The Syndicate

insertnamehere wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:Killing animals is wrong unless we eat them.

Can I get a Vompatti translator over here?

So, you disagree with the plan? Do you have a reason why?

You have no proof that MP or anyone else claiming to be an animal is an animal. Ergo the plan is flawed!

So if we don't kill an animal, then we kill a liar.

Both are edible.

How am I lying? I could see how I could be called stupid, or even wrong, but how am I lying?

I wasn't talking about you mate, I was talking about the person we lynch, specifically MP.

Metalmarsh89 wrote: This would make for a good Talking Heads cover graphic.

It totally would!

No one has an incentive to lie, though.

Like I said, assuming every player wants to win, the plan makes the most sense.

MovingPictures07 wrote:No one has an incentive to lie, though.

Like I said, assuming every player wants to win, the plan makes the most sense.

It sure does. It is clearly a quite popular and accessible strategy.

But unfortunately, I just don't feel like doing things the mainstream way. Brian Eno wouldn't want this.

Mongoose wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Mongoose wrote:I mean a win is a win, but it doesn't feel as good as you win on a technicality. And I'd be as sad as a bison if it happened in my game.

BUT for Day 1, this is as good a place as any to start.

What?

What's wrong with it?

If anything, it's completely in the spirit of the game, and I'm certain it's a scenario Llama considered.

It's certainly an oblique strategy!

THIS.

To everyone not wanting to use this strategy, because it would be "ruining Llama's game", you need to step back and read the rules. He clearly wrote the roles and rules around the idea that everyone could win if they were honest and put faith in other people.

THE POINT OF THIS GAME IS TO SEE IF WE CAN ALL UNITE AND TRUST EACH OTHER.

I think it's quite genius. It turns the conventions of mafia based on distrust and deceit on it's head.

Can we as a group, as a community unite so that everyone can win? Or will our selfishness and distrust turn us to sabotage and ruin?

This game is surprisingly philosophical in a way that I've never seen before in a mafia game.

This is a dynamite fucking idea as far as games go, and I wished I would have thought of it first.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:No one has an incentive to lie, though.

Like I said, assuming every player wants to win, the plan makes the most sense.

It sure does. It is clearly a quite popular and accessible strategy.

But unfortunately, I just don't feel like doing things the mainstream way. Brian Eno wouldn't want this.

But it's anything but the mainstream way.

The mainstream way would be to play this game as mafia games are typically played.

We're doing Brian Eno justice if we can actually accomplish this win in an unconventional, non-musician-esque fashion.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:No one has an incentive to lie, though.

Like I said, assuming every player wants to win, the plan makes the most sense.

It sure does. It is clearly a quite popular and accessible strategy.

But unfortunately, I just don't feel like doing things the mainstream way. Brian Eno wouldn't want this.

Mafia. A game based around people being self-serving and distrustful, and eliminating others in order to win.

Oblique Strategies - an Eno Mafia. A game where everyone can win if they completely set aside all familiar notions of how to play mafia. A game where everyone can win if they just trust other people.

This is the most anti-status quo game I've ever played, and is probably one of my favorite concepts for mafia ever.

insertnamehere wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:No one has an incentive to lie, though.

Like I said, assuming every player wants to win, the plan makes the most sense.

It sure does. It is clearly a quite popular and accessible strategy.

But unfortunately, I just don't feel like doing things the mainstream way. Brian Eno wouldn't want this.

Mafia. A game based around people being self-serving and distrustful, and eliminating others in order to win.

Oblique Strategies - an Eno Mafia. A game where everyone can win if they completely set aside all familiar notions of how to play mafia. A game where everyone can win if they just trust other people.

This is the most anti-status quo game I've ever played, and is probably one of my favorite concepts for mafia ever.

Would this still be your favorite if everyone agreed with you and followed through?

