MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 6:17 am
Wait you wanna bury TSP too? That's tight.
In Fallout I said that he seemed scummy because he was machine gunning out hot takes to try to match his town meta. I didn't put much genuine effort into figuring out how correct that analysis was because I was Metzger, but he did end up flipping scum. I think he is playing up his "says confusing things" persona a little too much here, in a very similar way.
Also his vote on Michelle was a total wolf move. I am happy to vote him out.
Out of all the egregious things Tony has done, I don't think him asking people to vote Michelle was one of them
Michelle is egregiously town. I know it. Mac knows it. Sloonei knows it. Jay knows it. All of these people are town. I think if TSP was town, he'd know it too. Or at least put more weight into our opinions. It was a very naked flash wagoning attempt on someone who is almost certainly a townie to save a scummy slot. And I hate that.
I get that (I think Michelle town too), but I think Tony would have provided an easier option than going against the consensus like that. I scum read Tony too but it was one of his plus points I think
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:04 am
Okay well Mac's and Alison's posts about Michelle blend in well with together, but tutuu's comment about how she wouldn't defend a teammate so weakly is meh to me. This lobby is so big that I'm not really willing to change my vote because a universally town-leaned/read player doesn't think they're scum
what does this mean
Well it all started when Tutuu made some comment about how Michelle wouldn't defend a teammate so lightly and that they're not w/w. MacDougall said something about mich being town so I asked why. Mac provided me with meta and as he posted that ALison posted a post about michelle that went hand in hand with the new meta i learned about michelle from mac. So the first sentence is me thinking out loud. the second sentence is me thinking that isn't a great reason why people wouldn't be w/w. And the last sentence is self-explanatory.
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:09 am
I've seen glimpses of the town Ted. Enough for me not to prioritise his exsanguination today. Good job Ted if you're mafia.
I think I fool you every time
God damn it why would you do this?
you’re fun to play mind games with
I see.
Well as they say. The scarecrow walks at midnight.
when the fox does not reach the grapes it says they are unripe
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 6:17 am
Wait you wanna bury TSP too? That's tight.
In Fallout I said that he seemed scummy because he was machine gunning out hot takes to try to match his town meta. I didn't put much genuine effort into figuring out how correct that analysis was because I was Metzger, but he did end up flipping scum. I think he is playing up his "says confusing things" persona a little too much here, in a very similar way.
Also his vote on Michelle was a total wolf move. I am happy to vote him out.
Out of all the egregious things Tony has done, I don't think him asking people to vote Michelle was one of them
Michelle is egregiously town. I know it. Mac knows it. Sloonei knows it. Jay knows it. All of these people are town. I think if TSP was town, he'd know it too. Or at least put more weight into our opinions. It was a very naked flash wagoning attempt on someone who is almost certainly a townie to save a scummy slot. And I hate that.
I get that (I think Michelle town too), but I think Tony would have provided an easier option than going against the consensus like that. I scum read Tony too but it was one of his plus points I think
If Tony is in a bind (eg. if most or all of the scum team is POE'd) then I think he is forced to widen the POE. He can't just go after the easiest LHF because those slots are either his teammates or people who when removed from the game will leave his teammates as the most suspected slots. Voting Michelle might be a desperation move.
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:22 am
by Alison
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:20 am
Also, like, his response to Alison just now was a+ stuff tbh
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:09 am
I've seen glimpses of the town Ted. Enough for me not to prioritise his exsanguination today. Good job Ted if you're mafia.
I think I fool you every time
God damn it why would you do this?
you’re fun to play mind games with
I see.
Well as they say. The scarecrow walks at midnight.
when the fox does not reach the grapes it says they are unripe
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:09 am
I've seen glimpses of the town Ted. Enough for me not to prioritise his exsanguination today. Good job Ted if you're mafia.
I think I fool you every time
God damn it why would you do this?
you’re fun to play mind games with
I see.
Well as they say. The scarecrow walks at midnight.
when the fox does not reach the grapes it says they are unripe
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
BK went deep in Bee Mafia and fooled everyone. I don't think he should be towncleared just for having a pulse in a big game.
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
They're good for a player who thinks like Alison does, i don't think bo is that player
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:09 am
I've seen glimpses of the town Ted. Enough for me not to prioritise his exsanguination today. Good job Ted if you're mafia.
I think I fool you every time
God damn it why would you do this?
you’re fun to play mind games with
I see.
Well as they say. The scarecrow walks at midnight.
when the fox does not reach the grapes it says they are unripe
i love mac and ted's interactions they're so great together
they're like ... these cowboys that were in a bar shootout, enemies at first, but then an unlikely camarederie emerged, so it feels im watching on my tv screen as they ride on their adventures like geralt and dandellion (but both of them are main characters) and seeing their interactions is greatt
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 6:17 am
Wait you wanna bury TSP too? That's tight.
