single post as one that she can't make as mafia. She has a weird energy and tone.

Honestly, I felt differently. Though, I'm admittedly bad at reading tone.

[VOTE: Poison] aubergine

Had to copy format from another user. Also, I checked through Mac's ISO. Looks good TBH.

@Ruri you made this vote while talking about other things and didn't even talk about Poison at all either prior, during or afterwards. What caused this vote?

I voted Poison for asking me a question unrelated to this game. Didn't know how to vote yet, though it was in the polls. How to pull up vote counts BTW?

[MacDougall]

I wish there were more people around and posting right now.

[Ruri]

Mac is IC. Time to sheep.


[VOTE: Syn] aubergine

[MacDougall]

@ruri we don't have a modbot to track vote counts, it's just what is in the poll. Sometimes we get lucky and a tryhard town decides to try to track the postcounts manually.

As for Tutuu, keep in mind I've played a lot with Tutuu and seen her wolf. She's a very good player, and one of the best wolves in this community. For someone with no meta on her she'd always look like an easy townread.