The Syndicate

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:12 pm**

zeek wrote:Ah, I remember now I was confused because you gave Blooper her first vote.

What are your thoughts on Mongoose? I'm probably voting that way again.

I did a re-read of you and your thoughs on the Mongoose case just to be sure. I think both Boom and Mongoose have sketchy voting records, but the thing that clinches Boomslang for me is his back and forth with Dom that was really more for show than anything (Remember, when Dom voted Bass it was just about useless.) And Boomslang wasted no time in trying to point out that their back-and-forth was good for him when Dom flipped baddie.

LC, you made a comment a few days ago about how you thought I planted a post so that I could go back and say "Oh look, this must mean i'm good" or whatever. Something similar to what Boom did, would you not agree that this is suspect?

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:23 pm**

If you're talking about the comment where he said "this should burnish my Civvie rep", then yes, that comment tickled my suspish bone the second I read it.

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:25 pm**

Long Con wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Made wrote:Damn, nice guys. Full transparency, If i would of got into thread before the lynch was over I would of voted Dom, so good thing i didn't.
Raised over $1000 at last night fundraiser!!!!

Going to do a more thorough read, but from the little i skimmed, caught this:
Is forcing a tie so a civvie(stanley) decided the lynch a good idea in close lynches.
How do you know Dom is a civvie? If you had broken the tie and gone with Dom, we still had a possibility of lynching a baddie, just not the Warden.
So, if we find out Dom is a baddie, then you could easily come back to this statement and say, "Look, I was right about him!"

That would be good for your rep, wouldn't it?

This is basically what Boomslang did, yes?

(This is directed to LC, but mostly to the rest of you)

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:30 pm**

As for MP07, I for one welcome our new nightkill overlord! I’d like to remind them that as a trusted Civ-minded individual, I can be helpful in rounding up others to toil in his underground fight club!

MP, how about an update? I assume you must have soft-recruited bea and Elohcin at the very least by now, how is your endgame looking?

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:36 pm**

I've just noticed Snow Dog voted Boom when DF got lynched. Turned out not to mean anything but at the time DH had only two voted and DF had none. One thing that worries me about voting Boom is that he could have voted DH when Snowy was lynched, but didn't. If he had DH would have led 7-6.

linki - civ-minded individual?

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:38 pm**

zeek wrote:I've just noticed Snow Dog voted Boom when DF got lynched. Turned out not to mean anything but at the time DH had only two voted and DF had none. One thing that worries me about voting Boom is that he could have voted DH when Snowy was lynched, but didn't. If he had DH would have led 7-6.

linki - civ-minded individual?

Snowy did not seem like he was enjoying himself going off of his in-thread posts. I'm sure BTS he was even less enthused about continuing

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:41 pm**

Elohcin wrote:
zeek wrote:Ermm...

Guess that means Roxy, Russ or INH was a Suit.
How do you figure?

@MP...does this mean we will see no more "so-and-so was killed by Tyler"

You tell me.

Long Con wrote:As for MP07, I for one welcome our new nightkill overlord! I’d like to remind them that as a trusted Civ-minded individual, I can be helpful in rounding up others to toil in his underground fight club!

MP, how about an update? I assume you must have soft-recruited bea and Elohcin at the very least by now, how is your endgame looking?

Much appreciated, LC.

My chances to win at endgame are looking definitely possible at the moment. If we were to lynch both Sorcerers remaining in a row, I can very possibly win. I can still lose, however, namely if we lynch a recruit today, the Sorcerers NK a recruit tonight, and the game ends really shortly thereafter.

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:43 pm**

True. I'm open to lynching either Boom or Mongoose, but I feel Mongoose might be the better option here. If you agree she's a good candidate, given the 3-vowel clue, she could be Voldemort. I'd rather take out Voldemort than Crowley, given the secrets.

MP, what do you think of Boom and Mongoose?

