The Syndicate

Scotty wrote:

Long Con wrote:Gotta leave for work soon. I see Scotty is just kind of avoiding explaining or answering questions about his post, so I'll place my vote where he did. *votes Scotty*

I did not see you voting anywhere else today mate, and I fail to see what I can answer that would assuage you.

Praytell, what haven't I answered?

Long Con wrote:I'm sorry to rehash this again, but I looked it over and I can't get my mind around it... and I don't understand Scotty's metaphors at all.

Scotty wrote:I think we should kill Typh first because no one would suspect it was SVS

Scotty, I understand the idea behind this joke. Discussed in a previous game, S~V~S would not kill Typh on Day 1. That's easy to get.

What I'm not getting is this: if you really meant to post this joke to the Game Thread, then who was the audience? Who is "we"? Is that part of the joke's intention - to fake like you slipped and posted that in the wrong place?

Your answer about knowing there was thread-based baddie chat was "I dunno. I guess?" So... that makes it a bit hard to believe that the "slip" idea was part of your original joke. If you knew the baddies were chatting in forum threads, then making the joke be a funny pretend 'oops wrong thread!' slip is possible, but you're equivocating about that, so

It looks like the majority of the people playing don't agree with me, so if any of you can answer these questions, I would appreciate it. I feel like I missed an episode of the show everyone loves, so I don't have the means to get the plot.

Long Con wrote:

Scotty wrote:

Long Con wrote:Gotta leave for work soon. I see Scotty is just kind of avoiding explaining or answering questions about his post, so I'll place my vote where he did. *votes Scotty*

I did not see you voting anywhere else today mate, and I fail to see what I can answer that would assuage you.

Praytell, what haven't I answered?

Ok, answering this is just going through the motions at this point, but I had to answer. How the F did you miss this post?

Long Con wrote:I'm sorry to rehash this again, but I looked it over and I can't get my mind around it... and I don't understand Scotty's metaphors at all.

Scotty wrote:I think we should kill Typh first because no one would suspect it was SVS

Scotty, I understand the idea behind this joke. Discussed in a previous game, S~V~S would not kill Typh on Day 1. That's easy to get.

What I'm not getting is this: if you really meant to post this joke to the Game Thread, then who was the audience? Who is "we"? Is that part of the joke's intention - to fake like you slipped and posted that in the wrong place?

Your answer about knowing there was thread-based baddie chat was "I dunno. I guess?" So... that makes it a bit hard to believe that the "slip" idea was part of your original joke. If you knew the baddies were chatting in forum threads, then making the joke be a funny pretend 'oops wrong thread!' slip is possible, but you're equivocating about that, so

It looks like the majority of the people playing don't agree with me, so if any of you can answer these questions, I would appreciate it. I feel like I missed an episode of the show everyone loves, so I don't have the means to get the plot.

Obviously, the answer is that you didn't miss it, you just didn't care because you wanted to be lynched. I hope you got something good from it, and I hope you're Civ. If you're a Repudiated Immortal and didn't get some benefit from the lynch, then WHY? WWWWHHHHYYYYYYY?

a2thezebra wrote:

nutella wrote: Notice that he said "I'm just enjoying watching who is jumping on this", rather than claiming he explicitly did it to see who would jump on it. He's trying to appear chill about it and enjoying the opportunity to turn suspicion away from him.

Scotty wrote:You're forgetting that I didn't ask to be lynched.

You kept pushing it. You and zebra. But you were completely flumberbuxt with my answers.

I just honestly would like my to have received votes at all. But here we are.

and I think you Sjould be lynched tomorrow.

Boulders wrote:I'm happy that nobody died!

though I'm a little confused as to why nobody died, I thought that the person with the most votes is the one who gets lynched

Made wrote:Why did the chicken cross the road????

Made wrote:Shit, wrong thread

sprityo wrote: mmm what can i say. i was basically right

Scotty wrote:I'm sorry you're disappointed you didn't get to lynch me, Nutella.

What is your opinion of LC?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Since nobody else asked, Scotty, do you know why you weren't lynched?

Scotty wrote:Hi.

sprityo wrote: Basically what I'm trying to say is, why is Scotty being so, not optimal? Surely it's not on purpose, right?

Perhaps he could be trying to draw out a lynch on himself to confirm himself?

sprityo wrote:@MM

sprityo wrote: Basically what I'm trying to say is, why is Scotty being so, not optimal? Surely it's not on purpose, right?

Perhaps he could be trying to draw out a lynch on himself to confirm himself?

i mean maybe im right, im at least halfway right.

DFaraday wrote:I'm so sorry I missed the vote, Enrique! I saw the end time when I wasn't logged in and thought I had two more hours. It won't happen again!

It seems like the most obvious solution is that Scotty is a Repudiated Immortal. And even though I have nothing to support this idea, I suspect that Nutella is the other member and Scotty kept saying he suspected her so that people wouldn't draw a connection between them.

