Misfits Mafia (END GAME)

#251

Canucklehead wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Canucklehead wrote:Yowza. Chattiness explosion.

I'm not super inclined to put too much stock into Day 0 actions as far as baddie hunting goes...I'm not sure the baddie teams would really risk drawing attention to themselves in order to get a title that, for all we know, might be a detriment rather than a boon to their gameplan. If I'm going to be trying to find baddies based on Day 0 actions, I'm much more inclined to be looking for people who were shirking the vote/not trying to be named leader/being overly effusive about "thinking it through" and "making the right choice for the town"...
However, I don't really have time to do a Day 0 read right now, so I'll just leave that for someone else to do if they desire. Long story short, I don't think Sorsha's puppy campaign really paints her in a baddie light. As for SVS, I'm more on the fence. It didn't stand out to me at the time, and I'm not sure if the case against SVS works if I don't also think Sorsha is bad, so I dunno.
Glad to see lots of talking, though.....even if it means I'm going to have a terrible time keeping up!

DH: Is there anything that you can tell us about what your duties as leader are? I'm guessing the host has forbidden it, but just in case..

Linki linki linki......
Good job puppies don't enter into my suspicions of Sorsha then. Do you really not see her painting herself as an obvious civvie as suspicious in any way? I can sort of see what you're saying about day zero actions but at the same time if you come into day one ignoring day zero then it may as well not have happened.
I think the post you're responding to actually contains the response to you (rhetorical? can't tell) question. No, I do not find Sorsha's Day 0 actions suspicious.

As for ignoring Day 0, I am defintely inclined to do that, in this game and in most games. I'm also often inclined to ignore Day 1, Day 2, Day 3, Day 4.....

Hmmmmm.....I actually might not really understand how mafia works...

Legit question, not rhetorical. I'm genuinely curious about other people's suspicions of basically anyone at all. Like I think Sorsha is suspicious for her actions but if every single other player were to turn around and call me an idiot for thinking it then I might be inclined to reconsider. Why ignore day zero though? I get what you say about baddies taking risks and stuff but it has happened several times. I screwed up big time in Pokemon mafia on Hedville by pushing my baddie team's day zero option too strongly and I'm not the only person to ever have done that.

#252

Epignosis wrote:Certainly feels like one of those Day 1s where people will just vote near the end without much reason beyond "randomized" or "didn't want to miss the vote."

Don't want to miss the vote.
*Randomized*

My suspicion coming shortly---

#253

Hey Roxy-

#254

Roxy wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Certainly feels like one of those Day 1s where people will just vote near the end without much reason beyond "randomized" or "didn't want to miss the vote."
Don't want to miss the vote.
*Randomized*

My suspicion coming shortly---

Made me check the poll then to see who you'd randomly voted for! :P

#255

I wonder how many missed votes there will be.

#256

I'm gonna vote for Sorsha now. Apart from the evidence against her, she did not seem all that interested in defending herself.

As a side note, I'm obviously hoping that this is not the case, but if Sorsha flips civvie it will be the funniest thing to happen in mafia since Ambray outed her entire team.

#257

Just out of curiosity, DH, would S~V~S have been your second choice if you got two votes?

#258

Epignosis wrote:Just out of curiosity, DH, would S~V~S have been your second choice if you got two votes?

Her, maybe hedgeowl, maybe boogs, IDK.

#259

Epignosis wrote:I wonder how many missed votes there will be.

None, hopefully. Nine, pessimistically. I shall be an optimist for once and hope the majority of players get in to vote before the deadline.

DharmaHelper wrote:I'm gonna vote for Sorsha now. Apart from the evidence against her, she did not seem all that interested in defending herself.

As a side note, I'm obviously hoping that this is not the case, but if Sorsha flips civvie it will be the funniest thing to happen in mafia since Ambray outed her entire team.

This happened? How did I miss that?