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:46 pm**

Good question, zeek. I'm not totally sure; they're difficult to read. Mongoose is my biggest suspect at the moment: Her voting record supports Sorcerer and her contributions have been trivial at best. I'm not convinced she's bad, however, so I could see my vote going elsewhere if a convincing case is made against Boomslang or juliets.

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:48 pm**

MovingPictures07 wrote:Good question, zeek. I'm not totally sure; they're difficult to read. Mongoose is my biggest suspect at the moment: Her voting record supports Sorcerer and her contributions have been trivial at best. I'm not convinced she's bad, however, so I could see my vote going elsewhere if a convincing case is made against Boomslang or juliets.

You mean a second convincing case against Boomslang? :P

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:50 pm**

DharmaHelper wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Good question, zeek. I'm not totally sure; they're difficult to read. Mongoose is my biggest suspect at the moment: Her voting record supports Sorcerer and her contributions have been trivial at best. I'm not convinced she's bad, however, so I could see my vote going elsewhere if a convincing case is made against Boomslang or juliets.
You mean a second convincing case against Boomslang? :P

Well, sure.

Frankly, I thought Boomslang seemed civvie and genuine earlier in the game, and I have a role in mind for him, possibly.

Nonetheless, I do think his behavior has been suspicious, and I could see him being a Sorcerer. I just feel more strongly about Mongoose.

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:56 pm**

Mongoose likes DH's rebuttal you give DAY 6.

She doesn't want to vote DH on DAY 6,

She doesn't have a problem on DAY 7 [url]when Snowy is for the chop.[/url]

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:57 pm**

Gonna stick my vote there for now

Posted: **Sun Feb 01, 2015 11:58 pm**

zeek wrote:Mongoose likes DH's rebuttal you give DAY 6.

She doesn't want to vote DH on DAY 6,

She doesn't have a problem on DAY 7 [url]when Snowy is for the chop.[/url]

What are you getting at?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:01 am**

Changes her tune for no apparent reason. Or only that she didn't vote the case on Snowy.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:02 am**

zeek wrote:Changes her tune for no apparent reason. Or only that she didn't vote the case on Snowy.

Changes her tune how?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:03 am**

*love the case on Snowy.

She didn't want to vote for you, thought you defended yourself like a champ. The next day, having expressed no opinions on you since then, votes for you because she didn't want to vote for Snow Dog.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:04 am**

EBWOP: nevermind, I read that wrong and thought you meant she had no problem voting for Snowy

Gonna be interested in seeing her response.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:08 am**

It's not like she has a problem wasting her vote...

Like she did voting Hedgeowl the day before (who then got lynched because of game mechanics).

Or voting Daisy the day after.

Or in fact when she voted Lizzy D5, despite everybody else voting Dom except TH (who seemed to have his vote forced).

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 6:32 am**

Sorry so quiet, rl etc. Will vote later.

And I know MP is saying he is replacing the suits, but only 2 known dead of either team exists right? So we are taking his word on that? Or did I miss something?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 7:06 am**

S~V~S wrote:And I know MP is saying he is replacing the suits, but only 2 known dead of either team exists right? So we are taking his word on that? Or did I miss something?

Suits: Made, DFaraday and Bass.
Sorcerers: Dom and Snow Dog.

insertnamehere or Russtifinko were killed by the Sorcerers, so could have been the last Suit - or it could have been Roxy, as her role wasn't revealed.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 7:26 am**

It could also be the Sorcerers is my point, right?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 9:30 am**

I don't get what you mean. The Sorcerers took over the kill? The post says killed by Tyler Durden.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 10:10 am**

The Suits kill on odd nights. They no longer kill on odd nights because I do (if you want proof, I just killed last night).

Why else would that be if the Suits were still alive?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 10:38 am**

S~V~S wrote:It could also be the Sorcerers is my point, right?

