AIM Mafia [Town Wins!]

[Justplayingitcool]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

im not saying its your fault, just that nothing from our chat gave me a reason to townread you and so therefore i'm not convinced that you're town

It did not come across that way to me but okay

[falcon45ca]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

Do you think Dana is town or scum?

Town and that this argument is silly

It's not an argument, but ok.


[VOTE: VOTE JPIC] aubergine

[Justplayingitcool]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

Do you think Dana is town or scum?

Town and that this argument is silly

It's not an argument, but ok.


[VOTE: VOTE JPIC] aubergine

Your reason?

[Dana]

yeah idk if this is vote-worthy i said my suspicion from this was very weak

[Dana]

im worried falcon might be trying to make something bigger out of something very minor? hmm

[falcon45ca]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

@Justplayingitcool Your follow up responses have exacerbated this read.

[Justplayingitcool]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

@Justplayingitcool Your follow up responses have exacerbated this read.

What do you not like about it in detail

[falcon45ca]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

@Justplayingitcool Your follow up responses have exacerbated this read.

What do you not like about it in detail

It feels as tho you're a bit stand-offish, not willing to elaborate. It feels kinda like pulling teeth to get you to talk right now, and explain your take on things.

[Justplayingitcool]

Show me where a) i did not elaborate and b) not explain my take on things

[Justplayingitcool]

Whats my scum motivation from the last page falcon

[Justplayingitcool]

I answered your questions to the best of my ability so I don’t know why you feel like im being stand offish or feeling like you’re getting your teeth pulled by talking to me

[falcon45ca]

ok

How do you feel about Gav's away message? He didn't trust you BTW

yeah i know but i didn't trust him either so its fair i guess. ted seems town enough to me, idk about JPIC i have some weak suspicions

Walk me thru your JPIC suspicions plz

our btsc was kinda lame tbh and i get the sense that mafia might not want to chat too much to not give anything away. i could def be wrong (and probably am) but it just didn't rly inspire any confidence to townread him for me

It takes two to tango

Not elaborating.

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

Not elaborating.


I had to ask follow up questions to these to get to what you meant/intended, which goes to the pulling teeth I mentioned.

[Justplayingitcool]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

Do you think Dana is town or scum?

Town and that this argument is silly

And here are my subsequent posts after the fact. I take it you have issues with these as well?

You asked me a binary question and I gave you an answer to it

[MacDougall]

[VOTE: Falcon] aubergine

[MacDougall]

If Falcon flips town I'll reevaluate. Gavial dying after playing the way he was isn't a reason to reevaluate nor is it a reason to instantly push on me Tedxtr. I was pushing elsewhere. Nanook asked me to stop and told me he'd tunnel whoever I asked him to if I just let Gavial go over.

If you haven't bothered to use the thread then don't make pushes.

[falcon45ca]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

I don’t care. I just think it’s disingenuous

You think Dana's perspective on your BTSC is disingenuous?

Im saying that there was an equal amount of communication from both sides. Yes we didn’t talk much but I don’t think it’s fair to pin that all on me

Do you think Dana is town or scum?

Town and that this argument is silly

And here are my subsequent posts after the fact. I take it you have issues with these as well?

You asked me a binary question and I gave you an answer to it

Pretty sure I already said I had to ask follow up questions to your original responses. I had no issue with your follow up responses, more so that I had to prod you to get said responses. As I've already mentioned, not elaborating, felt like pulling teeth.

[Justplayingitcool]

So your scumread on me was determined before I had even made my response to elaborate. alright then

[Dana]

If Falcon flips town I'll reevaluate. Gavial dying after playing the way he was isn't a reason to reevaluate nor is it a reason to instantly push on me Tedxtr. I was pushing elsewhere. Nanook asked me to stop and told me he'd tunnel whoever I asked him to if I just let Gavial go over.

If you haven't bothered to use the thread then don't make pushes.

how would you feel about voting sean instead of falcon today?

[falcon45ca]

When Falcon flips town I'll reevaluate. Gavial dying after playing the way he was isn't a reason to reevaluate nor is it a reason to instantly push on me Tedxtr. I was pushing elsewhere. Nanook asked me to stop and told me he'd tunnel whoever I asked him to if I just let Gavial go over.

If you haven't bothered to use the thread then don't make pushes.

FTFY.

Haha, ok. Whatever you say. Ironically you say you'll reevaluate on my green flip, but not on Gav's.

[Dana]

also who's good at math, how many mislynches to we have left? 2?

[falcon45ca]

So your scumread on me was determined before I had even made my response to elaborate. alright then

That's not what I said, and you know it.

[Justplayingitcool]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

@Justplayingitcool Your follow up responses have exacerbated this read.