#260

DharmaHelper wrote:
Boogs wrote:This game is cray cray lol. I am off today trying to catch up and I don't know what to make of everything lol. I'm not sure to continue thinking Sorsha for the Day 0 vote was really her playing dumb or if she was really just confused. And I'm not sure what to make of SVS voting for her, I think it's ballsy that early to vote for a teammate when most of us were self voting. But it looked like DH won? I don't see the poll so I must have missed before it ended. Because if people wanted to bring up that maybe SVS was in cahoots with Sorsha, then wouldn't the same be said for DH voters? If anyone has the poll results that would help us all
I was waiting for this redirection.

I agree it looks as if Boogs was trying to redirect suspicion to you and your voters. Very nose twitching.

Hedgeowl wrote:Alrighty then this is a chatty game! Honestly, I read the Sorsha SVS Puppygate as the hilarious Day 0 event that it was and nothing more. I would look at Sorsha the most for being so Gungho about wanting to be a leader, but yeah SVS even shared pics of her dog and cat, so obviously this got "personal" I would say and would definitely not be the SVS baddie strategy some of us are used to.

Hedgeowl wrote:<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<snipsy of over-quoting>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Basically, I think it's pretty funny that one of her claims to be voted the leader was that she is so easy to read, which is one of the reason people are "reading" her as a potential baddie. I haven't decided myself how I feel about her since I also am a big fan of puppies.

Seems you are one of "people" "reading" her as a potential baddie you said as much in your first post. You seem to like straddling the fence here.

You first say you would "look at Sorsha" for being gung-ho then you say it is a reason "people" are "reading" her as a baddie. Then you say you haven't decided how you feel.

Seems to me you have made your mind up yet you want to leave yourself an out.

Hedge's posts here feel slippery to me. Its what I am looking at today and my gut and nose twitches make me think I am right.

Epignosis wrote:Hey Roxy-

#261

Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.

#262

Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.

Oh really? Since when? :P

I feel similarly, Sorsha is my primary target but I'd like to give her a chance to respond to my opinions before I vote.

#263

Also -

@Bullz

#264

Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.
Oh really? Since when? :P

Like, since forever ago.

#265

Epignosis wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.
Oh really? Since when? :P
Like, since forever ago.

Practically the most modest player in the game as well right?

#266

Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.
Oh really? Since when? :P
Like, since forever ago.
Practically the most modest player in the game as well right?

Maybe.

#267

inre: to other suspicions -

Sorsha - I did not like how she came out begging for votes. I said I would not vote for anyone "begging" for votes. If people do not think baddies would put themselves out there like this they are crazy

I put a hammer vote onto my poll choice to ensure I got a second recruit quickly when I was playing the Ultra-Morph in LC and BR's recruitment game on RM. So it does happen - even by people you don't think would do that as a baddie. Her defense has left a lot to be desired. I mean "people are going to see what they want to see" is not really a defense imo.

SVS - I am horrible at reading her but I really am much more suspicious of Sorsha than SVS. Her defense that she had limited time and put her focus on Fight Club was easily looked at and confirmed (by myself looking and checking). Yet she has not come out with any of her own suspicions and that is what twitched my nose about SVS. I will admit I am riding the fence here a bit but tbh I do not feel the gut reaction to her posts that I felt with Hedgeowl or Boogs for that matter.

linky- just agree you both <3 each other and hug it out

#268

Question time! Where is everyone? Who are you all suspicious of/going to vote for and why?

#269

Bullz, Epi -neither of you have anything thing to say or add about my Hedgeowl post?

#270

Roxy wrote:Bullz, Epi -neither of you have anything thing to say or add about my Hedgeowl post?

Nothing at the moment. I'm thinking it over, promise.