Not unless you think the Suits somehow recruited MovingDurden

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 11:12 am**

I'll look again at Boomslang and Mongoose. Mongoose just hasn't really been "in" the game. Most of her posts are jokey or reaction oriented or just adding a comment that doesn't add anything to our search. Boomslang I'm just not sure of at all. It seems like he's been real quiet. I'll take a look at them both and consider what evidence people bring on both of them.

Oh, and I tend to believe the Suits are gone given the logic they didn't kill last night, tyler did. Interesting that he inherited the kill, if that's what happened.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 11:43 am**

Also, before i forget, I will be traveling all day tomorrow and so won't be in the thread. The place I'm going supposedly does have wifi so I should be back on line day after tomorrow. We are going to take care of a family member who is having surgery so I may not be on quite as much but I will be on at least a couple of times a day.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:06 pm**

zeek wrote:It's not like she has a problem wasting her vote...

Like she did voting Hedgeowl the day before (who then got lynched because of game mechanics).

Or voting Daisy the day after.

Or in fact when she voted Lizzy D5, despite everybody else voting Dom except TH (who seemed to have his vote forced).

I'm a bit pinged by the phrase "wasting her vote" here. So if you don't go along with the dominant vote, you're wasting it? Or are you expressing honest doubt and trying to spur discussion on a different candidate?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:30 pm**

Sometimes I feel like I am coming in here and talking some foreign language

I always feel like that when I am a civvie.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:33 pm**

Ok, so I was getting some "vibes" about Boomslang... these vibrations of masterful intuition hummed to me that Boomslang might be hinting that he is the Face of Boe. But the fact that, at this point in the game, has only said there's 2 Civs he trusts and has given us no baddies... quite frankly, at this point in the game, I would expect the Face of Boe to be more of a leader in the thread.

So I looked back over his posts and there were some things I noticed. These are in chronological order:

Boomslang wrote:
juliets wrote:
juliets wrote:I was making a statement for the lie detector, Boe, if he she wanted to check it. Also someone, I think Made, asked several people including me about the contrast in our good and bad alignment behavior. Someone, maybe llama, maybe someone else, answered the question immediately. My impression was thats why they were making that statement. I just can't remember who it was. I think tha'ts what you may be remembering and if i had to guess I would say it was llama.

Boomslang wrote:Nevertheless, the statement makes a pretty firm commitment to a "civ" game. Because if Boe does check it, and finds it to be false, things could get awfully hairy for you. Unless you're an indy role with some secret that blocks lie detection... Hatter's insanity could be related. Just throwing that out there for consideration.
I don't think we disagree. I am making a firm commitment to a "civ" game. Maybe I'm missing your point but I think we agree.
I don't disagree. I'm just saying that making an absolute commitment to saying "I am civ" is painting a target on your back for being NK'ed, unless you have powers to prevent it (or are not in fact civ).

We have this exchange... so, if Boomslang is the Face of Boe, and clearly aware of a statement to detect, why hasn't he spoken up about juliets in any way? She's not really part of the Supertrust Club, her name is still being thrown around as a possible baddie. Where's Boomslang's opinion?

Boomslang wrote:I really am having trouble figuring out what to say this lynch. Obviously, I'm somewhat happy that Dom is getting attention, because I sure as hell don't deserve the tunnel vision hunt he's been throwing my way ever since Day 1. But jumping on that will make me seem bad, so... maybe I better keep my opinions to myself.

Boomslang wrote:
Dom wrote:Note: next time I'm getting heat-- I'll just say I can't play for a week-- no one will vote for me.

(Not saying Bass is lying, I'm just pointing out how dumb that is)
Agreed. In the interest of making Bass a more valid option for discussion and to forestall a Dom bandwagon picking up steam, I'll vote now.

Dom was after Boom all game, which could have been an extended distancing thing, but he still tries to save Dom in the two-man lynch...

Boomslang wrote:Caught up, frankly still unsure what's going on. Just let it be noted that Dom has been gunning for me this whole game; I think that burnishes my civvie cred a bit.

