Re: MINECRAFT - DAY FIVE
Posted: Thu Apr 11, 2013 7:52 pm
I'm just gonna assume I'm right about Boogs and 2 or 3 of the voters are on his baddie team. 

I don't think you were talking me out of Boogs.Roxy wrote:If you felt more strongly about boogs I would have followed you FH. <3
I really hope we are right today!
Well all this does not make me feel better tbs. Porcu![]()
I swear I will just flip out if I am wrong.
Oh no more talk of recruits!! My hed can't handle it tonight.
FH I know my theory sounds crazy but I just feel like we were onto something.... It does not seem logical he is Herobrine. I will admit i may not be accurate there, but a recruit? yes, largely largely possible. We all still have no idea what the secret part of Hero's role is, which COULD be just that. Also, his constant flip flopping and wishy washy feelings on everyone throw me a HUGEFlyin' High wrote:I don't think you were talking me out of Boogs.Roxy wrote:If you felt more strongly about boogs I would have followed you FH. <3
I really hope we are right today!
Well all this does not make me feel better tbs. Porcu![]()
I swear I will just flip out if I am wrong.
Oh no more talk of recruits!! My hed can't handle it tonight.
Boogs, can you please explain how MP can both be Herobrine and have been dead Night 1? When you can explain that, I might start believing you. Otherwise I don't understand how it's possible. A recruit at this point makes more sense to me than Herobrine killing from beyond the grave.
I was spider.Roxy wrote:I can't see the video so does it say who Porcu was?
Obv from others posts and Porcu's yay!
Porcu you just keep getting better
Yes, sorry about that freak out I had where I put the case together about you and BWT. MP's vote had me all uncertain, but I am glad I went with my gut rather than following MP this time. I really hope MP isn't recruited, but I want to hear from him for sure.thellama73 wrote:I'm catching up on poss now. Roxy, I feel sure BWT is not pulling the wool over my eyes.
I would hope that my tireless crusading against Porcu since day 1 would show people that I am on the side of good.
I don't think my mention of the ship early on should incriminate me, especially since I didn't vote for it. Remember that Snow Dog voted Ship and turned out to be good.
I think it must be either Boogs or SE, leaning towards Boogs. Some of his attempts to get us not to lynch him have been very convincing, though.Flyin' High wrote:Yes, sorry about that freak out I had where I put the case together about you and BWT. MP's vote had me all uncertain, but I am glad I went with my gut rather than following MP this time. I really hope MP isn't recruited, but I want to hear from him for sure.thellama73 wrote:I'm catching up on poss now. Roxy, I feel sure BWT is not pulling the wool over my eyes.
I would hope that my tireless crusading against Porcu since day 1 would show people that I am on the side of good.
I don't think my mention of the ship early on should incriminate me, especially since I didn't vote for it. Remember that Snow Dog voted Ship and turned out to be good.
I'm filling in some stuff on my spreadsheet now and trying to figure out who might be the last mafia.
If Boogs is the last mafia, who do you think Herobrine is?thellama73 wrote:I think it must be either Boogs or SE, leaning towards Boogs. Some of his attempts to get us not to lynch him have been very convincing, though.Flyin' High wrote:Yes, sorry about that freak out I had where I put the case together about you and BWT. MP's vote had me all uncertain, but I am glad I went with my gut rather than following MP this time. I really hope MP isn't recruited, but I want to hear from him for sure.thellama73 wrote:I'm catching up on poss now. Roxy, I feel sure BWT is not pulling the wool over my eyes.
I would hope that my tireless crusading against Porcu since day 1 would show people that I am on the side of good.
I don't think my mention of the ship early on should incriminate me, especially since I didn't vote for it. Remember that Snow Dog voted Ship and turned out to be good.
I'm filling in some stuff on my spreadsheet now and trying to figure out who might be the last mafia.
