Re: Mafia: A World Reborn Game Thread - Day 7
Posted: Tue Nov 17, 2015 3:17 pm
Let me go back and read that. When Canuck was lynched right?
Murder, Mayhem, and Mafia
https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/
Despite never changing my style, I get lynched based on my in thread play all the time.MacDougall wrote:DFaraday, we lynched him in Dune and he flipped civ despite scum slips and other assorted obvscum behaviour. I played scum with him in TH and he played the same. I don't think you can lynch him on his in thread play. He is also real life friends with Luke and they are both totally new to the game.DFaraday wrote:Affinity for Luke, vote for Nutella, Tranq's convenient death, coached-sounding comments...Golden wrote: Why do people think Floyd is bad?
Although I am starting to think there may be something to the Juliets case, if for no other reason than she's somehow gotten out of being lynched despite being the top discussion point for this long. Still, I feel more strongly about Floyd.
What do you mean by Tranq's convenient death? Can you please point out the coached-sounding comments?
I do think Floyd is scum too, but I think you are opposing scum...
Here Tranq points out that, for a new player, Floyd seems curiously knowledgeable about what constitutes a suspicious reason.Tranq wrote:Floyd, i went through your posts, looks like you started playing mafia roughly 1 month ago. What do you mean when you say "a vague reason is always a suspicious reason"? The always part. This doesn't seem like something a relatively new player would say.TheFloyd73 wrote: My point is that a vague reason is always a suspicious reason.
I'm feeling ok with a vote on Floyd today.
I have responded to everything I can respond to. For all of those saying it's my tone or something similar there's not a lot I can say about that except I have the same tone every game, whether I'm good or bad. It's a mistake to use my tone as the reason to vote me. Many of the people who are doing that haven't played with me before or haven't played with me for a long time. Not all but many. So I dont want to repeat myself over and over. And as for finding baddies, anything I pointed out would be seen immediately with suspicion just because it's me who's pointing it out, or worst case, i would point out some baddie behavior and everyone would think they were civv.Turnip Head wrote:C'mon mang I can't hold your hand. Look at her posts from the past couple of cycles and tell me if it feels like a civvie in danger, or a baddie lying just low enough until she can squeak by with some vote trickery.
I don't think that's true, in fact it's only really true if you are lynched and flip baddie.juliets wrote:And as for finding baddies, anything I pointed out would be seen immediately with suspicion just because it's me who's pointing it out, or worst case, i would point out some baddie behavior and everyone would think they were civv.
At the time I did not. Since then Mac has spread so many hints around I think I might know. As he said in his hints, and I'm paraphrasing, it was not me that caused him to be lynched.LoRab wrote:Really? You have no idea why you weren't lycnhed? I find that hard to believe.
How about why you and k-nuk were tied? Do you not know that, either?juliets wrote:At the time I did not. Since then Mac has spread so many hints around I think I might know. As he said in his hints, and I'm paraphrasing, it was not me that caused him to be lynched.LoRab wrote:Really? You have no idea why you weren't lycnhed? I find that hard to believe.
No I don't know why me and canuck were tied. And I also have no idea why Mac was a candidate. I know I voted for him because I was trying to save myself, but why everyone else did I have no idea. They said it was because he was asking for votes which I still don't understand.LoRab wrote:How about why you and k-nuk were tied? Do you not know that, either?juliets wrote:At the time I did not. Since then Mac has spread so many hints around I think I might know. As he said in his hints, and I'm paraphrasing, it was not me that caused him to be lynched.LoRab wrote:Really? You have no idea why you weren't lycnhed? I find that hard to believe.
And Mac has more hinted why he survived the lynch, not why he was the candidate. And if both of you are bad, then, well, I'm not sure I believe him, either.
Well I do think it's true.Turnip Head wrote:I don't think that's true, in fact it's only really true if you are lynched and flip baddie.juliets wrote:And as for finding baddies, anything I pointed out would be seen immediately with suspicion just because it's me who's pointing it out, or worst case, i would point out some baddie behavior and everyone would think they were civv.This feels like a copout answer juliets. You're saying you aren't looking for baddies because people suspect you.
