[END] Harry Potter Mafia

[Operator]

Let's compromise and go to 72 hour days.

[Celeste]

I'd personally prefer 48 hour days but i guess i'm ok with whatever.

72 hours would be great too, can we do that?

[Lizzy]

A big thank you to all who sent us some brilliant ideas regarding the use of the Polyjuice Potion. It got down to two, and unfortunately for the other person, to a coin flip which eventually decided our winner.

If it's all right with you, I'd like to post some of these when the game ends. They're pure gold!

[Lizzy]

Night 9: The Chamber of Secrets

‘THE CHAMBER OF SECRETS HAS BEEN OPENED. ENEMIES OF THE HEIR, BEWARE.’ ‘What the hell is that supposed to mean?’ asked Märet staring at the foot-high words that had been daubed on the wall between two windows, shimmering in the light cast by the flaming torches.

‘I haven’t the foggiest, and something tells me I’d not like to have the foggiest either. See… that’s blood. Thank you, good morning!’ said Malin turning away from the wall and looking for a place where she could throw up in peace. But as she turned, the armour that was right in front of her disintegrated into fine slivery dust.

‘WHO DID THAT? Did you see that? Someone tried to blow me to smithereens!’ cried Malin, but everyone seemed too busy examining the writing to pay any kind of attention to her.

‘I’ll get to the bottom of this!’ Märet told herself as the Professors and Prefects started to escort the crowd to their bedrooms. When they got to a corridor packed with statues and armours on both sides, she quietly sneaked behind a statue of an old witch and waited until the coast was clear.

‘The library has to have something on this. The Chamber of Secrets… Maybe there is some sort of weapon there we could use to defend ourselves’ thought Märet as she was making her way through the narrow corridors leading to the library. As she was getting closer, she heard whispers which sounded remarkably close to hissing sounds, and when she finally got turned around a corner, the scenery that greeted her left her speechless and breathless. A familiar face was standing next to what seemed like a gigantic serpent, hissing softly in its years.

‘Ah, Märet! I didn’t think anyone would be so unbelievably foolish to walk around the castle like this. Oh well! I’ve heard stupidity can be lethal. Should we test that?’ said the cold voice and started to hiss in the beast’s ear again.

With fantastic agility, despite its impressive size, the basilisk jumped at Märet’s arm almost tearing it apart. She dropped on her knees, feeling an excruciating pain, while she slowly got drowsier and drowsier and her vision turned blurry. Several minutes later, she was lying dead on a deserted corridor in the vicinity of the library.

Malin Matsdotter has survived a kill attempt with the mysterious disintegrating curse.

Märet Jonsdotter has been killed by Voldemort and the Death Eaters.

It is now Day 10. You have 48 hours to lynch someone.

Also, let us know what you think of 24-hour day periods.

[Young Lady]

*pops head into Day 10*

Vote Jennet! Jennet's bad! Vote Jennet!



But seriously...RIP Malin. So...who are we looking at today? Any suggestions?

[Young Lady]

Haha...oops....RIP Maret.

[A Person]

The Day 7 post has been updated.

[Jack Shephard]

*pops head into Day 10*

Vote Jennet! Jennet's bad! Vote Jennet!



But seriously...RIP Malin. So...who are we looking at today? Any suggestions?

[Celeste]

rip maret

[Spooky Ghost]

[Spooky Ghost]

Can't say I'm surprised. I always get killed right about now

[Operator]

Malin Matsdotter has survived a kill attempt with the mysterious disintegrating curse.

Märet Jonsdotter has been killed by Voldemort and the Death Eaters.

You'll have to try harder than thta, baddies. :P

And RIP Maret, I was pretty sure you were good.

[Chuck]

Malin Matsdotter has survived a kill attempt with the mysterious disintegrating curse.

Märet Jonsdotter has been killed by Voldemort and the Death Eaters.

You'll have to try harder than thta, baddies. :P

And RIP Maret, I was pretty sure you were good.

Did I miss the part where it says the baddies targeted you?

[Operator]

Malin Matsdotter has survived a kill attempt with the mysterious disintegrating curse.

Märet Jonsdotter has been killed by Voldemort and the Death Eaters.

You'll have to try harder than thta, baddies. :P

And RIP Maret, I was pretty sure you were good.

Did I miss the part where it says the baddies targeted you?

Girl, you'd miss the broad side of a barn. Snap!

[Chuck]

So that'd be a no then.

Vote Malin

[Operator]

So that'd be a no then.

Vote Malin

Yeah, let's all vote early again. That worked out well last time.