This implies you disliked my follow up responses that you literally just said you had no problem with

[TonyStarkPrime]

also who's good at math, how many mislynches to we have left? 2?

3, derp attempt denied but you’re town anyways probably so I guess derp attempt accepted

[TonyStarkPrime]

Update: TSP is bad at counting

[TonyStarkPrime]

2 until lylo

[Justplayingitcool]

TSP literally trying to derp clear

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

[Dana]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

[falcon45ca]

JPIC starting to ping me w/ his responses re: Dana's BTSC with him

@Justplayingitcool Your follow up responses have exacerbated this read.

This implies you disliked my follow up responses that you literally just said you had no problem with

Your original follow up responses to Dana's chat persprctive, not the follow up responses to my suspicion of you. Sorry, I could've worded it better

[falcon45ca]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

[MacDougall]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

[MacDougall]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

[MacDougall]

That post actually makes me so angry. I hate playing mafia sometimes holy shit.

[MacDougall]

"What has Mac done that's yieled positive results for town"?

What has ANYONE done?

"Which maf has he helped us lynch?"

Who has anyone!?

it is taking all my strength not to lose my shit...

[MacDougall]

Check out bastion of town awesomeness Falcon. Look at all his incredibly pro town play. Look at all the mafia that lay waste before him.

Honestly. Get the fuck out.

[falcon45ca]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

I'm not trying to blame you for where we sit right now, I'm just trying to say that there's no results that should give anyone cause to just lock town someone, which Nanook seems ok to do with you.

If you're town, are you OK with Nanook just lock stepping with you pushing my death given he asked you to drop solving outside of Gav?

[falcon45ca]

"What has Mac done that's yieled positive results for town"?

What has ANYONE done?

"Which maf has he helped us lynch?"

Who has anyone!?

it is taking all my strength not to lose my shit...

Exactly. Which is why it's ridiculous for Nanook to just lock step w/ you

[MacDougall]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

I'm not trying to blame you for where we sit right now, I'm just trying to say that there's no results that should give anyone cause to just lock town someone, which Nanook seems ok to do with you.

If you're town, are you OK with Nanook just lock stepping with you pushing my death given he asked you to drop solving outside of Gav?

Well for a start everyone that has bothered to have a private chat with me has come out of it town reading me including people who were suspecting me before them ie. Seanzie and JPIC.

So perhaps if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

You are scummy in a range of ways, including POE.

Nanook arriving at "we need to clear Gavial for the greater good" and asking me to just drop it for the day is not suspicious because I had similar thoughts that I had shared with Seanzie in private chat even. Seanzie also had similar thoughts.

Nanook is as suspicious as anyone in the game in that there is PROBABLY at least one wolf that is being widely town read. There is nothing particularly scummy about him moreso than anyone else, and from my point of view Nanook just going with the flow and chopping through a POE I largely agree with and not humouring tinfoil on me is fine.

[MacDougall]

"What has Mac done that's yieled positive results for town"?

What has ANYONE done?

"Which maf has he helped us lynch?"

Who has anyone!?

it is taking all my strength not to lose my shit...

Exactly. Which is why it's ridiculous for Nanook to just lock step w/ you

Gotta chop someone. I've been more towny than you. Describing it as lockstep is pretty disingenuous.

[falcon45ca]

We have four kills

Falcon is one

Sean and jpic probably

Nobody else really inspires me, we'll figure it out

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

I'm not trying to blame you for where we sit right now, I'm just trying to say that there's no results that should give anyone cause to just lock town someone, which Nanook seems ok to do with you.

If you're town, are you OK with Nanook just lock stepping with you pushing my death given he asked you to drop solving outside of Gav?

Well for a start everyone that has bothered to have a private chat with me has come out of it town reading me including people who were suspecting me before them ie. Seanzie and JPIC.

So perhaps if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

You are scummy in a range of ways, including POE.

Nanook arriving at "we need to clear Gavial for the greater good" and asking me to just drop it for the day is not suspicious because I had similar thoughts that I had shared with Seanzie in private chat even. Seanzie also had similar thoughts.

Nanook is as suspicious as anyone in the game in that there is PROBABLY at least one wolf that is being widely town read. There is nothing particularly scummy about him moreso than anyone else, and from my point of view Nanook just going with the flow and chopping through a POE I largely agree with and not humouring tinfoil on me is fine.

What does your game state look like assuming I am town?

[falcon45ca]

"What has Mac done that's yieled positive results for town"?

What has ANYONE done?

"Which maf has he helped us lynch?"

Who has anyone!?

it is taking all my strength not to lose my shit...