I can only say why I voted for him, and I've explained my suspicion.juliets wrote:No I don't know why me and canuck were tied. And I also have no idea why Mac was a candidate. I know I voted for him because I was trying to save myself, but why everyone else did I have no idea. They said it was because he was asking for votes which I still don't understand.LoRab wrote:How about why you and k-nuk were tied? Do you not know that, either?juliets wrote:At the time I did not. Since then Mac has spread so many hints around I think I might know. As he said in his hints, and I'm paraphrasing, it was not me that caused him to be lynched.LoRab wrote:Really? You have no idea why you weren't lycnhed? I find that hard to believe.
And Mac has more hinted why he survived the lynch, not why he was the candidate. And if both of you are bad, then, well, I'm not sure I believe him, either.
Hey Juliets. Y'know alignment is revealed on death right? If you are civ, you should try to baddie hunt regardless of lynch position. We will see the connections post mortem, so the only situation where you wouldn't want to establish those connections are if you are bad...juliets wrote:I have responded to everything I can respond to. For all of those saying it's my tone or something similar there's not a lot I can say about that except I have the same tone every game, whether I'm good or bad. It's a mistake to use my tone as the reason to vote me. Many of the people who are doing that haven't played with me before or haven't played with me for a long time. Not all but many. So I dont want to repeat myself over and over. And as for finding baddies, anything I pointed out would be seen immediately with suspicion just because it's me who's pointing it out, or worst case, i would point out some baddie behavior and everyone would think they were civv.Turnip Head wrote:C'mon mang I can't hold your hand. Look at her posts from the past couple of cycles and tell me if it feels like a civvie in danger, or a baddie lying just low enough until she can squeak by with some vote trickery.
So I don't know what else you want me to say. I see no reason why I wouldn't be lynched today and to whoever said it earlier today (Mac I think) I had no idea Mac would be lynched.
Well now I just feel badTheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.
Why's that?Draconus wrote:Well now I just feel badTheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.
I've been tunneling you.TheFloyd73 wrote:Why's that?Draconus wrote:Well now I just feel badTheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.
I've got exams happening at the moment, having oppressed memories constantly and (song)writer's block.Draconus wrote:I've been tunneling you.TheFloyd73 wrote:Why's that?Draconus wrote:Well now I just feel badTheFloyd73 wrote:I apologise for not paying much attention. I'm voting Juliet's for the moment, but if someone wants to replace me, that's perfectly fine.
You doing alright?
Ma...Matt F wrote:Wow that's a lot of votes. I'm going to switch it up and vote for MM just to let him know I haven't forgotten about him and Turnip.
Why so?HamburgerBoy wrote:Glad to see that worked. Although the Grim Shaman was unexpected, but *secrets* there so who knows, maybe she had items or something else as well. IIRC her history is also consistent with Floyd being Witherdeath as well, but I haven't been following as closely these last couple day phases and need to review a lot of stuff now that juliets was confirmed. I'm also now feeling a very strong scumvibe from MetalMarsh, which I hope to get to soon.
Good to know you can keep playing mafia. :PMacDougall wrote:Bam!
Suddenly x2!Matt F wrote:RIH Juliets
Hamburger, I don't think MM is scum per se but I'm down to vote for him!
Also, Hamburger, let's not forget last lynch when you suddenly moved your vote to Mac from juliets suddenly last second.
Suddenly Susan would be pleased.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Suddenly x2!Matt F wrote:RIH Juliets
Hamburger, I don't think MM is scum per se but I'm down to vote for him!
Also, Hamburger, let's not forget last lynch when you suddenly moved your vote to Mac from juliets suddenly last second.
I was bored. Also, Why would you vote for me if you don't think I'm scum?
