The Syndicate

DharmaHelper wrote:Must...exercise...restraint...

You made longwinded arguments that I did not buy into. Sorry. I tried.

But you are safe, are you not? We FINALLY successfully lynched a bad person, and we have more information.

Why would when they died have anything to do with affiliation? Actually the baddies may have had more of an idea who was civ in their later kills.

Great outcome, not what I expected so one more time I have to read the roles. See you later LT and bih Grey 1.

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Must...exercise...restraint...

You made longwinded arguments that I did not buy into. Sorry. I tried.

But you are safe, are you not? We FINALLY successfully lynched a bad person, and we have more information.

Not restraint against you, restraint against my desire to do a big ol' "Told ya so" dance.

Kate wrote:Why would when they died have anything to do with affiliation? Actually the baddies may have had more of an idea who was civ in their later kills.

Statistically, there are more civs on Day One, IMO. And like i said, i had bad feelings about a few of the others.

birdwithteeth11 wrote:You have to be kidding me. I went to click 'submit' to vote, and the polling closed at that exact moment.

It doesn't mean much, but I would have gone with CBK/Timmer probably. I didn't feel quite as comfortable with Troofie and Boats as I did with him and FH. But I'm more willing to give FH the benefit of the doubt for now.

If you were clicking submit, wouldn't you have already picked your vote?

Does anyone know if Boats voted?

ebwop, thats why heavy "random" day one voting tends to result in civ lynches. Night One kills are often pretty random~

Linki, yeah trice, inorite?? LOL

@DH I do not think he did

Doesn't look like Boats voted judging from his posts.

anyway, I vote chaindeath for rez because none of the others posted or did anything even when they were alive

so yeah

Illyria posted a ton and was very involved

Kate wrote:

birdwithteeth11 wrote:You have to be kidding me. I went to click 'submit' to vote, and the polling closed at that exact moment.

It doesn't mean much, but I would have gone with CBK/Timmer probably. I didn't feel quite as comfortable with Troofie and Boats as I did with him and FH. But I'm more willing to give FH the benefit of the doubt for now.

Who were u hitting submit to vote for?

I was hitting submit to vote for CBK/Timmer. I guess I was just a tad bit too late is all.

Although I guess it worked out in the end since we got a baddie! BIH LT!

S~V~S wrote:Apparently Flyin High talked her way out of it. When her case of Trice fell flat, she turned to CBK.

Um, what? I built a case on CBK long before my case on Trice. Did you really go back and read me like you claimed or are you just so intent on me being bad that you're getting your facts wrong to intentionally to make me look bad?

RIH Grey 1! Bye LT! I definitely felt something was up the second you agreed with me being bad so glad someone took their suspicion of you all the way.

And my case on Trice didn't fall flat, SVS. I was actually listening to you and giving it some thought before I hastily voted that way. But your snarkiness with regards to me is duly noted.

@DH: I don't have the voting order yet because I wasn't around for the last part of the lynch. I can compile it from the thread tomorrow. I'm heading to bed now.

As for who I think should be rezzed, maybe chaindeath as he wasn't giving me and major pings.

How many votes was LT at when the poll ended? Trying to do some math here. CBK had 6, DH had 4 (-2) IIRC, nobody else got more than 2

linki - svs the only thing I remember Illyria doing is not understanding what a movie quote is

Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

triceratopzeuhl wrote:

birdwithteeth11 wrote:You have to be kidding me. I went to click 'submit' to vote, and the polling closed at that exact moment.

It doesn't mean much, but I would have gone with CBK/Timmer probably. I didn't feel quite as comfortable with Troofie and Boats as I did with him and FH. But I'm more willing to give FH the benefit of the doubt for now.

If you were clicking submit, wouldn't you have already picked your vote?

See what I just posted. I'll clarify if you're still confused about it.

I was gonna say this~


Devin the Omniscient

DFaraday
LoRab
axxon n
Illyria
chaindeath

Axxon did not participate. I felt LoRab was a baddie, not sure why, but I just did. I kinda felt like that about chaindeath as well. Illy was very involved, but she just made me nervous~ that could just be me, she often does. But for me that leaves Faraday or Devin, and i guess I might consider illy as well.

I have to reread her to see if, considering subsequesnt events, she seemed as if she were associated with anyone subsequently proven bad.