[Phoebe Buffay]

Copy. . I have a feeling. It is not wrong. I do not agree that there should be a mind of winter, trying to get out, but from the first moment. In the same way that I think and that was the basis to display in Linz. (I)"

[Celeste]

i have no idea what you just said, jane

It does say in the post that malin was targeted for death, it doesn't say she was targeted by baddies though.

I don't think Malin is part of the Mafia.

[Ben Linus]

I won't be active much at all today. I came down with a fever yesterday, and am feeling pretty rugged. I would also prefer to keep the 48 hour days please mods.

I plan on voting Karin again today, but I'll wait 'til the end of the day to keep you witches somewhat happy.

[Gunther]

RIP Anne W - I'm sorry I was wrong about you.

i have no idea what you just said, jane

It does say in the post that malin was targeted for death, it doesn't say she was targeted by baddies though.

I don't think Malin is part of the Mafia.

I tend to agree with you, but out of curiosity - why do you think Malin isn't mafia?

[Gunther]

I feel like I'm completely lost this game and it's making me more than a little crankypants.

I'm going to steal this idea from Alizon to help me try to get my thoughts in order. I'll try to post some comments too as to why I'm thinking the way I'm thinking.

Color the ones you think should be lynched with red the ones you're nervous about with yellow and those who are good with green. Not sure? Leave it alone.

Alizon Device- I've caught her hints and I believe them. Also - when I stopped being narrow sighted and listened to her, she made a lot of sense.
Sarah Good - I don't have any real read on her at all and this late in the game that's what's making me nervous. I can't say she's bad, can't say she's good.
Katharina Henot She's definately good. She has made some bad judgment calls this game, but so have we all. Also she survived a Death Eater Attack.
Märet Jonsdotter Yellow-green here. I'm leaning toward good because she also survived a Death Eater kill also I have on and off agreed with her.
Malin Matsdotter Green-Yellow - I agree with her more than I don't.
Alice Nutter Yellow-green - also survived a Death Eater attempt, but I don't remember much of what she has had to say and that makes me wary.
Anne Redferne I know at one point in the beginning of the game I thought she was good, but now I'm not sure. Can't place my finger on why I can't move her solidly to the green category but I can't.
Jane Southworth I've agreed with her pretty much all game. She and Jennet were the two people I've felt most strongly to be civ since the beginning of the game.
Karin Svensdotter Green-yellow. I found the timing of people coming out for her odd. And not just because it was the rezzed players that started the ball rolling. I suspected her for days and days and days I even VOTED FOR HER and nobody gave it a second glance *including Karin*. She comes back, starts being more active, I start thinking hey - she might have just really been busy at the start of the game, and *bam* like all of a sudden she's public enemy number 1. That by itself has me leaning more toward green. But she can be being trickstery - I can't also ignore the fact that maybe Jennet is right even though I think it's highly unlikely.

So - see my dilemma here? Lots of yellow. Not enough green and red.

[Celeste]

RIP Anne W - I'm sorry I was wrong about you.

i have no idea what you just said, jane

It does say in the post that malin was targeted for death, it doesn't say she was targeted by baddies though.

I don't think Malin is part of the Mafia.

I tend to agree with you, but out of curiosity - why do you think Malin isn't mafia?

i guess mainly cus i believe she's something other than mafia

[Celeste]

it doesn't make sense for all the survivals and stuff between her and alizon to have been baddie related which is why i think there's something else going on there

[Operator]

I think in light of the last lynch, we need to reevaluate our suspicions a bit. Today I am going to take a look at Jane (even though she is insanified) since I have previously pretty much ignored her. I'm not saying I suspect her, just that I haven't given her a thorough look. I still suspect Sarah and Alice pretty hard for their continued refusal to participate, but I'm going to throw out some of my old prejudices today and try to see things with fresh eyes.

I find it interesting that Jennett implied she would be gone, and yet she is not.

[Young Lady]

Malin Matsdotter has survived a kill attempt with the mysterious disintegrating curse.

Märet Jonsdotter has been killed by Voldemort and the Death Eaters.

You'll have to try harder than thta, baddies. :P

And RIP Maret, I was pretty sure you were good.

Did I miss the part where it says the baddies targeted you?

Girl, you'd miss the broad side of a barn. Snap!

So that'd be a no then.

I'm afraid these comments make me have an eye on you. You just seem too snarky for a civ who hasn't participated much.

