Persona 5 Mafia [Game End]

[Jackofhearts2005]

nutella and JJJ are like Tom Brady and Antonio Brown.

Overachieving teammates who work for the devil.

The turn around is awkward in its speed. But like I expect them to put on better wolf theatre than a fight that lasts about a page on day 0.

So disagree.

[Dragomir]

You're so full of shit. Getting a reaction like I'm giving you now is exactly the purpose you intended. Stop pretending that didn't exist or you wouldn't have made the post at all. You got what you wanted, now fucking do something with it. You laid a brick for a wall, we'll want a roof eventually.

Let me look you dead in the Internet eye:

I did not give a damn about "getting a reaction". I did get them though, so that's swell (and I am doing things with them too)! I was cracking up as I made that post, and cracking up was all I cared about.

You're bad and this is bad and I hate it. I am actually angry. That is anti-town bullshit.

This is a really bad post. You counter to him by just calling him bad and raging about the situation. It's like when someone loses an argument, knowing it, and just calls the other person stupid and raging off. No, this is exactly like that. I don't get a townie perspective for your action here.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I want to watch the debate but I’m rocking a crying child.

[Dragomir]

I’m not commenting on JJJ/Nutella because I hate day zero arguments around two people with little substance. Gut is both town.

I would not discredit all that they did as little substance.

[Dragomir]

Ah you grouped them as both suspecting Jay. Drago came to it independently though while jack just sheeped me.

That’s worse. Scum puts in more effort. Drago came in, said something someone else had said, came up with basically the same reasoning, and that was it. I wouldn’t call that coming to it independently

If scum puts in more effort and what you're describing my entrance is little to no effort then shouldn't it be inherently better instead of worse based on your own logic?

[Dragomir]

Dragomir is like Christian McCaffery. My favorite player right now. Doing work.

Are you gonna be pulling out NFL references all game? Cause if so, keep doing them

[Dragomir]

After reading Nutella's recent posts, I'd say that she looks much better than before, not enough to be in my town strong reads but she's definitely getting close.

Jack I'm really not liking nor am I liking TSP(man I hate this. I don't like scum reading players already scum read by others). [mention]Jackofhearts2005[/mention] if you're going to town read me, can you at least give a genuine, decent reason? Like c'mon man, I'm not getting the one that you gave. It doesn't feel AI at all nor is it strong enough to add up to how you presented your town read on me(which came off as a strong or solid one, if it was slight or weak, I'd feel much more better about your reason).

[TonyStarkPrime]

I’m not commenting on JJJ/Nutella because I hate day zero arguments around two people with little substance. Gut is both town.

I would not discredit all that they did as little substance.

Everyone else seems to have?
Anyone else wanna say that someone said something reasonable and or suspicious or are we just going to ignore it?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I want to watch the debate but I’m rocking a crying child.

I’m watching it for you it’s not good

[MacDougall]

I wanna know why @MacDougall scumread the host.

Because of of his reply to TSP's question about double voting, I read it in the context of a player having posted it initially and it was weird in that context.

[MacDougall]

Stepping away from the thread for a couple hours I can't deal with this rn. Hope the actual phase starts soon though

How the hell did we get here already?

[MacDougall]

I mean I was literally parodying myself in that ISO.

I want you to play the game the way you want to. In order for you to do that you have to be able to roll with the punches. You must surely by now be able to predict how people respond to you not being the Jay everyone expects? If you are able to, then you can react in ways that don't provoke them further.

[MacDougall]

Shit man, I get ya. Sorry. I'll try to step back and loosen up.

We good! I'm sorry I got you riled up.

This game is stupid and we love it anyway!

(not you speedchuck, the general entity of Mafia)

Ah, this is nicer.

[Dragomir]

I’m not commenting on JJJ/Nutella because I hate day zero arguments around two people with little substance. Gut is both town.

I would not discredit all that they did as little substance.