Exactly. Which is why it's ridiculous for Nanook to just lock step w/ you

Gotta chop someone. I've been more towny than you. Describing it as lockstep is pretty disingenuous.

Well, given that Nanook seems to be doing it because you're doing it, I'd say lockstep is pretty apt. There are other choices, it's not as tho its a choice between only 2

[MacDougall]

how sure are you about falcon?

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

I'm not trying to blame you for where we sit right now, I'm just trying to say that there's no results that should give anyone cause to just lock town someone, which Nanook seems ok to do with you.

If you're town, are you OK with Nanook just lock stepping with you pushing my death given he asked you to drop solving outside of Gav?

Well for a start everyone that has bothered to have a private chat with me has come out of it town reading me including people who were suspecting me before them ie. Seanzie and JPIC.

So perhaps if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

You are scummy in a range of ways, including POE.

Nanook arriving at "we need to clear Gavial for the greater good" and asking me to just drop it for the day is not suspicious because I had similar thoughts that I had shared with Seanzie in private chat even. Seanzie also had similar thoughts.

Nanook is as suspicious as anyone in the game in that there is PROBABLY at least one wolf that is being widely town read. There is nothing particularly scummy about him moreso than anyone else, and from my point of view Nanook just going with the flow and chopping through a POE I largely agree with and not humouring tinfoil on me is fine.

What does your game state look like assuming I am town?

Marmot + TSP probably.

[falcon45ca]

Well, I promised Joseph id help him kill falcon, and tbh I do think he's been kind of scummy, so

Confident enough to push it!

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

I'm not trying to blame you for where we sit right now, I'm just trying to say that there's no results that should give anyone cause to just lock town someone, which Nanook seems ok to do with you.

If you're town, are you OK with Nanook just lock stepping with you pushing my death given he asked you to drop solving outside of Gav?

Well for a start everyone that has bothered to have a private chat with me has come out of it town reading me including people who were suspecting me before them ie. Seanzie and JPIC.

So perhaps if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

You are scummy in a range of ways, including POE.

Nanook arriving at "we need to clear Gavial for the greater good" and asking me to just drop it for the day is not suspicious because I had similar thoughts that I had shared with Seanzie in private chat even. Seanzie also had similar thoughts.

Nanook is as suspicious as anyone in the game in that there is PROBABLY at least one wolf that is being widely town read. There is nothing particularly scummy about him moreso than anyone else, and from my point of view Nanook just going with the flow and chopping through a POE I largely agree with and not humouring tinfoil on me is fine.

What does your game state look like assuming I am town?

Marmot + TSP probably.

What's your read on TSP?

[MacDougall]

That's a pretty shallow reason to push me. Is Joe Mac? Tell me, what can we say that Mac has done that's yielded positive results for the town? Which Maf has he helped us lynch?

This is a pretty unfair way to play the game if you're town Falcon. I am not responsible for either of the lynches. I didn't promote the day 1 sleepwalk and in fact I opposed it. I also was solving outside of the Gavial sleepwalk until Nanook asked me to drop it.

I'm not trying to blame you for where we sit right now, I'm just trying to say that there's no results that should give anyone cause to just lock town someone, which Nanook seems ok to do with you.

If you're town, are you OK with Nanook just lock stepping with you pushing my death given he asked you to drop solving outside of Gav?

Well for a start everyone that has bothered to have a private chat with me has come out of it town reading me including people who were suspecting me before them ie. Seanzie and JPIC.

So perhaps if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

You are scummy in a range of ways, including POE.

Nanook arriving at "we need to clear Gavial for the greater good" and asking me to just drop it for the day is not suspicious because I had similar thoughts that I had shared with Seanzie in private chat even. Seanzie also had similar thoughts.

Nanook is as suspicious as anyone in the game in that there is PROBABLY at least one wolf that is being widely town read. There is nothing particularly scummy about him moreso than anyone else, and from my point of view Nanook just going with the flow and chopping through a POE I largely agree with and not humouring tinfoil on me is fine.

What does your game state look like assuming I am town?

Marmot + TSP probably.

What's your read on TSP?

He's been pretty town mostly by virtue of consistently just noping pushes on me.

[TonyStarkPrime]

mac talk to me about ted

[MacDougall]

mac talk to me about ted

What's to say? He's been tunneling me for days and I am town. I thought he found me town yesterday but then I'm supposed to believe that because Gavial, someone almost everyone agreed was POE flips town that I am outed mafia. He's playing terribly and should be POE for it but I also don't like to just assume such things.

[TonyStarkPrime]

mac is your poe just people who are calling you mafia

[MacDougall]

mac is your poe just people who are calling you mafia

That's a pretty dumb thing to say given what I just said about Ted.

[TonyStarkPrime]

He's playing terribly and should be POE