[Young Lady]

Well..that was quick. I challenge you all to go back and read Sarah Good. I promise, it won't take but a minute

She has contributed nothing. The only Good she has done in the game is vote for Mary which is what she claims proves her civviness. So let me give you a run down of her two votes for Mary.

Her first vote for Mary was Day 1 - She gave the second vote on Mary. All baddies do a little distancing, wouldn't you agree?

Her second vote for Mary was Day 5 - She was the 19th voter overall and voted 12th (LAST) for Mary.



What do you have to say for this Sarah?

[Chuck]

Well..that was quick. I challenge you all to go back and read Sarah Good. I promise, it won't take but a minute

She has contributed nothing. The only Good she has done in the game is vote for Mary which is what she claims proves her civviness. So let me give you a run down of her two votes for Mary.

Her first vote for Mary was Day 1 - She gave the second vote on Mary. All baddies do a little distancing, wouldn't you agree?

Her second vote for Mary was Day 5 - She was the 19th voter overall and voted 12th (LAST) for Mary.



What do you have to say for this Sarah?

Go ahead and vote for the player that sniffed out Mary from Day 1 and see how far that takes you.

[Chuck]

Malin Matsdotter has survived a kill attempt with the mysterious disintegrating curse.

Märet Jonsdotter has been killed by Voldemort and the Death Eaters.

You'll have to try harder than thta, baddies. :P

And RIP Maret, I was pretty sure you were good.

Did I miss the part where it says the baddies targeted you?

Girl, you'd miss the broad side of a barn. Snap!

So that'd be a no then.

I'm afraid these comments make me have an eye on you. You just seem too snarky for a civ who hasn't participated much.

Not being snarky. Malin was trying to be all sly and clear herself as a civ by saying "Oh nice try baddies." When the post clearly says the mafia targeted someone else, and Malin survived a curse from an unknown source.

[Young Lady]

Even though you did sound snarky to me, I hear what you're saying about Malin commenting about the baddies. To be technical however, the Mafia could have killed Maret AND cursed Malin, am I correct? I mean, they (as a team) have more than just the kill, right? Then again, a civ role could have a curse too I am sure. I guess I'm just saying that we don't know for sure where the curse came from.

And, I still don't think your voting record for Mary clears you of being a baddie.

[Chuck]

Even though you did sound snarky to me, I hear what you're saying about Malin commenting about the baddies. To be technical however, the Mafia could have killed Maret AND cursed Malin, am I correct? I mean, they (as a team) have more than just the kill, right? Then again, a civ role could have a curse too I am sure. I guess I'm just saying that we don't know for sure where the curse came from.

And, I still don't think your voting record for Mary clears you of being a baddie.

Well lynching me will certainly clear me.

Has it been considered/discussed that some of these survivals by Malin could be due to Horcruxes? :P

[Young Lady]

That's the hard part about this. There are so many possibilities. I just don't read Malin as a baddie.

[Chuck]

I disagree.

[Young Lady]

Anyone else wanna weigh in?

[Jack Shephard]

Sarah hon, you broke your pattern. You were supposed to vote for me today, not Malin.

[Jack Shephard]

I have just read through all of Jane Southworth's posts.

Rebecca Nurse made a painfully bad "case" (I hesitate to even use the word) on Jane, and Jane handled it with competence.

Jane defended my vote against Merga solidly, which I appreciated.

Jane was suspicious of Karin Day 4 through 8. The opportunity to lynch Karin presented itself on Day 9, but Jane showed restraint. No, it didn't work out well in the end, but I think it speaks to goodness on her part.

Jane and I are on the same page in a lot of respects. One subject I am going to discuss momentarily.

One thing I found that weirded me out~

Hello?? I feel like...a new person.

Don't attack someone with Amnesia, OK? Let me catch up.

Can someone help a witch out and give me a highlights reel?

Welcome, Merga! I don't think a recap will do you much Good, so here is a link to a list of all of the players in the game. The names you find there contain links to all of that witch's posts in this thread. I suggest you start trying to read the full thread, beginning around the start of Day 1, and if something you read catches your eye, you can use that list to quickly peak at any player's contributions to the game. Do try to keep in mind the context around posts that you find in this way, because if you aren't sure what's being discussed, you might draw wrong conclusions about what you're reading. You must only use this shortcut for Good!

Unfortunately there is not an easy way to recap the thread for you because we haven't caught a baddie yet. We're still flying a little blind, and the thread will probably reflect that. Most everything that you NEED to know can be found in the first few posts of the game.