#271

Roxy wrote:inre: to other suspicions -

Sorsha - I did not like how she came out begging for votes. I said I would not vote for anyone "begging" for votes. If people do not think baddies would put themselves out there like this they are crazy I put a hammer vote onto my poll choice to ensure I got a second recruit quickly when I was playing the Ultra-Morph in LC and BR's recruitment game on RM. So it does happen - even by people you don't think would do that as a baddie. Her defense has left a lot to be desired. I mean "people are going to see what they want to see" is not really a defense imo.

SVS - I am horrible at reading her but I really am much more suspicious of Sorsha than SVS. Her defense that she had limited time and put her focus on Fight Club was easily looked at and confirmed (by myself looking and checking). Yet she has not come out with any of her own suspicions and that is what twitched my nose about SVS. I will admit I am riding the fence here a bit but tbh I do not feel the gut reaction to her posts that I felt with Hedgeowl or Boogs for that matter.

linky- just agree you both <3 each other and hug it out

Roxy, we're just playing :P He knows he's my favourite Epignosis on the entire internet. For some reason I didn't get linki on this post but there you go. Thanks for your contributions, I think your point about Sorsha's defense is very damning for her really.

Linki - I will take a look now and get back to you!

#272

Roxy wrote:
Seems you are one of "people" "reading" her as a potential baddie you said as much in your first post. You seem to like straddling the fence here.

You first say you would "look at Sorsha" for being gung-ho then you say it is a reason "people" are "reading" her as a baddie. Then you say you haven't decided how you feel.

Seems to me you have made your mind up yet you want to leave yourself an out.

Hedge's posts here feel slippery to me. Its what I am looking at today and my gut and nose twitches make me think I am right.

Seems like you make some decent points here. She definitely seems to be both accusing and not accusing Sorsha at the same time if you see what I mean. Sort of like you said, she's trying to leave herself an out almost while still saying Sorsha stands a chance of being bad. Slipping in and out of suspicion so if she votes Sorsha then she can either say yay I helped lynch a baddie or oh well I was never really that suspicious of her to start with.

#273

Epignosis wrote:
Roxy wrote:Bullz, Epi -neither of you have anything thing to say or add about my Hedgeowl post?
Nothing at the moment. I'm thinking it over, promise.

is that a real promise or a "plomise"? LOL

Bullzeye wrote:
Roxy wrote:inre: to other suspicions -

Sorsha - I did not like how she came out begging for votes. I said I would not vote for anyone "begging" for votes. If people do not think baddies would put themselves out there like this they are crazy I put a hammer vote onto my poll choice to ensure I got a second recruit quickly when I was playing the Ultra-Morph in LC and BR's recruitment game on RM. So it does happen - even by people you don't think would do that as a baddie. Her defense has left a lot to be desired. I mean "people are going to see what they want to see" is not really a defense imo.

SVS - I am horrible at reading her but I really am much more suspicious of Sorsha than SVS. Her defense that she had limited time and put her focus on Fight Club was easily looked at and confirmed (by myself looking and checking). Yet she has not come out with any of her own suspicions and that is what twitched my nose about SVS. I will admit I am riding the fence here a bit but tbh I do not feel the gut reaction to her posts that I felt with Hedgeowl or Boogs for that matter.

linky- just agree you both <3 each other and hug it out
Roxy, we're just playing :P He knows he's my favourite Epignosis on the entire internet. For some reason I didn't get linki on this post but there you go. Thanks for your contributions, I think your point about Sorsha's defense is very damning for her really.

Linki - I will take a look now and get back to you!

hahhaa I knew that hence my use of the

smiley

#274

On an unrelated note, Robin Williams hanged himself with a belt after his wife went to bed.

https://celebrity.yahoo.com/blogs/celeb ... 08746.html

#275

Roxy wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Roxy wrote:Bullz, Epi -neither of you have anything thing to say or add about my Hedgeowl post?
Nothing at the moment. I'm thinking it over, promise.
is that a real promise or a "plomise"? LOL

Promise. I've never heard of a "plomise."

