Alright friends, here we go!
Bea - Like I have said, I trust Bea quite a lot, and that really scares me.
I mean how can I not when she has that adorable kitty as her icon?! But I have honestly felt that she’s been contributing a lot, and I haven’t seen any reason to question or doubt her so far. From skimming back through her posts, I see that she’s been asking a lot of questions and for clarification which I think is a very good thing, and makes me think she’s a good guy. So yes, she is probably bad since I trust her.
birdwithteeth11 - I kind of haven’t really been paying too much attention to BWT (sorry:() Like Bea, from a quick skim of his posts, he also seems to be contributing quite a bit, and I think he is doing some genuine hunting.
”BWT” wrote:Alright. I won't necessarily vote for Made today. I will take that back. But I REALLY need to think long and hard about this.
I definitely think statements like this, showing that he’s rethinking and similar things point to BWT being good. If he were bad and he knew Made wasn’t then he’d try and jump right on it and not budge. I think questioning yourself and others and trying to figure it all out is exactly what a good guy would do. So I guess I half trust BWT since I haven’t seen anything that would make me not trust him.
Boogs - He has been one of the quieter ones, but I guess I really can’t comment since I’ve been pretty quiet too. I think he’s acting very slightly different from how he acted in Misfits where he was bad, but alone. It’s very possible he’s trying to fly under the radar, but I think it’s more likely that he’s just quiet like I am. I think I’ll wait to hear more from him before making a stronger opinion.
Bullz - I really want to trust Bullz because of the last game, but I know that’s not how these things work. In this game, though, he seems to be adding a lot of opinions and seriously searching for who’s bad. He made some pretty good points against MM in his most recent post that I mostly agree with. I trust him a good amount. More than Boogs and very slightly less than Bea.
To SVS, about the “derail” thing, I commented because I happened to be in the thread at the time and thought I could contribute. I assume it was the same for Bullz? He only replied agreeing with me. Quote for clarity:
Bullzeye wrote:Dana wrote:S~V~S wrote:Made, where did you hear the term "derail"? I searched this thread for derail, derailed & derailing, and The Misfits as well, and no one said it.
Derail is a common word... Like derailing the conversation? I don't think it's that odd for him to have said it.
Yeah... Derail is a widely used metaphor, it's not like it's exclusive to mafia. He could have heard it anywhere and applied it here.
I also thought it was a weird thing to point out/go after since it’s such a commonly used word. I understand you meant in that context, but I didn’t find it odd at all. At the time, I saw it as you trying to pick out anything you could find to target Made some more. I’m not certain that’s the case anymore since you didn’t really stick with it much, but that is what I thought then.
Canucklehead - She made some really good points and came up with a good theory. Even if it turns out that it isn’t true, I think her taking the time to think it through shows that she’s interested in the greater good. I trust her about as much as Bullz.
Dana - Very overwhelmed and confused.
Sorting out thoughts and trying to help as much as possible.
Enrique - Like Bullz, I also want to trust Enrique, but I’m scared to do so without any in-thread evidence. On the other hand, I also don’t have any reason to not trust him. I agree with him about Llama’s case against Made. I feel like it didn’t have much of a basis and though it had some interesting points, it was taken so far that it seemed like the structure behind it didn’t even matter anymore. Enrique seems very genuine, and like he knows what he’s talking about. Even though he is acting a bit differently than how he is when I talk to him normally, I don’t think that means he’s bad.
fingersplints/Spacedaisy - So how do I read people that have been replaced? Do I look at the player before they were replaced? And then the new player after? This is quite confusing. I’m going to hold off on commenting here.
Hedgeowl - People were very suspicious of Hedge and I still don’t completely understand the reasoning. I kind of feel like he was being used as a scapegoat, but I’m not sure. I’m running out of time to make this list before the lynch deadline, so I will revisit Hedge later. At the moment, I don’t see anything too weird.