Linki BWT~ So wht=y did you say PROBABLY???

Linki again~ Illyria, 31 posts, Chaindeath, 15, and she died like a week before him

S~V~S wrote:

birdwithteeth11 wrote:You have to be kidding me. I went to click 'submit' to vote, and the polling closed at that exact moment.

It doesn't mean much, but I would have gone with CBK/Timmer probably. I didn't feel quite as comfortable with Troofie and Boats as I did with him and FH. But I'm more willing to give FH the benefit of the doubt for now.

Probably? But you were hitting "Submit" to vote.

Why did you say PROBABLY?

birdwithteeth11 wrote:

triceratopzeuhl wrote:

birdwithteeth11 wrote:You have to be kidding me. I went to click 'submit' to vote, and the polling closed at that exact moment.

It doesn't mean much, but I would have gone with CBK/Timmer probably. I didn't feel quite as comfortable with Troofie and Boats as I did with him and FH. But I'm more willing to give FH the benefit of the doubt for now.

If you were clicking submit, wouldn't you have already picked your vote?

See what I just posted. I'll clarify if you're still confused about it.

I'm still confused about it.

DharmaHelper wrote:Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

Luckily =/= obviously.

Looks to me like CBK either got a lynch protect prize from somewhere (Damo Suzuki's bag, maybe?), or she could be the Mysterious Voice

By which I mean,

Looks to me like Timmer either got a lynch protect prize from somewhere (Damo Suzuki's bag, maybe?), or he could be the Mysterious Voice

linki - weird

linki2 - yeah BWT why do you constantly feel the need to make things up this game? Does that help you in any way?

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

Luckily =/= obviously.

Is now a good time to remind you DH about how you unmercifully attacked me in West Wing for the whole game even though i was a civv?

juliets wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

Luckily =/= obviously.

Is now a good time to remind you DH about how you unmercifully attacked me in West Wing for the whole game even though i was a civv?

That won us baddies the game. Our whole team lived.

juliets wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:Going to go to bed, but before I do I just want to say that my methods may seem whacked out but, obviously, they work.

Luckily =/= obviously.

Is now a good time to remind you DH about how you unmercifully attacked me in West Wing for the whole game even though i was a civv?

Well hey you did serve a good distraction so my team and I could win.

linki: ninja'd by Kate.

Flyin' High wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Apparently Flyin High talked her way out of it. When her case of Trice fell flat, she turned to CBK.

Um, what? I built a case on CBK long before my case on Trice. Did you really go back and read me like you claimed or are you just so intent on me being bad that you're getting your facts wrong to intentionally to make me look bad?

RIH Grey 1! Bye LT! I definitely felt something was up the second you agreed with me being bad so glad someone took their suspicion of you all the way.

And my case on Trice didn't fall flat, SVS. I was actually listening to you and giving it some thought before I hastily voted that way. But your snarkiness with regards to me is duly noted.

@DH: I don't have the voting order yet because I wasn't around for the last part of the lynch. I can compile it from the thread tomorrow. I'm heading to bed now.

As for who I think should be rezzed, maybe chaindeath as he wasn't giving me and major pings.

It is not snarkiness, i really think you are bad. I think it is bluntness

And I menat to say "fell back on", i know you suspected her before, along with Boomslang and Droopy. I am not getting my facts wrong intentionally~ and your hyperbole is duly noted

S~V~S wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

birdwithteeth11 wrote:You have to be kidding me. I went to click 'submit' to vote, and the polling closed at that exact moment.

It doesn't mean much, but I would have gone with CBK/Timmer probably. I didn't feel quite as comfortable with Troofie and Boats as I did with him and FH. But I'm more willing to give FH the benefit of the doubt for now.

Probably? But you were hitting "Submit" to vote.

Why did you say PROBABLY?

Because that's who I was trying to vote for when I went to vote, and then had my vote not count in the end.

I apologize. It was poorly worded. But I've had an extremely long day today and am really tired right now, so if I say something that sounds confusing again, just ask me to clarify it. Because the last thing I want to do right now is confuzzle anyone. I already feel bad enough for screwing it up with which prizes I won in what order.