Jane used the word "Good" (capital letter). At first I thought it was a mistake, but then it appears again in the fifth line ("You must only use this shortcut for Good!"). I don't know. It just seems kind of spooky.

[Phoebe Buffay]

I won't be active much at all today. I came down with a fever yesterday, and am feeling pretty rugged. I would also prefer to keep the 48 hour days please mods.

I plan on voting Karin again today, but I'll wait 'til the end of the day to keep you witches somewhat happy.

Why is there, but I want some words enclosed within 48 hours.

Go ahead and vote for the player that sniffed out Mary from Day 1 and see how far that takes you.

If you have a test that can be used. Prosecutors, meanwhile, has sought to use Barbara not Kathleen. The reason why. Maria allotriwse, everywhere the wrong account twice, Maria, who voted for him. Mary Kathleen to pick, but I don't want to use, just to prove he is not guilty.

Has it been considered/discussed that some of these survivals by Malin could be due to Horcruxes? :P

I found it, but the problem of work: this is a good choice.

Jane used the word "Good" (capital letter). At first I thought it was a mistake, but then it appears again in the fifth line ("You must only use this shortcut for Good!"). I don't know. It just seems kind of spooky.

This was not a joke.

[Jack Shephard]

Go ahead and vote for the player that sniffed out Mary from Day 1 and see how far that takes you.

Glad you said that. You know, you give yourself far too much credit for something that happened basically without you.

Day 1~

Voted for Eastly cuz she's not Good

So this is sniffing "out Mary from Day 1."

Day 2~

No time. Voted me.

If you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1" as you put it, why not vote for Mary on day 2 instead of yourself?

Day 3~ You didn't post at all, but voted Krystyna.

Again, if you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1," why not vote for Mary on Day 3 instead of Krystyna? Why not be a little more aggressive in trying to get people to vote for Mary like you are doing with Malin right now?

Day 4~ You posted (once) but you didn't vote.

Day 5~

Mary Mary quite contrary.

On day 5, you voted for Mary. Last. Without saying anything. Without trying to get her lynched. If you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1" as you put it, why not try to get others to vote for Mary? Why did you wait for eleven other people to vote before you tacked on your vote at the end?

[Chuck]

Go ahead and vote for the player that sniffed out Mary from Day 1 and see how far that takes you.

Glad you said that. You know, you give yourself far too much credit for something that happened basically without you.

Day 1~

Voted for Eastly cuz she's not Good

So this is sniffing "out Mary from Day 1."

Day 2~

No time. Voted me.

If you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1" as you put it, why not vote for Mary on day 2 instead of yourself?

Day 3~ You didn't post at all, but voted Krystyna.

Again, if you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1," why not vote for Mary on Day 3 instead of Krystyna? Why not be a little more aggressive in trying to get people to vote for Mary like you are doing with Malin right now?

Day 4~ You posted (once) but you didn't vote.

Day 5~

Mary Mary quite contrary.

On day 5, you voted for Mary. Last. Without saying anything. Without trying to get her lynched. If you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1" as you put it, why not try to get others to vote for Mary? Why did you wait for eleven other people to vote before you tacked on your vote at the end?

Because I'm a mafia trying to blend in

[Jack Shephard]

Go ahead and vote for the player that sniffed out Mary from Day 1 and see how far that takes you.

Glad you said that. You know, you give yourself far too much credit for something that happened basically without you.

Day 1~

Voted for Eastly cuz she's not Good

So this is sniffing "out Mary from Day 1."

Day 2~

No time. Voted me.

If you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1" as you put it, why not vote for Mary on day 2 instead of yourself?

Day 3~ You didn't post at all, but voted Krystyna.

Again, if you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1," why not vote for Mary on Day 3 instead of Krystyna? Why not be a little more aggressive in trying to get people to vote for Mary like you are doing with Malin right now?

Day 4~ You posted (once) but you didn't vote.

Day 5~

Mary Mary quite contrary.

On day 5, you voted for Mary. Last. Without saying anything. Without trying to get her lynched. If you "sniffed out Mary from Day 1" as you put it, why not try to get others to vote for Mary? Why did you wait for eleven other people to vote before you tacked on your vote at the end?

Because I'm a mafia trying to blend in

Day 9
Who is a nasty Death Eater?