Juliets - Possibly an unpopular opinion here, but I don’t think Juliets is bad. I feel that the case against her wasn’t extremely strong. She seems to be searching and hunting the best she can, and I don’t think her asking so many questions and not adding her own opinion is a bad thing at all. All civs can do is search for more information, right? I think her asking so many questions makes her seem more like a good guy instead of a bad one.
Keterman/Black Rock - I’ve been trying to keep up with the thread as I make this, so Keter’s posts are really confusing me. What is he talking about?! Also going to figure out this replacing stuff.
Long Con - Like BWT, I also haven’t been paying
too much attention to LC. I know there was some sort of argument with SVS but I didn’t follow that too much, I’ll have to go back and look again.
LoRab/Lizzy - More replacing. Nothing comes to mind at the moment, I will look deeper into them later.
Made - Made, Made, Made. What will we do with you? I am so lost on Made right now. I didn’t trust him last game when I should have, but apparently that was his goal, though I still don’t understand his reasoning for wanting to get himself lynched in Misfits. I know that Made has a very unique way of playing mafia, and well, of doing anything, really. I’m not 100% convinced that he’s bad, but he is pretty suspicious. I will say that he’s acting more like a good guy in this game than he was in the last game, from what I can tell. I don’t know if that means he’s learned from misfits or he’s bad and trying to act similar but less dramatic. I don’t think I would vote for him today, if only to see where he goes.
Metalmarsh - People have brought up a few good points about MM. The most suspicious things I’ve seen so far are the French thing and the Epi thing (was that MM? I think I might be getting confused. Also side note do we know for sure that Epi’s role was a bad one? I didn’t see it in the first post.) I am considering voting for MM, but it would be a half-hearted vote, so I’ll probably hold off until I look through everyone else.
Mister Rearranger - So very suspicious. I am strongly considering voting for MR today, but I also am worried that he’ll turn out to be good. Aaaah I hate calling people out so much. The thing with Juliets asking him for clarification and him pretty much avoiding the question really bothers me. Also from skimming through his posts, he hasn’t seemed to have said very many opinions, though there are a few. I definitely understand “getting off to a slow start” and am willing to wait and see. If he comes back to answer or add more to the conversation, I will definitely reconsider.
Mongoose - I haven’t seen much that would say she(?)’s bad, but I definitely want to look through again because some people are clearly suspicious of her.
nijuukyugou - A pretty quiet player, I’m not too sure what to think. I was pretty sure nijuu was good last game, but she confuses me very very much. I will hold off on searching through posts for a stronger opinion because I’m running out of time.
reywaS - Another quiet one, I think? Either that or I also haven’t paid too much attention to him (also sorry
). I will look into him more soon.
S~V~S - I feel like SVS is acting a tiny bit different than how she was when she was bad. I don’t think I know her (or anyone, really) well enough yet to say that she’s definitely good, but I’m not really suspicious of her. I still have to go back and read the LC/SVS thing, so my opinion might change, but for now, she seems pretty okay.
Thellama73 - I’m pretty suspicious of Llama at the current moment. At first I thought there was no way he could be bad because of that whole argument between Made and him. What bad guy would bring so much attention upon themselves on the very first day? But what if that’s just what he wants us to think?! I found it very odd that he went after Made so strongly, and is still continuing to be very against him. Him wanting to lynch Made just to find out doesn’t sit well with me. I also am extremely curious about what Made’s role is, but I don’t want to take the chance of lynching a good guy just because he was acting a little differently than most. Though I’m also pretty conflicted because he makes a lot of good points that I agree with, like about LC’s question and I think MM? (I know he said something else that I agreed with but I can’t seem to find it right now.) I don’t think I would vote for Llama today but I will be keeping a close eye on him.
Wow this was actually kind of a little bit stressful, it felt like writing an essay right before it’s due.
I will read it more in depth later, I just skimmed.
<- This is my shocked face.