...and still tries to make sure he gets his full allotment of cred. Which would probably have been more deserved had he voted for Dom in the two-man lynch.

Boomslang wrote:MP argues that we don't need to kill him to win. However, we don't need him alive to win, and his unknown qualities worry me. Voting MP

A seeming indication that Boomslang doesn't know any baddies... and to me, voting MP when you know he's indy is a nice way for a baddie to not ruffle any Civvie feathers.

Boomslang wrote:I know that Spacedaisy, Long Con, and myself are not bad. Talk amongst yourselves as to why/how I would say this.

Busts out the serious role-suggestion possibility. Note that The Sorcerers had The Necromancer, who learns the role of people they kill. So if they had killed Boe somewhere along the line, it would be an easy, practically inevitable plan for one of them to try to role-hint at being Boe.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 12:58 pm**

Hey all, starting to catch up now. Sorry but it was Super Bowl weekend and my Pats won so I've been busy!

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:07 pm**

zeek wrote:
S~V~S wrote:And I know MP is saying he is replacing the suits, but only 2 known dead of either team exists right? So we are taking his word on that? Or did I miss something?
Suits: Made, DFaraday and Bass.
Sorcerers: Dom and Snow Dog.

insertnamehere or Russtifinko were killed by the Sorcerers, so could have been the last Suit - or it could have been Roxy, as her role wasn't revealed.

I think it must have been INH.

Russ did vote early in the DF lynch for Boomslang, which could have been a try at saving, but he voted Bass over Dom at a key time in the Dom/Bass lynch. It doesn't scream Suit to me. And Roxy was definitely playing her civ game, I'd highly doubt it was her. INH is most likely, if the Suits are indeed gone.

Doesn't really matter, I guess. Either way, we need to find sorcerers today.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:10 pm**

S~V~S wrote:It could also be the Sorcerers is my point, right?

Could you expand on this? Do you mean that instead of Tyler taking over killing for the suits, that he has joined the sorcerers? Because I don't think the sorcerers killed and made it look like Tyler, as MP clearly indicated that yes, he did do the kill. So the only possible alternative would be that he joined the sorcerers? Is that what you mean?

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:15 pm**

I like the case against Mongoose slightly better than the one on Boomslang at the moment, but Dom DOES have a history of going after teammates in games. I can remember times where Dom warned me in BTSC that he would be going after me lol.

I'll reread both later today but for now I've got one other game to catch up on.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:23 pm**

Hey guys, I thought it might make it easier for me if you knew my role! It begins with B and ends with avmorda! LOL

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:30 pm**

Dom wrote:Hey guys, I thought it might make it easier for me if you knew my role! It begins with B and ends with avmorda! LOL

What a blatant lie there is no role on the roles list called Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaavmorda

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:40 pm**

DharmaHelper wrote:
Dom wrote:Hey guys, I thought it might make it easier for me if you knew my role! It begins with B and ends with avmorda! LOL
What a blatant lie there is no role on the roles list called Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaavmorda

Secret Role.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 2:23 pm**

MattMatt is gonna be lunched one of these days.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 2:58 pm**

Alright, LC, let's talk for a minute about the mechanics of Face of Boe. We've had nine night periods, so FOB could check up to nine statements. Some statements may be made by people with immunity due to secrets, and some nights the power might be blocked through targeting of FOB or the target of the lie detection. So it's likely FOB has gotten off fewer than nine usages of the power. Additionally, because of the existence of the role, baddies are unlikely to gambit with civ claims unless they know FOB is dead, which they don't. So FOB will be stuck checking civ claims by civs, providing little insight into baddie team makeup. Hard for FOB to be a leader with that sort of information.

