Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12

[Marmot]

The dana votes are bit surprising to me considering the lack of recent conversation about her. It seems like its coming from folks who havent been around as much this weekend. I also wish she would be here to answer some of these thoughts. I find this vote to be very interesting so far between Epi and MM especially as it keeps tying up. I am not sure atm where my vote will go, but should have a wee bit of time to consider some of the cases being made.

I've been pushing the lynching of Dana (as my activity would allow) since Day 3.

[Elohcin]

I know this is not the best way to go about this, but I am voting for the person I think is least civ rather than more suspicious. *votes MM*

Linki....I still think Dana is bad bad bad too.

[Marmot]

I know this is not the best way to go about this, but I am voting for the person I think is least civ rather than more suspicious. *votes MM*

Linki....I still think Dana is bad bad bad too.

Why do you think I am not very civ? And why wouldn't a vote for Dana be a better alternative?

[Elohcin]

I know this is not the best way to go about this, but I am voting for the person I think is least civ rather than more suspicious. *votes MM*

Linki....I still think Dana is bad bad bad too.

Why do you think I am not very civ? And why wouldn't a vote for Dana be a better alternative?

I didn't say I thought you were "not very civ" that is twisting words a bit. I said I thought Epi seems more civ than you. Meaning, I am more sure that Epi is civ than I am sure that you are.

As for Dana, why would I vote her when my vote would be meaningless?

[Elohcin]

If you can convince others to vote for Dana....I will switch to her, no problem.

[Tangrowth]

WTF guys, I already said Dana is not bad, I've defended her harder than anyone.

[Hedgeowl]

The dana votes are bit surprising to me considering the lack of recent conversation about her. It seems like its coming from folks who havent been around as much this weekend. I also wish she would be here to answer some of these thoughts. I find this vote to be very interesting so far between Epi and MM especially as it keeps tying up. I am not sure atm where my vote will go, but should have a wee bit of time to consider some of the cases being made.

I've been pushing the lynching of Dana (as my activity would allow) since Day 3.

I actually meant ninja and then mistakenly thought sabie, but I went back and had switched it in my brain. I just mean there hasnt been recent discussion of dana compared to you and Epi.

[Tangrowth]

If she was "hiding", it'd be apparently accomplishing very little. I think if she had baddie teammates they would be prodding her to the thread... and they are not.

How is Dana "hiding", Blooper, and not TH 2.0? He has vanished completely, even though he's been on the site in the last 24 hours.

This was his last post, almost 3 RL days ago:

Not really caught up enough to make an informed decision on this poll so I voted for the coolest sounding planet

[Tangrowth]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

[Hedgeowl]

WTF guys, I already said Dana is not bad, I've defended her harder than anyone.

Right, but if some people think you're bad...

I wont be voting Dana if thats makes you feel better.

[Tangrowth]

Also, sorry if you wanted to discuss more, MM, but I've been swamped and right now I'm only here for a few minutes, just to check in before the poll is over; I have more work I need to complete on this essay.

[Epignosis]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

[Tangrowth]

WTF guys, I already said Dana is not bad, I've defended her harder than anyone.

Right, but if some people think you're bad...

I wont be voting Dana if thats makes you feel better.

Last I checked, Elo and Blooper haven't said they think I'm bad. (They can correct me if I'm wrong?)

MM is a different story, obviously.

[Tangrowth]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you are a civvie, for god's sake, save yourself.

Now, gotta go for real, BBL folks.

[Long Con]

6-6 tie, six players left to vote, twenty minutes in the lynch. WHO'S IT GONNA BE??

[Marmot]

If she was "hiding", it'd be apparently accomplishing very little. I think if she had baddie teammates they would be prodding her to the thread... and they are not.

How is Dana "hiding", Blooper, and not TH 2.0? He has vanished completely, even though he's been on the site in the last 24 hours.

This was his last post, almost 3 RL days ago:

Not really caught up enough to make an informed decision on this poll so I voted for the coolest sounding planet

If she has baddie teammates, 2 of them are dead, and the other one might be just as inactive as her.

Dana was under suspicion and TH was not (that I'm aware of), so it made it much easier for TH to fly under the radar if that's what he's going for.

[Marmot]

Also, sorry if you wanted to discuss more, MM, but I've been swamped and right now I'm only here for a few minutes, just to check in before the poll is over; I have more work I need to complete on this essay.

No worries. If I survive this lynch I want to if you get the time to.

[S~V~S]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you are a civvie, for god's sake, save yourself.

