Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
Yup, let's do it.thellama73 wrote:Made wrote:Just thought of a good paradox/WIFOM type thingy to screw with mafia. Everyone attempt to solve the puzzle on your own. If you solve it, announce it in thread, so Ganon can figure out who is civvie and who is mafia, If more than 5 people announce they've solved the puzzle, the answer should be posted in thread as it would mean baddies had also solved the puzzle.[/quote
Yeah, and then all three members of the mafia lie and say they've solved it, so when two civvies solve it, they get the answer for free. Great plan.
I'm actually for announcing whether you've solved it. Obviously we know some responses can't be trusted, and I don't think revealing the answer is a good idea because of llama's point. However, announcing could be good.Made wrote:Just thought of a good paradox/WIFOM type thingy to screw with mafia. Everyone attempt to solve the puzzle on your own. If you solve it, announce it in thread, so Ganon can figure out who is civvie and who is mafia, If more than 5 people announce they've solved the puzzle, the answer should be posted in thread as it would mean baddies had also solved the puzzle.
Yes, I am on board with that. I have not yet solved the puzzle, for what it's worth.Russtifinko wrote:I'm actually for announcing whether you've solved it. Obviously we know some responses can't be trusted, and I don't think revealing the answer is a good idea because of llama's point. However, announcing could be good.Made wrote:Just thought of a good paradox/WIFOM type thingy to screw with mafia. Everyone attempt to solve the puzzle on your own. If you solve it, announce it in thread, so Ganon can figure out who is civvie and who is mafia, If more than 5 people announce they've solved the puzzle, the answer should be posted in thread as it would mean baddies had also solved the puzzle.
So llama, and I correct if I say that you are on board to lynch Elo tomorrow and Ninja the day after?
And that's why I wanted a more unanimous lynch.thellama73 wrote:I am so confused.
I can't believe you're trying not to take any blame.thellama73 wrote:I can't believe you guys are trying to blame this one me.
It is possible she's the river monster. I just don't see a single way she could possibly be civ. I'm hoping the river monster is dead, frankly. No offense to them, just that we need as many civs as we can get.Snow Dog wrote:I will vote Elo if that is what everyone wants. But if everyone wants to including Hyrule doesn't that mean that Elo is civ after all?
I think I solved the puzzle. Well i got an answer but I am way from certain
The person who has earned the fewest rupees among the tied is lynched.Elohcin wrote:Epi, what happens if lynch votes are tied?
A tie? How are you going to arrange that?Elohcin wrote:Epi, what happens if lynch votes are tied?
I don't. But it has been something I have been curios about since the beginning of the game and when I asked in PM, Epi said I had to ask in thread to get the answer.Snow Dog wrote:A tie? How are you going to arrange that?Elohcin wrote:Epi, what happens if lynch votes are tied?
Which means (Assuming you're not lying) Mafia don't know the answer to this question until everyone did. That's fun!Elohcin wrote:I don't. But it has been something I have been curios about since the beginning of the game and when I asked in PM, Epi said I had to ask in thread to get the answer.Snow Dog wrote:A tie? How are you going to arrange that?Elohcin wrote:Epi, what happens if lynch votes are tied?
Are we playing with the best mafia team of all time or what the fuck is going on even?Russtifinko wrote:Fair enough. Day 2, no pings. She follows votes because she doesn't like wasting hers.Elohcin wrote:As I said before I see little pings in various people. It is hard to choose between them. However, if you know me, you know I don't like to throw a vote away. So...I will vote Hedge.
Day 3: following Snow Dog (and was busy partying). Again, fair enough. As I said around that time, fairly standard Elo play.Elohcin wrote:As for my vote (which I have to do now) I am going to go ahead and *vote boogs* I think Snow Dogs gut may be right.
Can't help with the puzzle. Again, fair enough I suppose.Elohcin wrote:Bye Boogs.Sorry I was wrong about you.
I have no clue where to start with the labyrinth thing. I am no good with directions.
Day 4. Doesn't suspect anyone, but votes the person everyone suspects. A little weird even for Elo, not to have a single ping by D4.Elohcin wrote:My thoughts are that the baddies are being very discrete because I don't think any of the cases against people are particularly strong, as Snow Dog said. And, on top of that, I am having a hard time finding a case against anyone even though I have reread individual players. But, I believe the strongest case (although not strong) is the one on Sabie. So...that is where my vote will go.
Day 5 and the first ping! Yours truly. No rationale given, except that she doesn't "have good feelings" about me.Elohcin wrote:I went ahead and voted for Russ. I don't have good feelings about him.
The "Yay, no kill." just drips enthusiasm, right?Elohcin wrote:Also, Yay no kill.
