Jack Attack Mafia (Day 5)

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I continue to feel great about the state of the game. I am comfortable with my civilian reads; indeed that is only becoming more true as Day 1 progresses.

My clear POE pool remains: ColinIsCool, DrWilgy, sprityo, Long Con, and Funnygurl555. I said earlier in the phase that my goal was a pool of seven, so I have room for two more on the tinfoil side. I’d look first to Alison and TonyStarkPrime for that “tier”.

Anyone who has severe misgivings about this arrangement (ideally beyond “I’m on the list, how dare you”) should speak up.

[Alison]

Do you ordinarily start developing tinfoil reads on Day 1?

[Alison]

My understanding is that tinfoils is a way to root out suspected deepwolves as endgame nears and the pool of people with high wolf equity have all been killed. So I'm not sure why you're already forming a list of players you want to tinfoil as early as today.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Do you ordinarily start developing tinfoil reads on Day 1?

I keep them in my back pocket for the sake of due diligence. I don’t tend to dwell on them though. Paranoia is not necessary until it is.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

“Tinfoil” is also a bit strong a term. Instead I could be more general: “players I view as civilians for whom I could make arguments to the contrary if I wanted to”

[Alison]

You said you aren't going to be around EoD. Do you intend to leave your vote on LC before EoD then?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

You said you aren't going to be around EoD. Do you intend to leave your vote on LC before EoD then?

I might be around. I’m not sure, it depends how my work goes.

Long Con is a player I’d chop. He’s not the only candidate. I’ll see how I feel when I have to place my final vote.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Kitsu knowing their role but not knowing it was called a miller is hugely town indicative

I don’t know if I can say why but it looks like people are already there

Yeah Kitsu is just spewed town many times over by this point. Not re-evaluating read until F3 short of a cop check.

Was this...

A joke?

no

I really do think Kitsu's posts have been incredibly townie in ways that are incredibly difficult to fake, especially for a player new to TS and still trying to get comfortable with the format and culture

I meant the cop check line

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Let me say this differently...if someone came in tomorrow and claimed a red check on kits, how would you react?

[Alison]

Kitsu knowing their role but not knowing it was called a miller is hugely town indicative

I don’t know if I can say why but it looks like people are already there

Yeah Kitsu is just spewed town many times over by this point. Not re-evaluating read until F3 short of a cop check.

Was this...

A joke?

no

I really do think Kitsu's posts have been incredibly townie in ways that are incredibly difficult to fake, especially for a player new to TS and still trying to get comfortable with the format and culture

I meant the cop check line

Oh no, it was just a way to emphasize how strongly I felt about Kitsu's alignment. I only realized later it made no sense because they're a claimed Miller. You can replace it with "mod-confirmed to be scum" or something along those lines.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Yeah ok, that’s what I was getting at

Was trying to figure out if it was a possible perspective issue or not lol

[ColinIsCool]

WOW 30 pages to catch up on good lord

[sabie12]

Thanks everyone! On my way! Colin welcome to the game good luck catching up

[ColinIsCool]

I don’t believe it’s W/W

Long Con comes from an older generation of mafia in this community. We come from the same mafia background. It’s my experience that he tends to protect teammates rather than call attention to them.

I think it’s either a genuine town rage or he’s a wolf who is overreacting about something that I don’t think many of us were thinking much about.

Does this post TMI Jay to be town or nah

[Alison]

I don’t believe it’s W/W

Long Con comes from an older generation of mafia in this community. We come from the same mafia background. It’s my experience that he tends to protect teammates rather than call attention to them.

I think it’s either a genuine town rage or he’s a wolf who is overreacting about something that I don’t think many of us were thinking much about.

Does this post TMI Jay to be town or nah

I don't really understand why this post could be interpreted as TMI

[ColinIsCool]

I don’t believe it’s W/W

Long Con comes from an older generation of mafia in this community. We come from the same mafia background. It’s my experience that he tends to protect teammates rather than call attention to them.

I think it’s either a genuine town rage or he’s a wolf who is overreacting about something that I don’t think many of us were thinking much about.