To emphasize an important point, MP offering himself for lynch means that he only has a chance of achieving win conditions if he is an animal. So there is literally no reason for him to sacrifice himself if he is not an animal, ergo I think it's safe to assume MP is an animal. (well maybe if he got bored of the game only 1 day in and wants out...)

Also I'm not going to be home from work in time for the poll tomorrow so I'm going to go ahead and vote MP now

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:No one has an incentive to lie, though.

Like I said, assuming every player wants to win, the plan makes the most sense.

It sure does. It is clearly a quite popular and accessible strategy.

But unfortunately, I just don't feel like doing things the mainstream way. Brian Eno wouldn't want this.

Mafia. A game based around people being self-serving and distrustful, and eliminating others in order to win.

Oblique Strategies - an Eno Mafia. A game where everyone can win if they completely set aside all familiar notions of how to play mafia. A game where everyone can win if they just trust other people.

This is the most anti-status quo game I've ever played, and is probably one of my favorite concepts for mafia ever.

Would this still be your favorite if everyone agreed with you and followed through?

Yes.

Has anyone ever seen that movie "The Box"? It's not that great, but it had some ideas that I found really interesting. In the movie, a couple is sent a box with a big red button. If they press the button, they receive one million dollars, but someone that they don't know dies. It turns out *SPOILERS* that the box is sent by omniscient force to see if humanity is worth saving. If a certain amount of people push the button after 24 hours, then the "force" will declare humanity as "hopeless" and destroy the world.

That's what this game reminds me of. If we as a group, as a community can trust each other and put our faith in each other, and still win the game, I'd consider it not only another banner for my signature, but as a philosophical win.

Just this once, optimism can beat out cynicism, and everyone wins.

insertnamehere wrote:Just this once, optimism can beat out cynicism, and everyone wins.

I've chosen the path of cynic this game. Forgive me.

DAMN IT JACK, I'M JUST DOING WHAT THE ISLAND DEMANDS!

Personally, I feel there's no inherent reason to be a cynic this game given the circumstances, so why be cynical until given a reason to do so?

insertnamehere wrote:DAMN IT JACK, I'M JUST DOING WHAT THE ISLAND DEMANDS!

it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I voted for MP, I like that everyone is trying a cooperative win.

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

you'd argue wrong [stern smile]

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

you'd argue wrong [stern smile]

Well, maybe you're wrong, you cheeky little shit.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Personally, I feel there's no inherent reason to be a cynic this game given the circumstances, so why be cynical until given a reason to do so?

I'm not gonna stand around and wait for this reason to show up. I'm grabbing this bull by the horns.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Personally, I feel there's no inherent reason to be a cynic this game given the circumstances, so why be cynical until given a reason to do so?

I'm not gonna stand around and wait for this reason to show up. I'm grabbing this bull by the horns.

I'm an ordinary man, Metalmarsh, meat and potatoes, I live in the real world. I'm not a big believer in magic. But this game is different. It's special. The others don't want to talk about it because it scares them. But we all know it. We all feel it. Is this dream of harmony impossible? Probably. But what if everything that happened here, happened for a reason? What if we can all win? Even if it is impossible, let's say it's not… I don't know. But I've looked into the eyes of Llama. And what I saw was beautiful.

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

you'd argue wrong [stern smile]

Well, maybe you're wrong, you cheeky little shit.

that's a bit harsh k

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

you'd argue wrong [stern smile]

Well, maybe you're wrong, you cheeky little shit.

that's a bit harsh k

YOU'RE A BIT HARSH, K?

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

you'd argue wrong [stern smile]

Well, maybe you're wrong, you cheeky little shit.

that's a bit harsh k

YOU'RE A BIT HARSH, K?

that's what she said

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:

insertnamehere wrote:

Vompatti wrote:it's not ture victory unless someone loses

I'd argue that it's not a true victory unless everyone wins.

you'd argue wrong [stern smile]

Well, maybe you're wrong, you cheeky little shit.

that's a bit harsh k

YOU'RE A BIT HARSH, K?

that's what she said

STOP PEERING INTO MY LIFE, YOU DEMON WOMBAT!

insertnamehere wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Personally, I feel there's no inherent reason to be a cynic this game given the circumstances, so why be cynical until given a reason to do so?