I know I have a bad voting record. I was just thinking (at the end of the last day) that I need to stop listening to the "crowd" but it is difficult when I still feel like everyone is playing so civ-like. I have not been in a game where its Day 6 and still I have no great suspicions. It is odd. My biggest suspicion is Russ, but still not crazy convinced.Russtifinko wrote:So since I'm out of town, no time for a case. However, I think Elo needs to be given a much closer look. Mainly because of her really really bad voting record. If anyone cares to look into that I appreciate it, and it's where my vote is going for today.
Note the "everyone is playing so civ-like". Still no major suspicions, except her still unexplained one of me.
Still no reasons for any suspicions. She doesn't suspect anyone, but thinks Made, MR and I are baddie teammates. (Not MM, for the record.)Elohcin wrote:The votes I have cast were based of suspicions that other players have brought up. I just don't see anyone as very suspicious so far. If I were to go with my gut (which is usually right btw) I would say...Russ, MR, and Made are the baddies.I am voting Russ today as I did yesterday.
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 593#p97593
This here is an important post. Elo has decided it is so important that she get a suspicion that she goes back and reads every single player remaining in the game!
Two very important things to note here:
1) She now thinks I seem pretty good again, but is pinged by me too.Elohcin wrote:Russ - He seems to have a lot of helpful things to say. He seems to be trying and coming up with suspicions, however I am not sure that his suspicions have much weight. So, I am pinged by that.
Nothing else to say, unfortunately. Rereading each player didn't really bring about any new pings, but there you go. Maybe you will be encouraged to do your own read through and post on everyone. I know many of us are getting discouraged by lynch results.
2) SHE READ THE ENTIRE GAME OF PLAYERS STILL ALIVE AND HAS NO NEW PINGS AT ALL....on Day 7!!
Still nothing.Elohcin wrote:Made? Russ?Snow Dog wrote:So who is bad?
I'm trying, but this is a difficult game. What do you think SD?
Please explainMade wrote:Holy fuck, Russ is mafia.
But we had tied votes and no one died.Made wrote:Wait just a Damn second, a mafia then exist in the tied vote!?!?!?!
Double checking stuff
I rather stall for time I'll explain it at day, if alive, if dead, it's not too hard to figure out from what've said so far.Snow Dog wrote:Please explainMade wrote:Holy fuck, Russ is mafia.
shame. I need to know now.Made wrote:I rather stall for time I'll explain it at day, if alive, if dead, it's not too hard to figure out from what've said so far.Snow Dog wrote:Please explainMade wrote:Holy fuck, Russ is mafia.
We going an hour earlier or have one of us not adjusted for daylights savings time?Epignosis wrote:You have thirty-five minutes.
My best guess is maybe because no one died in the Dom/Russ lynch? but idk there are other explanations for that as wellSnow Dog wrote:shame. I need to know now.Made wrote:I rather stall for time I'll explain it at day, if alive, if dead, it's not too hard to figure out from what've said so far.Snow Dog wrote:Please explainMade wrote:Holy fuck, Russ is mafia.
I'm not sure I'm willing to ditch faith in Russ now that I've finally abandoned my stubborn suspicion of himI see where you're coming from, I think.Made wrote:Holy fuck, Russ is mafia.
I was kinda hoping you wouldn't admit to that first, so i could say i got it right, then you might say say i got it right too, then i could be like lol psych wrong, Ganon knows now muahaha etcetc.Snow Dog wrote:Yep i gott it wrong
me.
good game guys 
Made wrote:Wait just a Damn second, a mafia then exist in the tied vote!?!?!?!
Double checking stuff
Where is this coming from? I don't see anything indicating that a mafia member has to exist in tied votes. I am not bad, and I had almost definitely earned more rupees than Dom, so I am also confused about why he didn't die.Made wrote:Holy fuck, Russ is mafia.
in thread he hid a the name tag of todd on a post of mine, the point was to go through the game and find this picture.Russtifinko wrote: I don't understand Epi's solution to the riddle.
Giving up?nijuukyugou wrote:Is no one else curious why Eloh would vote herself??
This combined with the fact that She just asked a question in thread that mafia would most likely want to answer to, and most civvie (at least i did) assumed we already had the answer to supports this.thellama73 wrote:Giving up?nijuukyugou wrote:Is no one else curious why Eloh would vote herself??
Can you better explain this? I am not understanding what you are trying to say.Made wrote:This combined with the fact that She just asked a question in thread that mafia would most likely want to answer to, and most civvie (at least i did) assumed we already had the answer to supports this.thellama73 wrote:Giving up?nijuukyugou wrote:Is no one else curious why Eloh would vote herself??
Medicine, but fuck you're right.... With MR being civvie, Bloop as Mafia does make sense if you assume that the liz lynch was bought.Russtifinko wrote:My best guess is she has a shield and think it'll buy time.
We could all vote Blooper if that's the case, I suppose.