Now, gotta go for real, BBL folks.

Epi doesn't believe in "playing like a civvie". This is the only thing he's said in this game that has given me pause since he replaced back in. But it isn't enough to change my mind, I will risk looking foolish~ I do it with class & style

[Tangrowth]

If she was "hiding", it'd be apparently accomplishing very little. I think if she had baddie teammates they would be prodding her to the thread... and they are not.

How is Dana "hiding", Blooper, and not TH 2.0? He has vanished completely, even though he's been on the site in the last 24 hours.

This was his last post, almost 3 RL days ago:

Not really caught up enough to make an informed decision on this poll so I voted for the coolest sounding planet

If she has baddie teammates, 2 of them are dead, and the other one might be just as inactive as her.

Dana was under suspicion and TH was not (that I'm aware of), so it made it much easier for TH to fly under the radar if that's what he's going for.

Ha, glad I saw this before leaving!!!

But your entire suspicion of me and Dana is predicated on both of us being Enrique's teammates.

You just contradicted yourself, buddy.

Now, seriously, see you folks later!

[Epignosis]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you are a civvie, for god's sake, save yourself.

Now, gotta go for real, BBL folks.

Epi doesn't believe in "playing like a civvie". This is the only thing he's said in this game that has given me pause since he replaced back in. But it isn't enough to change my mind, I will risk looking foolish~ I do it with class & style

And, if I may offer a compliment, I respect you for that.

[Long Con]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you're gonna use sketchy language on purpose to get people's suspicions up to prove some point, then you getting lynched for it kind of makes you look foolish. There were so many ways to have ended this differently. "I'm not a baddie" instead of Sketchy McSketchersons.

[Marmot]

If she was "hiding", it'd be apparently accomplishing very little. I think if she had baddie teammates they would be prodding her to the thread... and they are not.

How is Dana "hiding", Blooper, and not TH 2.0? He has vanished completely, even though he's been on the site in the last 24 hours.

This was his last post, almost 3 RL days ago:

Not really caught up enough to make an informed decision on this poll so I voted for the coolest sounding planet

If she has baddie teammates, 2 of them are dead, and the other one might be just as inactive as her.

Dana was under suspicion and TH was not (that I'm aware of), so it made it much easier for TH to fly under the radar if that's what he's going for.

Ha, glad I saw this before leaving!!!

But your entire suspicion of me and Dana is predicated on both of us being Enrique's teammates.

You just contradicted yourself, buddy.

Now, seriously, see you folks later!

I don't understand what you're trying to say here.

But your flamboyant certainty may be the death of me.

[Hedgeowl]

If she was "hiding", it'd be apparently accomplishing very little. I think if she had baddie teammates they would be prodding her to the thread... and they are not.

How is Dana "hiding", Blooper, and not TH 2.0? He has vanished completely, even though he's been on the site in the last 24 hours.

This was his last post, almost 3 RL days ago:

Not really caught up enough to make an informed decision on this poll so I voted for the coolest sounding planet

If she has baddie teammates, 2 of them are dead, and the other one might be just as inactive as her.

Dana was under suspicion and TH was not (that I'm aware of), so it made it much easier for TH to fly under the radar if that's what he's going for.

We think 2 might be dead, but as far as i know thats not certain. So you think Dana and MP are the last two?

Linki what is mp trying to say? Do you mean dana and th are daleks?

[Roxy]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

It makes me feel like Epi is being saved.

[Marmot]

We think 2 might be dead, but as far as i know thats not certain. So you think Dana and MP are the last two?

Linki what is mp trying to say? Do you mean dana and th are daleks?

I'm certain Dana is a Dalek. I'm entertaining the possibilty that MP is on that team as well. I have no read on TH, but was only responding to MP's post.

[Epignosis]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you're gonna use sketchy language on purpose to get people's suspicions up to prove some point, then you getting lynched for it kind of makes you look foolish. There were so many ways to have ended this differently. "I'm not a baddie" instead of Sketchy McSketchersons.

Say what you like to justify your vote if/when I flip. I play the game my way. Always.

[S~V~S]

Were you to occasionally play it OUR way, you might get a civ win or two. Just saying :whistle:

[Long Con]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you're gonna use sketchy language on purpose to get people's suspicions up to prove some point, then you getting lynched for it kind of makes you look foolish. There were so many ways to have ended this differently. "I'm not a baddie" instead of Sketchy McSketchersons.