Everyone else seems to have?
Anyone else wanna say that someone said something reasonable and or suspicious or are we just going to ignore it?

Bro. Only 5 ppl have been around to witness it. You, me, Mac, Jack, and Epi. There's 11 players and I don't think it's little substance. I doubt Mac has had much time to give things a thorough read considering how sparingly here's players so pretty much only 3 players could be considered to think it's of little substance. You consider that to be everyone and thus you go with the majority to not engage in it?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I’m not commenting on JJJ/Nutella because I hate day zero arguments around two people with little substance. Gut is both town.

I would not discredit all that they did as little substance.

Everyone else seems to have?
Anyone else wanna say that someone said something reasonable and or suspicious or are we just going to ignore it?

Bro. Only 5 ppl have been around to witness it. You, me, Mac, Jack, and Epi. There's 11 players and I don't think it's little substance. I doubt Mac has had much time to give things a thorough read considering how sparingly here's players so pretty much only 3 players could be considered to think it's of little substance. You consider that to be everyone and thus you go with the majority to not engage in it?

Do you have anything to say about it

[nutella]

You can't just drop some jayish crap on d0 and expect to get credit for it. You have to actually care about the subsequent analysis and about actually finding scum. You don't.

>Nutella first says she didn't take it seriously
>Is taking Jay's posts very seriously in this post

Do you see the contradiction?

The gist is that I obvious didn't take it seriously as a case/iso post, but I believed he intended for it to generate reactions and start up some discussion

[Dragomir]

I’m not commenting on JJJ/Nutella because I hate day zero arguments around two people with little substance. Gut is both town.

I would not discredit all that they did as little substance.

Everyone else seems to have?
Anyone else wanna say that someone said something reasonable and or suspicious or are we just going to ignore it?

Bro. Only 5 ppl have been around to witness it. You, me, Mac, Jack, and Epi. There's 11 players and I don't think it's little substance. I doubt Mac has had much time to give things a thorough read considering how sparingly here's players so pretty much only 3 players could be considered to think it's of little substance. You consider that to be everyone and thus you go with the majority to not engage in it?

Do you have anything to say about it

I've already said plenty about it. Not the overall situation but specific posts that I didn't like.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I wanna know why @MacDougall scumread the host.

Because of of his reply to TSP's question about double voting, I read it in the context of a player having posted it initially and it was weird in that context.

I’m gonna townlean this. I don’t remember how Speed does things but generally townies get a role on and scum get a role pm and sometimes a separate wolfchat pm and then the host makes a discord or chatzy or whatever.

So scum should be more aware that Speed is the host than town.

I feel like

[Dragomir]

You can't just drop some jayish crap on d0 and expect to get credit for it. You have to actually care about the subsequent analysis and about actually finding scum. You don't.

>Nutella first says she didn't take it seriously
>Is taking Jay's posts very seriously in this post

Do you see the contradiction?

The gist is that I obvious didn't take it seriously as a case/iso post, but I believed he intended for it to generate reactions and start up some discussion

Like the content in the posts you just thought were jokes but the intent behind them was all serious and business right?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Lol when you start writing a post, read some bedtime stories and then start the post over without deleting the original start.

[Jackofhearts2005]

After reading Nutella's recent posts, I'd say that she looks much better than before, not enough to be in my town strong reads but she's definitely getting close.

Jack I'm really not liking nor am I liking TSP(man I hate this. I don't like scum reading players already scum read by others). Jackofhearts2005 if you're going to town read me, can you at least give a genuine, decent reason? Like c'mon man, I'm not getting the one that you gave. It doesn't feel AI at all nor is it strong enough to add up to how you presented your town read on me(which came off as a strong or solid one, if it was slight or weak, I'd feel much more better about your reason).

There’s tone in there too. It’s a day 0 read. It’s not that strong. I was just happy to have it.