In Fallout I said that he seemed scummy because he was machine gunning out hot takes to try to match his town meta. I didn't put much genuine effort into figuring out how correct that analysis was because I was Metzger, but he did end up flipping scum. I think he is playing up his "says confusing things" persona a little too much here, in a very similar way.
Also his vote on Michelle was a total wolf move. I am happy to vote him out.
Out of all the egregious things Tony has done, I don't think him asking people to vote Michelle was one of them
Michelle is egregiously town. I know it. Mac knows it. Sloonei knows it. Jay knows it. All of these people are town. I think if TSP was town, he'd know it too. Or at least put more weight into our opinions. It was a very naked flash wagoning attempt on someone who is almost certainly a townie to save a scummy slot. And I hate that.
I get that (I think Michelle town too), but I think Tony would have provided an easier option than going against the consensus like that. I scum read Tony too but it was one of his plus points I think
If Tony is in a bind (eg. if most or all of the scum team is POE'd) then I think he is forced to widen the POE. He can't just go after the easiest LHF because those slots are either his teammates or people who when removed from the game will leave his teammates as the most suspected slots. Voting Michelle might be a desperation move.
Bingpot
Why do I get the feeling a small handful of us have the Mafia by the scrote but we won't kill enough of them before we all die and then the ones left will coast?
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:09 am
I've seen glimpses of the town Ted. Enough for me not to prioritise his exsanguination today. Good job Ted if you're mafia.
I think I fool you every time
God damn it why would you do this?
you’re fun to play mind games with
I see.
Well as they say. The scarecrow walks at midnight.
when the fox does not reach the grapes it says they are unripe
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
They're good for a player who thinks like Alison does, i don't think bo is that player
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
To be clear I don't think he's a bad scum player i just don't think he's this scum player, if that makes sense
Also I literally just saw him win as mafia so my meta is reasonably good
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:20 am
Also, like, his response to Alison just now was a+ stuff tbh
The hugging emoji? Why?
Zero desire to push back against a read that's in that moment being parroted as a strong one by mac
No selling reads is like the first tactic you check viability for in this scenario. It's like my mafia go to. Overdefensiveness is obvwolf shit to even pleb wolves. That reaction is the correct play as wolf because its NAI not because its townie.
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:09 am
I've seen glimpses of the town Ted. Enough for me not to prioritise his exsanguination today. Good job Ted if you're mafia.
I think I fool you every time
God damn it why would you do this?
you’re fun to play mind games with
I see.
Well as they say. The scarecrow walks at midnight.
when the fox does not reach the grapes it says they are unripe
i love mac and ted's interactions they're so great together
they're like ... these cowboys that were in a bar shootout, enemies at first, but then an unlikely camarederie emerged, so it feels im watching on my tv screen as they ride on their adventures like geralt and dandellion (but both of them are main characters) and seeing their interactions is greatt
should've seen us in the zelda mash
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:27 am
by tutuu
what happened in zelda mash?
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:27 am
by NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
tutuu wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:27 am
what happened in zelda mash?
I stomped mac
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:27 am
by tedxtr
tutuu wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:27 am
what happened in zelda mash?
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
If I'm mafia vote for me
Thats silly. I'm currently using my vote to support a wagon pushed by a town player with a stronger hold on the gamestate than me on someone that's scummier than you. If I had a spare one maybe I'd humour you brosephusinephistopheles.
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:04 am
Okay well Mac's and Alison's posts about Michelle blend in well with together, but tutuu's comment about how she wouldn't defend a teammate so weakly is meh to me. This lobby is so big that I'm not really willing to change my vote because a universally town-leaned/read player doesn't think they're scum
what does this mean
Well it all started when Tutuu made some comment about how Michelle wouldn't defend a teammate so lightly and that they're not w/w. MacDougall said something about mich being town so I asked why. Mac provided me with meta and as he posted that ALison posted a post about michelle that went hand in hand with the new meta i learned about michelle from mac. So the first sentence is me thinking out loud. the second sentence is me thinking that isn't a great reason why people wouldn't be w/w. And the last sentence is self-explanatory.
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
If I'm mafia vote for me
Thats silly. I'm currently using my vote to support a wagon pushed by a town player with a stronger hold on the gamestate than me on someone that's scummier than you. If I had a spare one maybe I'd humour you brosephusinephistopheles.
How can someone be scummier than me when you said "I've seen him do better as mafia than this". That is implying that you know I'm mafia.
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:29 am
by MacDougall
Thats it. You've all held me back long enough. I'm going to mafia clown college.
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:04 am
Okay well Mac's and Alison's posts about Michelle blend in well with together, but tutuu's comment about how she wouldn't defend a teammate so weakly is meh to me. This lobby is so big that I'm not really willing to change my vote because a universally town-leaned/read player doesn't think they're scum
what does this mean
Well it all started when Tutuu made some comment about how Michelle wouldn't defend a teammate so lightly and that they're not w/w. MacDougall said something about mich being town so I asked why. Mac provided me with meta and as he posted that ALison posted a post about michelle that went hand in hand with the new meta i learned about michelle from mac. So the first sentence is me thinking out loud. the second sentence is me thinking that isn't a great reason why people wouldn't be w/w. And the last sentence is self-explanatory.