According to my notes, it has to be either SE or BF, unless of course MP has somehow fooled all of us.Flyin' High wrote:If Boogs is the last mafia, who do you think Herobrine is?thellama73 wrote:I think it must be either Boogs or SE, leaning towards Boogs. Some of his attempts to get us not to lynch him have been very convincing, though.Flyin' High wrote:Yes, sorry about that freak out I had where I put the case together about you and BWT. MP's vote had me all uncertain, but I am glad I went with my gut rather than following MP this time. I really hope MP isn't recruited, but I want to hear from him for sure.thellama73 wrote:I'm catching up on poss now. Roxy, I feel sure BWT is not pulling the wool over my eyes.
I would hope that my tireless crusading against Porcu since day 1 would show people that I am on the side of good.
I don't think my mention of the ship early on should incriminate me, especially since I didn't vote for it. Remember that Snow Dog voted Ship and turned out to be good.
I'm filling in some stuff on my spreadsheet now and trying to figure out who might be the last mafia.
No, not at all. I was taking your assumption that Boogs was the last Mafia. Boogs has voted for a civvie FIVE times in a row now. That maes him more likely to be mafia than hero, but he could be either.Flyin' High wrote: So you have it that Boogs can't be Herobrine on your spreadsheet, llama?
Boogs voted for Snow Dog twice and rustifinko once. We know that those were civvies. He voted for me once, and I know I am a civvie. He voted for BWT once, and I am very confident that BWT is civvie.blindfaeth wrote:llama, where are you getting these numbers? Just curious. bc we still dont know BWT was good, so how do you know boogs has voted a civ 5 times? You said the same thing about me recently, when really we only knew two of the roles of the 4 people I'd voted at the time.
I don't think BF can be mafia, because of his DP vote, but he could still be Hero.MovingPictures07 wrote:I also agree that it's likely SE is the last mafia and Boogs is Hero, but I don't know. I guess I am probably wrong about BF given that DP flipped, so it would be impossible for Boogs and BF to be teammates. I know people got on me for this last time, but if Stevie is somehow still alive, I think he should definitely NK Boogs, or even SE.
DisgruntledPorcupine wrote:I was spider.Roxy wrote:I can't see the video so does it say who Porcu was?
Obv from others posts and Porcu's yay!
Porcu you just keep getting better
And thanks.
>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:He-Man, I dont think anybody has really been specifically targeting anybody for the lynch yet, and i cant see anybody as of right now that looks like theyre tied to epi in any way. i dont think its fair to go throwing out conclusions of any sort yet. we need to talk about all of this first before we jump to "youre suspicious and bad, so die" kind of thing. in fact, I think epi's post actually makes a lot of sense, but so does the point made of quality over quantity.
>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:Haha thanks, i think youre misunderstanding epi though.He-Man wrote:I'm sorry I could not eloquently explain my suspicion to your eyes, I will try harder to appease you in future>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:I dont think youre making too much sense to anyone, tbhHe-Man wrote:Maybe someone else can explain since I'm not making sense to you.Epignosis wrote:What?
From what I can tell, epi is just saying that llama said the exact same thing even before epi did, yet epi is the only one youre going after. and i think youre thinking that epi is trying to pull your attention over to llama instead of him. youre both misunderstanding i think.
Note: This is where he votes for He-Man and at this point, He-Man had already chosen to vote for Epignosis.>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:this is the last chance i will get before the poll ends, i'm going out with friends. so i guess i have to vote now. i honestly have no idea who to vote for and i dont know if i'm okay with an SD lynch JUST YET. ill give him a chance to prove himself civvie to me. so i'm going to vote he-man, just cuz he's he-man and always pings me
This meant nothing to me at the time, but I have seen people forget to vote and then come back because they were reminded in their BTSC chatroom.>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:(I'm on my phone quick because I realized I never voted in the poll) I only voted he man as sort of a throw away vote because I don't know who else to vote for. All of these arguments seem like civvie-civvie to me and I cant decide who is who yet.