Poll ended at Mon Mar 10, 2014 2:06 am

Jennet Bierley
0
No votes

Alizon Device
1
Alice Nutter (9)
7%

Sarah Good
0
No votes

Katharina Henot
0
No votes

Märet Jonsdotter
0
No votes

Barbara Kollerin
0
No votes

Malin Matsdotter
1
Sarah Good (13)
7%

Alice Nutter
0
No votes

Anne Redferne
0
No votes

Jane Southworth
0
No votes

Karin Svensdotter
5
Jennet Bierley (2), Barbara Kollerin (3), Anne Whittle (5), Anne Redferne (7), Märet Jonsdotter (8)
33%

Anne Whittle
5
Katharina Henot (10), Malin Matsdotter (11), Alizon Device (12), Karin Svensdotter (14), Jane Southworth (15)
33%

Fluttershy (Hosts/Mod/Deadies)
3
Lizzy (1), S~V~S (4), A Person (6)
20%

Total votes : 15

You're doing it wrong.

[Chuck]

Maybe I should take lessons from Malin.

[Jack Shephard]

I want to link to Jane's post and add to it now.

I am operating under the opinion that the resurrected persons are in service to Tom Riddle.

Jennet said she gunned hard for Mary and knew she would be killed for it. So if Jennet was Hermoine and checked Mary, that explains the sudden fervor. If this is true, then looking at when Jennet voted might be helpful~

1. Enjen (21st, no info)
2. Krystyna (22nd, no info)
3. Enjen (19th, likely no info)
4. Mary (4th, info)
5. Mary (3rd, info)

Now then, if Jennet were Hermoine, and she came back to life insisting on a Karin lynch, she'd be implying that she checked Karin. Asking to be lynched, then, would be an effective strategy in getting others to believe Karin should be lynched. However, looking at the above sequence, it can be assumed that Jennet did not check Karin unless she did so on the night she was killed.

Rewind to Agnes Sampson.

Agnes never said we should lynch Sarah Good. I threw out an interpretation of her vague comment and Anna Koldings expressed agreement with my thinking~

Cool it with the snark everyone. Zombie don't play that. Anyway, we have more important things to discuss. The underworld was most illuminating. I can't be very specific, but let me just say that names can be deceiving.

So Sarah Good is not good.

I'd buy that. It doesn't work with anyone else's name (if that Agnes was driving at).

But right after this, Mary went nuts and Agnes never responded to me. Weirdly enough, Agnes spent her time back going after Entjen, then said this~

I really do have thoughts on players other than Entjen I swear, I will get to them soon, Im glad we have 24 hours and not a only a few like Margarethe almost had me believing! :P But alas, I am likely not long for this world so I will have to hurry in any case.

Then

Okay Entjen then who do you think is bad? The only person being discussed that I see right now is Mary, who I will get to in a bit. We need to be talking about more than one person in order to see which way the discussions head toward. As you have said before yourself there is more than one baddie out there.

I have thoughts on other players that I'm trying to get organized, but I'd like to hear your thoughts on other players as well.

Isn't it funny that Agnes came back and tried to have people discuss someone other than Lucius Malfoy?

Then

I think the case on Mary is pretty compelling. I'm placing my vote there.

Agnes never got back to us about any of these other players she supposedly had thoughts on, nor did she respond to my interpretation of what she said.

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

But if Sarah Good WERE bad, and Agnes was working for the baddies, then her cryptic remark backfired. Agnes would have had no reason to address it and could move on to getting Entjen lynched. That didn't happen, and Agnes voted second to last for Mary, right before Sarah Good.

[Young Lady]

Alizon, speaking of players using a capital 'G'...check out this post made by Ms. Good herself.

Voted for Eastly cuz she's not Good

[Chuck]

Alizon, speaking of players using a capital 'G'...check out this post made by Ms. Good herself.

Voted for Eastly cuz she's not Good

:O Code cracked.

[Ben Linus]

That, coupled with my opinion that resurrected persons are working for Tom Riddle, had been giving me pause about Sarah Good being bad.

Wait, so you hinted that you brought me back to life, and yet you think it was the doing of Tom Riddle?

[Celeste]

Sarah Good did seem to be exaggerating her involvement in the whole Mary thing

[Celeste]

is it really a code? i thought it was just a lame pun based on Sarah's punning earlier

like it would be the same if i walked into the room and said hey "Alizon u ok? You're seeming pretty Divisive"

[Chuck]

Is it really an exaggeration though. Is it really.

[Operator]

I have just read through all of Jane Southworth's posts.

Me too. General observations are that she is helpful, analytical and proactive. She has clearly put a lot of effort into her posts, and frequently makes sound, logical points.

I have a really hard time believing she is bad.

[Operator]

But Sarah Good is not Good.

[Jack Shephard]

Malin, what is your opinion about the resurrected ones?