No, I'm not trying to make things up. I'm sorry if it seems that way. But we got the clarification with the prizes thing worked out, so I'm sure I can figure out a way to get this worked out so everyone understands where I'm coming from. I'm not intentionally trying to be confusing, so I apologize if you think I am.

In other words, you're a shitty communicator.

"likes to cause chaos and confusion" anyone?

Oh, i wasn't confused. i thought you maybe made a slip there. I still kinda think maybe you did Because what you just described there does not equate with "probably"

Nice to know you are giving FH the benefit of the doubt.

Epignosis wrote:In other words, you're a shitty communicator.

Why yes. Yes I am.

triceratopzeuhl wrote:"likes to cause chaos and confusion" anyone?

I'M ZILLLLLLTOIIIIIIIIID
I DON'T GIVE A SHIT
I LIVE ABOVE EARTH IN A BIG ROCKET SHIP
I'M ZILLLLLLLLLLLLTOOOOOOOOIIIIIIIIIIIIIID
THE HORRORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
THE HORRORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Linki: If you feel it was a slip on my part, then by all means so be it.

tbh I've never listened to Ziltoid the Omniscient, so I'm gonna assume you are telling me I have the wrong team

<3

DisgruntledPorcupine wrote:*votes BWT*

You mean for getting rezzed or for the next lynch? :P

And WTF COOLIN! You really should give it a listen because it is an awesome album.

I play for every team if you know what I mean.

I rolled a six sided die and got a six. So chaindeath.

Probably evil, given my luck.

As for who I wish to rezz, I'm thinking either DFarady, Devin, or chaindeath. Chain because he pinged me the least of all those people, and the other two because while they might not be civvies, I'm all for giving people who died on Night 1 another chance to play.

Good times.

I have no idea who should get the rezz yet. I'll have to do some research on this decision.

Another strange thing said by BWT...weird stuff.

I'm going to go spend some time with my gf for the rest of the night. I might look it over a bit tonight, but definitely tomorrow I will re-read the 3 I mentioned and decide which is most worthy of a rezz.

S~V~S wrote:

The Truth wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

The Truth wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:I'm not planning anything Boats. I just feel very strongly that LT tangled herself up in her reaction to my voting analysis and her reactions since.

You're being rather condescending, that sometimes makes me think people are baddies.

Actually, it is my experience that DH tends to be more condescending when he is a civ. Hes a little friendlier when hes bad, trying to trick people and all.

i was gonna vote FH, but am waiting to see if there is a last minute push for DH

Consider me part of that push... Maybe he's using reverse psychology? Regardless, it seems suspicious to me.

yeah your post was what made me fear the wagon of bands~ and i see you didn't vote after all

Dang, I meant to, I just lost track of time.

I'm voting BWT for resurrection for personal reasons.

Wait, he's not an option.

That seems strange- why would you assume to vote for him?

Personal reasons.

It's not the ambiguous Vomps personal reasons, I could just never see Davey as a baddie and I misread some of the above posts.

Tanner he's not even dead, lmao

I didn't vote for the last poll because I really couldn't choose anyone. DH sprang to mind, but it's possible he's just trying to help. I'm just as clueless as ever.

I'm interested to know Timmer's thoughts on the lynch result.

Kate wrote:

The Truth wrote:I sense some tension.

Tension, indeed.

triceratopzeuhl wrote:Look people, the 2 times I've said "us" or "we" or whatever this game, both of them I was referring to every single player in the game. That's all there is to it, but I understand that when you keep lynching civs it's hard for you to tell what's actually worth being suspicious of. Like maybe Dom arbitrarily trying to make cases that won't stick off semantics.


To be entirely fair, the role reveals from the book do force me to re-evaluate you at least to some degree. Yes, I agree with people saying this is your civ game, but like I explained early you (everybody) play(s) civ game as an indy. That's the only way you can win.

It's almost like I'm smart or something. Not like I'm an electrical engineer or anything.

For the 3rd time, nobody is actually stupid enough to copy-paste things from a btsc chat room. Anybody who did that, would be doing 10000 other nooby mistakes and it would be obvious they are bad. You can even copy-paste that, if you want.