What do you think of Hamburger Boy throwing his vote on you last second now that we know Juliets alignment?MacDougall wrote:It's time for me to die. My job here is done. Goodbye world.
I'm not the doctor. I was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. I didn't even realize we were chums.Matt F wrote:Suddenly Susan would be pleased.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Suddenly x2!Matt F wrote:RIH Juliets
Hamburger, I don't think MM is scum per se but I'm down to vote for him!
Also, Hamburger, let's not forget last lynch when you suddenly moved your vote to Mac from juliets suddenly last second.
I was bored. Also, Why would you vote for me if you don't think I'm scum?![]()
Anyway, cuz I think you're the crazy Doctor who killed Turnip. Based on map reasons, I know you were the last person to see Turnip's dead body. Since that's the case, you could've easily been three squares away from him when he was originally captured. Then he's rezzed afterwards, again you were the last to see his dead body. Now the two of you are chums despite some fake sussing of each other some pages back.
I think somebody theorized that the crazy Doctor is indy, and I think that's probably true. Thus, I don't think you're mafia but I think you're dangerous all the same.
I don't trust a man always in such high spirits.Metalmarsh89 wrote:Why so?
Let's also not forget that Mac had this to say just recently...Matt F wrote:Also, Hamburger, let's not forget last lynch when you suddenly moved your vote to Mac from juliets suddenly last second.
I could also point out that I had stated my suspicion of her fairly early in the game, and only switched my vote when it seemed very unlikely that she would be lynched, under my assumption that she was Scrippleskitz.MacDougall wrote:I will repeat myself for the benefit of the scum player who is trying to drive her agenda without actually making an effort to read the explanation I already just gave.
The lion's share of my content up until end of day was pushing the juliets lynch, as it has been each day. I believe I have made it clear without explicitly using words to such effect why I believe her to be scum. I began to receive votes that put my close enough to juliets for me to understand that her lynch was not to be. Well before our vote tally's were six a piece. I already knew she was not going to be lynched.
Me receiving votes was a positive thing for the civ win con but the positive impact of votes on me has now been exhausted and are no longer useful to the civ win con. I cannot diverge exactly why/how they were positive, but I expect there are a few players who know why.
When it became obvious to me that juliets was not going to be lynched. I went back to vote harvesting. Simples.
But, alas, that is no longer the case. Ergo I will no longer be requesting.
I didn't feel like sticking around because the doctor was probably still in the area.Matt F wrote:Well at least you didn't deny the map claims, so that actually makes me feel better about you.
As for TH, whether you're the Doctor or not, what do you think? Doctor kills and rezzes Turnip (Turnip even claims that when he was killed he was told he'd be rezzed a short time later), I can't see any good coming from that.
Oooookay, but what do you think about Turnip?Metalmarsh89 wrote:I didn't feel like sticking around because the doctor was probably still in the area.Matt F wrote:Well at least you didn't deny the map claims, so that actually makes me feel better about you.
As for TH, whether you're the Doctor or not, what do you think? Doctor kills and rezzes Turnip (Turnip even claims that when he was killed he was told he'd be rezzed a short time later), I can't see any good coming from that.
Heaps pro civ.Matt F wrote:Oooookay, but what do you think about Turnip?Metalmarsh89 wrote:I didn't feel like sticking around because the doctor was probably still in the area.Matt F wrote:Well at least you didn't deny the map claims, so that actually makes me feel better about you.
As for TH, whether you're the Doctor or not, what do you think? Doctor kills and rezzes Turnip (Turnip even claims that when he was killed he was told he'd be rezzed a short time later), I can't see any good coming from that.
Basically, with the added caveat that voting for who I thought was civvie at the time was a move in favor of Mac's quest to be heaps pro-civ, and the clarification that whether role or something else, juliets was winning lynches unexpectedly.Matt F wrote:Linki - So your defense of not being a baddie is that you sussed her early in the game, but then decided to vote for who you thought was civvie in the last three minutes of the poll based on your assumption of what juliets bad guy role was?