The Syndicate

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Whoa. I guess 3 it is. Jeez guys.

Long Con wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Whoa. I guess 3 it is. Jeez guys.

I was getting worried about you for a sec there, Marshy! Everyone seems pretty relaxed about the 3 vote so far though. We could have a "Chinese Fire Drill" (or "CFD") and all bustle to change our vote to a different number before the lynch ends... but I don't see the point. From a personal standpoint, that is, I'm against rocking this lynch boat at all, because I don't want to be the one who ends up in the water.

timmer wrote:Yes, I was silenced. I imagine that whoever did it hadn't anticipated that it would be such a bizarre lynch day where silencing me would actually have little effect.

FZ. wrote:

timmer wrote:Yes, I was silenced. I imagine that whoever did it hadn't anticipated that it would be such a bizarre lynch day where silencing me would actually have little effect.

Who do you think would want you silenced?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

FZ. wrote:

timmer wrote:Yes, I was silenced. I imagine that whoever did it hadn't anticipated that it would be such a bizarre lynch day where silencing me would actually have little effect.

Who do you think would want you silenced?

If he actually was silenced.

FZ. wrote:

timmer wrote:Yes, I was silenced. I imagine that whoever did it hadn't anticipated that it would be such a bizarre lynch day where silencing me would actually have little effect.

Who do you think would want you silenced?

Long Con wrote:I'm not that interested in the silencing, it's too WIFOMy as someone said. Let's just all be happy that we didn't have to listen to Timmer all Day.

Damn, we were hoping that Soneji was Plunder! Too bad he wasn't... or was he?

Plunder – A marksman from the Mirror Universe. He kills on even nights. Like Mirror Master, he will not appear as his role if he is checked.

Black Rock wrote:Well tbh honest I was hoping the lynched player was Soneji. I was not expecting that lynch result at all. I was certain he was Plunder. I did not expect him to be modkilled because a host would not want to take the numbers away from the baddies. With him being neutral I am very surprised he wasn't modkilled, as it really would not make a difference to the game. That, I guess, was just a host call.

So IS Plunder dead OR is it Rabbit?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Black Rock wrote:Well tbh honest I was hoping the lynched player was Soneji. I was not expecting that lynch result at all. I was certain he was Plunder. I did not expect him to be modkilled because a host would not want to take the numbers away from the baddies. With him being neutral I am very surprised he wasn't modkilled, as it really would not make a difference to the game. That, I guess, was just a host call.

So IS Plunder dead OR is it Rabbit?

I just assumed Plunder was dead. What if DFaraday was Plunder? That would explain the lack of killing and why Grodd's kill was 'inherited'.

Mister Rearranger wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Question for the host: If the New Rogue's killer ever dies, does the kill pass on to another teammate, or does the kill die with him/her?

Neither...Both?

The kill is passed down if the killer is killed, but remains with the killer if the killer is imprisoned.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Mister Rearranger wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Question for the host: If the New Rogue's killer ever dies, does the kill pass on to another teammate, or does the kill die with him/her?

Neither...Both?

The kill is passed down if the killer is killed, but remains with the killer if the killer is imprisoned.

Hopefully this answers your question BR.

Long Con wrote:We haven't lynched Girder, Blacksmith, Murmur, Tar Pit... we have lynched The Top and Double Down...And we have more and more reason to believe that Plunder is out of the picture at this point.

Girder must be alive (assuming that "he can't be nightkilled" includes "he can't be imprisoned"), and it's reasonable enough to assume that at least one of the other three have been randomly killed at some point.

We have killed Grodd and Professor Zoom, but Zoom may still be out there.

So... my estimate is that there are three or four baddies still out there. And how many players total now? 10 or 11?

Long Con wrote:Heeeeere, hosty hosty hosty...

FZ. wrote:

Long Con wrote:We haven't lynched Girder, Blacksmith, Murmur, Tar Pit... we have lynched The Top and Double Down...And we have more and more reason to believe that Plunder is out of the picture at this point.

Girder must be alive (assuming that "he can't be nightkilled" includes "he can't be imprisoned"), and it's reasonable enough to assume that at least one of the other three have been randomly killed at some point.

We have killed Grodd and Professor Zoom, but Zoom may still be out there.

So... my estimate is that there are three or four baddies still out there. And how many players total now? 10 or 11?

I thought we had fewer still alive.

If you had to pick 2 players who are old rogues right now, who would they be?

S~V~S wrote: Actually, I think there may be fewer baddies. What did people think of Faraday, Epi & DH? Any roles in mind for them? They were all killed by non bad roles so could have been bad. I think 1 or 2 of the three were possibly bad; I think Bullz might have been bad. I think there is either one Old Rogue left , me, and perhaps one other. I thought Bass may have been, but I am also in the throes of recruit paranoia for him, so

I think everyone else is spread over the other affiliations.

Long Con wrote:

FZ. wrote:

Long Con wrote:As for my own opinion on Bullzeye, I'm just not sure. I'd say he's not Captain Cold or Heat Wave, because I think BF probably checked Bullz and reinforced his own opinion that he's less likely to be Civ. So that's 50% of the Old Rogues that 's not, in my opinion. He's not Magenta, because he'd have stopped a lynch by now to get BTSC with the Detectives (assuming my secret solution is right for her). He's not a Detective, I'd say.

Actually, after saying all that together, he's got a reasonably good chance of being a baddie. Or a "scum" as the broader Mafia vernacular prefers.

I think he's most probably an independent Rogue, but that's me. That said, if he's not interested in defending himself, I'm not going to be defending him.
LC, has your opinion of BR changed or actually, do you have any opinion of her now?

I usually stay away from too much in-thread analysis of BR because she's my wife and we most often use the same computer and that kind of meta-analysis can get to be a little sketchy. Why are you specifically asking me about BR, and no one else? I just make it a general rule when playing in the same game as her to keep my distance, at least until later in the game, and let other players make their own unbiased analyses of her.

I do have an opinion of her, I'm just not going to share it until later in the game, presuming we're still alive. You should develop an opinion of her that doesn't involve my opinion of her, I just think it's a more generally fair way to play.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I found you on facebook.

Can I use your own smiley when I talk to you like that?

Why yes.... yes you may.

DREAM wrote:Yes! First!

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Well, RIP rabbit. I was expecting a more active player to be taken.

Black Rock wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Well, RIP rabbit. I was expecting a more active player to be taken.

I don't think it was a bad option.

Long Con wrote:Hey dude! I feel pretty good about BR at this point. She's playing like she truly wants to find the baddies, not like she's trying to not get caught AS a baddie. I hear rainbow lists are in vogue right now, so I'll do one of my own:

Long Con
Bass_the_Clever
Sophie
Black Rock
FZ.
Devin the Omniscient
Metalmarsh
S~V~S
Timmer
Rabbit

That's about how I'm looking at things. Rabbit is right down at the Most Suspicious end of the list just because of the number of baddies I think there is, and the number of players left... he's just got to be one. I don't know what happened to him, I hope he didn't get hit by another car.