Now, if we look alll the way back at that Bea lynch, the one successful one we've had, there was an idea floating about that her teammates voted rabbit to save her. If we work on my personal belief that if the baddies were actually morons they'd be dead by now, I think maybe 1 person and no more on the team would have done that. I don't know whether that one person is CBK (or whoever replacement was) or FH. But I also think FH let slip her role, and it's a civ one. I will find the quote in a sec here.

Where the hell do I start with this?
First of all, thank you for being condescending. As if anyone who has ever made a mistake like that is SO below you. It happens. Often enough that semantics are often a pretty good tip off in Mafia. I don't see you arguing with the BWT suspicion over the "probably" (which was weird for the record ). Sounds like it's only an invalid motivation for suspicion if it's directed at you.
Secondly, I could care less what you're fucking job is. Your profession does not make you smarter than me or anyone else here and I won't have you pretend like it does.
Third, interestingly enough, you seem to be following in-line with FH and LT. . . interestingly enough, I think they are on the same team. I did not see the LT suspicion (until her vote for rey which was totally random)
Have a nice day, electrical engineer.

Thank you DH. Really. I'm sorry I've given you such a hard time. You're not completely off the hook yet! But you're looking better to me.

triceratopzeuhl wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:@Trice if you think FH let slip which civvie role she is, requoting it so all the baddies know what you're talking about might not be the best course of action.

Good point.

If you're such a not-noob why didn't you already realize this?

LittleTiger wrote:
So then why did he slip in the "I am going to vote LT"?

Again, I was not the first to comment that his analyses served no purpose at this point in the game. Later, maybe it will help. So, I comment.... and BOOM! DH says THAT is his case... the fact that I commented. Something that others have also done.

Now, here you are joining him. I am sorry, but you cannot tell me that his analyses has any bearing on shit right at this point.

Maybe there is something to the fact that YOU are jumping on DH's bogus case. I mean, how convenient, right? Easy vote. DH has even said that he is trying to stop "sheeple votes" - so clearly he is just stirring the pot. Yet you jump on it.

Except that all it has done is distract from actual discussion of the actual possible baddies. But, maybe that is the plan.

My eye is still on FH, tbh. Although, I am not ready to vote her atm. Her explanations about the books rang true to me.

Instead, I am now very interested in reywaS. I think he has played this game long enough that him jumping on DH's "case" makes me very suspicious of him.

*vote reywaS*

This is when I *saw* the LT suspicion... like WTF , but I have been proven wrong about that.

S~V~S wrote:YES~!!!!

Bye LT, BIH Grey 1

And i would feel best about Faraday or Devin coming back. They went on Night One which doesn't make them more likely to be civ, but i did not have a good feeling about a few of the others.

I agree. Maybe Illy, maybe chaindeath (less likely on chaindeath, I just found his (her?) third person charming) <3. I did not get the warm fuzzies from Rabs.



Good job guys. I think we're on the right track with these lynches... FH wouldn't be bad next IMO, especially seeing as how she defended FH and definitely did not see herself dying as I don't think she even had more than a few votes, right?

Which brings me to Timmer.... do you know how you didn't die? If I'm not mistaken you had the most votes at the end of the poll (I was keeping a rough count in my head... I could be wrong)

I've got no idea how I survived the lynch, if i had the most votes. I don't even know if I did have the most votes. I'm going to read back over everything tomorrow.

I am making this statement because I have been following along and it's hard to ignore the rising tension in this game. I realize that of late this is the trend in mafia games, but it will never change if we do not deal with our own part we play in the problem. So, after reading everything in this thread I just want to say, stop taking yourselves so seriously! And stop taking this game so seriously! If it pisses you off, step away from the computer, because it is only a game. And stop underhandedly insulting each other's intelligence!! There is not a single person in this game who is stupid. Not one. But there are a bunch of players who approach things differently, see things differently, and draw different conclusions. If you can't handle someone not agreeing with you, then you may want to reconsider playing mafia altogether, because it will happen. Every. Single. Game. Have fun, but at the same time do not intentionally make the game not fun for someone else. Refer to Babb's Law found in my signature please. Learn to shrug stuff off and move on. We want all of you to enjoy yourselves!

In short, chill out already!



This concludes our public service announcement, you may now return to killing each other mercilessly...

P.S. if you have personal issues you want to take out on someone, go over to the Gladiators section, where you can slay each other in combat! What better way to hash it out than that?