I'm not gonna stand around and wait for this reason to show up. I'm grabbing this bull by the horns.

I'm an ordinary man, Metalmarsh, meat and potatoes, I live in the real world. I'm not a big believer in magic. But this game is different. It's special. The others don't want to talk about it because it scares them. But we all know it. We all feel it. Is this dream of harmony impossible? Probably. But what if everything that happened here, happened for a reason? What if we can all win? Even if it is impossible, let's say it's not… I don't know. But I've looked into the eyes of Llama. And what I saw was beautiful.

And he spit in your face. That is what llamas do.

Let us not forget that regardless of my intentions, there is a 33% chance that I am the exact player you need lynched. Or more accurately 29% if we assume that MP is an animal.


And again, this beautiful llama you see in your dreams is not a reality. Read the Day 1 post. Your strategy is in big trouble if a player or two are modkilled.

I woudln't mind seeeing a beauutiful lllamaa in my dreamms if yijknknnkonkwmehwahtI mean

I think as long as we all post and don't become obnoxious there would be no need for Llama to modkill everyone. I believe we can do this!

I see no reason to not attempt this.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

And again, this beautiful llama you see in your dreams is not a reality. Read the Day 1 post. Your strategy is in big trouble if a player or two are modkilled.

Unless he's a fella

Voted.
No need to post again until the night poll see you then.

I'm here I'm here don't modkill me! I still have no internet ugh. I read through all five pages of dialogue. I guess this whole everyone wins thing would be nice since I've been doing pretty horrible in mafia lately. I will vote for MP.

Voted MP

Down with those that didn't.

S~V~S wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

And again, this beautiful llama you see in your dreams is not a reality. Read the Day 1 post. Your strategy is in big trouble if a player or two are modkilled.

Unless he's a fella

But if six animals and one fella die, the poor animals lose.

That's not a risk I'm willing to take. The Animal Sanctuary Squad should agree with this.

Snow Dog wrote:Voted MP

Down with those that didn't.

That was the blue pill mate.

I definitely want to see if we can pull off what would be one of the great games of mafia - everyone wins. I don't understand why there are people who don't want to at least try to make this philosophy work. Hopefully they are not the ones with night kills. I'm voting MP because I support the idea we can all trust each other and all come out on the winning side.

votes MP

ps MP I havent had any problems the last two days with not being able to post

I don't blame anyone fro deviating from the plan. I voted with the group, because let's try it, and there's rarely a better plan this early on anyway. My skepticism remains, but I'd rather leave that door open just in case.
I had been such a Nervous Horse about my hearings for over a week, but I had them this morning and they went swimmingly.

Yesterday I feel into a full bathtub with all my clothes on, so what a difference a day makes.

I'm not blaming anyone, I'm just expressing my lack of understanding for why anyone wouldn't want to at least try this. There could be very good reasons, I just don't know what they are. I would be happy if I could understand. Anyway, since I have bought into this plan if it works with this first try I won't be voting for anyone who doesn't say they're an animal so it's not like I would vote for someone who would disagree with the plan.

Gahhh FINALLY work computer is so very very bad...

I'm voting MP. I'm giving this strategy a shot.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

And again, this beautiful llama you see in your dreams is not a reality. Read the Day 1 post. Your strategy is in big trouble if a player or two are modkilled.

Unless he's a fella

But if six animals and one fella die, the poor animals lose.

That's not a risk I'm willing to take. The Animal Sanctuary Squad should agree with this.

Sometimes I think you and I speak different languages; you always seem to misconstrue my meaning (and I know I have done so with you, as well).