In addition to supplying reasons for MP's lynch that weren't baddie-related, after Epig starts to take a lot of heat he now says he thinks he'd be okay with it.>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:I have a feeling that baddies didnt have anything to do with MP getting lynched. I'm more inclined to think that Epi possibly had a lynch protection from somewhere (possibly from a role or from some item acquired) although i think it has to be part of the role because it seems weird that he would have received an item so early in the game. Unless it was a result of the day 0 vote. it seems like a waste for a baddie team to use a lynch switch so early, unless he was the only baddie member able to use the lynch switch, so thats an option too.
>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:Looks like a lot of people are heading towards Epi being lynched. I think I would be okay with it, I'm not so keep on the idea of baddies using their power so early just to frame a civ. It seems like an awful waste of something that could be extremely useful later in the game to save a teammate or themselves. So I'm more set on the fact that he is a baddie who saved his own life with it. Or it was a freak circumstance where both epi and llama are protected from being lynched and it just went down the line to MP
>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:OR the diamond sword could have saved him for some reason unbeknownst to us.
He finally votes Epignosis when there's no chance of saving him.>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:The reason I didnt completely rule out the diamond sword is because it has a *secret* as part of its role. I think theres a small chance it could have been some sort of power where the diamond sword would know epi was a civvie and then to save him? I dunno, its a stretch but i'm not ruling it out.MovingPictures07 wrote: Linki with SE: It makes absolutely NO sense the Diamond Sword saved him. Remember, the Diamond Sword has both a stop and a switch, and the baddies only have a switch. Since Diamond Sword has no BTSC, I incredibly doubt that role would use the switch when they cannot be sure anyone is civ or bad. I realize we can be paranoid, but I really think we don't have a better option than Epig. But I think you're right in that their hand was forced to use the lynch switch, even though they might not have wanted to.
After this most of his posts become very blendy.>SpaghettiEverywhere wrote:Great result!!!! Bye epi and BIH zombie!!! I think going after Elohcin would be a good idea, though I'm still leery of snow dog. His "no u" kind of playing here makes me lean a bit towards him being baddie, but i dont know for sure yet.
I agree.thellama73 wrote:I don't think BF can be mafia, because of his DP vote, but he could still be Hero.MovingPictures07 wrote:I also agree that it's likely SE is the last mafia and Boogs is Hero, but I don't know. I guess I am probably wrong about BF given that DP flipped, so it would be impossible for Boogs and BF to be teammates. I know people got on me for this last time, but if Stevie is somehow still alive, I think he should definitely NK Boogs, or even SE.
What do you mean?Roxy wrote:DisgruntledPorcupine wrote:I was spider.Roxy wrote:I can't see the video so does it say who Porcu was?
Obv from others posts and Porcu's yay!
Porcu you just keep getting better
And thanks.
Thanks for not insanifying me!
I totally panicked at the end too FH
Kk thoughts-
I do trust FH if she is bad she would have to be Herobrine as she could have easily voted Teeth to save Porcu. Is she I just don't feel it in my gut.
I really want to trust llama. At least I know he is not a mafia with the way he went after Porcu all game. Herobrine I don't think so.
I really wanna trust bf too. His last posts and vote during the lynch make me feel better about him. Could he be Herobrine? Maybe but I just don't think so.
As for the last baddie could be boogs. Iunno. Maybe Herobrine.
MP - wtf is up with the last couple of lynches?
I think Russ said that for a reason--he was the Minecart and had to have tracked someone that was either night-killed or had a kill attempted on them and saw that indi and Boogs targeted that player either Night 1 or Night 2. Indi couldn't have been bad. So logic says Boogs is bad.Russtifinko wrote:Wow, a guy goes Öb vacation and suddenly he's evil! I'm busy as have only phone access (and limited, at that) until Wednesday, as I stated. You can lynch me before then if you really want, or I can mount a defense when I get home. If you do lynch me, you'll understand why I can personally guarantee either boogs or indi is bad. I'm leaning that it was indi and Herobrine did us a favor, but boogs bears a look just in case.