#276

Why are you bumming this thread out

also I heard that this morning and it is quite sad especially for his wife

linky - a plomise is something I used to say to my parents when I did not promise but wanted them to think I did. Its a non-promise

#277

Quote="Roxy"]Why are you bumming this thread out

also I heard that this morning and it is quite sad especially for his wife

linky - a plomise is something I used to say to my parents when I did not promise but wanted them to think I did. Its a non-promise

[/quote]

Sorry.

Did you ever get away with your "plomises?"

#278

Royally screwed up those quotes.

#279

Epignosis wrote:Royally screwed up those quotes.

That's very true. You somehow managed to capitalise the first Q in the quote tag as well even though they're lowercase by default :P

#280

Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Royally screwed up those quotes.
That's very true. You somehow managed to capitalise the first Q in the quote tag as well even though they're lowercase by default :P

So I did.

#281

Epignosis wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Royally screwed up those quotes.
That's very true. You somehow managed to capitalise the first Q in the quote tag as well even though they're lowercase by default :P
So I did.

Unfortunate mistake. I wonder when everyone else is going to show up? I feel like the three of us posting have sort of said everything there is to say that's on topic. We need more people to come and join the conversation, lovely as the current company in here is.

#282

Epi -Yes all my plomises worked. My parents never knew or caught on until I told them after I had my first son years later hahaha

#283

DharmaHelper wrote:I'm gonna vote for Sorsha now. Apart from the evidence against her, she did not seem all that interested in defending herself.

As a side note, I'm obviously hoping that this is not the case, but if Sorsha flips civvie it will be the funniest thing to happen in mafia since Ambray outed her entire team.

And how exactly is lynching a civvie on day one funny?

This post makes me think that you know that I AM a civvie you just don't care. Get over it DH..... you won the day 0 poll AND I'm willing to bet you aren't a good guy this game.

#284

The thing about Hedgeowl is that I don't think I've ever been right a single time about her. I've read her posts twice. I do see what you're saying, although it's not enough to make me abandon my current suspect in order to vote for her. One thing I do wonder is if Hedgeowl is gunning for high posters as she has in previous games. If so, I may be in jeopardy.

#285

Sorsha wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:I'm gonna vote for Sorsha now. Apart from the evidence against her, she did not seem all that interested in defending herself.

As a side note, I'm obviously hoping that this is not the case, but if Sorsha flips civvie it will be the funniest thing to happen in mafia since Ambray outed her entire team.
And how exactly is lynching a civvie on day one funny?

This post makes me think that you know that I AM a civvie you just don't care. Get over it DH..... you won the day 0 poll AND I'm willing to bet you aren't a good guy this game.

Very strange response here. What does him winning the day zero poll have to do with anything? How can he possibly know you're a civvie? Even if he's bad, there's another baddie team plus a probable indy. This makes little sense.

#286

Sorsha wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:I'm gonna vote for Sorsha now. Apart from the evidence against her, she did not seem all that interested in defending herself.

As a side note, I'm obviously hoping that this is not the case, but if Sorsha flips civvie it will be the funniest thing to happen in mafia since Ambray outed her entire team.
And how exactly is lynching a civvie on day one funny?

This post makes me think that you know that I AM a civvie you just don't care. Get over it DH..... you won the day 0 poll AND I'm willing to bet you aren't a good guy this game.

It would be funny because you insisted that you are easy to read.

#287

DharmaHelper wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:I'm gonna vote for Sorsha now. Apart from the evidence against her, she did not seem all that interested in defending herself.

As a side note, I'm obviously hoping that this is not the case, but if Sorsha flips civvie it will be the funniest thing to happen in mafia since Ambray outed her entire team.
And how exactly is lynching a civvie on day one funny?

This post makes me think that you know that I AM a civvie you just don't care. Get over it DH..... you won the day 0 poll AND I'm willing to bet you aren't a good guy this game.

It would be funny because you insisted that you are easy to read.