Say what you like to justify your vote if/when I flip. I play the game my way. Always.

The vote is already justified, you made sure of that with your sly not-quite-LD-statement. I don't know what your endgame is for a "strategy" like that.

[Marmot]

I don't like the way MP left the thread. For any last minute voters popping in, that post will jump to their attention as they scan through and put the spotlight on me. Unfortunately that post doesn't make any sense if you've actually been following the discussion...

[Marmot]

I'm moving my vote to Epi. No hard feelings mate, but I don't want to be lynched.

[Epignosis]

Were you to occasionally play it OUR way, you might get a civ win or two. Just saying :whistle:

NEVER!

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

On the one hand, I want to live. On the other, I like seeing people look foolish. It's kind of win-win for me.

If you're gonna use sketchy language on purpose to get people's suspicions up to prove some point, then you getting lynched for it kind of makes you look foolish. There were so many ways to have ended this differently. "I'm not a baddie" instead of Sketchy McSketchersons.

Say what you like to justify your vote if/when I flip. I play the game my way. Always.

The vote is already justified, you made sure of that with your sly not-quite-LD-statement. I don't know what your endgame is for a "strategy" like that.

My endgame strategy is to have fun. And I am accomplishing that. The only full game I have ever won was my very first here, and I was evil. So I amuse myself whenever possible.

[Epignosis]

I'm moving my vote to Epi. No hard feelings mate, but I don't want to be lynched.

No hard feelings sir.

[Hedgeowl]

Its a tough call btwn made and enrique. Theyve both survived nks under mysterious circumstances and Im thinking they might be connected. My vote is currently going to Enrique because I feel that voting him or made will finally find us a baddie. Looks like we are close to a tie so it may not matter which I choose anyway. Also sorry the typing is so atrocious. Im on my tablet.

Ok see this is the stuff i am finding curious post made/enrique. What made you think they were connected sabie. I need to keep reading back before this, but i am wondering.

I voted Mm for now since i didnt want to run out of time. i am trying to find if Epi was the first perosn to bring up a made/enri connection or if others were discussing it first.

[Tangrowth]

Grrrrr, screw productivity. It'll have to wait until after the post is up! I just can't stay focused.

MM, you're a liar. Dana is not a Dalek. And neither am I.

[Tangrowth]

If she was "hiding", it'd be apparently accomplishing very little. I think if she had baddie teammates they would be prodding her to the thread... and they are not.

How is Dana "hiding", Blooper, and not TH 2.0? He has vanished completely, even though he's been on the site in the last 24 hours.

This was his last post, almost 3 RL days ago:

Not really caught up enough to make an informed decision on this poll so I voted for the coolest sounding planet

If she has baddie teammates, 2 of them are dead, and the other one might be just as inactive as her.

Dana was under suspicion and TH was not (that I'm aware of), so it made it much easier for TH to fly under the radar if that's what he's going for.

Ha, glad I saw this before leaving!!!

But your entire suspicion of me and Dana is predicated on both of us being Enrique's teammates.

You just contradicted yourself, buddy.

Now, seriously, see you folks later!

I don't understand what you're trying to say here.

But your flamboyant certainty may be the death of me.

You've said over and over that Dana and I are the remaining Daleks, but here you float a theory in which I am clearly not a Dalek. It's a complete inconsistency and proves that your theory about me being baddie all of a sudden is completely fabricated. Because my baddieness is predicated ENTIRELY on me being a Dalek in your arguments.

[Epignosis]

Its a tough call btwn made and enrique. Theyve both survived nks under mysterious circumstances and Im thinking they might be connected. My vote is currently going to Enrique because I feel that voting him or made will finally find us a baddie. Looks like we are close to a tie so it may not matter which I choose anyway. Also sorry the typing is so atrocious. Im on my tablet.

Ok see this is the stuff i am finding curious post made/enrique. What made you think they were connected sabie. I need to keep reading back before this, but i am wondering.

I voted Mm for now since i didnt want to run out of time. i am trying to find if Epi was the first perosn to bring up a made/enri connection or if others were discussing it first.

I believe it was me first.

[Elohcin]

Grrrrr, screw productivity. It'll have to wait until after the post is up! I just can't stay focused.

You are too funny

[Marmot]

Grrrrr, screw productivity. It'll have to wait until after the post is up! I just can't stay focused.

MM, you're a liar. Dana is not a Dalek. And neither am I.

I am not a liar. My uninformed hypothesis is not a lie, but a guess made in an attempt to further my knowledge, based on logic that I have deduced from interactions and observations with other players.