Does this post TMI Jay to be town or nah

I don't really understand why this post could be interpreted as TMI

Daisy says it’s not W/W but there’s just discussion of LC with no consideration that Jay could be wolf.

[ColinIsCool]

Btw I have about 7 pages left to catch up on, but .... I’m a miller

[ColinIsCool]

sprityo and wigly have still done nothing despite being here

idk why people are voting colin when he hasnt posted yet. its not really gonna do anything

Since I am town, I am giving +1 town credit to everyone who said they didn’t get a vote for me at this juncture — mafia would know I’m not on their team and should be happy to see a completely wasted lynch of a non-poster

[ColinIsCool]

Fwiw my colin vote is not a placeholder I genuinely want to kill him

At the same time, I think NANOOK is pretty townie in this game so far. Matches what I’ve come to view as his meta

[Millium]

I'll be around after like 3-4pm EST
[mention]ColinIsCool[/mention]
Glad to see you join the game, and starting off with talking about things that bother you

[Millium]

Somebody make a list of all the Miller's for me, please?

[ColinIsCool]

speaking of not cool, where's colin?

He signed up for this ages ago and it was delayed months. I doubt he even knows the game is active.

For the record if I am ever absent in the future at the start of a game and there are RYMers playing drop me a line over there, I forget to check this site if a game hasn’t started sometimes

[ColinIsCool]

Thanks everyone! On my way! Colin welcome to the game good luck catching up

Thanks sabie, best of luck today. I townread you, your progressions all feel genuine.

[ColinIsCool]

Town reads:

Alison - maybe my top townread, feels like the most solviest mindset and I find myself nodding a lot in agreement

JJJ - seems like a duh at this moment

Long Con - his conflict with JJJ feels towny to me, like he legitimately feels singled out or just doesn’t get the shade.

KitsuShel: angle shooty reasons

People who feel within a town meta for me include Tony, sabie, Wilgy, Epi, and NANOOK but I feel less confident about these minus the ones I mentioned earlier (sabie, NANOOK).

I found myself agreeing the most with the early funnygurl suspicions and that’s seemed to have died off a bit but it seems like the best way to go.

[VOTE: Funnygurl] aubergine

Pool: sprit, Spacedaisy,

[ColinIsCool]

* + everyone else I didn’t name in the pool

[Millium]

gunna catch up on all the posts while I was asleep, and then go do real life stuff for a bit

[Millium]

[mention]Alison[/mention]
what bad ideas am I pushing?
Tony being a wolf is minuscule lean because he decided to answer Jagged's game with answers other than good or bad, which I believe tends to come from wolves more than town. But it doesn't seem like anyone is gonna go there

[Millium]

ya I'm not ready to die on that Tony hill yet
Kitsu is obvious town because of AS reasons? Guess I'll just sheep that

[Millium]

today is the big day. I'm sure all will go okay wish me luck! I'll check in here and there and I'll be home by end of day

good luck Sabie

[Epignosis]

It'd be neat and swell and stuff if some folks could give me a quick ranking (least-to-most suspicious/worthy of chopping) of the four players <20 posts:

KitsuShel
sprityo
DrWilgy
ColinIsCool

Swap the last two names and there's my list.

[Long Con]

ya I'm not ready to die on that Tony hill yet
Kitsu is obvious town because of AS reasons? Guess I'll just sheep that

What's AS?

[Millium]

ya I'm not ready to die on that Tony hill yet
Kitsu is obvious town because of AS reasons? Guess I'll just sheep that

What's AS?

the reason is around, I don't like to use the term, but it already been explained
they didn't know what a miller was, but claimed afterward when they realized what it was, which makes their claim more believable? I also give that Kitsu is off doing their own thing with no care in the world

[Long Con]

ya I'm not ready to die on that Tony hill yet
Kitsu is obvious town because of AS reasons? Guess I'll just sheep that

What's AS?

the reason is around, I don't like to use the term, but it already been explained
they didn't know what a miller was, but claimed afterward when they realized what it was, which makes their claim more believable? I also give that Kitsu is off doing their own thing with no care in the world

I figured it out! Thanks.