At the moment, I'm most suspicious of the people who voted LC for no particular reason (i.e., all of them).

S~V~S wrote:

DFaraday wrote:I'm so sorry I missed the vote, Enrique! I saw the end time when I wasn't logged in and thought I had two more hours. It won't happen again!

It seems like the most obvious solution is that Scotty is a Repudiated Immortal. And even though I have nothing to support this idea, I suspect that Nutella is the other member and Scotty kept saying he suspected her so that people wouldn't draw a connection between them.

At the moment, I'm most suspicious of the people who voted LC for no particular reason (i.e., all of them).

I had a reason. What makes you think I did not?

And Scotty, while on the one hand yay for no death, especially if you are someone in my civ group, on the other I was hoping to get a sense of direction from your death. Either you flipped bad, and I got my affairs in order, or you didn't and the baddie slip theory could fade into oblivion where it belongs, but alas. But if Faradays theory is correct, and it makes sense, hopefully that puts paid to that.

Although he seems to think Nutella is the other one, and didn't she buy into the baddie slip theory? So that bit is kinda shaky.

But congrats on living Scotty

Long Con wrote:S~V~S, I have never seen you act like this as a baddie in any game. I have never seen you act like this as a Civvie in any game. I have never seen you act like this at all. Don't bother pulling your meta anymore, because there's no point. You're breaking new ground here for S~V~S meta.

S~V~S wrote:

DFaraday wrote:I'm so sorry I missed the vote, Enrique! I saw the end time when I wasn't logged in and thought I had two more hours. It won't happen again!

It seems like the most obvious solution is that Scotty is a Repudiated Immortal. And even though I have nothing to support this idea, I suspect that Nutella is the other member and Scotty kept saying he suspected her so that people wouldn't draw a connection between them.

At the moment, I'm most suspicious of the people who voted LC for no particular reason (i.e., all of them).

I had a reason. What makes you think I did not?

And Scotty, while on the one hand yay for no death, especially if you are someone in my civ group, on the other I was hoping to get a sense of direction from your death. Either you flipped bad, and I got my affairs in order, or you didn't and the baddie slip theory could fade into oblivion where it belongs, but alas. But if Faradays theory is correct, and it makes sense, hopefully that puts paid to that.

Although he seems to think Nutella is the other one, and didn't she buy into the baddie slip theory? So that bit is kinda shaky.

But congrats on living Scotty

Boulders wrote:yooo haha

Boulders wrote:

Boulders wrote:yooo haha

heyyy lol

Scotty wrote:

S~V~S wrote:

DFaraday wrote:I'm so sorry I missed the vote, Enrique! I saw the end time when I wasn't logged in and thought I had two more hours. It won't happen again!

It seems like the most obvious solution is that Scotty is a Repudiated Immortal. And even though I have nothing to support this idea, I suspect that Nutella is the other member and Scotty kept saying he suspected her so that people wouldn't draw a connection between them.

At the moment, I'm most suspicious of the people who voted LC for no particular reason (i.e., all of them).

I had a reason. What makes you think I did not?

And Scotty, while on the one hand yay for no death, especially if you are someone in my civ group, on the other I was hoping to get a sense of direction from your death. Either you flipped bad, and I got my affairs in order, or you didn't and the baddie slip theory could fade into oblivion where it belongs, but alas. But if Faradays theory is correct, and it makes sense, hopefully that puts paid to that.

Although he seems to think Nutella is the other one, and didn't she buy into the baddie slip theory? So that bit is kinda shaky.

But congrats on living Scotty

Hey thanks, SVS!

I think both are valid theories. I guess we should probably lynch Nutella tomorrow and find out.

Also. Still down for killing Typh tonight since he just called me a nub?

Boulders wrote:

Boulders wrote:

Boulders wrote:yooo haha

heyyy lol

oyyy jaja

Black Rock wrote:Sorry I missed the vote, exhaustion took over my life last night and fizzled my brain. I certainly missed a lot of argument. SVS I sincerely love you. I do believe you, put your hackles down.

I don't know what you're about Scotty but you can't expect people to ignore such a statement. You wanted attention you got it. Doesn't mean everyone that gave you attention is bad.

Scotty wrote:

Boulders wrote:

Boulders wrote:

Boulders wrote:yooo haha

heyyy lol

oyyy jaja

You're a special kind of boulder, aren't you?

S~V~S wrote:Hopefully at the bottom of it

a2thezebra wrote:Where is S~V~S on your list, Scotty?

a2thezebra wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Hopefully at the bottom of it

From most scummy to least scummy, of course.

Scotty wrote:

a2thezebra wrote:Where is S~V~S on your list, Scotty?

She is not on my list.

You are one step below LC.

DFaraday wrote: If Nutella is the other Immortal, she would know that Scotty wouldn't die on Day 1, so it makes sense to me that she'd throw him under the bus. Distancing when your teammate secretly isn't in any real danger seems like a clever move to me.