For the little it's worth, is it so far-fetched that I made a correct judgment? I know it's only my third game, but I'm fairly intelligent. I explained clearly the logical steps I took at the time to conclude it was Epi. I believe BWT's post was saying that in rl I'm a logical guy, so he may believe me at least.
Beyond that, make your own conclusions at least until wed. MP has, apparently, and that worked out very well for us last lynch, so I can't fault people for following him. MP, in a recent post you said you don't feel bad about sometimes being wrong in your suspicions. If I die, I hope this changes your mind some. You have unmatched power in thus game, and killing everyone you suspect may eventually lead to a win since you're experienced and good, but at the expense of some civvie lives. I was thinking maybe I could win this one for the first time, that seems unlikely now. Shame you chose to do this when I can't adequately defend. Good night all
I explained this, but let me lay it out for you again. I think I drank something seriously messed up last night before I went to bed because I could not shake the feeling that they were lying and that this was some elaborately genius baddie move, and it would be if they were the last two baddies on Epig's team and managed to run away with it.Roxy wrote:Yes that too FH! Yay!
Also great points on spaghetti he has not posted nearly as much as he was. I am sure they were just trying to lay low.
I don't think spaghetti is Herobrine.
I also left Teeth off my list.
I have a role in mind for him and it is not Herobrine.
I wonder why boogs would come up with this crazy theory that makes no sense. He even said Porcu was not Herobrine. Could he be Herobrine? FH your post about him is very on point with my thinking!
Sock - why did you suddenly vote with boogs against Teeth? What exactly made you jump to that conclusion? All game long you have been saying you trust llama that he was good but then you don't trust him and vote for someone he was absolutely saying not to vote for?
Llama - I agree I hope they are the last 2.
When did i ever say DP was Hero? I've only said that MP was him then said is agree he is a recruit and the last 2 baddies i felt were DP (I was correct on and mentioned that yesterday too) and BWT.Roxy wrote:Yes that too FH! Yay!
Also great points on spaghetti he has not posted nearly as much as he was. I am sure they were just trying to lay low.
I don't think spaghetti is Herobrine.
I also left Teeth off my list.
I have a role in mind for him and it is not Herobrine.
I wonder why boogs would come up with this crazy theory that makes no sense. He even said Porcu was not Herobrine. Could he be Herobrine? FH your post about him is very on point with my thinking!
Sock - why did you suddenly vote with boogs against Teeth? What exactly made you jump to that conclusion? All game long you have been saying you trust llama that he was good but then you don't trust him and vote for someone he was absolutely saying not to vote for?
Llama - I agree I hope they are the last 2.
I think I got most of them, but what was that run where you were basically posting "catch catch catch catch catch catch catch" for ages?MovingPictures07 wrote:Oh, and do people actually need me to translate any of my posts from this period? I think I covered what I was trying to mainly say and a lot of it is irrelevant now. But I'd be glad to try and recall what the messages were if anyone was wondering. Lol.
Catch = BWT. I was trying to say BWT and it wasn't getting through no matter how I tried it. birdwithteeth didn't work the first few times but I finally got it to go through.thellama73 wrote:I think I got most of them, but what was that run where you were basically posting "catch catch catch catch catch catch catch" for ages?MovingPictures07 wrote:Oh, and do people actually need me to translate any of my posts from this period? I think I covered what I was trying to mainly say and a lot of it is irrelevant now. But I'd be glad to try and recall what the messages were if anyone was wondering. Lol.
The algorithms of these insanifiers are truly baffling.MovingPictures07 wrote: Catch = BWT.
I know, right? What was the other word? That was BWT too. It wasn't catching... maybe fishing or whatever I said a few times like that as well.thellama73 wrote:The algorithms of these insanifiers are truly baffling.MovingPictures07 wrote: Catch = BWT.
It feels very, very good. I love when my instincts turn out right. I'm only sorry I didn't have the same insight about Snow Dog being good.MovingPictures07 wrote:And so, llama, how does it feel to have been right about DP from the beginning?