[Creature]

Oh this thread gained steam

Should I add more steam?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I’m not commenting on JJJ/Nutella because I hate day zero arguments around two people with little substance. Gut is both town.

I would not discredit all that they did as little substance.

Everyone else seems to have?
Anyone else wanna say that someone said something reasonable and or suspicious or are we just going to ignore it?

Bro. Only 5 ppl have been around to witness it. You, me, Mac, Jack, and Epi. There's 11 players and I don't think it's little substance. I doubt Mac has had much time to give things a thorough read considering how sparingly here's players so pretty much only 3 players could be considered to think it's of little substance. You consider that to be everyone and thus you go with the majority to not engage in it?

Do you have anything to say about it

I've already said plenty about it. Not the overall situation but specific posts that I didn't like.

That’s fine. I just don’t want to spend 72 hours where we hash out a conflict that no one is invested in
(Now at this point it’s clear that’s not going to happen)

[Dragomir]

I wanna know why @MacDougall scumread the host.

Because of of his reply to TSP's question about double voting, I read it in the context of a player having posted it initially and it was weird in that context.

I’m gonna townlean this. I don’t remember how Speed does things but generally townies get a role on and scum get a role pm and sometimes a separate wolfchat pm and then the host makes a discord or chatzy or whatever.

So scum should be more aware that Speed is the host than town.

I feel like

I don't think the difference between them is big enough for something that Mac did with the scum read would be AI.

[Creature]

I'm very glad we have a game running. Let's ensure it's an active one, yes? Let's wake up the slumbering Syndicate community, yes? Let's not allow the mafia to do whatever they want without any actual resistance in the thread, yes?

Yes, yes?

Nice to see you're excited

[TonyStarkPrime]

Ah you grouped them as both suspecting Jay. Drago came to it independently though while jack just sheeped me.

That’s worse. Scum puts in more effort. Drago came in, said something someone else had said, came up with basically the same reasoning, and that was it. I wouldn’t call that coming to it independently

If scum puts in more effort and what you're describing my entrance is little to no effort then shouldn't it be inherently better instead of worse based on your own logic?

maybe

[Creature]

This post right here sure is suspicious, isn't it! Someone ought to accuse me of being a mafioso for having made this extremely suspicious post!

Okay, that's enough for me

[Creature]

Jack is bad for making a post

okay seems reasonable vote:Jack

???

[Creature]

Hold on am I voting twice in the poll?

This is town or I am being overconfident

[Creature]

Jay is making up complete bullshit to mimic his civilian meta. Wolf

(Actually I think he's just trying to kick start the thread but it's super cringey and doesn't make him town)

Super cringey entrances are fun though

[Creature]

Let me guess:

Voting phase will take forever to start and when it does I'll have to pull something I know is completely bullshit to justify my vote when there's absolutely no need to.

If this weren’t Creature it’d seem like scum preemptively making excuses, but this is a legitimate form of complaint I think from our resident complainer and scum wouldn’t be quite so quick on the excuse? Lean town?

"If this weren't Creature it'd seem like scum preemptively making excuses"

Uh? You can change my name to any player and it remains the same. It's not AI anyway.

[Creature]

Also I liked the totodile but the new icon is cool too.

Totodile had to go, it made me feel pessimistic for some reason.

[Creature]

Mac and creature can be my towncore

Calling me town is easy, I want to see if you can stand up for me.

[Creature]

I am busy today though.

I'll check this later.

What the hell kinda pokemon is that?

Pikachu?

[Dragomir]

Ah you grouped them as both suspecting Jay. Drago came to it independently though while jack just sheeped me.

That’s worse. Scum puts in more effort. Drago came in, said something someone else had said, came up with basically the same reasoning, and that was it. I wouldn’t call that coming to it independently

If scum puts in more effort and what you're describing my entrance is little to no effort then shouldn't it be inherently better instead of worse based on your own logic?

maybe

Give me something concrete.

[Creature]

Nutella why did you make that towncore post?