[Long Con]

Fwiw my colin vote is not a placeholder I genuinely want to kill him

this isnt really optimal

if he doesnt post he’s getting subbed out so idc

I strongly disagree and am largely pro-killing lurkers, especially when I feel good about a towncore

how do you feel about LC?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

AS is angleshoot[y/ing], and it’s a Very Bad Word that only Extremely Naughty Players use

[Long Con]

AS is angleshoot[y/ing], and it’s a Very Bad Word that only Extremely Naughty Players use

Not sure if joking or if I am missing something.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

AS is angleshoot[y/ing], and it’s a Very Bad Word that only Extremely Naughty Players use

Not sure if joking or if I am missing something.

Mostly kind of a joke? Idk a lot of people have hang ups about/very strict definitions of what constitutes unfair angle shooting, so AS does stand for angle shooting AFAIK but I’m also poking fun at how uptight people can be sometimes

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It’s not that funny when you have to explain it!

[Millium]

It doesn't belong in the game honestly, I usually stick with [redacted] reasons if I decide to use stuff like that, or don't use it at all. It's hilarious because if used to call someone a wolf it has a negative connotation, but if you use it to call someone town, it's better?

[Spacedaisy]

I don’t believe it’s W/W

Long Con comes from an older generation of mafia in this community. We come from the same mafia background. It’s my experience that he tends to protect teammates rather than call attention to them.

I think it’s either a genuine town rage or he’s a wolf who is overreacting about something that I don’t think many of us were thinking much about.

Does this post TMI Jay to be town or nah

I don't really understand why this post could be interpreted as TMI

Daisy says it’s not W/W but there’s just discussion of LC with no consideration that Jay could be wolf.

I never said anything about Jay because I was only discussing the reason why I didn’t believe it was W/W. That reason was based upon LC’s behavior, not Jay’s. I wasn’t explaining guilt or innocence for either of them, just that I really didn’t believe they were both on the baddie team together.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean I don’t think it’s better or worse personally, YMMV

And yeah what constitutes unfair angleshooting is a matter of some contention. Some people consider talking about colin zero posting angleshooting, some draw the line at talking about someone subbing out, etc. etc.

I’m fairly liberal about it, not sure what site policy is

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Some people would consider “Epi never NKs someone on their first night in their first game on site” to be angleshooting! I wouldn’t, to be clear. It’s a word with an ambiguous definition.

[Spacedaisy]

I do at least like Colin coming in and playing immediately. I’m moving my placeholder to Wilgy for now.

[VOTE: DrWilgy] aubergine

[Long Con]

It’s not that funny when you have to explain it!

Sorry, since wisp used the acronym and seemed to not want to say the actual word, I didn't know if there was something wrong with the word, like how we are phasing out of the word Lynch.

I didn't understand the acronym until he explained it, then I realized what it meant.

[Long Con]

I mean I don’t think it’s better or worse personally, YMMV

And yeah what constitutes unfair angleshooting is a matter of some contention. Some people consider talking about colin zero posting angleshooting, some draw the line at talking about someone subbing out, etc. etc.

I’m fairly liberal about it, not sure what site policy is

IIRC, someone subbed in for a scum, and I was angle shooting that in my mind a great deal, and when it came time to decide if I suspected the person, I think I overcompensated to remove my angle shooting bias, and it bit me in the ass.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Honestly the kits read isn’t even that angelshooty, it’s just that they’re unlikely to have partners based on how their miller claim progressed

[ColinIsCool]

I’m not gonna put any effort into defending him cause I don’t feel strongly town at all, but Wilgy feels like a crapshoot lynch at this point.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I think there’s a group of 4 [colin/wilgy/LC/sprityo] that all have roughly similar odds of flipping mafia

Largely based on my confidence in my towncore meaning that group is correspondingly significantly >rand mafia

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

But sure we can start with wilgy instead

[Long Con]

I think we shouldn't lynch Wilgy. The reason is [redacted].