I am not a liar.

[Tangrowth]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

It makes me feel like Epi is being saved.

It could be, but if that were the case, and MM is a Dalek, that makes Epig a Cyberman.

[Tangrowth]

Grrrrr, screw productivity. It'll have to wait until after the post is up! I just can't stay focused.

MM, you're a liar. Dana is not a Dalek. And neither am I.

I am not a liar. My uninformed hypothesis is not a lie, but a guess made in an attempt to further my knowledge, based on logic that I have deduced from interactions and observations with other players.

I am not a liar.

I'm sorry, sir, but if you are in fact a civvie this game, then you've paid practically no attention to what's going on, no offense intended of course, and you refuse to listen to logic.

Why will you not recognize that I have plenty of in-game reason to believe Dana is good?

Earlier you said it was because you thought I was bad and Dana's teammate.

But you JUST floated a theory where you clearly contradicted that.

[Tangrowth]

I'm absolutely confident that I've caught MM in a lie, and I'd like to see him lynched.

If he does flip civvie, I'll be 1,000,000 times more shocked than I was when JC 1.0 got lynched.

[Tangrowth]

Ah, I see the poll is over. I suppose now we wait.

[Marmot]

You've said over and over that Dana and I are the remaining Daleks, but here you float a theory in which I am clearly not a Dalek. It's a complete inconsistency and proves that your theory about me being baddie all of a sudden is completely fabricated. Because my baddieness is predicated ENTIRELY on me being a Dalek in your arguments.

I am more convinced about Dana than I am about you. And please show me these statements where I said you are baddie mcbaddersons.

And to the post you were talking about, I was adding a hypothetical addition to your statement. Forgive me for doing such a horrid thing.

[Epignosis]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

It makes me feel like Epi is being saved.

It could be, but if that were the case, and MM is a Dalek, that makes Epig a Cyberman.

I disagree?

[Tangrowth]

Thanks for posting this MP, you now have me convinced that you and Dana are on Enrique's team.

This was on N5.

[Black Rock]

What? The poll time changed? I was going to come and catch up and decide who I was going to vote for.

[Tangrowth]

Also, I do agree it's odd that he didn't name hardly any suspects in his analysis, mostly people he thought were good or likely good.

Hey, that sounds a lot like Dana...

Linki: I haven't gotten around to reading it yet, but I will now. I think you've got the wrong adjective there. And because I've got a strong suspicion that you and Dana or on a baddie team together (with Enrique), I'm taking whatever you say with a grain of salt.

Also, this, posted earlier today.

Sorry, MM, but you're as bad as they come.

[Hedgeowl]

Its a tough call btwn made and enrique. Theyve both survived nks under mysterious circumstances and Im thinking they might be connected. My vote is currently going to Enrique because I feel that voting him or made will finally find us a baddie. Looks like we are close to a tie so it may not matter which I choose anyway. Also sorry the typing is so atrocious. Im on my tablet.

Ok see this is the stuff i am finding curious post made/enrique. What made you think they were connected sabie. I need to keep reading back before this, but i am wondering.

I voted Mm for now since i didnt want to run out of time. i am trying to find if Epi was the first perosn to bring up a made/enri connection or if others were discussing it first.

I believe it was me first.

Ok, i wish you didnt have so many posts then. Lol. I will check them though. I am finding Snow dog referecing a connection, sabie, TH didnt think was one at first. zeek seems to think there was one and suggested lynching enri first and then strax kill made and that is all before the lynch. However, its all mixed up with ideas of whether they were on the same team or different, whereas after the lycnh it seemed much more obvious that it would be the same. I will keep digging for now.

Linki yeah i thinkth at was the a major part of the case on epi, that he might be cyber.

[Marmot]

I'm absolutely confident that I've caught MM in a lie, and I'd like to see him lynched.

If he does flip civvie, I'll be 1,000,000 times more shocked than I was when JC 1.0 got lynched.

You didn't seem surprised when juliets flipped civ.


Linki:

[Marmot]

The dichotomy of the votes being 6-6-2-1-1 this late in the lynch makes me wonder if the two main contenders are either baddies on opposing teams, or if one is baddie and one is civ (if I had to guess here, MM as bad and Epig 2.0 as civ).

Guess we'll see.

It makes me feel like Epi is being saved.

It could be, but if that were the case, and MM is a Dalek, that makes Epig a Cyberman.

I disagree?

Why the question mark?