Cause I got some warm fuzzy feelins

:/

[Creature]

You're so full of shit. Getting a reaction like I'm giving you now is exactly the purpose you intended. Stop pretending that didn't exist or you wouldn't have made the post at all. You got what you wanted, now fucking do something with it. You laid a brick for a wall, we'll want a roof eventually.

Let me look you dead in the Internet eye:

I did not give a damn about "getting a reaction". I did get them though, so that's swell (and I am doing things with them too)! I was cracking up as I made that post, and cracking up was all I cared about.

You're bad and this is bad and I hate it. I am actually angry. That is anti-town bullshit.

So he must be town?

[Creature]

TSP, Sprityo and Speedchuck are Mafia.

There’s a problem here

Conductor, we have a problem.

[Rej]

Wow sorry guys I totally missed the start of this game, I will catch up soon I promise. I will just go sleep now... count me in to fully play then!

[Creature]

Stepping away from the thread for a couple hours I can't deal with this rn. Hope the actual phase starts soon though

Hopefully we can get crazy when D1 starts rather than just go "I think X is scum because blah blah blah and blah blah blah blah blah"

[MacDougall]

Or maybe it was deliberate bait, but I don't think so. Either way it was an easy thing to jump on and they both bit.

Yup I figure accidental bait.

Definitely was accidental

[Creature]

Okay, I can see TSP scum

[MacDougall]

nutella and JJJ are like Tom Brady and Antonio Brown.

Overachieving teammates who work for the devil.

Way to disrupt

[MacDougall]

You're so full of shit. Getting a reaction like I'm giving you now is exactly the purpose you intended. Stop pretending that didn't exist or you wouldn't have made the post at all. You got what you wanted, now fucking do something with it. You laid a brick for a wall, we'll want a roof eventually.

Let me look you dead in the Internet eye:

I did not give a damn about "getting a reaction". I did get them though, so that's swell (and I am doing things with them too)! I was cracking up as I made that post, and cracking up was all I cared about.

You're bad and this is bad and I hate it. I am actually angry. That is anti-town bullshit.

This is a really bad post. You counter to him by just calling him bad and raging about the situation. It's like when someone loses an argument, knowing it, and just calls the other person stupid and raging off. No, this is exactly like that. I don't get a townie perspective for your action here.

I feel the opposite. Nutella cracking up is usually a civ tell.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Jack is bad for making a post

okay seems reasonable vote:Jack

???

i a m j o k i n g

[MacDougall]

You better hold on, life won’t change

Emoji tell. Works every fucking time. Please let me test it.

[TonyStarkPrime]

Ah you grouped them as both suspecting Jay. Drago came to it independently though while jack just sheeped me.

That’s worse. Scum puts in more effort. Drago came in, said something someone else had said, came up with basically the same reasoning, and that was it. I wouldn’t call that coming to it independently

If scum puts in more effort and what you're describing my entrance is little to no effort then shouldn't it be inherently better instead of worse based on your own logic?

maybe

Give me something concrete.

in context you were being compared to Jack. Out of context I have no clue if you did a scum amount of work or not.

[Creature]

Dragomir

Creature
MacDougall

Long Con
Rej

nutella
sprityo
Epignosis

Jackofhearts2005
TonyStarkPrime

I assume Long Con and Rej are the null point?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Let me guess:

Voting phase will take forever to start and when it does I'll have to pull something I know is completely bullshit to justify my vote when there's absolutely no need to.

If this weren’t Creature it’d seem like scum preemptively making excuses, but this is a legitimate form of complaint I think from our resident complainer and scum wouldn’t be quite so quick on the excuse? Lean town?

"If this weren't Creature it'd seem like scum preemptively making excuses"

Uh? You can change my name to any player and it remains the same. It's not AI anyway.

I disagree

[Creature]

Lol convenient.

What is convenient?

That your readlist is exactly Nutella’s.

So is mine on top 2 and bottom 2