Golden wrote:Silverwolf wrote:There's a paranoid part of me that wonders why Sloonei is still in the game, being super obvious town.
However, in a game like this, that doesn't necessarily mean anything.
I also find it odd that LC is suspecting Quin but also voting with Quin on Nerolunar.
I can understand the sig suspicion based on his reaction to Fuzz lynch, but again, this just seems too obvious to me.
I'm kind of frustrated that I think we are on the wrong track and scum are flying under the radar successfully while we are going after active posters who could very well be town, and not forcing scum to answer for their inactivity.
Has anyone noticed sonjei has only 3 posts in this game and they are all crap? He was an ika voter as well.
This is the worst one.
There has been literally only one chance at a nightkill since EOD2, at which point sloonei became 'superobvious town' (except for the fact that he was taking suspicion from a number of people). Why would you be surprised to see him alive?
Why is something obvious likely to be 'too obvious'? Why isn't it likely to be just what it looks like?
I've begun to see a very strong pattern from silverwolf of opposing what I'd call 'prevailing wisdom' and trying to push for less obvious/less likely explanations. The same thing I'm seeing for sig.
Despite that... she votes for LC. A person whose vote is frankly just as scummy-looking as sigs. If it wouldn't be as obvious as sig, why would it be as obvious as LC?
OK, I found this and the fact that you declared me a teammate to sig and I have to say Golden, as nice of a person as you seem to be, your play is starting to annoy me.
You seem to see everything as black and white. If RadicalFuzz is scum, then anyone defending him must be a teammate. If I think sig is town and don't want to lynch him, he must be bad and I must be a teammate. You refuse to consider that town can be wrong. You refuse to consider that RadicalFuzz could of been bussed. You are also assuming those on the ika train were bad as well when it is perfectly reasonable to assume they were wrong town. Or it is even possible ika is scum. I mean, I'm leaning that he isn't based on RadicalFuzz's vote on him and his pushing the RadicalFuzz lynch, but ika hard core busses as scum so I'm not going to rule it out until I see more of his D3 play and see him contributing to the game more. But you've alread assumed he's town and you are making some sort of crazy assumption that I'm trying to get him to townread me based on me defending him or pushing the lynch on Fuzz-I got this from a previous post of yours. What you don't seem to understand is that ika can almost always accurately read me because he has played many games with me and knows how I behave because we have discussed our game meta before in past conversations. Is it possible for us to fool one another? Yes. Is it likely? Not really.
Now, As far as me going against the prevailing wisdom. Yes, I will do this. If I think town is on the wrong track, I will try to steer them onto the correct one. I consider it far more scum than town to just go along with popular opinion, get the easy mislynch, and avoid drawing suspicion to yourself. I have no idea why scum would always try to stand out like a sore thumb and argue against popular lynches if they aren't falling on scum. I thought town was wrong on quin, Nero, and sig. I think scum is lying low and getting away from it. So I voiced my opinion. I want my opinion on this known.
I'll give you another example. We had a really good player on MS who would often lead mislynches on town as town. You wanna know why? Because he would tunnel and get into confbias and once he declarded someone scum, he would rarely if ever let it go. It was detrimental to town. Town should always be willing to reconsider their reads based on new info. You can into D2 with absolute certainty that a certain few people were scum and a certain few people were town. Without being will to reconsider and look at ALL possibilities, you are headed for a disaster. I can't tell you how many times I've seen scum get away or town die for exactly your line of thinking. I mean, it was at the point I was scumreading you for it because of the immediate lining up lynches mentality based on a single flip. If you play this game like it's black and white, you will very likely lose. I've seen it happen far too often.