Also, juliets is civ.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 3:06 pm**

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 3:19 pm**

Well, while I see the *possibility* of Mongoose being bad, I'd also like to at least see her rebuttal. And since Boomslang has been around and has not made me feel any better about him, I will say this much:

There is a *possibility* that Mongoose is bad, but I would rather deal with *certainty* any day of the week. And I am absolutely, indisputably certain that Boomslang is bad and needs to be lynched today. I've tried to beat around the bush but there's just no point. He's bad, he's gotta go. Lynch him.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 3:37 pm**

DH why are you so sure? In my situation I know he is right about me and it seems he would have to be the role he hints to know that about me.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 3:41 pm**

juliets wrote:DH why are you so sure? In my situation I know he is right about me and it seems he would have to be the role he hints to know that about me.

Except not. There are *At best* 2 mafia left, so his odds of being "right" when saying someone is a civ are astronomical.

I'm sure. He's bad.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 3:43 pm**

OK, thanks for the quick reply.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 4:07 pm**

DharmaHelper wrote:
juliets wrote:DH why are you so sure? In my situation I know he is right about me and it seems he would have to be the role he hints to know that about me.
Except not. There are *At best* 2 mafia left, so his odds of being "right" when saying someone is a civ are astronomical.

I'm sure. He's bad.

And the odds of you being right when calling someone a baddie are equally astronomical. In this case, as it refers to me, they are precisely zero. You're barking up the wrong tree, and your sudden turn to "absolute certainty" seems rather desperate without additional information.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 4:09 pm**

Boomslang wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
juliets wrote:DH why are you so sure? In my situation I know he is right about me and it seems he would have to be the role he hints to know that about me.
Except not. There are *At best* 2 mafia left, so his odds of being "right" when saying someone is a civ are astronomical.

I'm sure. He's bad.
And the odds of you being right when calling someone a baddie are equally astronomical. In this case, as it refers to me, they are precisely zero. You're barking up the wrong tree, and your sudden turn to "absolute certainty" seems rather desperate without additional information.

Desperate? Yes, I am very desperate to avoid a wrong step in this lynch. Addtional information? Some of us prefer not to dump information

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 4:32 pm**

I am posting here so I can find my place when I return. I have had the thread open since about 9am, maybe earlier, and have been reading a bit here and there throughout the day as my kids and I did school. For some reason, the day has flown by and it took use much longer than usual to complete assignments. I really don't have anything to add to the thread atm, but I did want to ask DH if he would quote the place where Boom said what he said to try and gain civvie cred.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 4:33 pm**

Boomslang wrote:Caught up, frankly still unsure what's going on. Just let it be noted that Dom has been gunning for me this whole game; I think that burnishes my civvie cred a bit.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 4:33 pm**

If Boomslang is a sorcerer, then he knows full well who his remaining partner is, and can label anyone else he pleases as civ, since he's clearly trying to say he is face of boe without saying it.

I've got to think.

Posted: **Mon Feb 02, 2015 4:41 pm**

DharmaHelper wrote:
Boomslang wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
juliets wrote:DH why are you so sure? In my situation I know he is right about me and it seems he would have to be the role he hints to know that about me.
Except not. There are *At best* 2 mafia left, so his odds of being "right" when saying someone is a civ are astronomical.

I'm sure. He's bad.
And the odds of you being right when calling someone a baddie are equally astronomical. In this case, as it refers to me, they are precisely zero. You're barking up the wrong tree, and your sudden turn to "absolute certainty" seems rather desperate without additional information.
Desperate? Yes, I am very desperate to avoid a wrong step in this lynch. Addtional information? Some of us prefer not to dump information

And some of us don't actually have any information to dump...

timmer wrote:If Boomslang is a sorcerer, then he knows full well who his remaining partner is, and can label anyone else he pleases as civ, since he's clearly trying to say he is face of boe without saying it.

I've got to think.

This is heading to WIFOM city. I really wish I could indicate who the baddies are, but I don't have the certainty that DH appears to have. I'm still skeptical of Mongoose, however, and will likely end up voting that way unless startling new info arises.

The Syndicate

The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [ENDGAME]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Night 4]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 3]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 5]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]

Re: The Syndicate 2014 Game of Champions [Day 10]