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
If I'm mafia vote for me
Thats silly. I'm currently using my vote to support a wagon pushed by a town player with a stronger hold on the gamestate than me on someone that's scummier than you. If I had a spare one maybe I'd humour you brosephusinephistopheles.
How can someone be scummier than me when you said "I've seen him do better as mafia than this". That is implying that you know I'm mafia.
No I am saying I've seen you as mafia look less mafia than you do here.
MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 6:17 am
Wait you wanna bury TSP too? That's tight.
In Fallout I said that he seemed scummy because he was machine gunning out hot takes to try to match his town meta. I didn't put much genuine effort into figuring out how correct that analysis was because I was Metzger, but he did end up flipping scum. I think he is playing up his "says confusing things" persona a little too much here, in a very similar way.
Also his vote on Michelle was a total wolf move. I am happy to vote him out.
Out of all the egregious things Tony has done, I don't think him asking people to vote Michelle was one of them
Michelle is egregiously town. I know it. Mac knows it. Sloonei knows it. Jay knows it. All of these people are town. I think if TSP was town, he'd know it too. Or at least put more weight into our opinions. It was a very naked flash wagoning attempt on someone who is almost certainly a townie to save a scummy slot. And I hate that.
I get that (I think Michelle town too), but I think Tony would have provided an easier option than going against the consensus like that. I scum read Tony too but it was one of his plus points I think
If Tony is in a bind (eg. if most or all of the scum team is POE'd) then I think he is forced to widen the POE. He can't just go after the easiest LHF because those slots are either his teammates or people who when removed from the game will leave his teammates as the most suspected slots. Voting Michelle might be a desperation move.
fair
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:31 am
by MacDougall
All I am saying is that you not going belly up isn't a reason to townread you tbh.
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:31 am
by NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Maybe bo just exists jn my blind spot but he seems pretty townie to me and these arguments seem pretty silly
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:04 am
Okay well Mac's and Alison's posts about Michelle blend in well with together, but tutuu's comment about how she wouldn't defend a teammate so weakly is meh to me. This lobby is so big that I'm not really willing to change my vote because a universally town-leaned/read player doesn't think they're scum
what does this mean
Well it all started when Tutuu made some comment about how Michelle wouldn't defend a teammate so lightly and that they're not w/w. MacDougall said something about mich being town so I asked why. Mac provided me with meta and as he posted that ALison posted a post about michelle that went hand in hand with the new meta i learned about michelle from mac. So the first sentence is me thinking out loud. the second sentence is me thinking that isn't a great reason why people wouldn't be w/w. And the last sentence is self-explanatory.
So, do you believe michelle/al is w/w or not
No. t/w maybe.
So then what was the point of the original post?
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:31 am
by tedxtr
no, but for real, apart from alison's explanation, why are people voting marmot?
I've seen him do better as mafia than this. Not here but my first experience with him he was mafia and he didn't go belly up. I understand your reasoning but it can just be that he's more participatory in this game. Alison's points are too good for you to be ignoring them off bad meta though.
If I'm mafia vote for me
Thats silly. I'm currently using my vote to support a wagon pushed by a town player with a stronger hold on the gamestate than me on someone that's scummier than you. If I had a spare one maybe I'd humour you brosephusinephistopheles.
How can someone be scummier than me when you said "I've seen him do better as mafia than this". That is implying that you know I'm mafia.
No I am saying I've seen you as mafia look less mafia than you do here.
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:32 am
by MacDougall
Here's the thing.
If Alison, Mac, Jay, Sloonei are all town here.
It wouldn't be fun being a wolf.
Who isn't being their usual fun engaged towny selves?
Find me some wolves with answers.
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:32 am
by Alison
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:31 am
Maybe bo just exists jn my blind spot but he seems pretty townie to me and these arguments seem pretty silly
I think irreverent and goofy slankers who give sarcastic or joking answers to being suspected are more likely to be in your blindspot!
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:04 am
Okay well Mac's and Alison's posts about Michelle blend in well with together, but tutuu's comment about how she wouldn't defend a teammate so weakly is meh to me. This lobby is so big that I'm not really willing to change my vote because a universally town-leaned/read player doesn't think they're scum
what does this mean
Well it all started when Tutuu made some comment about how Michelle wouldn't defend a teammate so lightly and that they're not w/w. MacDougall said something about mich being town so I asked why. Mac provided me with meta and as he posted that ALison posted a post about michelle that went hand in hand with the new meta i learned about michelle from mac. So the first sentence is me thinking out loud. the second sentence is me thinking that isn't a great reason why people wouldn't be w/w. And the last sentence is self-explanatory.
So, do you believe michelle/al is w/w or not
No. t/w maybe.
So then what was the point of the original post?
Most of it is thinking outlaid, and town-leaning Michelle.