What I meant here was that if INH is a fella, he won't care if the plan fails. If it works, yay, we all win. If it doesn't, yet for the fellas, some animals are dead. Volunteering for the slaughter, yet. So if he is a fella, he would not care if his strategy works or not.

Who will hang by the neck until dead (over Fire Island)?

Poll ended at Mon Dec 08, 2014 6:42:41 pm

insertnamehere
1
Vompatti (8)
6%

Boogs
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
14
insertnamehere (2), S~V~S (3), Mongoose (4), MovingPictures07 (5), Bass_the_Clever (6), triceratopzeuhl (9), Black Rock (10), DFaraday (11), Dom (12), Roxy (13), Snow Dog (14), sabie12 (15), juliets (16), nijuukyugou (17)
82%

Dominus
0
No votes

Black Rock
0
No votes

sabie12
0
No votes

Metalmarsh89
1
Metalmarsh89 (7)
6%

S~V~S
0
No votes

Ninja Blooper
0
No votes

Mongoose
0
No votes

A Person
0
No votes

Vompatti
0
No votes

Roxy
0
No votes

Bass Something Something Clever
0
No votes

DFaraday
0
No votes

Snow Dog
0
No votes

Juliets
0
No votes

triceratopzeuhl
0
No votes

David Byrne (Host/Mod/Dead/NP)
1
thellama73 (1)
6%


Total votes : 17

S~V~S wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

And again, this beautiful llama you see in your dreams is not a reality. Read the Day 1 post. Your strategy is in big trouble if a player or two are modkilled.

Unless he's a fella

But if six animals and one fella die, the poor animals lose.

That's not a risk I'm willing to take. The Animal Sanctuary Squad should agree with this.

Sometimes I think you and I speak different languages; you always seem to misconstrue my meaning (and I know I have done so with you, as well).

What I meant here was that if INH is a fella, he won't care if the plan fails. If it works, yay, we all win. If it doesn't, yet for the fellas, some animals are dead. Volunteering for the slaughter, yet. So if he is a fella, he would not care if his strategy works or not.

We are indeed very good at that.

Your post in response to the quote you included sounded like you were talking about the inactive players. I didn't realize you were talking about INH.

And so it was that MovingPictures07 nobly offered himself up for the good of the group. Offering nary a movement of resistance, he allowed his body to be hoisted up and hurled downward towards the rocky coast of Fire Island. No one could bear to look as his body broke on the stones below.

“It’s wrong to kill animals unless you eat them,” tutted Vompatti, shaking his head sadly.

“This is depressing,” said MetalMarsh89. “Let’s go somewhere else.”

MovingPictures07 has been lynched. He was Sombre Reptiles.
It is now Night 1. You have 24 hours to send in your Night Actions, and to decide where to go next.

Go Animals! And everyone else!

OK, I think that "winning" by not sending in night actions and volunteering to be lynched is not really *winning*, or even playing, tbh. If i wanted to trust y'all, I would not be playing Mafia.

So I am gonna say I am an animal, and volunteer to be the next sacrifice.

I just realized how that sounds, I am not just saying i am an animal to say it, I really AM an animal

S~V~S wrote:OK, I think that "winning" by not sending in night actions and volunteering to be lynched is not really *winning*, or even playing, tbh. If i wanted to trust y'all, I would not be playing Mafia.

So I am gonna say I am an animal, and volunteer to be the next sacrifice.

Well done SVS. This game is very refreshing. I like it.

linki. Of course!

S~V~S wrote:OK, I think that "winning" by not sending in night actions and volunteering to be lynched is not really *winning*, or even playing, tbh. If i wanted to trust y'all, I would not be playing Mafia.

So I am gonna say I am an animal, and volunteer to be the next sacrifice.

I'm using my night action tonight because I have one.

RIP sockface. You brought this upon yourself.

I picked Tiger Mountains.

For the animals.

Speaking of Animal Sanctuary Squad -- where the heck are you? Is it just me? And Vomps, who has been extra hilarious this game, btw.