When you said you were going to vote for Sorsha, did you literally mean right then? It's just I noticed you haven't actually voted yet.

Sorsha, who are you likely to vote for today and why?

#288

Check the poll again Bullz :P

#289

Until I hear what S~V~S has to say, I won't vote.

#290

Xenon, Neon, and Argon walk into a bar. The barman says "Get out, we don't serve noble gases here!". The three elements don't react.

Just thought I'd share a little chemistry joke for no reason in particular!

DharmaHelper wrote:Check the poll again Bullz :P

Haha, did you just do that or am I stupid and somehow failed to notice?

#291

Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.
Oh really? Since when? :P

I feel similarly, Sorsha is my primary target but I'd like to give her a chance to respond to my opinions before I vote.

Bullz- You have seemed to have made up your mind about me anyway so I'm going to give my fingers a break and not go over every point you've made about me. You are wrong, get me lynched and you'll see I'm right.

#292

Bullzeye wrote:Xenon, Neon, and Argon walk into a bar. The barman says "Get out, we don't serve noble gases here!". The three elements don't react.

Just thought I'd share a little chemistry joke for no reason in particular!

DharmaHelper wrote:Check the poll again Bullz :P
Haha, did you just do that or am I stupid and somehow failed to notice?

Vote? He did it over an hour ago.

#293

Sorsha wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.
Oh really? Since when? :P

I feel similarly, Sorsha is my primary target but I'd like to give her a chance to respond to my opinions before I vote.
Bullz- You have seemed to have made up your mind about me anyway so I'm going to give my fingers a break and not go over every point you've made about me. You are wrong, get me lynched and you'll see I'm right.

You say I've made up my mind but I've been clear about the fact I wanted to wait for you to respond. You could talk me out of it if you had a reasonable defense and perhaps a good case against someone else.

Linki - yeah I must be crazy then. I looked at the poll right before I posted and it looked like nobody had any votes other than the host option.

#294

What gives me pause about Sorsha is her lack of defense. Wouldn't her team encourage her to fight back if she were bad?

#295

Clearly, I should have caught up sooner. I wont have much time till an hour from now, but just catching up. I think you misread my first comment roxy, but no worries. bbl.

#296

Sorsha wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Keterman's big post on S~V~S, combined with what I've said, makes S~V~S my primary choice for today, but I can wait to vote and see what she has to say. I'm a nice guy.
Oh really? Since when? :P

I feel similarly, Sorsha is my primary target but I'd like to give her a chance to respond to my opinions before I vote.
Bullz- You have seemed to have made up your mind about me anyway so I'm going to give my fingers a break and not go over every point you've made about me. You are wrong, get me lynched and you'll see I'm right.

Sorsha - how would you feel if you made a case and awaited a response to get this type of post?

#297

Hedgeowl wrote:Clearly, I should have caught up sooner. I wont have much time till an hour from now, but just catching up. I think you misread my first comment roxy, but no worries. bbl.

Hard to misread a few sentences tbh but ok

#298

Hedgeowl wrote:Clearly, I should have caught up sooner. I wont have much time till an hour from now, but just catching up. I think you misread my first comment roxy, but no worries. bbl.

Xyloid positions in Mafia can be dangerous. It's nice when people can be flexible.

#299

Epignosis wrote:What gives me pause about Sorsha is her lack of defense. Wouldn't her team encourage her to fight back if she were bad?

Zip over to half the games where I've been bad and caught out and take a quick look at my posts. I do that kind of "oh you've made your mind up just kill me already" when I'm a baddie and can't think of how to defend myself. I've done it as a neutral as well and very rarely as a civ. When people post like that it makes me suspect them more.

#300

Epignosis wrote:What gives me pause about Sorsha is her lack of defense. Wouldn't her team encourage her to fight back if she were bad?

I have never had teammates tell me how to play or defend. I have never told my teammates how to play or defend. Have you?

Who's next?